Erdut killings

Erdut killings
Erdut Erdut on the map of Croatia, JNA/Croatian Serb-held areas in late 1991 are highlighted in red
Location	Erdut, Croatia
Date	10 November 1991 – 3 June 1992
Target	Hungarian and Croat civilians
Attack type	Mass murder, ethnic cleansing
Deaths	37
Perpetrators	SAO SBWS Territorial Defence Forces, Serb Volunteer Guard

The Erdut killings were a series of murders of 37 Hungarian and Croat civilians in the village of Erdut, Croatia committed by Croatian Serb forces and Serb Volunteer Guard paramilitaries between November 1991 and June 1992, during the Croatian War of Independence. Twenty-two Hungarians and 15 Croats were killed. The first killings occurred on 10 November 1991, when twelve civilians died. Eight more were killed over the following several days. Five more civilians were killed on 10 December, and another seven on 16 December. Four others were killed on 21 February 1992 and the final one was killed on 3 June. The bodies of these victims were either buried in mass graves or thrown into nearby wells.

Most of the victims were exhumed in 1998, after the area reverted to Croatian control following the signing of the Erdut Agreement in 1995. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) charged several Serbian and Croatian Serb officials, including Slobodan Milošević, Jovica Stanišić, Franko Simatović and Goran Hadžić, for their alleged involvement in the killings. Milošević and Hadžić died before their trials could be completed. Stanišić and Simatović were initially acquitted, but their acquittals were overturned on appeal, and they are being retried.

Background

Main article: Croatian War of Independence

In 1990, following the electoral defeat of the government of the Socialist Republic of Croatia by the Croatian Democratic Union (Croatian: Hrvatska demokratska zajednica, HDZ), ethnic tensions between Croats and Serbs worsened. The Yugoslav People's Army (Jugoslovenska Narodna Armija – JNA) confiscated the weapons of Croatia's Territorial Defence (Teritorijalna obrana - TO) forces to minimize resistance.^[1] On 17 August, tensions escalated into an open revolt by Croatian Serbs,^[2] centred on the predominantly Serb-populated areas of the Dalmatian hinterland around Knin,^[3] parts of the Lika, Kordun, Banovina and eastern Croatia.^[4] This revolt was followed by two unsuccessful attempts by Serbia, supported by Montenegro and Serbia's provinces of Vojvodina and Kosovo, to obtain the Yugoslav Presidency's approval for a JNA operation to disarm Croatian security forces in January 1991.^[5]

After a bloodless skirmish between Serb insurgents and Croatian special police in March,^[6] the JNA itself, supported by Serbia and its allies, asked the Federal Presidency to give it wartime authorities and declare a state of emergency. The request was denied on 15 March, and the JNA came under the control of Serbian President Slobodan Milošević. Milošević, preferring a campaign to expand Serbia rather than to preserve Yugoslavia, publicly threatened to replace the JNA with a Serbian army and declared that he no longer recognized the authority of the Federal Presidency.^[7] By the end of the month, the conflict had escalated into the Croatian War of Independence.^[8] The JNA stepped in, increasingly supporting the Croatian Serb insurgents and preventing Croatian police from intervening.^[7] In early April, the leaders of the Croatian Serb revolt declared their intention to integrate the area under their control, known as SAO Krajina, with Serbia. The Government of Croatia viewed this declaration as an attempt to secede.^[9] In May, the Croatian government responded by forming the Croatian National Guard (Zbor narodne garde - ZNG),^[10] but its development was hampered by a United Nations (UN) arms embargo introduced in September.^[11] On 8 October, Croatia declared independence from Yugoslavia.^[12]

Prelude

Vukovar

Erdut

Dalj

Vinkovci

Osijek

Bogojevo

Aljmaš

Ćelije

class=notpageimage|

Map of eastern Slavonia area between Osijek and Vukovar (Modern county lines provided for reference)

The first artillery attack against ZNG units in Erdut occurred on 25 July, when 24 mortar rounds were fired by the JNA from the Serbian province of Vojvodina on the opposite bank of the Danube. Besides the damage to the medieval Erdut Castle,^[13] the attack caused six deaths and resulted in the injury of 18 soldiers from the 1st Guards Brigade.^[14] The unit deployed approximately a hundred troops, stationed in a facility normally operated by Osijek water supply utility, earlier that month.^[15] The general area of the villages of Dalj, Erdut and Aljmaš was targeted by an artillery bombardment in the early morning of 1 August. Croatian sources indicate that the artillery fire came from the JNA 51st Mechanised Brigade on the left bank of the Danube and the Croatian Serb TO. The JNA denied taking part in the bombardment.^[16]

