The Woman-Identified Woman

"The Woman-Identified Woman" was a ten-paragraph manifesto, written by the Radicalesbians in 1970.[1] It was first distributed during the Lavender Menace protest at the Second Congress to Unite Women, hosted by the National Organization for Women (NOW) on May 1, 1970, in New York City in response to the lack of lesbian representation at the congress.[2] It is now considered a turning point in the history of radical feminism and one of the founding documents of lesbian feminism redefining the term "lesbian" as a political identity as well as a sexual one.

It was written by a group of lesbian radical feminists who formed the group Radicalesbians or, originally, the Lavender Menace. The authors consisted of Artemis March, Lois Hart, Rita Mae Brown, Ellen Shumsky, Cynthia Funk, and Barbara XX. It was edited by Artemis March. A group of lesbian radical feminists staged a "zap" for the opening session of the Congress, during which they cut the lights, took over the stage and microphone and denounced the exclusion of lesbian speakers at the Congress. They distributed mimeographed copies of "The Woman-Identified Woman", in which they argued that lesbians are at the forefront of the struggle for women's liberation because their identification with other women defies traditional definitions of women's identity in terms of male sexual partners, and expressed, "...the primacy of women relating to women, of women creating a new consciousness of and with each other which is at the heart of women's liberation, and the basis for the cultural revolution." At the following NOW conference, held in New York City in September 1971, the Congress adopted a resolution acknowledging the rights of lesbians as a "legitimate concern for feminism".[3]

Background

Prior to the release of the “Woman-Identified Woman” manifesto, the gay liberation and women’s liberation movements were primarily separated. Members of the Lavender Menace came from both the Gay Liberation Front and National Organization for Women and, prompting the formation of their own group, had experienced sexism and homophobia respectively from the organizations.[4] The name of the group, in fact, came from the leader of NOW, Betty Friedan, referring to lesbian feminists as a “lavender menace” distracting from the core of the movement.[5] It was the general sentiment of many feminists at the time that lesbianism was a private and personal matter that shouldn’t be mentioned in a public sense and had no place in their discussions.[6] It was this attitude of fellow feminists that thus prompted their organization and the manifesto demanding their inclusion.

Responses

The reception immediately following the zap from attendants of the NOW conference was largely positive and prompted immediate action towards inclusion of lesbians at the conference.[7][8] This manifested in the form of events added to the program like a workshop of heterosexism as well as congress resolutions as proposed by the Lavender Menace. Those at the conference recall the zap as exciting and the energy of the conference following as empowering.[8] In recollection of the zap, one attendant called it "funny and wonderful" while another noted the members' "wit and vaudevillian charm" in the performative zap.[8]

Outside of the conference, however, reactions were more mixed. More conservative lesbian newsletters at the time such as Lesbian Tide and The Ladder rejected the notions of the manifesto and saw it too radical. Other lesbians rejected the woman-identified label expressing their discomfort in it blurring lines of heterosexual and homosexual women and, despite the stigma surrounding the name, instead opted to embrace and reclaim “lesbian” itself. Another newsletter, Lavender Woman, asserts themselves as “lesbian-identified lesbians” not believing in the comradery with straight women and viewing the women-identified label as a joke.[6]

Impacts

Lesbian Advocacy

The manifesto was critical of the potentially regressive nature of the feminist movements in the 1970s, namely neglecting the significance of lesbian voices and the importance of incorporating lesbian ideals in the construction of feminist movements. At its publication in the 1970s, it was seen as a pioneer of lesbianism advocacy in feminist political theories.

The delivery of the manifesto was a watershed moment during the period of second-wave feminism. The primary focus of the period was gender inequality in law and culture. The Radicalesbians argued that mere opposition to patriarchy in American society would be ineffective and inefficient to bring about the triumph of feminism, due to the sheer dominance of patriarchy.

The manifesto points out that, although changes have occurred in American society for women, these changes are superficial, nominal displays presented to cope with the rising tide of feminism. The manifesto claims the overt political actions of "liberating women" are overshadowed by the covertly oppressive civil actions of men. It also questions the validity of the core ideals of feminism and feminist movements and alerted feminists to the threat of passive feminine argument.[9]

The manifesto established the foundation for lesbians in feminist politics. This inclusion of lesbians in feminism was formal in the form of pacts written between NOW and the Lavender Menace and informal in the transformed community now more eager to learn.[5][8] It triggered a ripple effect leading to the emergence of lesbian literature along with feminist writings that further shaped other radical and controversial theories.[10]

Woman-Identified and Political Lesbians

One of the central grievances of the text is women's inability to self-identify; they are instead being prescribed suppressive sexist and heteronormative roles. This view of females, the authors argued, served only to keep a woman down, "poisoning her existence, keeping her alienated from herself, her own needs, and rendering her a stranger to other women."[11][12]

