Siege of Przemyśl

For other uses, see Battle of Przemyśl (disambiguation).

Siege of Przemyśl
Part of the Eastern Front of World War I
Establishment of Russian power in Przemysl
Date 16 September 1914 – 22 March 1915[1] (6 months and 6 days) Location Przemyśl, Austria-Hungary (present-day Poland) Result Russian victory Full results First Siege: Russians discontinue siege Second siege: Russian victory
Belligerents
Austria-Hungary	Russian Empire
Commanders and leaders
Hermann Kusmanek  Karl Weizendorfer  Arpad Tamashi  Wilhelm Nickel  Rudolf Zeide  Alfred Veber  George Komm  Arthur Keltnecker  Friedrich Kloiber  Svetozar Boroević	Radko Dimitriev Andrei Selivanov
Units involved
Przemyśl fortress garrison	3rd Army[a] 11th Army
Strength
138,000 men: 93,000 soldiers 45,000 impressed levy[2]	300,000 men^[citation needed]
Casualties and losses
137,000 20,000 dead 120,000 captured (including wounded) 700 artillery pieces[2] 9 general captured	115,000 total casualties (20,000–40,000 casualties were sustained in the first few days of the siege.[3])

The siege of Przemyśl^[b] was the longest siege in Europe during the First World War.^[4] The siege was a crushing defeat of the Austro-Hungarian Army by the Russian Army. Przemyśl was a fortress-town and stronghold on the River San in what is now southeastern Poland. The investment of Przemyśl began on 16 September 1914 and was briefly suspended on 11 October, due to an Austro-Hungarian offensive. The siege resumed again on 9 November and the Austro-Hungarian garrison surrendered on 22 March 1915, after holding out for a total of 133 days.^[1] The siege has been referred to as "Austria-Hungary's Stalingrad".^[5][6]

Background

In August 1914, Russian armies moved against both German East Prussia and one of Austria-Hungary's largest provinces, Galicia, straddling the present-day border between Poland and Ukraine. Its advance into Germany was soon repulsed but its Galician campaign was more successful. General Nikolai Ivanov overwhelmed the Austro-Hungarian forces under Conrad von Hötzendorf^{[citation needed]} during the Battle of Galicia, and the whole Austrian front fell back over 160 kilometres (100 mi) to the Carpathian Mountains. The fortress at Przemyśl was the only Austrian post that held out and by 28 September, was completely behind Russian lines. The Russians were now in a position to threaten the German industrial region of Silesia, making the defense of Przemyśl of importance to the Germans as well as the Austro-Hungarians.

50 kilometres (30 mi) of new trenches were dug and 1,000 km (650 mi) of barbed wire were used to make seven new lines of defence around the perimeter of the town. Inside the fortress, a military garrison of 127,000, as well as 18,000 civilians, were surrounded by six Russian divisions. Przemyśl reflected the nature of the Austro-Hungarian Empire – orders of the day had to be issued in fifteen languages. Austrians, Poles, Jews and Ruthenians (Ukrainians) were together in the besieged town, that was hit constantly with artillery fire, and as the toll of the dead, sick and wounded rose, and starvation threatened, so did mutual distrust and ethnic tension.^[7]

First siege

Map of Przemysl and surrounding forts

On 24 September, General Radko Dimitriev, commander of the Russian Third Army began the siege of the fortress with six divisions. Dimitriev, after a brief artillery bombardment, ordered a full-scale assault on the fortress. The fortress was defended by 120,000 soldiers, under the command of Hermann Kusmanek von Burgneustädten. For three days the Russians attacked and accomplished nothing at the cost of 40,000 casualties.^[8]

During the Battle of the Vistula River, Svetozar Boroevic von Bojna's Third Army advanced towards Przemyśl. On 5 October, Russian assaults continued, under the command of General Scherbakov, including a major one on 7 October. Yet, with Austro-Hungarian forces advancing, the Russian assault was discontinued. On 9 October, a cavalry unit from the Third Army entered the besieged fortress, and the main body on 12 Oct.^{[8]: 327–328}

Second siege

By the end of October, the German and Austro-Hungarian armies were retreating west after their reversals in the Battle of the Vistula River. On 4 November, civilians were ordered to leave Przemyśl. On 10 November, the second siege started.^{[8]: 354–355} The Russian 11th Army (General Andrei Nikolaevich Selivanov) took up the siege operations. Unlike Dimitriev, Selivanov did not order any frontal assaults, and instead settled to starve the garrison into submission. By mid-December, the Russians were pounding the fortress with ceaseless artillery fire, seeking to compel the town's surrender. During the winter 1914–1915 the Habsburg armies continued to fight their way to the fortress. Months of fighting resulted in great losses, largely from frostbite and disease but relieving forces failed to reach the garrison at Przemyśl.

