National Industrial Relations Court

The National Industrial Relations Court (NIRC) was established on 1 December 1971 under Section 99 of the Industrial Relations Act 1971. The NIRC was created by the Conservative government of Edward Heath as a way to limit the power of trade unions in the United Kingdom. It was abolished by the Trade Union and Labour Relations Act 1974 soon after the Labour government of Harold Wilson came to power in 1974.

History

The NIRC was introduced by the Industrial Relations Act 1971 which was a key part of the Heath government's modernisation programme that aimed to introduce greater regulation of trade unions.[1]: 202  Unions saw the proposals as undue state interference.[1]: 202  The legislation was widely protested against even while still in Parliament and its powers ended up being infrequently used; eventually, even the government acknowledged that much of the act would need to be amended.[2]

The NIRC itself was established on 1 December 1971 by secondary legislation under the Industrial Relation Act.[3]: 259  The court's president John Donaldson made a statement stressing the institutions focus on conciliation and the informal aspects of the court's approach.[3]: 259  The court started off with a backlog of 48 appeals from industrial tribunals regarding the Redundancy Payments Act 1965, which had been originally assigned to the dockets of the High Court or Court of Session but were reassigned to the NIRC following its creation.[3]: 259  Eight of the appeals decisions were officially reported (meaning the case established a new legal rule or principle) and only one of them, Woodhouse v Peter Brotherhood Ltd [1972] ICR 186, was successfully appealed to the Court of Appeal.[3]: 259–260 

In its first three months, only three cases were brought to the NIRC under the Industrial Relations Act: Car Collection v Transport & General Workers Union [1972] ICR 135; National Union of Bank Employees v United Dominions Trust, which was withdrawn before trial in favour of conciliation; and C.A. Parsons & Co. Ltd v Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers and others [1972] ICR 143.[3]: 260 

The possibility of the government submitting an emergency application to the court to intervene in the 1972 miners' strike after the publication of the Wilberforce Report on 18 February meant that the court "put itself on full standby" that night but the strike ended up being settled without the NIRC's involvement.[3]: 261 

On 28 February 1972, further secondary legislation brought most of the remaining parts of the Industrial Relations Act into force giving the NIRC two new jurisdictions: 'rights of workers' (which included unfair dismissal) and 'unfair industrial practices'.[3]: 262 

As part of the protests against the legislation, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) promoted a policy of non-compliance, resulting in an effective boycott of the NIRC.[4]: 263–264  Initially, TUC-affiliated unions were not allowed to cooperate with the NIRC at all, including to defend themselves.[4]: 264  This was relaxed in April 1972 when the court threatened to sequester the assets of the Transport and General Workers' Union (TGWU) if it did not pay its fine for contempt of court by 4 May; the TGWU then represented itself before the court on 3 May.[4]: 264  Some unions, such as the Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers (AUEW), kept boycotting the NIRC.[3]: 269 [4]: 264 

By 1974, the Industrial Relations Act had been discredited and, when the Labour Party returned to government in 1974, it repealed it (therefore abolishing the NIRC) with the Trade Union and Labour Relations Act 1974.[5]: 241–243 

Composition and powers

Its first and only President was John Donaldson, supported by John Brightman (both High Court judges who later became Law Lords) and Lord Thomson, a judge of the Scottish Court of Session. The court also had nine appointed lay members, and one of the three judges sat with a lay panel. The court hearings were in public, but its procedure was relatively informal, with neither the judge nor barristers wearing wigs or gowns.

Unusually, the court's jurisdiction extended throughout the UK, making no distinction between England and Wales or Scotland. The NIRC could also sit anywhere in Great Britain although cases were almost always held in the court's rooms on Chancery Lane, London or at its Scotland branch which was initially in Edinburgh and then in Glasgow from mid-1972.[3]: 281–282  There was only one exception to this: Powell Duffryn v House and others, which was heard in Cardiff in December 1972.[3]: 282–283 

It was empowered to grant injunctions as necessary to prevent injurious strikes and to settle a variety of labour disputes. It also heard appeals from the industrial tribunals.