Thus, this manifesto introduced the concept of being “woman-identified” which many feminists embraced for themselves as a sign of unified identification between straight women and lesbian women. This pushed the recognition of lesbian issues as simply women’s issues. Moreover, as the manifesto presented being a lesbian as the ultimate rejection of the patriarchy, many women took these ideas and considered themselves political lesbians with the sense they wanted to live with women separated from male society but did not have a sexual attraction to women.[13][14] Resulting from this was categorization of realesbians, who were sexually attracted to women, and political lesbians, who simply embraced the ideology.[15]

Limitations

Despite connecting the issues of homophobia and sexism, the manifesto did not extend to racial oppression. Some black women activists, especially those engaging in mixed-gender civil rights activism, critiqued the separatism of the manifesto as men weren’t seen as the ultimate source of all their oppression.[16] This lack of racial recognition is something women involved in the movement have also discerned in interviews looking back on their activism.[15]

Additionally, there were some unintended effects of the release of the Woman-Identified Woman manifesto and subsequent movement as feminists were increasingly associated with and, many times, interchangeable with lesbians. Scholars have suggested the manifesto was coopted by antifeminists such as Phyllis Schlafly primarily in the efforts to rally against the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). In pushing the image of ERA supporters, feminists, as man-hating lesbians, they thus mobilized the country’s homophobia.[16]

Full text online

References

  1. ^ Faderman, Lillian (2015). The Gay Revolution: The Story of the Struggle. Simon & Schuster.
  2. ^ Weiss, Penny (2018). Feminist Manifestos : A Global Documentary Reader (1 ed.). New York University Press. pp. 221–222. ISBN 9781479805419.
  3. ^ Iovannone, Jeffry J. (2018-06-04). "Rita Mae Brown: Lavender Menace". Queer History For the People. Retrieved 2019-02-11.
  4. ^ Gianoulis, Tina. “Woman-Identified Woman.” (2015).
  5. ^ a b Burke, Leo J. "Lavender Menace." Women in American History: A Social, Political, and Cultural Encyclopedia and Document Collection, edited by Peg A. Lamphier and Rosanne Welch, vol. 4: Cold War America to today, ABC-CLIO, 2017, pp. 166-167. Gale eBooks, link.gale.com/apps/doc/CX7268100842/GVRL?u=umuser&sid=bookmark-GVRL&xid=39078dc0. Accessed 3 Dec. 2023.
  6. ^ a b Samek, Alyssa A. (2015-10-02). "Pivoting Between Identity Politics and Coalitional Relationships: Lesbian-Feminist Resistance to the Woman-Identified Woman". Women's Studies in Communication. 38 (4): 393–420. doi:10.1080/07491409.2015.1085938. ISSN 0749-1409.
  7. ^ Weiss, Penny (2018). Feminist Manifestos : A Global Documentary Reader (1 ed.). New York University Press. pp. 221–222. ISBN 978-1-4798-0541-9
  8. ^ a b c d Warner, Sara (2012-10-26). Acts of Gaiety: LGBT Performance and the Politics of Pleasure. University of Michigan Press. ISBN 978-0-472-11853-3
  9. ^ "Examining "The Woman-Identified Woman"". prezi.com. Retrieved 2019-01-25.
  10. ^ Bindel, Julie (2009-01-30). "Julie Bindel on political lesbianism". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2019-01-25.
  11. ^ Summers, Ian (April 2014). "Birth of the Militant Queer Identity: Analyzing The Woman-Identified Woman and Queers Read This". Utah Foreign Language Review. 21: 9–29. ISSN 2165-4905. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
  12. ^ "The Woman-Identified Woman / Women's Liberation Movement Print Culture / Duke Digital Repository". Duke Digital Collections. Retrieved 2019-02-11.
  13. ^ Kristan Poirot (2009) Domesticating the Liberated Woman: Containment Rhetorics of Second Wave Radical/Lesbian Feminism, Women's Studies in Communication, 32:3, 263-292, DOI: 10.1080/07491409.2009.10162391
  14. ^ "Radicalesbians." Awake & Move, vol. 1, no. 2, Mar. 1971, p. 4. Archives of Sexuality and Gender, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/FWCDBI961652207/AHSI?sid=bookmark-AHSI&xid=96c735d6. Accessed 3 Dec. 2023.
  15. ^ a b Dulle, Claire. (2020). "Women's Liberation is a Lesbian Plot": How the Radicalesbians used their manifesto and zap to redefine the term "lesbian".. 10.13140/RG.2.2.15359.07844.
  16. ^ a b Helen Tate (2005) The Ideological Effects of a Failed Constitutive Rhetoric: The Co-option of the Rhetoric of White Lesbian Feminism, Women's Studies in Communication, 28:1, 1-31, DOI: 10.1080/07491409.2005.10162482

