Primitive recursive set function

In mathematics, primitive recursive set functions or primitive recursive ordinal functions are analogs of primitive recursive functions, defined for sets or ordinals rather than natural numbers. They were introduced by Jensen & Karp (1971).

Definition

A primitive recursive set function is a function from sets to sets that can be obtained from the following basic functions by repeatedly applying the following rules of substitution and recursion:

The basic functions are:

• Projection: P_n,m(x₁, ..., x_n) = x_m for 0 ≤ m ≤ n
• Zero: F(x) = 0
• Adjoining an element to a set: F(x, y) = x ∪ {y}
• Testing membership: C(x, y, u, v) = x if u ∈ v, and C(x, y, u, v) = y otherwise.

The rules for generating new functions by substitution are

• F(x, y) = G(x, H(x), y)
• F(x, y) = G(H(x), y)

where x and y are finite sequences of variables.

The rule for generating new functions by recursion is

• F(z, x) = G(∪_u ∈ z F(u, x), z, x)

A primitive recursive ordinal function is defined in the same way, except that the initial function F(x, y) = x ∪ {y} is replaced by F(x) = x ∪ {x} (the successor of x). The primitive recursive ordinal functions are the same as the primitive recursive set functions that map ordinals to ordinals.

Examples of primitive recursive set functions:

• TC, the function assigning to a set its transitive closure.^[1]: 26
• Given hereditarily finite ${\displaystyle c}$, the constant function ${\displaystyle f(x)=c}$. ^[1]: 28

Extensions

One can also add more initial functions to obtain a larger class of functions. For example, the ordinal function ${\displaystyle \alpha \mapsto \omega ^{\alpha }}$ is not primitive recursive, because the constant function with value ω (or any other infinite set) is not primitive recursive, so one might want to add this constant function to the initial functions.

The notion of a set function being primitive recursive in ω has the same definition as that of primitive recursion, except with ω as a parameter kept fixed, not altered by the primitive recursion schemata.

Examples of functions primitive recursive in ω:^{[1] pp.28--29}

• ${\displaystyle \mathbb {P} _{\omega }(x)=\bigcup _{n<\omega }x^{n}}$.
• The function assigning to ${\displaystyle \alpha }$ the ${\displaystyle \alpha }$th level ${\displaystyle L_{\alpha }}$ of Godel's constructible hierarchy.

Primitive recursive closure

Let ${\displaystyle f_{0}:{\textrm {Ord}}^{2}\to {\textrm {Ord}}}$ be the function ${\displaystyle f(\alpha ,\beta )=\alpha +\beta }$, and for all ${\displaystyle i<\omega }$, ${\displaystyle {\tilde {f}}_{i}(\alpha )=f_{i}(\alpha ,\alpha )}$ and ${\displaystyle f_{i+1}(\alpha ,\beta )=({\tilde {f}}_{i})^{\beta }(\alpha )}$. Let L_α denote the αth stage of Godel's constructible universe. L_α is closed under primitive recursive set functions iff α is closed under each ${\displaystyle f_{i}}$ for all ${\displaystyle i<\omega }$. ^[1]: 31

References

• Jensen, Ronald B.; Karp, Carol (1971), "Primitive recursive set functions", Axiomatic Set Theory, Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., vol. XIII, Part I, Providence, R.I.: Amer. Math. Soc., pp. 143–176, ISBN 9780821802458, MR 0281602

Inline

1. R. B. Jensen, Manuscript on fine structure, inner model theory, and the core model below one Woodin cardinal (pp. 22--31). Accessed 2022-12-07