Steve Keen

Steve Keen
Keen in 2013
Born (1953-03-28) 28 March 1953 (age 71)
NationalityAustralian
Education
Academic career
School or
tradition
Post-Keynesian economics, Ecological economics
Influences
ContributionsMathematical models of financial crises and debt-deflation
Information at IDEAS / RePEc

Steve Keen (born 28 March 1953) is an Australian economist and author. He considers himself a post-Keynesian, criticising neoclassical economics as inconsistent, unscientific, and empirically unsupported.

Keen was formerly an associate professor of economics at University of Western Sydney, until he applied for voluntary redundancy in 2013, due to the closure of the economics program at the university.[1] In 2014, he became a professor and Head of the School of Economics, History and Politics at Kingston University in London. He has since taken retirement and is crowd source funded to undertake independent research as well as being a Distinguished Research Fellow at the Institute for Strategy Resilience & Security, University College London.[2]

Early life and education

Keen was born in Sydney in 1953. His father was a bank manager. Keen graduated with a Bachelor of Arts in 1974 and a Bachelor of Laws in 1976, both from the University of Sydney. He then completed a Diploma of Education at the Sydney Teachers College in 1977.

In 1990, he completed a Master of Commerce in economics and economic history at the University of New South Wales. He completed his PhD in economics at the University of New South Wales in 1997.[3]

Economics

Financial instability and debt deflation

Most of Steve Keen's recent work focuses on modeling Hyman Minsky's financial instability hypothesis and Irving Fisher's debt deflation.[4][5] The hypothesis predicts that an overly large private debt to GDP ratio can cause deflation and depression. Here, the falling of the price level results in a continually rising real quantity of outstanding debt. Moreover, the continued deleveraging of outstanding debts increases the rate of deflation. Thus, debt and deflation act on and react to one another, resulting in a debt-deflation spiral. The outcome is a depression.

Debunking Economics

Keen's full-range critique of neoclassical economics is contained in his book Debunking Economics.[6] Keen presents a wide variety of critiques on neoclassical economic theory. He argues they show neoclassical assumptions which are fundamentally flawed. Keen claims several neoclassical assumptions are empirically unsupported (that is, they are unsupported by observable and repeatable phenomena) nor are they desirable for society at large (that is, they do not necessarily produce either efficiency or equity for the majority). He argues economists' overall conclusions are very sensitive to small changes in these assumptions.

Keen has attempted to counter Karl Marx's theory (in his view Marx's pre-1857 view, specifically) from a post-Keynesian perspective, by arguing machines can add more product-value over their operational lifetime than the total value of depreciation charged "during those asset lives".

For example, the total value of sausages produced by a sausage machine over its useful life might be greater than the value of the machine. Depreciation, he implies, was the weak point in Marx's social accounting system all along. Keen argues all factors of production can add new value to outputs. However he gives credit to Marx for contributing to the "financial instability hypothesis" of Hyman Minsky.[7][full citation needed]

Keen's book closes with a survey of various schools of heterodox economics, concluding "None of these is at present strong enough or complete enough to declare itself a contender for the title of 'the' economic theory of the 21st century." However, he argues neoclassical economics is a degenerative research program, not generating new knowledge. It primarily grows a belt of protective auxiliary hypotheses to shield its core beliefs from critique. There is an accompanying website which provides more detailed mathematical expositions.

Critique of neoclassical theory of the firm

Keen has challenged the core, elementary textbook neoclassical theories of Perfect competition and Monopoly, and in particular the argument that firms in "perfect competition" and monopolies are usefully thought of as representing polar opposites. Keen has referred to this as "the theory of the firm."

Neoclassical textbooks define a firm acting without any strategic awareness of the effect of its output choice on price as representing "perfect competition" and argue that this condition of "perfect competition" can be represented analytically by a horizontal demand curve facing the firm -- the firm acts as if it believes it can sell whatever it produces at the currently prevailing price, but nothing at any higher price; marginal costs for this firm, it is presumed, are rising and the firm does not want to sell more at the current price or a lower price. Something like such a state of affairs, it is sometimes argued, is approached as the number of firms competing in a market approaches infinity and the effect of any one firm's output decision on the overall market price becomes infinitesimal and can be practically disregarded by the individual firm in its decision-making.

By contrast a firm with strategic awareness that its output decision markedly affects the market price, faces, presumptively, a downward-sloping demand curve: expanding the rate of output sold depresses market price. In general, elementary neoclassical textbook presentations hold that all "profit-maximizing" firms will set marginal revenue equal to marginal cost. For the firm in "perfect competition", this means price = marginal revenue = marginal cost = average (unit) cost and no profit. For the "monopoly" firm aware that its output choice affects price, the "profit-maximizing" choice is to choose a rate of output where marginal cost = marginal revenue, but in the monopolist's case, that will mean constraining output to raise price above marginal cost.