When negotiations between unions and employers had failed, the government could apply to the court for a 'cooling off period' where the court ordered any industrial action to be deferred for up to 60 days.[4]: 255  The court could order a secret ballot to be held in cases industrial action where there was risk of serious public disorder, where there was doubt as to the level of support for strikes, or where disputes were seen as a threat to the national economy, health or security.[4]: 255 

Notable cases

Norton Tool Co Ltd v Tewson

One of the leading legal decisions of the NIRC was Norton Tool Co Ltd v Tewson [1972] ICR, in which Donaldson J ruled that damages for wrongful dismissal only extended to financial loss, and that compensation was not available for non-pecuniary losses, such as injury to pride or feelings. This position was doubted by Lord Hoffmann in Johnson v Unisys Ltd [2003] 1 AC 518, but upheld in Dunnachie v Kingston-upon-Hull City Council [2004] UKHL 36.

Goad v AUEW

Goad v Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers (AUEW) [1972] ICR 429 was an unfair industrial practices case which was lodged with the NIRC on 11 September 1972, during the court's vacation.[3]: 275 

James Goad, a member of the AUEW, sought an order to force the union to allow him to attend branch meetings, affirming a ruling from an industrial tribunal. Under sections 65 and 66 of the Industrial Rights Act, it was an unfair industrial practice to prevent a union member attending a branch meeting.[3]: 276  The Economist reported that if the AUEW had defended itself, it could probably have shown that the exclusion from branch meetings was not arbitrary but because Goad had failed to pay his union dues three times and because he had worked during a strike.[6]

It was first heard on 3 October, with Goad giving evidence on 30 October and the AUEW ordered to appear on 8 November.[3]: 276  The AUEW, continuing their policy of non-cooperation with the court as mandated by the union's national committee, did not appear in court or put up a defence and NIRC found them in contempt and fined them £5000.[3]: 275–276 [7] When Goad was again refused entry to a branch meeting on 30 November, the court fined the AUEW £50000 plus costs of £5000.[3]: 276  None of the fines were paid voluntarily and some had to be sequestered from stock-holdings which was approved at a hearing on 21 December, the court's last day in session for the year.[3]: 276–277 

Controversies

The NIRC was controversial throughout its short life. Donaldson, the president of the court, was known to have Conservative leanings, having stood as a Parliamentary candidate for the Conservative party and, indeed, having contributed to the drafting of the Industrial Relations Act. Many cases were decided against the trades unions, although the unions had a policy of not co-operating with, and in many cases ignoring, the court.

Pentonville Five

In July 1972, a dispute involving the dock workers union led to five shop stewards being imprisoned in Pentonville Prison for contempt of court. The NIRC had previously ordered seven dockworkers to stop picketing the premises of Midland Cold Storage Company in Hackney, London.[8] When they did not, five were held in contempt of court in hearings from 19 to 21 July while two remained free due to a lack of evidence.[3]: 271  Three of the five (Derek Watkins, Tony Merrick and Conny Clancy) were arrested at the Midland Cold Storage site on 21 July, while the two other (Bernie Steer and Vic Turner) were arrested later.[9]

The arrest of the workers prompted immediate walk-outs in several industries and protests outside Pentonville Prison, where the workers were being held.[1]: 203 [10] The TUC called for a general strike on 31 July.[11]

The Official Solicitor applied to the NIRC on the afternoon of 26 July for the Pentonville Five to be released, mainly on the grounds that the Law Lords overturned a Court of Appeal ruling that morning and had judged that trade unions were primarily responsible for the unlawful behaviour of their shop stewards.[3]: 271 [12] The five dockers were subsequently released, and "borne from the prison in triumph".[12]

The dispute helped to discredit the NIRC and has been named as a defining moment in post-war industrial relations.[11] In 2001 letters to J. A. G. Griffith, Donaldson expressed that he felt he had been "faced with a catch 22 situation".[1]: 200, 208  He said that if he had fined the dockers according to their means, "they would have a quick whip round in the pub and hold the court up to derision" and that if he had fined them harshly, he would have been criticised for being "oppressive".[1]: 208  As such, Donaldson said that at the time he saw a custodial sentence as the only answer to the dilemma but that in hindsight he would have imposed a small fine and then imprisoned the workers if they had kept ignoring the court order.[1]: 208 

