United States v. Forty Barrels and Twenty Kegs of Coca-Cola

United States v. Forty Barrels and Twenty Kegs of Coca-Cola
Argued February 29, 1916
Decided May 22, 1916
Full case nameUNITED STATES, Plff. in Err., v. FORTY BARRELS and Twenty Kegs of Coca Cola, the Coca-Cola Company of Atlanta, Georgia, Complainant. No. 562.
Citations241 U.S. 265 (more)
36 S. Ct. 573; 60 L. Ed. 995
Holding
An ingredient may be considered "added" regardless of whether a product's formula called for it; whether a specific ingredient is harmful is a jury matter; compounded names (such as Coca-Cola) are only distinctive to the product and not the named ingredients should the name achieve a 'secondary significance' of the product itself.
Court membership
Chief Justice
Edward D. White
Associate Justices
Joseph McKenna · Oliver W. Holmes Jr.
William R. Day · Charles E. Hughes
Willis Van Devanter · Mahlon Pitney
James C. McReynolds

United States v. Forty Barrels and Twenty Kegs of Coca-Cola, 241 U.S. 265 (1916), was a federal suit under which the government unsuccessfully attempted to force the Coca-Cola Company to remove caffeine from its product.

Context

In 1906, Harvey Washington Wiley was the head of the United States Department of Agriculture Bureau of Chemistry when Congress passed the Pure Food and Drug Act. The Bureau started prosecuting companies which were selling products with harmful components and companies which were making misleading claims about their products.[1] In 1903, Coca-Cola had already stopped using spent coca leaves (which only carried trace amounts of cocaine) and had dropped the claim that it cured headaches.[1] But to compensate, the company had increased the amount of caffeine, and Wiley believed that even small amounts of caffeine in beverages was harmful to people.[2] He was particularly worried that Coca-Cola was being consumed by children as young as 4 years old.[1] So, in 1909, he ordered the seizure of 40 barrels and 20 kegs of a Coca-Cola shipment.[1]

Claim

On March 13, 1911, the government initiated the case under the 1906 Pure Food and Drug Act. It tried to force the Coca-Cola Company to remove caffeine from the Coca-Cola formula, believing that the product was adulterated and misbranded.[3]

  • "Adulterated": The allegation of adulteration was, in substance, that the product contained an added poisonous or added deleterious ingredient (namely, caffeine) which might render the product injurious to health.[3] The government stated that the syrup, when diluted as directed, would result in a beverage containing 1.21 grains (or 78.4 mg) of caffeine per 8 oz serving.[3]
  • "Misbranded": It was alleged to be misbranded in that the name "Coca Cola" was a representation of the presence of coca and cola but that the product "contained no coca and little if any cola" and thus was an "imitation" of these substances and was offered for sale under their "distinctive name".[3] At that time, the labels had images of coca leaves and kola nuts.[1]

Title

The case title—naming an object, "Forty Barrels and Twenty Kegs of Coca-Cola", as defendant—is an instance of jurisdiction in rem (jurisdiction against a thing). Rather than directly naming the Coca-Cola Company as defendant, the food itself was the subject of the case, with the company only indirectly subject. The barrels and kegs had been seized in 1909 by the government.[1]

Decision

  • "Adulterated": The decision, delivered by Justice Hughes, states that the intent of the word "added" in the context of the Act did not exclude the ingredients of a formula "sold under some fanciful name which would be distinctive" if any were found deleterious and was included to protect natural foodstuffs from prosecution because of constituent poisons rendered inert in their natural state (such as fusel oil in liquor); furthermore, it states that the introduction of caffeine in the later stages of syrup production made it an "added ingredient" in any sense of the term and the removal of harmful ingredients, even if vital to the identity of the product, did not constitute adulteration.[3]
  • "Misbranded": Of the misbranding charge, the Court held neither had the government proved that "coca cola" was a descriptive name nor had the Coca-Cola Company proved it was not, making both of these assertions irrelevant. Thus the Court found that the issue of whether the product contained any coca or cola had not been settled.[3]
  • "Details": The case was returned to the lower court for retrial to determine the remaining, factual matters; Justice McReynolds abstained.[3]

Effect

In 1912, even though Coca-Cola had won the case, two bills were introduced to the U.S. House of Representatives to amend the Pure Food and Drug Act to add caffeine to the list of "habit-forming" and "deleterious" substances, which must be listed on a product's label.[citation needed]

The government made a first appeal in 1913 to the Sixth Circuit Court in Cincinnati, but the ruling was reaffirmed.[1] Worried that this ruling would debilitate the Pure Food and Drug Act, it appealed again in 1916 to the Supreme Court.[1] This time it won, as the Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Charles Evans Hughes, ruled among other things that the original case had evidence both for and against caffeine being toxic, and that it should not have been dismissed by the judge before reaching the jury, and sent the case back to a lower court.[1]