Shortly after the bombardment, as the Croatian Serb TO and Serbian Volunteer Guard (SDG) paramilitaries attacked the police station in Dalj, the Croatian police requested the JNA's assistance in terminating the TO attack.^[16] As the JNA deployed, it reported receiving gunfire from the ZNG 1st Company of the 1st Battalion of the 3rd Guards Brigade in Erdut as it moved towards 15 kilometres (9.3 miles) of road between Bogojevo and Dalj and returning fire before proceeding to Dalj.^[17] Conversely, the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) witness of the event claimed that the JNA fired against civilian homes in Erdut unprovoked.^[18] The same day, the JNA tanks entered Erdut.^[19] After the takeover, Croatian Serbs established the government of the SAO Eastern Slavonia, Baranja and Western Syrmia (SAO SBWS)—a breakaway territory in Croatia—in Erdut,^[20] and Serbia's Special Anti-Terrorist Unit, specifically its commander Radovan Stojičić, set up an SDG camp in the village,^[21] run by Željko Ražnatović.^[22] The second half of 1991 saw the fiercest fighting of the war, as the 1991 Yugoslav campaign in Croatia culminated in the Siege of Dubrovnik,^[23] and the Battle of Vukovar.^[24] At the same time, Croatian Serb authorities began systematically expelling non-Serb civilians in areas under their control. The expulsions in the area of Erdut and elsewhere in eastern Slavonia were primarily motivated by the aim of changing the ethnic composition in favour of Serbs and the resettling of Serb refugees who had fled western Slavonia following operations Swath-10 and Hurricane-91.^[25]

Timeline

Serbian Volunteer Guard troops in Erdut in December 1991

On 9 November, the Croatian Serb TO and the SDG arrested ethnic Hungarian and Croat civilians in Erdut as well as in the nearby villages of Dalj Planina and Erdut Planina, and detained them in the SDG training camp.^[26] According to the ICTY prosecutor's office, twelve members of the group were killed the next day. The bodies of eight of the victims were buried in the village of Ćelije, one was buried in Daljski Atar and three bodies were thrown down a well in Borovo Selo.^[27] Five more non-Serb civilians were arrested by the Croatian Serb TO and the SDG in the village of Klisa on 11 November, one in Bijelo Brdo and one in Dalj, and taken to Erdut for interrogation.^[28] Two of the seven had Serb relatives and were released, while the remaining five were brutally treated,^[26] and were killed and buried in a mass grave in Ćelije after being interrogated. Three more civilians, including the family members of those killed on 10 November, were arrested and executed by Croatian Serb TO and SDG personnel in mid-November.^[28]

The killings continued the next month, when the Croatian Serb TO and the SDG arrested five more non-Serb civilians in Erdut.^[26] They were killed at the TO training centre in Erdut and the bodies of three were thrown down a well in Daljski Atar. Seven more Hungarian and Croat civilians were arrested by the Croatian Serb TO and police and the SDG in Erdut and detained in the Erdut training centre until 26 December, when they were killed. The bodies of six of them were also thrown into a well in Daljski Atar.^[29]

Further killings occurred on 21 February 1992, when four non-Serb civilians were arrested by Croatian Serb forces and the SDG and killed in the training centre^[29] after being interrogated.^[30] The four were subsequently buried in a mass grave in Daljski Atar.^[29] One more Hungarian civilian was murdered by the Serbian State Security Service—with SDG assistance—after inquiring about her relatives who were killed in November 1991. Her body was thrown down a well in Dalj Planina.^[31] With her murder, the total number of civilians killed in Erdut between November 1991 and June 1992 reached 37, of which 22 were Hungarians and 15 were Croats.^[32]

Aftermath

Goran Hadžić at the ICTY in 2011

In August 1995, following Operation Storm, Croatia regained control of territories previously held by Croatian Serb forces, with the exception of eastern Slavonia—the region around Erdut. Eastern Slavonia was gradually transferred to Croatian control based on the Erdut Agreement signed on 12 November 1995,^[33] and the transfer, facilitated by United Nations peacekeepers, was completed on 15 January 1998.^[34]