References

  1. ^ a b c d e f Maureen Spencer; John Spencer (June 2006). "The Judge as 'Political Advisor': Behind the Scenes at the National Industrial Relations Court". Journal of Law and Society. 33 (2): 199–220. doi:10.1111/j.1467-6478.2006.00355.x.
  2. ^ Doug Pyper (7 September 2015). "Trade Union Bill" (PDF). House of Commons Library. p. 8. Retrieved 16 December 2023.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r D.H. Hills (July 1973). "The National Industrial Relations Court – A Personal History". British Journal of Industrial Relations. 11 (2): 259–285. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8543.1973.tb00866.x. ISSN 0007-1080.
  4. ^ a b c d e f S.C. Ghosh (1980). "The British Trade Unions and the Labour Law: The Case of the Industrial Relations Act 1971". Relations Industrielles / Industrial Relations. 35 (2): 251–278. Retrieved 16 December 2023.
  5. ^ Howard F. Gospel; Gill Palmer (1993). British Industrial Relations (2nd ed.). Routledge. ISBN 0415084539.
  6. ^ "In this season of peace, goodwill and big pay packets". The Economist. Vol. 245, no. 6747. 16 December 1972. p. 91.
  7. ^ "If Hughie still won't come". The Economist. Vol. 245, no. 6742. 11 November 1972. p. 103.
  8. ^ "Remembering the Pentonville Five". Tribune. 21 July 2022. Retrieved 17 December 2023.
  9. ^ "Five men, six days: Pentonville voices". University of Warwick. Retrieved 17 December 2023.
  10. ^ "Pentonville voices: Persuasion and march". University of Warwick. Retrieved 17 December 2023.
  11. ^ a b Peta Steel (18 January 2013). "Vic Turner: Trade union leader and docker who was part of the imprisoned Pentonville Five". The Independent. Retrieved 17 December 2023.
  12. ^ a b "Pentonville voices: Parliament, release and conclusions". University of Warwick. Retrieved 17 December 2023.

Read other articles:

Darian Dam was constructed on the Sirwan River between 2009 and 2015. The Dam is located in the Hawrāmān region of Kurdistan and Kermanshah. The Darian Dam Archeological Salvage Program (DDASP) was planned by Iranian Center for Archaeological Research before flooding the reservoir.[1] A Middle Paleolithic rockshelter site near Hajij villageThis archaeological program, under the general direction of Fereidoun Biglari, has conducted several seasons of archaeological surveys and excava...

 

Vidi AldianoVidi pada tahun 2020LahirOxavia Aldiano29 Maret 1990 (umur 33)Jakarta, IndonesiaNama lainVidi AldianoAlmamaterUniversitas Pelita Harapan(2008-2012) University of Manchester, Berklee College of MusicPekerjaanPenyanyipenulis lagupembawa acaraaktorTahun aktif2008–sekarangSuami/istriSheila Dara Aisha ​(m. 2022)​KerabatVadi Akbar (adik)Karier musikGenrePopR&BsoulInstrumenVokalLabel Depic Production (2008–2010) Trinity Optima Productio...

 

Community radio station in South Dublin, Ireland This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (June 2020) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Dublin South FM (DSFM)Dublin, IrelandBroadcast areaSouth DublinFrequency93.9 MHzProgrammingFormatCommunity RadioOwnershipOwnerCommon ShareholdersHistoryFirst air date5 June 1995LinksWebsitedublinsouth...

Child Exploitation and Online Protection CommandHistoireFondation 2006CadrePays  Royaume-UniOrganisationSite web www.ceop.police.ukmodifier - modifier le code - modifier Wikidata Le Child Exploitation and Online Protection Command (CEOP Command ou CEOP) est un organisme de la police du Royaume-Uni, rattaché à la National Crime Agency. Fondé en avril 2006 sous le nom de Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre, le CEOP est chargé de lutter, à l'échelle nationale et internatio...