Keen challenges the theory and pedagogy of "perfect competition" and "monopoly" as polar opposites from multiple angles, arguing that they are contradictory and incoherent taken as a whole. He shows that the number of firms in a market is practically irrelevant to whether the firm's output choice affects the overall market price in the simplified (and practically unlikely) case of uniform firm cost structures and a downward-sloping market demand curve. He goes on to explore various scenarios by which multiple firms might arrive at an "equilibrium" market price and level of output. Keen further notes that cost structures are rarely uniform and that in the presence of significant economies from scale of production, a so-called "monopoly" realizing such economies of scale would be led to higher output and lower price than a large number of competing firms unable to realise such economies of scale. Keen also takes note of empirical evidence that many actual business firms are producing in a range of output where marginal cost may be less than average cost and falling, and firms openly desire to produce and sell more at current prices.[8]

Keen's article on "profit maximisation, industry structure, and competition"[9] has had counter-arguments by Paul Anglin.[10] Chris Auld has additionally claimed to show that Keen & Standish's arguments are inconsistent with standard assumptions used in perfect competition, and their analysis uses calculus improperly.[11]

Climate change

Keen criticises the economics of climate change generally and the 2018 work by Nordhaus in particular: "economists made their own predictions of damages, using three spurious methods: assuming that about 90% of GDP will be unaffected by climate change, because it happens indoors; using the relationship between temperature and GDP today as a proxy for the impact of global warming over time; and using surveys that diluted extreme warnings from scientists with optimistic expectations from economists."[12][13] For example, indoor activities can be disrupted by extreme weather (eg Hurricane Sandy). Keen also argues that regressions of the GSP of states in the US to average temperature are flawed as the states have similar per capita income, that other factors are more important to GSP rather than average temperature, and that assuming the weak correlation found would continue to hold true with further global warming is begging the question.

When specifically speaking about Nordhaus, he says that "Nordhaus has misrepresented the scientific literature to justify the using a smooth function to describe the damage to GDP from climate change. Correcting for these errors makes it feasible that the economic damages from climate change are at least an order of magnitude worse than forecast by economists, and may be so great as to threaten the survival of human civilization."[12][13]

Politics

In August 2015, Keen endorsed Jeremy Corbyn's campaign in the Labour Party leadership election.[14] Keen ran as a senate candidate for The New Liberals in New South Wales during the 2022 Australian federal election.[15][16]

Views on the UK's EU referendum

Keen was in favour of the UK leaving the European Union, stating mainstream economists were over-certain and exaggerating the likely effects following the country's withdrawal. Keen regards the open-borders free-movement policy of the EU as precipitate and unsustainable in the absence of a common fiscal policy; all the more so, given how migrants impose burdens on public services in destination countries also experiencing austerity.

He also states the Euro is destined to fail, not least because of the way it penalises recession-hit countries unable to pursue expansive fiscal policy, and indeed considers the whole EU project as a failed one destined for[17] collapse.[18]

Minsky software project

Recently, Keen commissioned the development of a software package called Minsky[19] for visually modelling national economies, in a way that is intended to be more accurate than mainstream macroeconomic models – which he contends do not properly include debt and banking. He envisages it being used for both educational and research purposes.

The first phase of the development was funded by an academic research grant, as is typical for academic research projects – but in February 2013 Keen launched a crowdfunding project on Kickstarter to allow members of the public to contribute towards taking MINSKY to the next level of development.[20] In the first 24 hours, this project raised approximately 15% of its funding target, and has since fully achieved its initial funding goal of $50,000.00.

Criticism

Economist Chris Auld argues that Keen's criticism of the basic model of perfect competition makes basic mathematical errors.[21]

Matthijs Krul[22] maintains that Keen, while broadly accurate in his criticism of the neoclassical synthesis, generally misrepresents Marx's views in Debunking Economics and in earlier work when asserting that, in the production of commodities, machinery produces more value than it costs.[23]

Austrian School economists Robert P. Murphy and Gene Callahan claim Keen's 2001 book "suffers from many of the very faults of which he accuses the mainstream". They also claim that much of his work is "ideologically motivated even while criticising neoclassical economics for being ideological". They praise his critique of perfect competition and his chapter on dynamic vs. static models, whilst they criticise his attempts at objective value theory and what they claim is his misrepresentation of the Austrian School interpretation of Say's law.[24]