Sources

Read other articles:

この記事には参考文献や外部リンクの一覧が含まれていますが、脚注による参照が不十分であるため、情報源が依然不明確です。適切な位置に脚注を追加して、記事の信頼性向上にご協力ください。(2020年1月) 台湾電力5号形蒸気機関車は、かつて日本統治時代の台湾で台湾電力が使用したタンク式蒸気機関車である。なお、この名称は、台湾電力では形式を付与してい

 

River in the United States of America Tugaloo RiverBank of the Tugaloo River at Lake Hartwell near the Tugaloo State Park campgroundLocationCountryUnited StatesStatesGeorgia, South CarolinaPhysical characteristicsSourceChattooga River • locationCashiers, North Carolina • coordinates35°07′08″N 83°07′05″W / 35.119°N 83.118°W / 35.119; -83.118 • elevation1,187 m (3,894 ft) 2nd sourceTallulah River&...

 

Ієронімо Санчес де Карранза ісп. Jerónimo Sánchez de Carranza порт. Hieronimo de Carança Народження 1539-місце Севілья, Кастильська КоронаСмерть 1600-місце Мадрид, ІспаніяГромадянство ІспаніяСтиль ДестрезаЗвання Перший в науці поводження зі зброєюДосягнення творець іспанської школи фехтуван�...

Edisi IIAlbum studio karya AlexaDirilis1 Agustus 2010GenrePop RockLabelWarner Music IndonesiaKronologi Alexa Alexa (2008) Alexa: Special Edition (2009)Alexa2008 Edisi II (2010) Dulu, Kemarin, Sekarang (2015) Singel dalam album Edisi II Andai Dulu, Kemarin, Sekarang2015 Edisi II adalah album kedua dari grup musik Indonesia, Alexa yang dirilis pada tahun 2010. Berisikan 13 buah lagu dengan lagu Andai sebagai hits singel album ini. Daftar lagu Selagi Ku Mampu Andai Separuh Jiwaku Selalu Kuke...

 

مورنان تقسيم إداري البلد إيران  إحداثيات 32°41′28″N 51°47′10″E / 32.6911°N 51.7861°E / 32.6911; 51.7861  تعديل مصدري - تعديل   مورنان هي قرية في مقاطعة أصفهان، إيران. عدد سكان هذه القرية هو 413 في سنة 2006.[1] مراجع ^ تعداد سكان جمهورية إيران الإسلامية، 1385 / 2006. جمهورية إيران ال�...

 

Untuk kegunaan lain, lihat Virus (disambiguasi). Untuk artikel yang bersifat nonteknis dan lebih mudah dimengerti, silakan lihat pengantar tentang virus Virus Rekonstruksi partikel Rotavirus menggunakan komputer. Klasifikasi virus Dunia[1] Duplodnaviria Monodnaviria Riboviria Varidnaviria Virus adalah mikroorganisme patogen yang hanya dapat bereplikasi di dalam sel karena mereka tidak memiliki perlengkapan seluler untuk bereproduksi sendiri. Semua bentuk kehidupan dapat diinfeksi oleh...

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Jordan et Camille Jordan. Camille JordanCamille Jordan.FonctionsPrésidentAcadémie des sciences1er janvier - 31 décembre 1916Edmond PerrierArsène d'ArsonvalPrésident de la Société mathématique de France1879Pierre-Ossian BonnetEdmond LaguerrePrésident de la Société mathématique de France1879Camille JordanEdmond LaguerreBiographieNaissance 5 janvier 1838LyonDécès 21 janvier 1922 (à 84 ans)7e arrondissement de ParisNationalité FrançaisF...

 

Annie BesantAnnie BesantLahir(1847-10-01)1 Oktober 1847Clapham, London, InggrisMeninggal20 September 1933(1933-09-20) (umur 85)Adyar, Kepresidenan Madras, British IndiaDikenal atasTeosofis, hak asasi manusia aktivis, penulis dan oratorSuami/istriFrank Besant(m. 1867, bercerai 1873)AnakArthur, Mabel Annie Besant (1 Oktober 1847 – 20 September 1933) adalah seorang sosialis, teosofis, aktivis hak asasi wanita, penulis dan orator dan pendukung kemerdekaan Irlandia dan India. ...

 

جزء من سلسلة مقالات سياسة سلطنة عمانسلطنة عمان جامعة الدول العربية آل بو سعيد قائمة سلاطين عمان هيثم حكومة سلطنة عمان مجلس سلطنة عمان مجلس الدولة العماني مجلس الشورى العماني سياسة عمان التقسيمات الإدارية مناطق ومحافظات سلطنة عمان ولايات عمان علاقات سلطنة عمان الخارجية و�...