In February 1915, Boroevic led another relief effort towards Przemyśl. By the end of February, all relief efforts having been defeated, Hötzendorf informed Hermann Kusmanek von Burgneustädten that no further efforts would be made. Selivanov was given sufficient artillery to reduce the fortress. The Russians overran the northern defenses on 13 March. An improvised line of defense held up the Russian attacks long enough for Kusmanek to destroy anything left in the city that could be of use to the Russians once captured. On March 19 Kusmanek ordered an attempt to break out but his sallies were repulsed and he was forced to retreat back into the city. With nothing useful left within the city, Kusmanek had no choice but to surrender. On 22 March, the remaining garrison of 117,000 surrendered to the Russians. Among the captured were nine generals, ninety-three senior staff officers, 2,500 other officers,^[9][10] and the Hungarian war poet Geza Gyoni.

Life in Przemyśl under siege

Diaries and notebooks kept by various people in the town have survived. The diary of Josef Tomann, an Austrian recruited into military service as a junior doctor, reveals the results of the activities of garrison officers: "The hospitals have been recruiting teenage girls as nurses. They get 120 crowns a month and free meals. They are, with very few exceptions, utterly useless. Their main job is to satisfy the lust of the gentlemen officers and, rather shamefully, of a number of doctors, too … New officers are coming in almost daily with cases of syphilis, gonorrhea and soft chancre. The poor girls and women feel so flattered when they get chatted up by one of these pestilent pigs in their spotless uniforms, with their shiny boots and buttons." Other accounts reveal the pervasive presence of starvation and disease, including cholera, and the diary of Helena Jablonska, a middle-aged, quite wealthy Polish woman, reveals class and antisemitic and racial tensions in the town; " The Jewish women in basements rip you off the worst", and on March 18, 1915 – "The Jews are taking their shop signs down in a hurry, so that no one can tell who owns what. … They've all got so rich off the backs of those poor soldiers, and now of course they all want to run away!" When the Imperial Russian Army finally took the city in March, the Tsarist soldiers unleashed a violent pogrom against the Jewish population of the city. Jablonska noted: "The Cossacks waited until the Jews set off to the synagogue for their prayers before setting upon them with whips. There is such lamenting and despair. Some Jews are hiding in cellars, but they'll get to them there too."^[11]

Censored balloon mail from Przemysl to Vienna

Mail communications

Airmail flights from Przemyśl during both sieges when airmail postcards, mostly military mail, were flown from the besieged city on twenty-seven flights. Following a forced landing, mail from one flight was confiscated by the Russians and sent to Saint Petersburg for postal censorship and onward transmission. Balloon mail, on some manned but mainly unmanned paper balloons, was also carried out of the city.^[12] Pigeon mail was also used to send messages out of the city.^[13]

Results

Statue commemorating the siege of Przemyśl in Budapest, Hungary

On March 9, 1915, Russian troops captured 9 Austrian generals in the Przemysl fortress: Infantry General Hermann Kusmanek von Burgneustädten Field Marshal-Lieutenants Karl Weizendorfer, Arpad Tamasha von Fogaras, Wilhelm Nickl and Major Generals Rudolf Zeide, Alfred Weber, George Komm, Arthur Kaltnecker and Friedrich Kloiber. The commandant of the fortress, G. Kusmanek, became the highest-ranking general of the German bloc among those who were captured by the Russians.^[14]

The fall of Przemyśl led many to believe that Russia would now launch a major offensive into Hungary. This anticipated offensive never came, but the loss of Przemyśl was a serious blow to Austro-Hungarian morale. A further blow to Austria-Hungary was the fact that Przemyśl was only supposed to be garrisoned by 50,000, yet over 110,000 Austro-Hungarians surrendered with the fortress, a much more significant loss. The Russians held Przemyśl until the summer of 1915 when the Gorlice–Tarnów offensive pushed back the Russian front in Galicia. Przemyśl stayed in Austro-Hungarian hands until October 1918, at which point Eastern Galicia left the Austro-Hungarian Empire and became part of the newly created independent state of Poland. The Austro-Hungarian army never recovered from its losses in the winter of 1914–1915 and the Habsburgs would rely henceforth on German assistance both in their sector of the Eastern Front and in the Balkans.^[15]

Meanwhile Austro-Hungarian attempts to relieve the fortress ended catastrophically as the poorly supplied and outnumbered imperial forces attempted offensive after offensive through the Carpathian Mountains. Casualties for January to April 1915, in the Carpathians, were officially reported as 800,000, mostly due to weather and disease rather than combat. Russian casualties were nearly as high, but easier to replace, and balanced out more by the surrender of 117,000 Austro-Hungarian troops at the end of the siege.^[16] All told, the siege and the attempts to relieve it cost the Austro-Hungarian army over a million casualties and inflicted on it significant damage from which it would never recover.