Other publications

  • Keen, Steve (2021). The New Economics. A manifesto. Polity. ISBN 9781509545292.
  • Keen, Steve (2017). Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis? Polity. ISBN 9781509513734.
  • Keen, Steve (2015). Developing an economics for the post-crisis world. World Economics Association and College Publications. ISBN 9781848901865.
  • Lee, Frederic S. and Steve Keen (2004): "The Incoherent Emperor: A Heterodox Critique of Neoclassical Microeconomic Theory", Review of Social Economy, V. 62, Iss. 2: 169–199
  • Co-editor of: Commerce, Complexity and Evolution: Topics in Economics, Finance, Marketing, and Management: Proceedings of the Twelfth International Symposium in Economic Theory and Econometrics. New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-62030-9.
  • The Debunking Economics Podcast: with Phil Dobbie and Prof. Steve Keen (http://debunkingeconomics.com)

See also

References

  1. ^ "Debtwatch economist Steve Keen takes UWS to Fair Work Commission, but uni gets ready to fire back". 20 January 2013. Archived from the original on 15 July 2014. Retrieved 6 July 2014.
  2. ^ ISRS, UCL staff
  3. ^ Economic growth and financial instability
  4. ^ The Roving Cavaliers of Credit
  5. ^ Steve Keen (1995): "Finance and economic breakdown: modelling Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis", Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, Vol. 17, No. 4, 607–635
  6. ^ Debunking Economics: The Naked Emperor of the Social Sciences (2001, Pluto Press Australia) ISBN 1-86403-070-4
  7. ^ Keen, Steve The Debtwatch Manifesto 2012 http://www.debtdeflation.com/blogs/manifesto/
  8. ^ Keen, Steve; Standish, Russell (26 June 2010). "Debunking the theory of the firm—a chronology" (PDF). Real-World Economics Review (53): 56–94.
  9. ^ Steve Keen & Russel Standish (2006):"Profit Maximization, Industry Structure, and Competition: A critique of neoclassical theory" Archived 2 November 2006 at the Wayback Machine, Physica A 370: 81–85
  10. ^ Paul Anglin (2008): On the proper behavior of atoms: A comment on a critique Physica A 387: 277–280
  11. ^ Chris Auld (2012): Steve Keen still butchering basic microeconomics
  12. ^ a b Keen, Steve (1 September 2020). "The appallingly bad neoclassical economics of climate change". Globalizations. 18 (7): 1149–1177. doi:10.1080/14747731.2020.1807856. ISSN 1750-6816. S2CID 225300874.
  13. ^ a b Keen, Steve (9 June 2020). "The Appallingly Bad Neoclassical Economics of Climate Change". Patreon of Prof Steve Keen. Archived from the original on 10 June 2023.
  14. ^ "The Labour party stands at a crossroads". The Guardian. 14 August 2015. Retrieved 15 July 2017.
  15. ^ How bad is the political situation in Australia right now?, 16 October 2021, archived from the original on 12 December 2021, retrieved 16 October 2021
  16. ^ "Senate candidates". Australian Electoral Commission. 1 July 2022. Retrieved 25 January 2024.
  17. ^ Unia to tonący statek/Rzeczpospolita/2016/09/29 [failed verification]
  18. ^ "What Next After Brexit?". Forbes.
  19. ^ "Minsky". IDEA Economics: Institute for Dynamic Economic Analysis. Retrieved 21 November 2019.
  20. ^ Steve Keen (2013). "Kickstarter project". Retrieved 10 February 2013.
  21. ^ Chris Auld (2012): Steve Keen still butchering basic microeconomics
  22. ^ Steve Keen’s Critique of Marx’s Theory of Value: A Rejoinder
  23. ^ Keen, S., "Use-value, Exchange-value, and the Demise of Marx's Labor Theory of Value", Journal of the History of Economic Theory, 15 (Spring 1993).
  24. ^ Review of Austrian Economics 2003 – http://www.gmu.edu/depts/rae/archives/VOL16_4_2003/6_BR_Murphy.pdf

Read other articles:

Coatbridge Localidad Escudo CoatbridgeLocalización de Coatbridge en North LanarkshireCoordenadas 55°51′45″N 4°01′36″O / 55.8625, -4.0266666666667Entidad Localidad • País  Reino Unido • Nación constitutiva Escocia Escocia • Concejo North LanarkshireSuperficie   • Total 6,82 mi² (17,66 km²) Población (2016)   • Total 43 960 hab. • Densidad 6447,64 hab/km²Huso horario UTC±00:00C

 

  Spondylus Spondylus regius en Filipinas.TaxonomíaReino: AnimaliaFilo: MolluscaClase: BivalviaOrden: OstreoidaSuborden: PectininaFamilia: SpondylidaeGray, 1826Subfamilia: PectinoideaGénero: SpondylusLinnaeus, 1758[editar datos en Wikidata] Spondylus es un género de moluscos de la familia Spondylidae. Descripción Es un bivalvo o pelicípodo que se caracteriza por su fuerte concha, sus espinas exteriores y su coloración que va desde el blanco hasta el púrpura intenso. Se a...