In October 1998, three bodies were retrieved from a well in Erdut.^[35] Days later, more bodies were retrieved from a well in Daljski Atar,^[36] where a total of 23 victims were found.^[37] A total of 32 sets of human remains were recovered in the village of Ćelije by 2012. The mass grave in Ćelije is toured annually by a procession commemorating the victims buried there and in several other locations in eastern Slavonia,^[38] while the site in Daljski Atar is marked by a monument to the civilian victims since 2013.^[37]

War crime charges

The ICTY charged Milošević with the extermination of non-Serb civilians in Erdut, the forcible transfer of at least 2,500 inhabitants of the village and destruction of their property.^[39] Milošević's trial commenced on 12 February 2002, but he died in March 2006 before a verdict could be reached.^[40] The SDG, which became the most powerful paramilitary formation in eastern Slavonia,^[41] and Ražnatović gained notoriety for war crimes and ethnic cleansing. The SDG systematically plundered villages in the region, turning the area into a source of oak lumber, crude oil and wine for Ražnatović to sell in Serbia,^[21] and in Erdut itself.^[42] Ražnatović was never charged for any war crimes committed by the SDG in Erdut. The ICTY only charged him with several war crimes committed in or near Sanski Most.^[43] He was assassinated in Belgrade on 15 January 2000 before he could stand trial.^[21]

The ICTY charged Jovica Stanišić, deputy head of Serbia's State Security Service in 1991, and Franko Simatović, head of the Special Operations Unit of the State Security Service and subordinate to Stanišić,^[44] in connection with the war crimes committed in Erdut and elsewhere. The indictment specifically charged them with facilitating communication between Milošević and various Serb forces in Croatia, as well as providing training, logistics and funding to those forces as part of a joint criminal enterprise, planning of war crimes and practical assistance to the physical perpetrators of various war crimes.^[45] According to an ICTY witness, Stanišić and Simatović provided assistance to the SDG throughout the war.^[46] The ICTY trial chamber acquitted both of them on 30 May 2013.^[47] The acquittals were overturned on 15 December 2015 and a new trial is set to resume.

The ICTY also indicted Goran Hadžić, a Croatian Serb political leader at the time and the head of the SAO SBWS government, before the SAO SBWS merged into the Republic of Serbian Krajina. The charges include war crimes of persecutions, extermination, murder, imprisonment, torture, inhumane acts and cruel treatment, deportation, forcible transfer of population, wanton destruction and plunder of property in Erdut and elsewhere.^[48] He died of brain cancer in July 2016, aged 57, and judgement was never passed. On 31 July 2012, Croatian authorities indicted Božo Bolić, the commander of the police station in Erdut in late 1991 and 1992, and charged him with unlawful arrests and abuse of civilian population, who were later turned over to the SDG. As of 2014^[update], Bolić remains at large.^[49][50]

See also

• List of massacres in Croatia

Footnotes

1. Hoare 2010, p. 117.
2. Hoare 2010, p. 118.
3. The New York Times & 19 August 1990.
4. ICTY & 12 June 2007.
5. Hoare 2010, pp. 118–119.
6. Ramet 2006, pp. 384–385.
7. Hoare 2010, p. 119.
8. The New York Times & 3 March 1991.
9. The New York Times & 2 April 1991.
10. EECIS 1999, pp. 272–278.
11. The Independent & 10 October 1992.
12. Narodne novine & 8 October 1991.
13. O'Keefe 2010, pp. 114–115.
14. t-portal & 24 July 2011.
15. Osijek-Baranja County 2011.
16. Nazor 2011a.
17. Nazor 2011b.
18. ICTY & 28 August 2003, pp. 25554–25555.
19. index.hr & 16 October 2012.
20. The New York Times & 10 December 1991.
21. Vreme & 14 January 2010.
22. CIA 2002, p. 209.
23. Bjelajac & Žunec 2009, pp. 249–250.
24. The New York Times & 18 November 1991.
25. The New York Times & 10 May 1992.
26. Cencich 2013, p. 102.
27. ICTY & 22 March 2012, p. 10.
28. ICTY & 22 March 2012, p. 11.
29. ICTY & 22 March 2012, p. 12.
30. Cencich 2013, p. 103.
31. ICTY & 22 March 2012, pp. 12–13.
32. Zebić & 25 July 2011.
33. Søberg 2007, p. 46.
34. Søberg 2007, p. 60.
35. HRT & 22 October 1998.
36. HRT & 28 October 1998.
37. Ministry of Veterans' Affairs & 27 November 2013.
38. Večernji list & 31 March 2012.
39. ICTY & 23 October 2002, item 36.
40. ICTY 2006, pp. 7–8.
41. The Guardian & 19 January 2000.
42. The New York Times & 26 March 1995.
43. ICTY 2000.
44. ICTY & 9 July 2008, p. 2.
45. ICTY & 9 July 2008, pp. 5–8.
46. The New York Times & 24 April 2003.
47. ICTY 2013, p. 5.
48. ICTY & 22 March 2012, pp. 8–16.
49. Glas Slavonije & 31 July 2012.
50. Večernji list & 26 April 2011.

