After the back-to-back successes of Houston's "I Will Always Love You" and "I'm Every Woman", "I Have Nothing" became yet another hit, peaking at number four on the US Billboard Hot 100 and being certified double platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America. The song also became a hit on the Billboard Hot R&B Singles chart, with a number four peak, and a number-one peak on the Billboard Adult Contemporary chart. Houston established another historic milestone in Billboard chart history with the two previous singles off the soundtrack and this song, becoming the first artist to have three songs inside the top 11 of the Hot 100 chart in the same week since the chart began using Broadcast Data System and SoundScan data in 1991. Internationally, the song reached number one in Canada, the top five in Ireland and the United Kingdom, the top ten in Denmark and Portugal, and peaked within the top forty in Australia, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, and Switzerland. The song received various nominations, including for the Academy Award for Best Original Song, Grammy Award for Best Song Written for Visual Media, and Soul Train Music Award for Best R&B Single (Female).
As with much of Houston's material, the song has been an extremely popular choice on many reality television series around the world, in particular American Idol, on which it has become one of the most performed songs in the show's history; as of 2014, it had been covered eight times.[3] "I Have Nothing" was also featured on the second half of the trailer, for the estate-approved documentary on Houston's life, Whitney.
Background
"I Have Nothing" was co-written by then husband and wife team David Foster and Linda Thompson. In her 2016 memoirs, A Little Thing Called Life: On Loving Elvis Presley, Bruce Jenner, and Songs in Between, Thompson mentions that The Bodyguard director Mick Jackson approached her to write a song for the film. Thompson, who was in a relationship with Elvis Presley shortly before his death, revealed that the lyrics "Stay in my arms if you dare / Or must I imagine you there / Don't walk away from me" was inspired by her time with Presley. "Having lived with the very biggest rock star of all time, I had a good deal of experience to draw on while creating that lyric," Thompson recounts.[4]
Critical reception
Stephen Thomas Erlewine from AllMusic complimented the song as a "first-rate urban pop song that skillfully captures Houston at her best".[5]Larry Flick from Billboard called it a "booming power ballad". He added that it "has the same lung-bursting drama" as "I Will Always Love You", "tweaked with a quasi-symphonic climax that never fails to push all the right buttons. No need to predict single's future. Just count the minutes to its planting at No. 1."[6] Another Billboard editor, Chuck Taylor, in his writing about Britney Spears on October 24, 1998, issue, described "I Have Nothing" as "bombastic and ultra-challenging."[7] Jan DeKnock of Chicago Tribune said it is "yet another scorcher of a ballad" from the soundtrack.[8] Dave Sholin from the Gavin Report complimented Houston's "emotionally-charged performance".[9] In his weekly UK chart commentary, James Masterton wrote, "A classic ballad like the Whitney we used to know and love showing her voice off to best effect and making a deservedly high new entry."[10]
Howard Cohen from The Miami Herald remarked that Houston "soars effortlessly as she belts out the brass-inflected ballad".[11] James Montgomery of MTV said the song was "untouchable."[12] Alan Jones from Music Week declared it as "an emotionally charged rollercoaster of a song, giving Ms Houston another chance to display her range."[13] Nancy Culp from NME felt the "big ballad epic-ness" of "I Have Nothing" "calls for that kind of treatment."[14]Stephen Holden of The New York Times wrote that the song and "Run to You" are "booming generic ballads to which Houston applies her typical stentorian delivery."[15]James T. Jones IV of USA Today praised the song with "Run to You" as "thrilling ballads, powered by an operatic coloratura alto."[16]