 

Untuk bidang ilmiah, lihat hukum (ilmiah). Bagian dari seriIlmu Pengetahuan Formal Logika Matematika Logika matematika Statistika matematika Ilmu komputer teoretis Teori permainan Teori keputusan Ilmu aktuaria Teori informasi Teori sistem FisikalFisika Fisika klasik Fisika modern Fisika terapan Fisika komputasi Fisika atom Fisika nuklir Fisika partikel Fisika eksperimental Fisika teori Fisika benda terkondensasi Mekanika Mekanika klasik Mekanika kuantum Mekanika kontinuum Rheologi Mekanika be...

Neighbourhood of Zagreb, Croatia This article uses bare URLs, which are uninformative and vulnerable to link rot. Please consider converting them to full citations to ensure the article remains verifiable and maintains a consistent citation style. Several templates and tools are available to assist in formatting, such as reFill (documentation) and Citation bot (documentation). (August 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Southern part of Ribnjak Ribnjak (pronounced [...

 

إن تخليق اليوريا (والمواد العضوية الأخرى) من المركبات غير العضوية كانت تدحض فرضية vitalist وهي أن الكائنات الحية فقط يمكن أن تخلق هذه المركبات . المذهب الحيوي هو الاعتقاد بأن «الكائنات الحية تختلف اختلافًا جوهريًا عن الكيانات غير الحية لأنها تحتوي على بعض العناصر غير المادية أ...

 

1970 studio album by Mal WaldronTokyo BoundStudio album by Mal WaldronReleased1970RecordedFebruary 7 & 12, 1970GenreJazzLength45:06LabelRCA Victor (Japan)Mal Waldron chronology Free at Last(1969) Tokyo Bound(1970) Tokyo Reverie(1970) Tokyo Bound is a studio album by American jazz pianist Mal Waldron recorded in Tokyo in 1970 and released on the Japanese RCA Victor label.[1] Track listing All compositions by Mal Waldron Japanese Island — 10:34 Rock One for Jimbosan &#...

Bài viết này cần thêm chú thích nguồn gốc để kiểm chứng thông tin. Mời bạn giúp hoàn thiện bài viết này bằng cách bổ sung chú thích tới các nguồn đáng tin cậy. Các nội dung không có nguồn có thể bị nghi ngờ và xóa bỏ.Nam Hải đổi hướng tới đây. Đối với các định nghĩa khác, xem Nam Hải (định hướng).Xin xem các mục từ có tên tương tự tại Biển Đông (định hướng). Biển ĐôngV...

 

This article does not cite any sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: The Soul Is in the Software – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 2002 studio album by Icon of CoilThe Soul Is in the SoftwareStudio album by Icon of CoilReleasedMay 7, 2002Length44:22LabelMetropolis...

 

水道町 町名国 大日本帝国都道府県 台北州市 台北市等時帯 UTC+8 (西部標準時) 水道町(すいどうちょう)は、日本統治時代の台湾における台北市の行政区画。おおよそ台北市の南端にあり、富田町に西に位置した。上水道の供給施設が設置されたことに由来する。新店渓に隣接しており、現在の水源路、羅斯福路(ルーズベルト路)三段、四段、温州街、龍泉街の一部が...

Stasiun Kasugihan Tampak dekat bangunan utama Stasiun KasugihanLokasiKesugihan, Kesugihan, Cilacap, Jawa Tengah 53274IndonesiaKetinggian+9 mOperatorKereta Api IndonesiaDaerah Operasi V PurwokertoLetak dari pangkal km 388+350 lintas Bogor–Bandung–Banjar–Kutoarjo–Yogyakarta km 1+966 lintas Maos-Cilacap[1] Jumlah peron2 (satu peron sisi yang agak rendah dan satu peron pulau yang rendah)Jumlah jalur3 (jalur 2: sepur lurus)Informasi lainKode stasiunKH2313[2]KlasifikasiIII/k...

 

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: 121 South African Infantry Battalion – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (October 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 121 South African Infantry Battalion121 SAI emblemActive1979 to presentCountry South AfricaBranch So...