References

Books

• Bjelajac, Mile; Žunec, Ozren (2009). "The War in Croatia, 1991–1995". In Charles W. Ingrao; Thomas Allan Emmert (eds.). Confronting the Yugoslav Controversies: A Scholars' Initiative. West Lafayette, Indiana: Purdue University Press. pp. 230–271. ISBN 978-1-55753-533-7.
• Cencich, John R. (2013). The Devil's Garden: A War Crimes Investigator's Story. Lincoln, Nebraska: Potomac Books. ISBN 978-1-61234-172-9.
• Central Intelligence Agency, Office of Russian and European Analysis (2002). Balkan Battlegrounds: A Military History of the Yugoslav Conflict, 1990–1995, Volume 2. Washington, D.C.: Central Intelligence Agency. ISBN 9780160664724. OCLC 50396958.
• Eastern Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States. London, England: Routledge. 1999. ISBN 978-1-85743-058-5.
• Hoare, Marko Attila (2010). "The War of Yugoslav Succession". In Ramet, Sabrina P. (ed.). Central and Southeast European Politics Since 1989. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press. pp. 111–136. ISBN 978-1-139-48750-4.
• O'Keefe, Roger (2010). The Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflict. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-139-46098-9.
• Ramet, Sabrina P. (2006). The Three Yugoslavias: State-Building And Legitimation, 1918–2006. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press. ISBN 978-0-253-34656-8.
• Søberg, Marius (2007). "Croatia Since 1989". In Ramet, Sabrina P.; Matić, Davorka (eds.). Democratic Transition in Croatia: Value Transformation, Education & Media. College Station, Texas: Texas A&M University Press. ISBN 978-1-58544-587-5.

News reports

• Bellamy, Christopher (10 October 1992). "Croatia built 'web of contacts' to evade weapons embargo". The Independent. Archived from the original on 10 November 2012.
• Burns, John F. (10 May 1992). "The Demographics of Exile: Victorious Serbs Repopulate Croatian Villages". The New York Times.
• Cohen, Roger (26 March 1995). "The World; In the Balkans, Doing Well by Waging War". The New York Times.
• Engelberg, Stephen (3 March 1991). "Belgrade Sends Troops to Croatia Town". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 2 October 2013.
• Engelberg, Stephen (10 December 1991). "Serbs in Croatia Build Political Foundation to Support Their Military Gains". The New York Times.
• Flego, Miroslav (31 March 2012). "Tisuću hodočasnika na Križnom putu "Putem masovnih grobnica"" [A Thousand Pilgrims in Mass Graves Procession]. Večernji list (in Croatian).
• Glenny, Misha (19 January 2000). "Arkan". The Guardian.
• "Hadžić se na optužbe tužitelja samo nasmijao: "Bio je Miloševićev čovjek na terenu, krvnik i ubojica"" [Hadžić Only Scoffs at Charges by the Prosecutor: "He Was Milošević's Man in the Field, Executioner and Murderer"] (in Croatian). index.hr. 16 October 2012.
• "Sumnjiči ga se za smrt 12 civila i ozljeđivanje još njih troje" [Suspected of Death of 12 Civilians and Injuring Three Others]. Večernji list (in Croatian). 26 April 2011.
• "Mučio civile, a potom ih poslao na pogubljenje Arkanovim "tigrovima"" [Civilians Tortured, then Sent to Arkan's "Tigers" for Execution]. Glas Slavonije (in Croatian). 31 July 2012.
• "Otkrivena spomen-ploča za poginule 'Tigrove'" [Memorial Plaque to Killed Tigers Unveiled]. t-portal (in Croatian). T-Hrvatski Telekom. 24 July 2011.
• "Na području između Dalja i Aljmaša ekshumirano 20 žrtava srpske agresije" [20 Victims of Serbian Aggression Exhumed Between Dalj and Aljmaš] (in Croatian). Croatian Radiotelevision. 28 October 1998.
• "Roads Sealed as Yugoslav Unrest Mounts". The New York Times. Reuters. 19 August 1990. Archived from the original on 21 September 2013.
• Simons, Marlise (24 April 2003). "Mystery Witness Faces Milosevic". The New York Times.
• Sudetic, Chuck (18 November 1991). "Croats Concede Danube Town's Loss". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 14 November 2013.
• Sudetic, Chuck (2 April 1991). "Rebel Serbs Complicate Rift on Yugoslav Unity". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 2 October 2013.
• Švarm, Filip (14 January 2010). "Arkanova ostavština" [Arkan's Legacy]. Vreme (in Serbian). No. 993.
• Zebić, Enis (25 July 2011). "Bolna prisjećanja na vrijeme Hadžićeve strahovlade" [Painful remembrance of Hadžić's reign of terror]. Slobodna Evropa (in Croatian).
• "U Erdutu traje najzahtjevnija ekshumacija" [The Most Demanding Exhumation in Progress in Erdut] (in Croatian). Croatian Radiotelevision. 22 October 1998.