Notes

1. She did not take direct part in the siege and guarded the rear of the 11th Army
2. Polish: Oblężenie twierdza Przemyśl; German: Belagerung von Premissel; Russian: Перемы́шльская осада

1. Dowling, Timothy C. (2014). Russia at War: From the Mongol Conquest to Afghanistan, Chechnya, and Beyond. Przemyśl, Siege of (September 24, 1914 – March 22, 1915). Vol. 2 volumes. ABC-CLIO. pp. 170, 681–682, 913. ISBN 978-1-59884-948-6.
2. "Przemysl leltára" [account of Przemyśl] (in Hungarian). Budapest, Hungary: Huszadik század. April 1915. Retrieved 2 August 2011.
3. "Przemyslt teljesen felszabadítottuk" [Przemyśl has been fully liberated] (in Hungarian). Budapest: Huszadik század. October 1914. Retrieved 2 August 2011.
4. Palmer, Svetlana; Wallis, Sarah (2003). A War in Words. Simon & Schuster. p. 69. ISBN 0-7432-4831-7.
5. Watson, Alexander (2020-07-22). "World War I's Stalingrad: The Siege of Przemyśl and Europe's Bloodlands". The National WWII Museum | New Orleans. Retrieved 2024-04-03.
6. Wilson, Peter H. (2023). Iron and Blood: A Military History of the German-Speaking Peoples since 1500 (1st ed.). Harvard University Press. p. 535. ISBN 978-0-674-98762-3.
7. A War in Words, p. 70, Svetlana Palmer & Sarah Wallis, Simon & Schuster, 2003 ^{[ISBN missing]}
8. Buttar, Prit (2016). Collision of Empires, The War on the Eastern Front in 1914. Oxford: Osprey Publishing. pp. 272–274. ISBN 978-1-4728-1318-3.
9. Rothenburg 1976, p. 185.
10. Buttar, Prit (2017). Germany Ascendant, The Eastern Front 1915. Oxford: Osprey. pp. 57–61, 138–144. ISBN 978-1-4728-1937-6.
11. A War in Words, pp. 87–88
12. Kupiec-Weglinski, Jerry (December 2009). "The Siege Of Przemysl 1914–15". Airpost Journal. 80 (12). Mineola, NY: American Air Mail Society: 494–509. ISSN 0739-0939.
13. "Pigeon Post From Przemysl; "We Are Doing Very Well," Says Message to Vienna", New York Times, p. 2, 1914-11-29
14. Из истории генеральских потерь Германского блока
15. A War in Words, p. 93
16. Tucker, Spencer. World War I: A Student Encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO Publishing. 2005. p. 349.

References

• Dowling, Timothy C. (2014). Russia at War: From the Mongol Conquest to Afghanistan, Chechnya, and Beyond. Przemyśl, Siege of (September 24, 1914 – March 22, 1915). Vol. 2 volumes. ABC-CLIO. pp. 170, 681–682, 913. ISBN 978-1-59884-948-6.
• Rothenburg, G. (1976). The Army of Francis Joseph. West Lafayette, Ind: Purdue University Press. ISBN 978-0-911198-41-6.
• Tucker, Spencer (2002) [1997]. The Great War, 1914–1918. Routledge. ISBN 1134817495 – via Goggle Books.

Further reading

• Tunstall, Graydon A. (2016). Written in Blood: The Battles for Fortress Przemysl in WWI. Indiana University Press. ISBN 9780253021977.
• Watson, Alexander (2019). The Fortress: The Great Siege of Przemysl. London: Allen Lane. ISBN 9780241309063. online review in H-DIPLO
• Watson, Alexander (2020). The Fortress: The Siege of Przemysl and the Making of Europe's Bloodlands. Basic Books. ISBN 978-1-5416-9732-4.

External links

• Fall of Przemysl (1915) on YouTube
• The Siege of Przemysl – A Sketch from a British War-Correspondent. Wayback capture.