 

American actress and model (born 1975) Shanna MoaklerMoakler in 2010BornShanna Lynn Moakler (1975-03-28) March 28, 1975 (age 48)[1]Providence, Rhode Island, U.S.Other namesShanna Moakler Barker[2]Occupation(s)Actress, model, reality television celebrityYears active1992–presentSpouse Travis Barker ​ ​(m. 2004; div. 2008)​Children3Websiteshannamoakler.com Shanna Lynn Moakler (/ˈʃeɪnə/; born March 28, 1975)[...

Village in County Tyrone, Northern Ireland Human settlement in Northern IrelandCarrickmoreIrish: An Charraig MhórLocation within Northern IrelandPopulation612 (2011)Irish grid referenceH630574• Belfast52 mi (84 km)DistrictFermanagh and OmaghCountyCounty TyroneCountryNorthern IrelandSovereign stateUnited KingdomPostcode districtBT79Dialling code028UK ParliamentWest TyroneNI AssemblyWest Tyrone List of places UK Northern Ireland Tyrone 5...

 

Questa voce sull'argomento medici italiani è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Giulio Raffaele Giulio Raffaele (Napoli, 1895 – Roma, 1977) è stato un medico italiano. Figlio di Federico Raffaele, diresse l'Istituto Ettore Marchiafava e nel 1972 fu nominato socio dei Lincei. Nel 1936, durante uno studio sulla malaria, dimostrò che i plasmodi degli uccelli presentano una fase del ciclo parassita detta fase esoeritrocita. Nel 1969 ha ricev...

 

Slab serif typeface created in 1974 Typeface American TypewriterCategorySerifClassificationSlab SerifDesigner(s)Joel Kaden and Tony StanFoundryITC, published by: Adobe, Apple and Linotype[1][2]Date created1974[3]Design based onSholes's 1868 typewriter patentAlso known asITC American Typewriter, Helvetica Typewriter American Typewriter is a slab serif typeface created in 1974 by Joel Kaden and Tony Stan for International Typeface Corporation.[4] It is based on t...

18 Delphini ClassificazioneGigante gialla Classe spettraleG6III C[1] Distanza dal Sole≈ 238 a.l.[2] CostellazioneDelfino Coordinate(all'epoca J2000[1]) Ascensione retta20h 58m 25,934s Declinazione10° 50′ 21,43″ Lat. galattica-21,9749° Long. galattica58,6915° Parametri orbitaliSistema planetario1 (b)[2] Dati fisiciRaggio medio8,5[3] R⊙ Massa2,3[3] M⊙ Temperaturasuperficiale4979 ± 18[3] K (medi...

 

Diagram Tata Surya Dalam menggambarkan Troya Jupiter (warna hijau) didepan dan di belakang planet Jupiter dan berada disepanjang jalur orbitnya. Disana juga terlihat sabuk asteroid (putih) di antara orbit planet Mars dan planet Jupiter, serta asteroid keluarga Hilda (coklat). Troya Jupiter adalah kelompok besar dari benda langit yang berbagi orbit dengan planet Jupiter yang sama-sama mengelilingi matahari. Lihat pula Daftar asteroid Troya Jupiter Pranala luar Wikimedia Commons memiliki media ...

 

American basketball player (born 1987) Wesley JohnsonJohnson with the Clippers in 2016Los Angeles ClippersPositionPlayer development assistantLeagueNBAPersonal informationBorn (1987-07-11) July 11, 1987 (age 36)Corsicana, Texas, U.S.NationalityAmericanListed height6 ft 7 in (2.01 m)Listed weight215 lb (98 kg)Career informationHigh schoolCorsicana (Corsicana, Texas)College Iowa State (2006–2008) Syracuse (2009–2010) NBA draft2010: 1st round, 4th overall pickSe...

This list is incomplete; you can help by adding missing items. (January 2022) The statue of Charles II by Grinling Gibbons at Royal Hospital Chelsea This is a list of public art in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea. Map of public art in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea Belgravia See the list of public art in Belgravia. Brompton Image Title / subject Location andcoordinates Date Artist / designer Type Material Designation Notes More images Statue of Cardina...

 

Río Grande de Arecibo Vista de la desembocadura del ríoUbicación geográficaNacimiento Unión de los ríos Vacas y CidraDesembocadura Bahía de Arecibo, Océano AtlánticoCoordenadas 18°28′22″N 66°42′38″O / 18.472777777778, -66.710555555556Ubicación administrativaPaís  Puerto RicoDivisión Puerto RicoCuerpo de aguaLongitud 52,8 km[editar datos en Wikidata] Río Grande de Arecibo[1]​ o simplemente Río Arecibo[2]​ es un río del estado ...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!