Joo Koon rail accident

Joo Koon rail accident
Joo Koon MRT Station, where the accident occurred at the platform towards Tuas Link.
Details
Date	15 November 2017; 7 years ago (2017-11-15) approximately 8.30 a.m. (SST)
Location	Joo Koon MRT station
Coordinates	1°19′39.86″N 103°40′42.55″E
Country	Singapore
Line	East–West MRT line
Operator	SMRT Trains Ltd (SMRT Corporation)
Incident type	Signalling bubble disable, Software failure in CBTC signalling system resulting in collision between two trains[1] and track circuit failure
Cause	Software-related issue
Statistics
Trains	2 Kawasaki-Sifang C151A trains
Passengers	517[2]
Deaths	0
Injured	38 (including 2 crew)[3]

The Joo Koon rail accident, sometimes referred to as the Joo Koon train collision, was a crash which happened on 15 November 2017, when a C151A train travelling at 16 kilometres per hour (9.9 mph) rear-ended a stationary C151A train at Joo Koon station on the East–West MRT line, resulting in 38 injuries.^[2][3] The stationary train was in the process of being detrained due to a train fault. Both trains were operating under the recently installed Thales SelTrac CBTC signalling system at the time of incident, and the Minister of Transport Khaw Boon Wan expressed that he was "disturbed" by an initial finding that "critical safety software" was inadvertently removed from the stationary train, possibly due to a malfunctioning signalling circuit, which led to the crash.^[4] This incident is the second train collision in Singapore MRT's history, after the Clementi rail accident.

Background

The East–West MRT line, at the time of the incident, was in the transition process between the older Westinghouse ATC fixed block signalling and the newer Thales Group SelTrac CBTC moving block signalling.^[4] Both systems are in use on the same line, but only the newer CBTC signalling equipment was available for the Tuas West Extension between Joo Koon and Tuas Link.^[4][5] As a result, trains are required to switch from the Westinghouse signalling to the Thales signalling at Pioneer prior to heading towards Tuas Link, and vice versa in the other direction.^[5]

There were previous high-profile train disruptions in June 2017 during the testing phase on the North–South MRT line, when it was transitioning to the Thales SelTrac CBTC.^[5] Those incidents were found to be a result of human error when new software was being installed.^[5] Before this crash, SMRT had originally scheduled full-line testing of Thales CBTC to begin on the East West Line in December 2017.^[5]

Incident

The first train, a Kawasaki-Sifang C151A bound for Tuas Link, had to be removed from service due to a train fault at 8.18am caused by a separate signalling fault.^[1][6] The second train, another C151A, bound for the same terminus, stopped behind the first train while the automatic platform gate was manually overridden to allow the detrainment of the first train.^[1][6] The second train had 517 passengers on board.^[2] As the doors of the first train were closed, the second train suddenly accelerated to a speed of 16 km/h and rear-ended the first train.^[2] Witnesses outside the train reported hearing a loud bang.^[7] The collision resulted in 38 injuries, including two SMRT Trains staff members.^[2] Many of the injuries resulted from passengers losing their balance and impacting the floor or fixtures, and ranged from vomiting to a broken tooth.^[2][7] The injured passengers and staff were treated at National University Hospital and Ng Teng Fong General Hospital.^[3]

Response and investigation

Reactions

The collision increased public anger and pressure on both SMRT Corporation and Land Transport Authority (LTA),^[8] in light of a major tunnel flooding incident weeks prior, which resulted in a discovery that SMRT maintenance workers had failed to perform the necessary maintenance work on its pumps and had falsified records.^[9] Both organizations described the collision as one train "coming into contact" with another train in their initial media releases. The statements drew controversy, and were seen by some as an attempt to downplay the incident.^[10][11] A later statement by the LTA referred to the incident as a collision.^[10]

