In 2004, Trenyce began to focus on theatre, playing roles in the plays Not a Day Goes By, The Vagina Monologues, Soul Kittens Cabaret and Mama's Sweet Potato Pie. In 2006, she played the lead role of Deena Jones in an Indianapolis production of the musical Dreamgirls. She made her film debut in 2008 and became the first American Idol contestant to headline a show in Las Vegas. She originated the role of Portia in David E. Talbert's play Love in the Nick of Tyme. Trenyce performed in a 2009 North American tour of the musical Ain't Misbehavin'.
From 2010 to 2013, she was the leading female vocalist in the revueThriller – Live during a European tour and its West End run. She appeared in the 2013 comedy film Kick-Ass 2. In 2015, Trenyce hosted the Franco Dragone-produced cabaret show Taboo at the casino City of Dreams in Macau, China. She then returned to London for an extended reprise of her role in Thriller – Live. In 2017, she starred in the cabaret production Heart & Soul: Music of Whitney Houston, Dionne Warwick & Diana Ross, in California. In the same year, she played Diana Ross in a North American tour of Motown: The Musical.
At the age of nineteen, Trenyce was arrested for theft at work. A Shelby County, Tennessee, court permitted her to participate in a pre-trial diversion program that expunged the felony charges from her record.[5][6] She has denied the theft and claimed that it was a co-worker who stole the items from her workplace.[2] Trenyce attended the University of Memphis on a full music scholarship.[3] While in college, she joined the University Singers ensemble choir and its band Sound Fuzion, which toured throughout Tennessee.[4][7] After completing three years of the school's nursing program, Trenyce left the University of Memphis to pursue music full-time, performing in such venues as Rhythms Night Club, Precious Cargo and Isaac Hayes' Restaurant.[3]
Career
2002–03: American Idol
In October 2002, Trenyce auditioned for the second season of the reality television series American Idol.[3] She became one of the 32 semi-finalists. She was eliminated in the top 30 round, but judge Paula Abdul chose her as a "wildcard selection" to become one of the twelve finalists.[3][8] Trenyce's arrest was disclosed to the public during an appearance on the show, but she was not removed from the series, as had happened with some former contestants. Producer Nigel Lythgoe clarified that Trenyce informed the producers of her criminal history from the outset.[9] Trenyce placed fifth during the season finals.[3]Jim Cantiello of MTV News connected the disclosure of Trenyce's mug shot and felony theft charges to her elimination from the show by public voting.[10]Entertainment Weekly also concluded that the news relating to her criminal record reduced her appeal with voters.[11] Several media commentators suggested that racism may have played a role in Trenyce's elimination, as she was one of only two dark-skinned finalists during the season (the other was winner Ruben Studdard).[12][13]
Entertainment Weekly found her to be one of the show's most underrated contestants and called her a "polished performer with enough sass to eschew her surname".[11] Tim Cuprisin of Milwaukee Journal Sentinel criticized Trenyce's use of her mononymous stage name as "a bit too slick even for a slick competition".[14] Jan Jagodzinski argued in a 2005 book, however, that the name was an attempt to garner "an American appeal", since her birth name Lashundra Cobbin is "an impossible 'pop' signifier".[15] Judge Simon Cowell said that he "never really warmed" to Trenyce, as she "worked very hard at her image – too hard".[16]
In 2016, Billboard magazine included Trenyce's rendition of "I Have Nothing" in its list of the 100 best American Idol live performances.[17]Vulture.com's Maura Johnston criticized Trenyce for being "[a] little yell-y, a little pitch-y, a little guarded", but praised her voice and song choices and felt that she set "a precedent for the divas who followed" in later American Idol seasons.[18] Trenyce's performance of "Let's Stay Together" was included on the compilation album American Idol Season 2: All-Time Classic American Love Songs (2003). AllMusic's Heather Phares thought Trenyce was one of the strongest performers of the show, but criticized her cover version for having an "indistinct quality".[19] In an interview, Trenyce said that she was offered a record deal, following her appearance on American Idol, but she and her mother (who was her manager) rejected it because she found the terms unsatisfactory.[20]
Following her elimination, Trenyce made appearances on television shows, including Live with Regis and Kelly, Extra, ET, Fox and Friends, The Early Show, The Wayne Brady Show, Inside Edition, Good Day Live, the Today Show and TRL. She also was featured in various Memphis periodicals, including as one of Memphis' 30 Most Beautiful People in Elite Magazine's June 2003 issue, and appeared on a cover of "God Bless the USA" along with the other American Idol Season 2 finalists.[19][21] Trenyce participated in a three-month concert tour with the other season 2 finalists, performing "Proud Mary" and "I Have Nothing".[3]Robin Givhan of The Washington Post was critical of Trenyce's performance on the tour, saying that she demonstrated the "earsplitting finesse of a sledgehammer".[22] Arion Berger of the same publication described her as "a female drag queen with a diva's intimidating presence".[23]
Trenyce's work in theatre has mostly focused on "various entertainment aspects of African-American interest".[24] In 2004, she made her theatre debut as Yancey in a North American tour of Not a Day Goes By, a play with songs adapted from the E. Lynn Harris' 2000 novel of the same name. The tour ran from January to May 2004.[25][26]Jet magazine wrote that Trenyce "breathes life and voice into Yancey", describing her as one of the show's "rich vocal talents".[25]The Chicago Defender felt that Trenyce displayed a "theatrical perception as she interprets a character".[27] She soon performed in the play The Vagina Monologues.[28] In 2005, she played in two Nicci Gillbert stage productions: Soul Kittens Cabaret and Mama's Sweet Potato Pie,[28][29] participating in a North American tour of the latter.[30] Trenyce's performance as the wife in Mama's Sweet Potato Pie was praised by Call and Post's Chris Bournea.[31] The same year, she made a cameo appearance in the comedy film Beauty Shop,[32] and performed on the BET reality television series College Hill.[33]