Other sources

• "Case Information Sheet - Goran Hadžić (IT-04-75)" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. 2014.
• "Case Information Sheet - Kosovo, Croatia & Bosnia (IT-02-54) Slobodan Milošević" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. 2006.
• "Case Information Sheet - Stanišić & Simatović (IT-03-69)" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. 2013.
• "Case Information Sheet - Željko Ražnatović "Arkan" (IT-97-27)" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. 2000.
• Nazor, Ante (April 2011). ""Informacija o angažovanju jedinice JNA u Dalju 01. 08. 1991. godine" (okupacija Dalja, Aljmaša i Erduta) – (I. dio)" [Information on Engagement of a JNA Unit in Dalj on 1 August 1991 (Occupation of Dalj, Aljmaš and Erdut) – (Part 1)]. Hrvatski vojnik (in Croatian) (341). Ministry of Defence. ISSN 1333-9036. Archived from the original on 7 December 2013.
• Nazor, Ante (April 2011). ""Informacija o angažovanju jedinice JNA u Dalju 01. 08. 1991. godine" (okupacija Dalja, Aljmaša i Erduta) – (II. dio)" [Information on Engagement of a JNA Unit in Dalj on 1 August 1991 (Occupation of Dalj, Aljmaš and Erdut) – (Part 2)]. Hrvatski Vojnik (in Croatian) (342). Ministry of Defence (Croatia). ISSN 1333-9036. Archived from the original on 8 December 2013.
• "Obilježena godišnjica pogibije hrvatskih branitelja 1. gardijske brigade Tigrovi u Erdutu" [Anniversary of Death of Croatian Defenders of the 1st Guards Brigade - Tigers in Erdut] (in Croatian). Osijek-Baranja County. 2011.
• "Odluka" [Decision]. Narodne novine (in Croatian) (53). Narodne novine d.d. 8 October 1991. ISSN 1333-9273. Archived from the original on 2009-09-23.
• "Otkrivanje spomen-obilježja mjesta masovne grobnice "Daljski Atar - Glogovac"" [Memorial at the Daljski Atar - Glogovac Mass Grave Unveiled] (in Croatian). Ministry of Veterans' Affairs (Croatia). 27 November 2013. Archived from the original on 2014-10-24.
• "The Prosecutor of the Tribunal Against Goran Hadžić - Second Amended Indictment" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia. 22 March 2012.
• "The Prosecutor of the Tribunal Against Jovica Stanišić and Franko Simatović - Third Amended Indictment" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia. 9 July 2008.
• "The Prosecutor of the Tribunal Against Slobodan Milosevic - Second Amended Indictment". International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. 23 October 2002.
• "The Prosecutor vs. Milan Martic – Judgement" (PDF). International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia. 12 June 2007.
• "Trial of Slobodan Milošević – Transcript". International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia. 28 August 2004. pp. 25477–25594.

45.525095°N 19.059371°E / 45.525095; 19.059371