The Singapore Democratic Party called for transport minister Khaw Boon Wan to resign, while the Workers Party asked for a full investigation.^[12] Prime Minister of Singapore Lee Hsien Loong admitted that both the tunnel flooding and the Joo Koon accident "hurt public confidence a lot."^[9] Despite the incidents, PM Lee insisted that Singapore's public transport remains "first class".^[9]

Transport minister Khaw initially apologized to the commuters involved.^[13] Later, Khaw expressed that he was "disturbed" by an initial finding that "critical safety software" was inadvertently removed from the stationary train, possibly due to a malfunctioning signalling circuit, which led to the accident.^[4]

Investigation

A preliminary investigation held jointly between SMRT Trains, Land Transport Authority, and Thales found that the first train had a safety protection feature removed when it went over a faulty signalling circuit.^[6] That safety protection feature was designed to fix a known bug which wrongly designated the six-car train as a three-car train under certain degraded modes, such as when the two onboard computers in the train's Thales CBTC system are unable to communicate with each other.^[6]

While the first train was being detrained and the automatic platform doors were opened, a separate protection module was activated to block off the entire length of the platform at Joo Koon station.^[14][15] The module notified the second train's signalling computer that the Joo Koon station's westbound platform was occupied and to stay clear of the platform.^[6][14] The second train stopped at the correct distance behind the first train while the automatic platform doors were open. However, once the doors were closed, the platform length protection module was removed. When the signalling on the second train detected the first train as only three cars instead of six, it started moving to close the perceived gap between both trains for the distance of three cars, thus allowing the acceleration of the second train and the rear-end collision with the first train.^[6] SMRT later explained that when the first train was detraining at the platform, a signal was given off to show that the platform was occupied. However, when the platform screen doors closed, the protection was then removed, allowing the second train to hit the first.^[16]

Aftermath

Temporary suspension of service

Following the incident, SMRT announced that services on the Tuas West Extension (TWE) would be suspended on 16 November 2017 for safety checks on the signalling system. This was then extended to 20 November 2017, when SMRT announced that the TWE would reopen but operate separately from the rest of the line for at least a month. Eastbound trains from Tuas Link would terminate at Gul Circle, while westbound trains from Pasir Ris would terminate at Joo Koon,^[17] allowing the two different signalling systems to be isolated until a solution was found.^[17] Service between Gul Circle and Joo Koon was suspended on that date and free bus bridging services became available. On 21 November 2017, in a media statement made by Transport Minister Khaw, SMRT and LTA announced that services between Gul Circle and Joo Koon would be further suspended until mid-2018, when signalling upgrades on the remainder of the line are expected to be completed, to prevent another collision in the future.^[18] Services between Gul Circle and Joo Koon resumed on 28 May 2018 after the entire EWL transitioned to the CBTC signalling system.^[19]

Early closure on NSEWL

Following the investigation, SMRT announced that operation hours on the NSEWL would be reduced to facilitate more maintenance works and the complete transition to the CBTC signalling system. Starting from 8 December 2017 to 31 December 2017, 17 stations on the East–West Line from Tiong Bahru to Tuas Link and two stations on the North–South Line from Bukit Batok to Bukit Gombak would close early at 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays, while the opening will be delayed to 8 a.m. on Saturdays and Sundays, and stations were closed throughout the day on Sundays (10 & 17 December 2017).^[20] A second round of closures planned for January 2018 would affect the line from Paya Lebar to Pasir Ris and Changi Airport.^[21] In the final round of closures, all stations on the East–West Line would close earlier at 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays and open later on Saturdays and Sundays throughout the month, with two days having even earlier closing times. This was to facilitate additional maintenance works along the line as it switches over to the new CBTC signalling system.^[22]

Subsequent maintenance works

It was announced on 1 January 2018 that sections of NSEWL were to conduct facilitation of maintenance works with stations closing earlier and opening later on weekends starting with the East-West Line stretch, with the exception of weekends with public holidays. Thereafter, sections of NSEWL were to do the same in a month or two to mitigate such incidents.^[23]

