Local currency

In economics, a local currency is a currency that can be spent in a particular geographical locality at participating organisations. A regional currency is a form of local currency encompassing a larger geographical area, while a community currency might be local or be used for exchange within an online community. A local currency acts as a complementary currency to a national currency, rather than replacing it,^[1] and aims to encourage spending within a local community, especially with locally owned businesses.^[2] Such currencies may not be backed by a national government nor be legal tender.^[2] About 300 complementary currencies, including local currencies, are listed in the Complementary Currency Resource Center worldwide database.^[3]

Terminology

Some definitions:

• Complementary currency - is used as a complement to a national currency,^[4] as a medium of exchange, which is usually not legal tender.^[5]: 2
• Community currency - a complementary currency used by a group with a common bond, such as residents of a locality, association, or members of a business or online community.
• Local currency - a complementary currency used in a locality.^[2]
• Regional currency - a local currency where the locality is a larger region.
• Auxiliary currency, microcurrency, Eco-Money - less common synonyms for community or local currency. (see for example Douthwaite & Wagman 1999)
• Private currency - a currency issued by an individual, business or non-governmental organization. Complementary currencies are a type of private currency.^[6]
• Sectoral currency - a complementary currency used within one economic sector, such as education or health care.
• Alternative currency - generally, a synonym for complementary currency, referring to a currency designed to work in conjunction with the national currency; less often refers to a type of private currency which attempts to supplant or circumvent the national currency.

Purpose

Local currencies aim at using money as a tool to achieve social or environmental objectives. According to the New Economics Foundation partner Community Currencies in Action:^[1]

... money is simply a social technology and the ways in which it is designed, produced and controlled – far from being neutral or predetermined factors – all influence the effects it has upon society at large.

— People Powered Money: designing, developing and delivering community currencies.

Some of the purposes for community currencies identified by Community Currencies in Action^[1] include:

• Democratizing services and organisations: time credits for volunteering encourage people to actively engage in their community while making services, such as elderly care, more democratic. Zeitvorsoge,^[1] Makkie^[1]
• Supporting small and medium enterprises: Community currencies can serve as a means to promote independent shops over large corporations since they keep on circulating locally. They can also help SMEs support each other financially by lending and receiving credit, goods and services within the currency network. Examples are: Bristol Pound, SoNantes,^[7] TradeQoin,^[8] Chiemgauer
• Countering inequality and social exclusion: Specially designed currencies can address inequality issues by giving everyone the chance to get involved in their community; for instance by rewarding participation in voluntary programs. (Spice Time Credits,^[9] Makkie)
• Addressing environmental impacts: Community currencies can play a role in better valuation of environmental resources and providing an incentive for more sustainable behavior. For example, the Belgian Portemonnee rewards residents for environmentally positive actions such as composting. Reward currencies can also encourage businesses to adopt more environmentally sound practices.
• Maintaining the purchasing power, value preservation. Example: Convertible Minute / Minutes Bank

Benefits

The Wörgl experiment illustrates some of the common characteristics and major benefits of local currencies.^[10]

1. Local currencies with negative interest rate or demurrage tend to circulate much more rapidly than national currencies. The same amount of currency in circulation is employed more times and results in far greater overall economic activity. It produces greater benefit per unit. The higher velocity of money is a result of the negative interest rate which encourages people to spend the money more quickly.
2. Local currencies enable the community to more fully use its existing productive resources, especially unemployed labor, which has a catalytic effect on the rest of the local economy. They are based on the premise that the community is not fully using its productive capacities, because of a lack of local purchasing power. The alternative currency is used to increase demand, resulting in a greater exploitation of productive resources. So long as the local economy is functioning at less than full capacity, the introduction of local currency need not be inflationary, even when it results in a significant increase in total money supply and total economic activity.
3. Since local currencies are only accepted within the community, their usage encourages the purchase of locally produced and locally-available goods and services. Thus, for any level of economic activity, more of the benefit accrues to the local community and less drains out to other parts of the country or the world. For instance, construction work undertaken with local currencies employs local labor and uses as far as possible local materials. The enhanced local effect becomes an incentive for the local population to accept and use the scrips.
4. Some forms of complementary currency can promote fuller use of resources over a much wider geographic area and help bridge the barriers imposed by distance. The Fureai kippu system in Japan issues credits in exchange for assistance to senior citizens. Family members living far from their parents can earn credits by offering assistance to the elderly in their local community. The credits can then be transferred to their parents and redeemed by them for local assistance. Airline frequent flyer miles are a form of complementary currency that promotes customer-loyalty in exchange for free travel. The airlines offer most of the coupons for seats on less heavily sold flights where some seats normally go empty, thus providing a benefit to customers at relatively low cost to the airline.
5. While most of these currencies are restricted to a small geographic area or a country, through the Internet electronic forms of complementary currency can be used to stimulate transactions on a global basis. In China, Tencent's QQ coins are a virtual form of currency that has gained wide circulation. QQ coins can be bought for Renminbi and used to buy virtual products and services such as ringtones and on-line video game time. They can also be obtained through on-line exchange for goods and services at about twice the Renminbi price, by which additional 'money' is being directly created. Though virtual currencies are not 'local' in the traditional sense, they do cater to the specific needs of a particular community, a virtual community. Once in circulation, they add to the total effective purchasing power of the on-line population as in the case of local currencies. The Chinese government has begun to tax the coins as they are exchanged from virtual currency to actual hard currency.^[11]