In 2012, Porcys listed it at number 99 in their ranking of "100 Singles 1990-1999".[21] In 2017, ShortList's Dave Fawbert listed the song as containing "one of the greatest key changes in music history".[22]
Commercial performance
"I Have Nothing" was released as the third single from The Bodyguard Soundtrack in February 1993. The single debuted at number 42 on the US Billboard Hot 100 Singles chart, the issue date of February 27, 1993, when her two songs, "I Will Always Love You" and "I'm Every Woman" still placed within the top ten.[23] Remarkably, for the weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 chart ending March 13 and 20, Houston had three songs inside the top 11, making her the first artist to achieve the trifecta on the same week since 1991, when the Hot 100 using Broadcast Data System and SoundScan data.[24][25] On the Hot 100 Airplay chart, Houston equaled the feat with the aforementioned tracks on the February 27 and March 6 issues.[24][26] The song peaked at number four on the Hot 100 on the April 3 issue, becoming Houston's 14th top five hit, spending 20 weeks on the chart.[27] The single entered the Billboard Hot R&B Singles chart at number 37 on the February 27 issue and peaked at number four on the chart in the April 10 issue.[28][29] The song reached number one on the Billboard Hot Adult Contemporary chart the issue dated May 1, 1993, and remained there for two weeks, becoming her tenth number-one song on the chart.[30] It placed at number thirty and thirty-two on the Billboard Year-End Hot 100 and Hot R&B Singles charts respectively.[31] On the Cash Box pop singles charts, the song peaked at number one on the week of April 10, 1993.[32] On Cash Box's R&B chart, it peaked at number two behind Silk's "Freak Me" on the week of April 24 of 1993.[33] The single was certified Gold for shipments of 500,000 copies or more by the Recording Industry Association of America on June 1, 1993.[34] On March 11, 2019, it was certified platinum for shipments of 1 million copies or more by the Recording Industry Association of America and then, two years later, on what would've been Houston's 58th birthday, the song was certified double-platinum for sales of 2 million copies or more.[34]
In Canada, the song debuted at number 50 on the RPM Top 100 Hit Tracks chart on March 13, 1993,[35] and four weeks later reached the top ten.[36] In its eighth week of release, on May 1, 1993, the single topped the chart and spent three weeks at the summit, staying on the chart for 18 weeks.[37][38] The song entered the RPM Adult Contemporary Tracks chart at number 20 in the same week of its top 100 debut.[39] Within five weeks, it hit the pole position of the chart on April 17, 1993, and stayed on the top for six weeks.[40][41]
Worldwide, the song was a success but not as big as two previous singles from its parent soundtrack. In the United Kingdom, the single debuted at number nine on the UK Singles Chart on April 24, 1993, and the following week peaked at number three on the chart, making it Houston's ninth UK top five hit.[42][43] According to The Official Charts Company, the single sold 220,000 copies in the country.[44] It peaked at number four in Ireland,[45] number 16 in Belgium,[46] and number 20 in New Zealand.[47] The song also reached a peak of number 28 in Australia,[48] number 50 in France,[49] number 39 in Germany,[50] number 22 in the Netherlands,[51] and number 39 in Switzerland.[52]
Music video
A music video was produced to promote the single, directed by S. A. Baron. It depicts Houston performing the song to an audience in a dining room hall. The video is intercut with scenes from the film (The Bodyguard, the same thing for I Will Always Love You). It was later made available on Houston's official YouTube channel in November 2009, and has generated more than 885 million views as of November 2024, where it's her second most popular music video on YouTube after "I Will Always Love You".[53]
Live performances
Houston performing a medley of songs including "I Have Nothing" on the 21st American Music Awards on February 7, 1994.