 

1984 live album by Tangerine DreamPoland1984 LP album coverLive album by Tangerine DreamReleasedNovember 1984[1]Recorded10 December 1983 (1983-12-10)VenueTorwar Hall, Warsaw[1]GenreElectronic music, Berlin SchoolLength81:49LabelJive ElectroProducerFroese, Franke, SchmoellingTangerine Dream chronology Flashpoint(1984) Poland(1984) Heartbreakers(1985) Professional ratingsReview scoresSourceRatingAllMusic[2] Poland - The Warsaw Concert is the twenty...

 

Diacritic mark in the Greek alphabet Iota subscripts in the word ᾠδῇ, (ode, dative) The iota subscript is a diacritic mark in the Greek alphabet shaped like a small vertical stroke or miniature iota ⟨ι⟩ placed below the letter. It can occur with the vowel letters eta ⟨η⟩, omega ⟨ω⟩, and alpha ⟨α⟩. It represents the former presence of an [i] offglide after the vowel, forming a so‐called long diphthong. Such diphthongs (i.e., η...

Wilayah yang dikuasai oleh Tepanek Tepanek atau Tepaneka adalah suku Mesoamerika yang tiba di wilayah Lembah Meksiko pada akhir abad ke-12 dan awal abad ke-13. Suku Tepanek berkerabat dengan Aztek (atau Mexica) dan juga Acolhua. Mereka menuturkan bahasa Nahuatl dan pada umumnya mengimani dewa-dewi yang sama dengan perbedaan di tingkatan daerah dan kesukuan. Ketika conquistadores Spanyol tiba di Lembah Meksiko, suku Tepanek sudah tunduk kepada Persekutuan Tiga Kaum Aztek yang dipimpin oleh Ten...

 

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Nuclear power in the Czech Republic – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2017) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) DukovanyTemelínclass=notpageimage| Nuclear power stations in the Czech Republic (view) Active plants...

 

Eine Puma der Bundespolizei bei der Demonstration des Löschsystems Löschwasserbehälter Bambi Bucket Sikorsky S-70 des österreichischen Bundesheeres beim Entleeren eines 3000 Liter Feuerlöschbehälters SEMAT „F“ 3000. Löschwasser-Außenlastbehälter für Hubschrauber sind Behältnisse zur Aufnahme von Löschmitteln, die von einem Hubschrauber unter dem Rumpf mitgeführt werden. Sie dienen der Brandbekämpfung an schwer zugänglichen Stellen (z. B. Gebirge) sowie bei Flur- und Wa...

Residential skyscraper in Manhattan, New York 111 Murray Street111 Murray Street on June 10, 2019.General informationStatusCompletedTypeResidential, retailLocation111 Murray StreetManhattan, New York CityCoordinates40°42′56″N 74°00′46″W / 40.7155556°N 74.0127778°W / 40.7155556; -74.0127778Construction started2015CompletedFebruary 16, 2018HeightArchitectural792 ft (241 m)Roof749 feet (228 m)Technical detailsFloor count58Floor area372,000 sqft ...

 

2023 filmGeorge Michael: Portrait of an ArtistDirected bySimon Napier-BellStarringGeorge MichaelRelease date 25 June 2023 (2023-06-25)[1] LanguageEnglish George Michael: Portrait of an Artist is a 2023 documentary about English singer-songwriter George Michael.[1] Critical reception ABC wrote the documentary dives deeper into who George really was—a kind and generous person who ultimately fought many demons while being front and center as one of the most famou...

 

هذه المقالة بحاجة لصندوق معلومات. فضلًا ساعد في تحسين هذه المقالة بإضافة صندوق معلومات مخصص إليها.   لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع الكنيسة الإنجيلية (توضيح). هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (أكتوبر 2015) الكني...

An example page from Pigot's 1839 directory of Kent, Surrey and Sussex. This page has information on Bromley and Canterbury Pigot's Directory was a major British directory started in 1814 by James Pigot.[1] Pigot's Directories covered England, Scotland, and Wales in the period before official Civil Registration began and are a valuable source of information regarding all major professions, nobility, gentry, clergy, trades and occupations including taverns and public houses and much mo...