2011 action thriller film by Alister Grierson SanctumTheatrical release posterDirected byAlister GriersonWritten by John Garvin Andrew Wight Produced byAndrew WightStarring Richard Roxburgh Rhys Wakefield Alice Parkinson Dan Wyllie Ioan Gruffudd CinematographyJules O'LoughlinEdited byMark WarnerMusic byDavid HirschfelderProductioncompanies Relativity Media Wayfare Entertainment FilmNation Entertainment Distributed byUniversal PicturesRelease dates 3 February 2011 (2011-02-03)&#...

 

This list is incomplete; you can help by adding missing items. (August 2008) Oliver Stephenson, High Sheriff of Derbyshire, at the Derby Book Festival in 2015 This is a list of Sheriffs of Derbyshire from 1567 until 1974 and High Sheriffs since. The ancient Sheriff title originating in the time of the Angles, not long after the invasion of the Kingdom of England, which was in existence for around a thousand years. On 1 April 1974, under the provisions of the Local Government Act 1972, the tit...

 

Брак в Дре́внем Ри́ме считался священным таинством и опорой государства[1]. Большинство браков в богатых семьях Древнего Рима заключалось по расчёту[1]: для продолжения рода (лат. matrimonium — «брак», от лат. mater — «мать»), для объединения владений, а также дл�...

Railway station in Essex, England PitseaGeneral informationLocationPitsea, Borough of BasildonEnglandCoordinates51°33′36″N 0°30′22″E / 51.560°N 0.506°E / 51.560; 0.506Grid referenceTQ738875Managed byc2cPlatforms4Other informationStation codePSEClassificationDfT category C2HistoryOriginal companyLondon, Tilbury and Southend RailwayPre-groupingMidland RailwayPost-groupingLondon, Midland and Scottish RailwayKey dates1 July 1855Opened as Pitsea1 June 1888Re-sit...

 

ポータル クラシック音楽 フェデリコ・モレーノ・トローバ フェデリコ・モレーノ・トローバ(左) 右はオペラ歌手のプラシド・ドミンゴ。基本情報原語名 Federico Moreno Torroba出身地 スペイン、マドリード死没 (1982-09-12) 1982年9月12日(91歳没)ジャンル クラシック職業 指揮者、作曲家 フェデリコ・モレーノ・トローバ(Federico Moreno Torroba, 1891年3月3日 マドリード - 198...

 

Lee–Hines FieldLocationBaton Rouge, Louisiana, United StatesCoordinates30°31′15″N 91°11′02″W / 30.5209475°N 91.1838949°W / 30.5209475; -91.1838949OwnerSouthern UniversityOperatorSouthern UniversityCapacity1,500SurfaceNatural grassScoreboardElectronicOpened1992TenantsSouthern Jaguars baseball (NCAA) (1992–present) Lee–Hines Field is a baseball stadium in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. It is the home field of the Southern Jaguars baseball team.[1] Tour...

Irish Roman Catholic bishop (1933–2018) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Fiachra Ó Ceallaigh – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Styles ofFiachra Ó CeallaighReference styleThe Most ReverendSpoken styleYour GraceR...

 

Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: Laba Laba – berita · surat kabar · buku · cendekiawan · JSTOR Laba Labakompilasi (singel) karya Anggun C. SasmiDirilis1989-1990Direkam1989GenreHard Rock, Pop metal, Rock 'n' roll, Bala...

 

 Nota: Se procura outros significados de Mariano Procópio, veja Mariano Procópio (desambiguação). Esta página cita fontes, mas que não cobrem todo o conteúdo. Ajude a inserir referências. Conteúdo não verificável pode ser removido.—Encontre fontes: ABW  • CAPES  • Google (N • L • A) (Janeiro de 2024) Museu Mariano Procópio Museu Mariano ProcópioInterior do museu Tipo Artes Inauguração 1915 Website pjf.mg.gov.b...

Late Elizabethan mansion in Somerset, UK Montacute HouseThe garden facadeLocationMontacute, SomersetCoordinates50°57′09″N 2°42′58″W / 50.95250°N 2.71611°W / 50.95250; -2.71611, Listed Building – Grade I National Register of Historic Parks and Gardens Location of Montacute House in Somerset Montacute House is a late Elizabethan mansion in Montacute, South Somerset, England. An example of English architecture created during a period that was moving from the...

 

Paghimo ni bot Lsjbot. 46°20′58″N 91°49′06″W / 46.34939°N 91.81824°W / 46.34939; -91.81824 Lucius Woods State Park Parke Nasod  Tinipong Bansa Estado Wisconsin Kondado Douglas County Gitas-on 330 m (1,083 ft) Tiganos 46°20′58″N 91°49′06″W / 46.34939°N 91.81824°W / 46.34939; -91.81824 Timezone CST (UTC-6)  - summer (DST) CDT (UTC-5) GeoNames 5261244 Parke ang Lucius Woods State Park sa Tinipong Bansa...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!