Houston performed "I Have Nothing" at the 4th Billboard Music Awards on December 9, 1993, receiving a standing ovation.[54][55] Chris Willman of Los Angeles Times commented on the performance, saying "Houston's physically stationary, vocally mobile approach to the ballad―backlit behind the mike in a she-got-back-her-figure-flattering gown―effectively heightened the tune's diva dramaturgy, making it an easy highlight in a night otherwise short on compelling performances."[54] She also performed a rousing 10-minute-medley of show tunes that ended with the song―"I Loves You, Porgy" from Porgy and Bess, "And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going" from Dreamgirls, and "I Have Nothing"―at the 21st Annual American Music Awards, where she won the record eight awards, on February 7, 1994.[56] This performance was included in the 2014 CD/DVD release, Whitney Houston Live: Her Greatest Performances.[57]Jet magazine wrote about the AMA performance that "she [Houston] brought the house down with her soulful, stirring medley renditions."[58]
On November 12, 1994, Houston sang the song during the concert in Johannesburg, South Africa, entitled Whitney: The Concert for a New South Africa, telecast live via satellite on HBO.[59][60] The performance is found in VHS and DVD with the same title of the concert, originally released in December 1994, and later re-released on June 24, 2010.[61] The song was also performed on the concert to celebrate the wedding of Brunei royalty, at the Jerudong Park Garden on August 24, 1996.[62] Houston sang the short-edited version of the song along with "I Will Always Love You," which were followed by a standing ovation, at the 1st BET Awards on June 19, 2001, becoming the first artist ever to be given the Lifetime Achievement Award.[63][64]
Though "I Have Nothing" is one of Houston's notable hits during her career, the song was performed solely on The Bodyguard World Tour (1993–94) among her ten tours. Houston performed the song as the final part of a medley which included the aforementioned songs from Broadway shows on first North American leg of the tour in 1993, but since the European leg in 1993, the song was performed solely without two show tunes on almost all the rest of the tour dates. Four performances of the song on the South American leg of the tour (1994) were broadcast on each country's TV channel: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on January 23,[65]Santiago, Chile on April 14,[66]Buenos Aires, Argentina on April 16,[67] and Caracas, Venezuela on April 21.[68]
Cover versions
Official recording versions
Filipino singer Charice Pempengco recorded a version of the song on her debut release, the self-titled Charice EP released in May 2008.[69] Korean singer SunMin has a cover of the song on her mini album Cover Girl, released in Japan, August 2008.[70] The Italian variety TV show, Ti Lascio Una Canzone alumna Sonia Mosca covered the song on the compilation album Ti Lascio Una Canzone - La Compilation, released in May 2009.[71][72] In 2012, the song is performed on the TV musical series Glee in episode 17 of season 3, "Dance with Somebody", by Chris Colfer (as his character Kurt Hummel). The whole episode pays tribute to Whitney Houston and her music.[73]
Demonstration versions
Jessica Simpson recorded a version of the song as a demonstration when she was a teenager age. Britney Spears revealed on VH1's Behind the Music, originally aired on November 9, 2003, that she recorded a demonstration of the song before she was signed to Jive Records.[74][75] Spears also later sang the song at her Jive audition at the age of fifteen.[7]
Live cover versions
On behalf of Houston who had given birth to a daughter the three weeks before the ceremony, Natalie Cole crooned Houston's two nominated songs including "I Have Nothing" at the 65th Annual Academy Awards on March 29, 1993.[76][77][78]
Patti LaBelle performed the song as a tribute to Whitney Houston, the first ever recipient of the Triumphant Spirit Award at the 10th annual Essence Awards, taped on April 4, 1997, and broadcast later on Fox TV, May 22, 1997.[80][81]
^I Have Nothing (EU 7" Vinyl Single). Whitney Houston. Europe: Arista Records. 1993. 74321 14158 7.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^I Have Nothing (Japanese 3" CD Single). Whitney Houston. Japan: BMG (Japan). 1993. BVDA-63.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^I Have Nothing (UK 7" Vinyl Single). Whitney Houston. United Kingdom: Arista Records. 1993. 74321 141147.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^I Have Nothing (US Maxi-CD Single). Whitney Houston. United States: Arista Records. 1993. 07822-12527-2.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^I Have Nothing (EU Maxi-CD Single). Whitney Houston. Europe: Arista Records. 1993. 74321 14158 2.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^I Have Nothing (UK Maxi-CD Single). Whitney Houston. United Kingdom: Arista Records. 1993. 14158-2.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^I Have Nothing (UK CD Single). Whitney Houston. United Kingdom: Arista Records. 1993. 74321 14614 2.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
^The Bodyguard: Original Soundtrack Album (CD album). Whitney Houston. Arista Records. 1992. 07822-18699-2.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