Coca-Cola then voluntarily reduced the amount of caffeine in its product, and offered to pay all legal costs to settle and avoid further litigation.[1][4] The settlement was accepted because Wiley had already resigned in 1912, and no one at the FDA was interested in continuing the pressure against Coca-Cola.[1]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Ronald Hamowy (2007), Government and public health in America (illustrated ed.), Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 140–141, ISBN 978-1-84542-911-9
  2. ^ Deborah Blum (2018). The Poison Squad: One Chemist's Single-Minded Crusade for Food Safety at the Turn of the Twentieth Century. Penguin Press. ISBN 978-1594205149.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g United States v. Forty Barrels and Twenty Kegs of Coca-Cola, 241 U.S. 265 (1916).
  4. ^ "Pop psychology: The man who saved Coca-Cola", by Ludy T. Benjamin, Monitor on Psychology, February 2009, Vol 40, No. 2, p. 18

Read other articles:

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: The Singles Collection, Volume 1 – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 2000 compilation album by Dropkick MurphysThe Singles Collection, Volume 1Compilation album by Dropkick Mu...

 

Joint CIS Air Defense System (Russian: Объединённая система ПВО СНГ) is a unified system that comprises air defense units and elements of the former Soviet republics under control of the Coordination Committee on Air Defense of the Council of Ministers of Defense of the CIS. Currently there are 6 de facto members of JADS: Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia and Tajikistan. 70% of all expenditures of the military budget of the Commonwealth of Independent S...

 

ЮканжUckange   Країна  Франція Регіон Гранд-Ест  Департамент Мозель  Округ Тьйонвіль Кантон Флоранж Код INSEE 57683 Поштові індекси 57270 Координати 49°18′11″ пн. ш. 6°09′21″ сх. д.H G O Висота 150 - 190 м.н.р.м. Площа 5,56 км² Населення 6951 (01-2020[1]) Густота 1202,88 ос./км² Розмі...

Ця стаття містить інформацію, яку треба перевірити на наявність недостовірних фактів і хибних даних. Будь ласка, ознайомтеся з відповідним обговоренням та допоможіть виправити недоліки. (листопад 2020) Антон Станіславович МалиновськийНародився 2 серпня 1940(1940-08-02)Скаржи...

 

The Big Blue é o nome dado para o clássico australiano entre Sydney Football Club e Melbourne Victory Football Club. As duas equipes representam as maiores cidades da Austrália, Sydney (onde se localiza a sede do Sydney FC) e Melbourne (onde se localiza a sede do Melbourne Victory). O nome do clássico vem devido a cor azul ser a principal cor de ambos os clubes.[1] História Rivalidades regionais Há uma rivalidade de longa data entre as cidades de Sydney e Melbourne, as duas maiores cida...

 

Forte de Santo Inácio de TamandaréTamandaré, Pernambuco in BrazilView of the front of the fortForte de Santo InácioLocation of Forte de Santo Inácio in BrazilCoordinates8°45′27″S 35°05′59″W / 8.757604°S 35.099620°W / -8.757604; -35.099620TypeFort Forte de Santo Inácio is a fort located in Tamandaré, Pernambuco in Brazil.[1] The fort was restored in 2015.[2][3] See also History of Pernambuco References ^ Fortalezas.org >...

Taiwanese footballer This article is about Taiwanese football player. For other people named Chang Han, see Chang Han (disambiguation). For other people named Zhang Han, see Zhang Han (disambiguation). This biography of a living person needs additional citations for verification. Please help by adding reliable sources. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libelous...

 

  此條目介紹的是高捷少女為題材的輕小說作品。关于高捷少女的整體介紹,请见「高捷少女」。 前進吧!!高捷少女 進め!たかめ少女 LET'S GO! K.R.T. GIRLS 輕小說:前進吧!!高捷少女 日常 作者 啞鳴、陽炎 插圖 Kaworu 出版社 尖端出版 發售日 2015年8月6日 冊數 全1冊 輕小說:前進吧!!高捷少女 音躍 作者 陽炎、甜咖啡 插圖 Riv 出版社 尖端出版 發售日 2016年4月7日 ...

 

Compagnie française des mers orientales Création 1601 Disparition ? Siège social Laval, Saint-Malo, et Vitré France Activité Commerce international modifier - modifier le code - voir Wikidata  La Compagnie des mers orientales – plus précisément Compagnie française des mers orientales – est une compagnie commerciale créée par une compagnie de marchands des villes de Laval, Saint-Malo, et Vitré en 1601 dont l'objet était de naviguer et négocier dans toutes les Indes e...