Difficulties and criticisms

Local currencies and the Transition Towns movement in the UK have been criticized for failing to address the needs of the wider population, especially lower socio-economic groups.^[12] Such local currency initiatives have been more widely criticized as having limited success in stimulating spending in local economies, and as an unrealistic strategy to reduce carbon emissions.^[13]

Modern local currencies

Salt Spring dollars are a community currency issued by the Salt Spring Island Monetary Foundation. The currency is used by both tourists and local residents of Salt Spring Island.^[14]

Modern local currencies can be classified into the following distinct types:

1. Transition currency based on the local currencies used by the Transition Towns movement in the UK. They include Brixton Pound and Bristol Pound in the UK, BerkShares in the USA, and Salt Spring Dollars in Canada.
   Transition currencies are payment voucher-based systems that are exchangeable with the national currency. Between 2002-2014 many experiments in local currency took this form. Such currencies aim to raise the resilience of local economies by encouraging re-localisation of buying and food production. The drive for this change has arisen from a range of community-based initiatives and social movements. The Transition Towns movement originating in the UK has used local currencies for re-localisation in the face of energy descent from peak oil and climate change. Other drives include movements against clone town^[15][16] and big-box trends.
2. Rewards currency based on the frequent flyer model. Consumer spends cash with participating businesses who issue rewards points in a local currency. These rewards points can be used to offset cash prices in future purchases. An example is Oakland Grown in Oakland, CA.^[17]
3. Mutual Credit currency based on the mutual credit system. This can be further sub-divided into two:
   1. Time-based currency also known as Time Banks that use time as a measure of value. An example is Dane County Time Bank.
   2. Trade exchanges and LETS (local exchange trading system) that use price as a measure of value. An example of local currency implemented as a trade exchange is Bay Bucks in the Bay Area of California, USA.^[18] LETS were originally started in Vancouver, Canada, there are presently more than 30 LETS systems operating in Canada and over 400 in the United Kingdom. Australia, France, New Zealand, and Switzerland have similar systems.

Software

Several software packages have been written supporting the management of community currencies.^[19] In 1998, Richard Kay, a senior lecturer at Birmingham City University,^[20] wrote a "Multi-registry System" specification for routing and processing community currency transactions using an approach designed to be decentralized, with no single point of control or failure, using the Domain Name System for server discovery.^[21]

List of local currencies

See also: List of complementary currencies

Africa Kenya Bangla-Pesa[22] South Africa Community Exchange System (CES) Ora Asia Japan Fureai kippu Korea Gyeonggi Province[23] Si-ru - Kyunggi-do Sheung city Bucheon Pay - Kyunggido Bucheon City Daeon - Kyunggido Ansan city Seoul Love Gift Token - Seoul city NO WON - Seoul city No won gu Kangdong Bilsalmoney - Seoul city Kang dong gu Incheon Euem Card - Incheon Metropolitan City Ontong Daejeon - Daejeon Metropolitan City Dong baek jeon - Busan Metropolitan City E Bargu pay - Busan Metropolitan City Donggu ohrukdo pay - Busan Metropolitan City Namgu Daegu Hangbok Pay - Daegu Metropolitan City Tamnanen Jeon - Jeju Malaysia Kelantanese dinar Europe Austria TriestingTaler[24] Belgium Zinne[25] [26] France Abeille Eusko[27] Krôkô[28] Occitan Germany Approximately 300 Tauschringe (comparable to LETS) Berliner Regional[29][30][31] Chiemgauer Urstromtaler Greece Ilios[32] Italy Simec

Russia Kolion Slovakia Zvolenský živec[33] Spain Recurs Econòmic Ciutadà (Barcelona)[34] Boniato Costavales Eco Ecoseny Ecosol Edenred Ekhi EuroDelta Expronceda Illa Irati Mola Ogerleko Osel Ossetana Pancha Puma Turuta Txanpon Txantxi Varamedí Switzerland WIR franc (since 1934)[35] Reka-Check (since 1940)[35] Léman[35] Farinet (since 2017)[35][36] United Kingdom See here: List of community currencies in the United Kingdom North America Canada See here: List of community currencies in Canada Mexico Amanatli[37] Caribe[37] Fausto[37] Itacate[37] Kuni[37] Túmin[38] United States See here: List of community currencies in the United States South America Argentina Crédito International Community Exchange System (CES) Ven by Hub Culture Convertible Minute (currency) by Minutes Bank