See also

• Shanghai Metro Line 10 Rail Accident, 2011 collision between two trains involving CBTC signalling during testing phase resulting in 271 injuries
• Pasir Ris rail accident, a fatal accident where a train struck track maintenance workers
• Tsuen Wan line accident, a non-fatal accident involving CBTC testing by MTR Corporation

References

1. "LTA statement in full: Software failure behind Joo Koon collision". Land Transport Authority. Today (online). 15 November 2017. Archived from the original on 17 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
2. "517 passengers on the moving train in Joo Koon collision". Channel NewsAsia. 16 November 2017. Archived from the original on 17 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
3. "Joo Koon train collision: Total number of injured rises to 38". Channel NewsAsia. 19 November 2017. Archived from the original on 19 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
4. Chai Chin, Neo. "Joo Koon MRT collision: Faulty train was transiting between old and new signalling systems". Today (newspaper). Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
5. Kotwani, Monica (14 July 2017). "North-South Line signalling system to take up to 6 months to stabilise". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 19 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
6. Lim, Adrian (16 November 2017). "Joo Koon collision: 'Inadvertent removal' of software fix led to collision". Straits Times. Archived from the original on 17 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
7. Tan, Tam Mei (16 November 2017). "Joo Koon train collision: Some passengers cried and there was vomit in the train, says witness". Straits Times. Archived from the original on 16 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
8. "28 injured in Singapore metro train collision". South China Morning Post. 15 November 2017. Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
9. Choo, Cynthia (19 November 2017). "MRT incidents have hurt public confidence: PM Lee". Today (newspaper). Archived from the original on 22 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
10. Tan, Christopher (16 November 2017). "Joo Koon collision: Signal failure hits confidence". Straits Times. Archived from the original on 19 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
11. "Your views: Aftermath of the Joo Koon train collision". Channel NewsAsia. 19 November 2017. Archived from the original on 19 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
12. Choo, Cynthia (16 November 2017). "Joo Koon collision points to systems 'failure', WP says in calling for 'exhaustive' checks". Today (newspaper). Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
13. Kotwani, Monica (15 November 2017). "Khaw Boon Wan apologises to commuters affected by Joo Koon train collision". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 17 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
14. Ong, Justin (15 November 2017). "SMRT train collision at Joo Koon due to 'inadvertent' removal of software protection feature". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 17 November 2017. Retrieved 19 November 2017.
15. Chia, Lianne (21 November 2017). "2 full-day shutdowns, shorter operating hours for 19 NSEWL MRT stations in December: LTA, SMRT". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 26 November 2017. Retrieved 21 November 2017.
16. Lim, Adrian (22 November 2017). "Protective 'bubbles' became disabled, causing collision". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 24 November 2017. Retrieved 22 November 2017.
17. "Joo Koon collision: Tuas West Extension train services suspended until Sunday for further checks". Channel NewsAsia. 16 November 2017. Archived from the original on 16 November 2017. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
18. "Joo Koon-Gul Circle link to remain closed till mid-2018". Straits Times. 22 November 2017. Archived from the original on 23 November 2017. Retrieved 22 November 2017.
19. Tan, Christopher (28 May 2018). "East-West Line running on new signalling system now – all the way to Tuas West and back". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 8 July 2018. Retrieved 8 July 2018.
20. "2 full-day shutdowns, shorter operating hours for 19 NSEWL MRT stations in December: LTA, SMRT". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 21 November 2017. Retrieved 22 November 2017.
21. "Sunday closures, shorter weekend service hours on another part of East-West Line in January". Archived from the original on 19 December 2017. Retrieved 21 December 2017.
22. "shorter operating hours on east west line". Archived from the original on 20 January 2018. Retrieved 20 January 2018.
23. "Shortened Operational Hours for January to Continue Until First Weekend of February, Shortened Operational Hours in March Along All 35 East – West Line MRT Stations". Archived from the original on 10 July 2021. Retrieved 19 January 2018.