Kuikka was recruited by Mark Krikorian to join his Florida State University squad for the 2015 season. In her freshman year, she played in a total of 19 games, all as a midfielder, tallying 6 goals and 5 assists. She scored the first goal of her career versus New Mexico State University on 21 August 2015. In the ACC tournament, her goal and two assists earned her the first of her ACC Tournament MVP Awards.[3]
Moving to the central defender role beginning her sophomore season, Kuikka helped solidify a defense that allowed a paltry 0.39 GAA. For the second year in a row, she won the ACC Tournament MVP award for her solid defensive play and two shootout penalty kick conversions.[4]
After being selected as a team captain, success as the director of the defensive line continued in her junior year. The Seminoles had eight clean sheets including two in the NCAA Tournament.[5]
As a senior and team captain, Kuikka anchored the Seminoles defense and led the team to a school-record 16 shutouts, including four in the NCAA Tournament. The final two being in the College Cup versus defending champion Stanford and in the final versus UNC to claim the NCAA Championship.[6] Her efforts garnered her the 2018-9 Honda Sport Award for the top female athlete in NCAA Division I soccer.[7][8]
Kuikka graduated in 2018 with a bachelor's degree in criminology.[9]
In the summer of 2017, Kuikka joined Santa Clarita Blue Heat in the United Women's Soccer league. She helped lead the defense to allow only 5 goals in 8 regular season games.[11] She started in the UWS semi-final and final alongside Florida State teammate, Deyna Castellanos.
On October 29, 2020, Portland Thorns FC announced that they signed Kuikka to a two-year deal, starting in 2021.[13] On September 20, 2022, the club announced that they signed Kuikka to a one-year deal, extending her contract through the 2023 season.[14] At the end of the 2022 season, Kuikka won the NWSL Championship title with Thorns.[15]
Chicago Red Stars
On 18 January 2024, fellow NWSL side Chicago Red Stars announced the signing of Kuikka on a three-year deal.[16]
International career
Having been capped for the Finnish U-16, U-17, U-18, U-19, and U-20 teams, Kuikka also played in the U-20 Women's World Cup in 2014.