For other uses, see Catch the Wind (disambiguation). 1965 single by DonovanCatch the WindSingle by Donovanfrom the album What's Bin Did and What's Bin Hid B-sideWhy Do You Treat Me Like You Do?[6]Released28 February 1965 (UK)[1][2][3][4]April 1965 (US)[5]Recorded1965GenreFolkLength2:21 (Side A)2:57 (Side B)LabelPye 7N.15801 (UK)[7]Hickory 45-1309 (US)[5]Songwriter(s)Donovan LeitchProducer(s)Terry Kennedy, Peter Eden, Geoff Stephe...

 

National park in Sweden Sarek National ParkSareks nationalparkIUCN category II (national park)The mountain Pierikpakte in the Äpar massifLocationNorrbotten County, SwedenCoordinates67°17′N 17°42′E / 67.283°N 17.700°E / 67.283; 17.700Area1,970 km2 (760 sq mi)[1]Established1909[2]Governing bodyNaturvårdsverket AbiskoÅsnenBjörnlandetBlå JungfrunDalby SöderskogDjuröFulufjälletFärnebofjärdenGarphyttanGotska San...

 

Armeense Kerk kan verwijzen naar: Armeens-Katholieke Kerk, de oosters-katholieke kerken Armeens-Apostolische Kerk, de oriëntaals-orthodoxe kerken Armeense kathedraal (Moskou), de residentie van de exarch van het bisdom Novo-Nachitsjevan Armeense Kathedraal (Lemberg), een kathedraal ten noorden van het marktplein in het oude stadscentrum van Lviv (Lemberg) Bekijk alle artikelen waarvan de titel begint met Armeense Kerk of met Armeense Kerk in de titel. Dit is een door...

This article is about a group of Romanian Gymnasts. For other uses, see Golden Team (disambiguation). This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Find sources: Romanian Golden Team – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (April 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Romanian Golden Team is the name of a group led by former Romanian gymna...

 

American filmmaker (born 1961) Aaron SorkinSorkin in 2016BornAaron Benjamin Sorkin (1961-06-09) June 9, 1961 (age 62)Manhattan, New York City, U.S.OccupationFilm directorscreenwriterplaywrightactorAlma materSyracuse University (BFA)Years active1984–presentSpouse Julia Bingham ​ ​(m. 1996; div. 2005)​Children1 Aaron Benjamin Sorkin (born June 9, 1961)[1] is an American playwright, screenwriter, and film director. Born in ...

 

Provincial public university in Wuhu, Anhui, China This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Find sources: Anhui Polytechnic University – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Anhui Polytechnic University安徽工程大学Other nameAHPUFormer namesAnhui Mechanical University Wuhu Mechanic...

Norwegian government agency Logo. The National Insurance Service (Norwegian: Trygdeetaten) was a Norwegian government agency responsible for social security. Organization It had its roots in the National Insurance Administration (Norwegian: Rikstrygdeverket), which was founded by parliamentary act on 23 July 1894 under the name Rigsforsikringsanstalten. The National Insurance Administration was the core of the agency, which also consisted of county and local offices for social security. The a...

 

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Find sources: Open Heaven / River Wild – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (September 2015) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) This article...

 

For other people named Robert Boyd, see Robert Boyd (disambiguation). Robert BoydBorn1870 (1870)NationalityCanadianOccupation(s)Stenographer, Professor Robert Boyd (10 April 1870 - Unknown), of Russell, Ontario, Canada, was the inventor of a system of shorthand, Boyd's Syllabic Shorthand.[1] The system was first published in 1903, with a later publication in 1912. References ^ Boyd, Robert (1912). Boyd Shorthand Instructor 1912 Edition. p. 6. Authority control databases Inte...

American baseball pitcher (born 1997) Baseball player Adam HillFree agent PitcherBorn: (1997-03-24) March 24, 1997 (age 26)Anderson, South CarolinaBats: RightThrows: Right Adam Dean Hill (born March 24, 1997) is an American professional baseball pitcher and a free agent. Hill attended T. L. Hanna High School in Anderson, South Carolina. He was drafted by the San Diego Padres in the 39th round of the 2015 MLB draft, but he elected to honor his college commitment to the University of South...

 

بطولة أمريكا المفتوحة 2007 - زوجي الرجال جزء من أمريكا المفتوحة 2007  البلد الولايات المتحدة  التاريخ 2007  الرياضة كرة المضرب  البطل(ة) سيمون أسبلين جوليان نول الوصيف(ة) لوكاش دلوهي بافل فيزنر النتيجة 7–5، 6–4 بطولة أمريكا المفتوحة 2006 - زوجي الرجال  بطولة أمريكا المفت...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!