 

This article is written like a review. Please help improve this article by rewriting it in encyclopedic style. (January 2008) The examples and perspective in this article may not represent a worldwide view of the subject. You may improve this article, discuss the issue on the talk page, or create a new article, as appropriate. (May 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Ali Bouali is perhaps Holland's best-known rapper, also successful in many other public roles. Dutch hip...

 

1988 studio album by Nuclear AssaultSurviveStudio album by Nuclear AssaultReleasedJune 13, 1988 (1988-06-13)RecordedJanuary–February, 1988StudioThe Music Grinder and Track Record Studios, Los Angeles, CaliforniaGenre Thrash metal crossover thrash Length30:15LabelI.R.S. MetalProducerRandy BurnsNuclear Assault chronology The Plague(1987) Survive(1988) Handle with Care(1989) Survive is the second studio album by American thrash metal band Nuclear Assault, released in 198...

Ilya PrigoginePrigogine pada tahun 1977Lahir(1917-01-25)25 Januari 1917Moscow, RussiaMeninggal28 Mei 2003(2003-05-28) (umur 86)Brussels, BelgiumKebangsaanBelgianAlmamaterUniversité Libre de BruxellesDikenal atasDissipative structuresPenghargaanNobel Prize for Chemistry (1977)Karier ilmiahBidangChemistry, PhysicsInstitusiUniversité Libre de BruxellesInternational Solvay InstituteUniversity of Texas, AustinPembimbing doktoralThéophile de DonderMahasiswa doktoralAdi BulsaraRadu BalescuDi...

 

Financial Stability BoardSingkatanFSBTanggal pendirianApril 2009; 14 tahun lalu (2009-04)TipeVereinKantor pusatBasel, SwissKetuaKlaas KnotSekretaris JenderalJohn SchindlerAfiliasiBank for International SettlementsG20Jumlah Staf (2017) 33Situs webfsb.orgNama sebelumnyaFinancial Stability Forum (FSF) Financial Stability Board (FSB, bahasa Indonesia: Badan Stabilitas Keuangan) adalah badan internasional yang memantau dan membuat rekomendasi tentang sistem keuangan global. FSB didirikan ...

 

Voetbal op de Olympische Zomerspelen 2016 Vrouwen Gehouden in Belo Horizonte, Brasília, Manaus, Rio de Janeiro, Salvador, São Paulo Jaar 2016 Data 3–19 augustus Sport Voetbal Accommodatie(s) Mineirão, Estádio Nacional de Brasília, Arena da Amazônia, Maracanã, Estádio Olímpico João Havelange, Itaipava Arena Fonte Nova, Arena Corinthians Deelnemers uit 12 landen Medailles 1   Duitsland 2   Zweden 3   Canada Vorige: 2012     Volgende: 2020 Port...

Copa Master de Supercopa 1994 Competizione Copa Master de Supercopa Sport Calcio Edizione 2ª Organizzatore CONMEBOL Date 3 marzo - 16 marzo 1995 Partecipanti 2 Risultati Vincitore  Cruzeiro(1º titolo) Secondo  Olimpia Statistiche Incontri disputati 2 Gol segnati 1 (0,5 per incontro) Cronologia della competizione 1992 Manuale La Copa Master de Supercopa 1994 è stata la seconda e ultima edizione del trofeo, ed è stata vinta dal Cruzeiro. Indice 1 Formula 2 Tabellino 2.1 Andat...

 

Spearfish SasquatchInformationLeagueIndependence League Baseball (Great Plains Division)LocationSpearfish, South DakotaBallparkBlack Hills Energy StadiumFounded2017League championships0Division championships2 (2021, 2022)Former league(s)Expedition LeagueColorsBlack, Light Blue, Light Gray     OwnershipEric SchmidtManagerJarrett HuntGeneral ManagerEric SchmidtWebsitewww.spearfishsasquatch.com// The Spearfish Sasquatch is a baseball team in the Independence League Baseball b...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!