Trenyce played the leading role of Deena Jones in an Indianapolis production of the musical Dreamgirls, which ran from June to July 2006.[34][35] Her performance received positive reviews, including one from the newspaper NUVO, commenting that Trenyce's "smooth voice creat[ed] a sound for The Dreams that could easily have taken the group to the top of the charts".[36] David Lindquist of The Indianapolis Star thought that Trenyce brought "star power" to the production.[37] In the same year, she became the first American Idol contestant to headline a show in Las Vegas, Nevada, with V: The Ultimate Variety Show and Late Night Idol at the Sahara Hotel and Casino.[30] She hosted it for nine months.[38]
In 2007, Trenyce played Portia in David E. Talbert's play Love in the Nick of Tyme.[35][39] It toured in North America to seventeen cities, starting in the Beacon Theatre in New York in January.[40] In 2010, a film of the play was released on DVD, and its soundtrack was released separately.[41][42] The film was also broadcast on Black Entertainment Television (BET).[43] Trenyce performed at the Razz Room in San Francisco from July 22 to August 2, 2008.[35] The same year, she made her film debut as Unique in the LGBT independent romantic comedy movie Friends & Lovers: The Ski Trip 2.[44] A year later, she contributed the title track to the soundtrack for the film Truth Hall.[45] Trenyce played a role in the 30th anniversary revival tour of the musical Ain't Misbehavin' after a recommendation from Ruben Studdard.[24] As traditionally done with the show, the performers used their own names for their characters.[46] The cast album received a nomination for the Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album at the 52nd Annual Grammy Awards.[47]
2010–14: Thriller – Live and work in London
Trenyce in a 2012 photoshoot in London
In 2010, Trenyce sang during the interludes and dance performances for Louis Van Amstel"s Ballroom with a Twist.[48] Karyn Saemann of Madison.com described Trenyce as "a truly gifted singer who did more than justice to several tunes", especially in her performances of Whitney Houston songs.[49]
Later in 2010, Trenyce joined the Michael Jackson tribute concert revueThriller – Live as the leading female vocalist during a European tour. She reprised her role when the show played at the Lyric Theatre in London's West End.[50] She starred in the concert for three years, from 2010 until 2013,[2] performing material from different periods in Jackson's career.[51] In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Trenyce said that the audience was initially hesitant to hear a woman interpret Jackson's music.[50]Theatreworld's Geoff Billingsley praised Trenyce's performance, writing that her voice sounded very similar to Jackson's and describing her as an improvement over the previous female lead Cleo Higgins.[52]
While in London, Trenyce also hosted the variety showThe Box.[53] In 2012, she provided the vocals for Baff Akoto's short film Afterglow about a group of friends who navigate jazz culture in London.[54][55] She had a minor role in the 2013 superhero, comedy filmKick-Ass 2 as Hit-Girl's cheerleading coach.[56] In December 2013, she released three songs: "Fever", "In the End (Alright)" and "Where Do They Go?" on iTunes.[57][58][59] The following year, she worked with producer DJ Guy Scheiman on his single "Brazil You're Ready (Synethetic)",[60] with remixes released in 2015.[61]
2015–present: Macau and other work
In 2015, Trenyce hosted Taboo, a cabaret show designed by Franco Dragone, in Macau, China. The show was staged in the casino City of Dreams; Trenyce was given creative control over the selection of musical genres and songs as long as they fit the cabaret's overall style. Macau.com praised Trenyce's stage presence and "the power of her voice and stature".[62][63] In 2016, Trenyce collaborated with DJ Guy Scheiman on his single "This Time".[64] From 2015 to 2017, Trenyce reprised her role in the West End production of Thriller – Live.[65] Reviewer Hannah Kerin praised Trenyce's performance of Jackson's 1987 single "The Way You Make Me Feel", calling it "show-stopping" and writing that it "stood out amidst many fantastic renditions of the hits and less well known material".[66]
In 2017, Trenyce starred in Heart & Soul: Music of Whitney Houston, Dionne Warwick & Diana Ross, promoted as part of "the Chris Isaacson Presents lineup of spring cabaret fare".[67] as one of "three sultry starlets".[68] She participated in the show during its stints at the Catalina Bar & Grill in Hollywood and Martinis Above Fourth in San Diego, California.[68][69] The same year, she volunteered in Karamu House, speaking to young girls and participating in its "Saving Our Daughters Cinderellas on Broadway" program;[70] she was named "Celebrity Godparent" for her work.[71]
Myers, Jared; Smith, Jared; Josephson, Erik; Meyers, Chris (2011). Your All-Access Pass to American Idol. Springville: Bonneville Books. ISBN978-1-59955-526-3.
Powers, John (2005). Sore Winners: American Idols, Patriotic Shoppers, and Other Strange Species in George Bush's America. New York: Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. ISBN1-4000-7655-2.
Jagodzinski, Jan (2005). Music in Youth Culture: A Lacanian Approach. New York: Springer. ISBN978-1-4039-6531-8.
Smith, Jon (2013). Finding Purple America: The South and the Future of American Cultural Studies. Athens: University of Georgia Press. ISBN978-0-8203-3321-2.
