You Shoulda Told Me You Were... is a studio album by the American musical group Kid Creole and the Coconuts, released in 1991.[2][3] It includes the single "(She's A) Party Girl".
"Oh Marie" is about a woman shot during a drug-related drive-by.[4] "Consequently" touches on the legacy of Christopher Columbus.[5]
The Calgary Herald determined that "the love duet 'My Soul Intention' is like 'Wooly Bully' gone starry-eyed."[6] The Sun Sentinel concluded that "Darnell has transformed himself from a sly, insightful lyricist to a sort of limp, Caribbean-flavored Prince."[9]
The Globe and Mail wrote: "Wildly imaginative and cockily crafted, this is dance music for people who don't like dance music."[10] The New York Times opined that "the temperament of American pop has narrowed, and it's hard to judge what room remains for the Kid Creole notion of a combined dance party and Broadway show."[11]
The Morning Call included the album on its list of the 10 best of 1991, as did Geoffrey Himes of The Washington Post.[12][13]
All tracks are written by August Darnell; except where indicated.