Of the original Tees Valley Metro project, only the construction of a new station at James Cook University Hospital in 2014 has come to fruition,[1] as well as the redevelopment of Hartlepool Station in 2024.[2]
A number of the initially planned projects received preliminary funding in 2024, including expansion to Darlington station, improvements at Eaglescliffe, Thornaby and Teesside Airport, and the construction of a new Teesside Park station.[3]
The proposed initial routes would have used sections of the Tees Valley, Esk Valley and Durham Coast Lines.[4] There were no plans as to the interoperability of the existing services and the planned metro services, but would have been considered at the next stage of the process. Several new stations would have been built across two phases.[5]
Additional routes using street running were to be considered after Stage 2 was implemented.[6]
Detailed plans
The two proposed lines of the Metro.
The project was planned to be delivered in two phases, with the first phase split into stages and further projects being delivered after.
In 2007, the full cost of the project was finalised as being £141.9 million, with an estimate of £88.8 million being allocated from existing funding. This left a £45 million funding gap, of which an estimated £14 million could be secured from local authorities with each of the 5 paying £3 million each. This was against an estimated £400 million of GVA benefits being generated for the community, which would be a £1 to £2.80 cost return.[6] By August 2009, project costs had increased to £220 million.[7]
It was also calculated that the running cost of the regional rail system would increase from £5.7 million to £6.6 million a year, but due to predicted increased passenger revenue, would also result in £1.5 million less per year in subsidy payments for the central Government.[6]
Phase 1 - Stage 1
Initial work was proposed to be complete by December 2012 and would have included new stations, rollingstock and timetable improvements, and station upgrades.[8]
Service and Rollingstock Improvements:
An increase in services from 1–2 to four trains per hour on the Tees Valley Line between Darlington and Saltburn.[4][6]
A reduction in journey time from 58 minutes to 48 between Darlington and Saltburn.[4]
Construction of additional trackage for future capacity.[4][6]
New rolling stock which would be more modern and lighter than existing stock[4][6][9] (Possibly refurbished Class 156 "Sprinters" rolling stock[citation needed]) (New rollingstock was also mentioned for Phase 2)[9].
Station Upgrades:
Possible new platforms at Middlesbrough,[4][6] and a new entrance to the north of the station creating access points for the Boho and Middlehaven developments.[9]
Darlington Station would have had two new bay platforms on the east side to reduce the need for local services to cross the East Coast Main Line.[10] The new platforms would be connected to the main building by a new footbridge and lifts. The existing car parking places that would have been lost with the new platforms would be replaced at a similar distance from the station, and a new entrance, including pick-up/drop-off facilities, was considered on the eastern side.[4]
Eaglescliffe station receiving new ticket office, waiting facility, outdoor shelters, electronic information displays, and possible extension to car park[4] (occurred after cancellation)[citation needed] (new footbridge started 2024).[11]
Thornaby station having footbridge replaced with a modern structure[4] (occurred after cancellation).[citation needed]
Redcar Central Station upgrades were considered for upgrading the existing footbridge, waiting shelters and passenger information facilities.[4][6] There would also be three new pedestrian links – one each to the new civic quarter, to the town centre and new seafront and to Redcar & Cleveland College, as well as a new bus/rail interchange and pick-up/drop-off facilities.[9]
Saltburn Station would receive new shelters and new electronic information displays.[4]
Hartlepool Station would receive a new glazed waiting area on the main platform. The existing bay platform would have been repaved and new waiting shelters provided and the north side platform would have been resurfaced and had new artwork installed. New electronic information screens would also have been provided.[4][6] There was also mention of a new bus/rail interchange.[9]
The cost of these improvements was estimated at £50 – 60 million.[12]
Phase 2
Service and Rollingstock:
Track capacity and signalling improvements along the Darlington to Saltburn line (providing east – west connections).[9]
Improvements to existing stations along the route.[9]
Examination of the best means of replacing life-expired rolling stock to allow increased frequencies whilst minimising any increase in operating costs.[9]
(New rollingstock was also mentioned to be delivered in Phase 2, in contradiction to other documents).[9]
Ensuring that the network is capable of accommodating 9’6” freight containers. This mainly involves platform alterations, changes to rail signals, partial reconstruction of the overbridge at Dinsdale rail station, and upgrading the freight rail network to W10 gauge clearance. This is to support the growth of PD Ports logistics platform at Teesport.[9]
(Teesside Airport was also mentioned to be constructed in Phase 2 instead of Phase 1)[9]
Further Details
During press releases, executive documents, and draft business cases, numerous further improvements and additional infrastructure was mentioned that would occur outside the two core phases, were mentioned in an unconfirmed "Phase 3", or were not given details as to when they would occur.
Release of track capacity on the ECML to allow more trains to run from Darlington to York and Newcastle.[6]
Enhanced heavy rail connections along the Durham Coast line, including Grand Central.[6]
Fast and frequent connections to the ECML at Darlington, TransPennine Express services stopping at Thornaby, and Grand Central services for Eaglescliffe and Teesside Airport.[6]
Proposed Further Street-Running Extensions [Source: [6]]
Start
End
Darlington
Darlington Town Centre
Stockton-On-Tees
Stockton Town Centre
Stockton-On-Tees
Ingleby Barwick
Redcar and Cleveland
Guisborough
Middlesbrough
Middlesbrough Town Centre
Bus Network:
There was also the expansion of the Tees Valley Bus Network as well as integration of metro stations into its system,[14][4][15] as well as the creation of express bus services where heavy rail/metro services are not economically viable in the short term.[6]
Timeline and shelving
In November 2005, Darlington MP and former Health SecretaryAlan Milburn first started partitioning that the Tyne and Wear Metro network to be extended into County Durham and Teesside.[16] In 2006, this evolved to being a business case being submitted to the Department for Transport by all of the involved local authorities, as well as Tees Valley Regeneration, with a reply from the DfT being given by the end of 2007.[17]
In March of 2007 the Tees Valley Metro was mentioned within a parliamentary debate, where the Secretary of State for Transport at the time (Tom Harris) stated the Department for Transport had "no plans to fund the development of a Tees Valley Metro system and has received no request to do so".[18]
The project had originally received approval from the Interim Regional Transport Board in September 2008, allowing more detailed plans and a public consultation to go ahead. Construction of the first phase was due to commence in 2010[19] and would have been completed by the end of 2013. Phase one would cost around £80 million and Network Rail had already committed £40 million for signalling improvements. The second phase would cost a further £140 million and would have been in place by 2018.