See also

• Barter
• Buy local
• Collaborative finance
• Conder token
• Emissions Reduction Currency System for community based initiatives aimed at emission reduction
• Fiscal localism
• Informal sector (aka informal economy)
• Local exchange trading system
• Local multiplier effect
• Paul Glover (activist)
• Schumacher Center for New Economics
• Scrip
• Sharing economy
• Time-based currency

References

1. "People Powered Money: designing, developing and delivering community currencies". Community Currencies in Action. Retrieved 31 July 2020.
2. Naqvi, Mona (2013). "Banknotes, local currencies and central bank objectives" (PDF). bankofengland.co.uk. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-09-23. Retrieved 2015-06-17.
3. Complementary Currency Resource Center. "Online Database of Complementary Currency Systems Worldwide". www.complementarycurrency.org. Archived from the original on 2013-01-16.
4. Robert Costanza et al., "Complementary Currencies as a Method to Improve Local Sustainable Economic Welfare", University of Vermont, Draft, Dec. 12th, 2003. Archived 2009-06-12 at the Wayback Machine
5. Lietaer, Bernard; Hallsmith, Gwendolyn (2006). "Community Currency Guide" (PDF). Global Community Initiatives. Retrieved 18 June 2015.
6. Chen, James. "Private Currency Definition". Investopedia.
7. "Community Currencies in Action: SoNantes".
8. "TradeQoin is a network of entrepreneurs". Archived from the original on 2017-02-11. Retrieved 2017-02-10.
9. "We Create Meaningful Change In Communities". www.justaddspice.org.
10. Lietaer, Bernard, The Future of Money, Century, 2002.
11. China Taxes Online Game Players Archived 2017-02-12 at the Wayback Machine KerryOnWorld, December 7, 2008
12. Jamie Doward and Naomi Loomes (2008-08-17). "Lewes, the proud town that is printing its own money". Guardian. London. Retrieved 2010-08-14.
13. Harford, Tim (May 3, 2008). "Do "local currencies" really help the communities that use them?". Slate Magazine.
14. "Salt Spring Dollars". Salt Spring Island Monetary Foundation. Retrieved 2011-04-27.
15. "Measures Aim To Tackle Problem Of Empty Shops". Publicnet.co.uk. 2009-04-15. Retrieved 2010-08-14.
16. Clone Town Britain survey: results reveals national identity crisis Archived 2012-11-08 at the Wayback Machine The new economics foundation, 6 June 2005
17. "Oakland Grown". Archived from the original on 2014-01-08. Retrieved 2014-01-15.
18. "Bay Bucks". Retrieved 2014-01-15.
19. "Comparison Matrix of Community Currency Software"./
20. "Our Staff". Birmingham City University.
21. "SPECIFICATION FOR MRS CLIENT-SERVER SYSTEMS". copsewood.net.
22. "Introducing the Bangla-Pesa, Kenya's beautiful new complementary currency". 20 May 2013.
23. Gyeonggi-do Local Currency Retrieved on 2020-09-04.
24. "Triestingtaler" pumpte schon 300.000 Euro in die Region, wirtschaftspressedienst.at, 13 May 2005
25. zinneke. "Zinne.brussels | Monnaie Locale/Burgervalua" (in Dutch). Retrieved 2023-02-25.
26. "Lokale munt 'Zinne' vanaf donderdag in omloop". www.bruzz.be (in Dutch). Retrieved 2023-02-25.
27. The French region with a new currency BBC (www.bbc.com). April 19, 2019. Retrieved on 2019-05-01.
28. Le Krôcô, monnaie locale complémentaire de Nîmes & alentours Retrieved on 2019-12-21.
29. offizielle Homepage
30. Berliner Morgenpost: Regionalwährung „Berliner“ steht endgültig vor dem Aus
31. Tóth, Balázs. (2011). The Function of Local Currencies in Local Economic Development.
32. Ilios
33. "Lokálna mena živec" (in Slovak). Archived from the original on 2015-08-21. Retrieved 2015-08-23.
34. "Recurs Econòmic Ciutadà" (in Catalan). Retrieved 2019-08-23.
35. Lila Erard, "Le Farinet, monnaie locale 100% valaisanne, verra le jour début 2017", Le temps, 18 November 2016 (page visited on 18 November 2016).
36. The criminal who inspired a new currency BBC (www.bbc.com). June 27, 2017. Retrieved on 2017-06-28.
37. Conoce las monedas alternativas que circulan en México Retrieved on 2019-12-21.
38. Túmin, moneda alternativa en México Retrieved on 2019-12-21.

Further reading

• People Powered Money: designing, developing and delivering community currencies (2015) Community Currencies in Action (https://neweconomics.org/uploads/files/0dba46d13aa81f0fe3_zhm62ipns.pdf PDF])
• An overview of parallel, local and community currency systems by DeMeulenaere, S (1998) Complementary Currency Resource Centre
• An economic analysis of contemporary local currencies in the United States by Krohn, G and Snyder, A (2008) International Journal of Community Currency Research, Vol. 12, pages 53–68