In March 2009, the Secretary of State for Transport at the time (Paul Clark), stated that the DfT was making "£5.46 million available to Middlesbrough over the three financial years, 2008-11" for general funding for transport which could be used for its plans. He also stated that the DfT was "committed to working with the Tees Valley Metro promoters to help them to develop their business case".[20]
In June 2009, Nick Brown Minister for the North-East, said he could not guarantee that the work done in phase one would lead to a Metro service and stated that there was “no permission for phase two or three” from the DfT.[7]
On 23 July 2009 the project received £23 million in-principle funding from the Department for Transport via the Regional Funding Allocation process.[4][10] Each of the individual components were treated as an individual project, eligible for fast track funding.[21] Funding was expected for the two new platforms at Darlington, the reopening of platform 3 at Middlesbrough, the relocation of Teesside Airport station to within 350m of the terminal building, improvements at Eaglescliffe, Thornaby and Hartlepool, including new lifts and footbridges, and the new station at James Cook University Hospital.[14][22] Reports also mentioned a possible new station between Middlesbrough and Redcar Central, proposed as a new station for Wilton International,[21] reopening Grangetown Station or improving and bringing South Bank station fully into use,[14] possible relocation of Redcar British Steel station,[12] as well as infrastructure and rolling stock improvements and increased train frequency.[14]
In August 2009, the cost of the project increased, going from £140 million to £220 million reportedly due to inflation, however £70 million for signalling upgrades had been confirmed from Network Rail.[7]
The project was officially shelved by central Government and Tees Valley Unlimited due to lack of funding and a lack of interest in the project from Network Rail. The project has effectively been cancelled due to funding goals being changed by the incoming Conservative government in 2010 and the scheme failing to acquire funding in 2011 and 2012. It was not listed in the 2012 £1.5bn Government transport package, and in 2011 the £9.05m light rail network bid was questioned over value/cost estimates.[23]
In 2020, at the time Leader of the OppositionSir Keir Starmer, urged the Rishi Sunak's government to "sort this issue and give the Tees Valley the infrastructure it needs" and saying that "the Tees Valley Metro would have provided a faster and more frequent service across the area".[24]
Implemented after shelving
A number of the projects first put forward by the project have been initially funded or reproposed as independent projects since the ending of the project in 2010.[23][3] Improvements to Darlington, Eaglescliffe, Thornaby, and Teesside International Airport received preliminary funding in 2024. This also includes construction of two new platforms at Darlington (already started as part of the Darlington station redevelopment plan in 2022[25]) as laid out in the Metro plan, and a new station at Teesside Park. There is also £20 million allocated for "15 trackless autonomous electric trams in town centres".[3]
Rail services provided by Northern Rail were altered to try and marginally improve journey times.[citation needed]
In May 2014, Thornaby Railway Station's ticket office was refurbished and extended. The Government, whilst not ensuring, requested that the new franchise holder from 2016 onwards must attempt to refurbish or replace 35 year old Pacer trains in use at the time.[citation needed]
Pacer trains began to be removed in 2019 from the network and were replaced with refurbished class 156 Sprinters from elsewhere.[26]
In December 2023, a £150 million pound plan was unveiled for the creation of a Teesside Park rail and bus station and improvements to Thornaby Station. The new station would also connect with the new Care and Health Innovation Zone at the Tees Marshalling Yards.[27]
In May 2024, improvements to Eaglescliffe Station started, with a new footbridge connecting to the west side as well as the existing footbridge and ramps refurbished, with new waiting areas and taxi office being added as part of the project.[11]
As of 2 June 2024, platform 3 at Hartlepool has been brought back into use with Northern introducing 3 trains every two hours at peak times on the Durham Coastline.[2]
In August 2024, the initial renders of the redeveloped Darlington train station were released. The plan involves the creation of two additional platforms, access to the roof via a new footbridge, and the creation of a new concourse and multistory carpark.[25]
In August 2024, Tees Valley Mayor Ben Houchen unveiled proposals of ''15 trackless autonomous electric trams in five town centres" in a £20 million plan.[29]
Proposals remain the same for rail across the Tees Valley with the Tees Valley Mayor (Ben Houchen) continuing the promise of trains twice an hour across the Tees Valley, with proposals dating back as early as 2013. This change as its stated will not take place without further funding from Department for Transport and private sector contributions. As of 2021 this has still not happened and neither currently have plans to do this.[citation needed]
Northern currently have put out to tender for the provision of new rolling stock to replace all class 15x units by 2028.[30] As of June 2024 no orders have been placed or plans submitted to the DfT or DOHL. Northern and DfT have not committed to new trains for the Tees Valley and may again use diesel trains from elsewhere to replace the current Sprinter fleet.
