Murder of Tulay Goren

Tulay Goren
Born	(1983-03-00)March 1983 Elbistan, Turkey
Died	7 January 1999(1999-01-07) (aged 15) Woodford Green, Greater London, England
Nationality	Kurd
Citizenship	British
Occupation	Student
Known for	Honour killing victim

Tulay Goren (March 1983 – 7 January 1999) was a 15-year-old Kurdish schoolgirl from Woodford Green, East London who went missing in January 1999.

In December 2009, some ten years after her disappearance, her father Mehmet Goren was convicted of her murder. She was killed in a so-called honour killing because of her relationship with an older man, from a different branch of the Islamic faith. Mehmet Goren was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 22 years. Tulay's body has never been found.^[1][2]

Goren's trial was the first time an expert witness in honour-based violence was called to give evidence in a British Court.^[3]

Background

Tulay was born in Turkey in March 1983; she was one of four children born to Mehmet and Hanim Goren. Her family, of the Alevi branch of Islam, are Turkish Kurds who originate from Elbistan, Kahramanmaraş^[4][5] and who arrived in the United Kingdom as illegal immigrants in the mid-nineties, later claiming asylum.^[6][7]

Tulay's father Mehmet was a convicted criminal with alleged ties to the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK). He had served custodial sentences in both Saudi Arabia^[4] and Turkey^[8] prior to entering the United Kingdom. He was violent towards his wife and children and had earlier made attempts to kill them.^[7] He failed to adjust to his new life in the United Kingdom,^[8] refused to learn to speak English^[9] and adhered to what was described as the "feudal" culture existent in his home village.^[10]

Tulay attended Woodbridge High School, Woodford Green; described by a schoolfriend as a "sad" individual, who "only smiled or seemed happy when she spoke about [Unal]" (an older Turkish Kurd with whom Tulay had embarked on a relationship, as discussed under § Timeline below); she didn't talk about her home life. Coming close to being excluded for truanting and smoking, her elder sister said she was rebelling "in a big way",^[1] later stating "Tulay was caught in the middle of two clashing worlds. At home she was expected to be a dutiful Turkish daughter, while out of the family home she was exposed to a lifestyle that was completely at odds with her upbringing."^[9]

Timeline

Pre-disappearance

During the school holidays of 1998, Tulay took a summer job at a clothing factory in Hackney, London where she met and then embarked on a relationship with Halil Unal.^[11] Unal, also a Turkish Kurd, was 15 years older than Tulay and from the Sunni branch of Islam;^[12] her family didn't approve, and Tulay was ordered to end the relationship.^[11][1][2]

After her summer job at the factory ended the couple maintained daily telephone contact; on 10 December 1998, Mehmet Goren went to Unal's place of work, assaulted him and warned him to stop "bothering" his daughter.^[13] Unal reported the assault but didn't press charges. On the same day, Tulay's family took her to the local police station and reported Unal for "pestering" her.^[14]

On 14 December 1998, Tulay ran away from home and went to live with Unal. After initially reporting her missing and reporting Unal for "unlawful sexual intercourse",^[15] the family changed track, agreed that the pair should get married, and a ceremony was scheduled for 21 December at Hackney Register Office.^[7] Despite Mehmet's attempts to bribe the registrar,^[5] the ceremony did not go ahead as Tulay, aged 15, was underage. A new date was set for 8 March 1999, when Tulay would've reached her 16th birthday.^[16]

The couple continued living together until 6 January 1999, when Tulay's father — claiming he objected to her sharing a home with Unal's male flatmate — forced her to return to the family home. He told Unal that she'd remain at home until he'd found somewhere suitable for the two of them to live.^[11]

Murder

Having forced Tulay to return home on 6 January, her father beat her, tied her up and drugged her with sleeping tablets.^[7] The following day he sent his wife and other children to stay with his brother overnight, telling her that he and Tulay had "things to talk about".^[17]

It is not known how she died, but police believe she was either smothered or strangled^[7] and then buried temporarily in the back garden of the family home before being moved to an unknown location.^[14]

Post-disappearance

When Hanim Goren returned to the family home following her overnight stay at the home of her brother-in-law, her husband told her that Tulay had run away.^[17]

Having already murdered his daughter, on 20 January 1999, Mehmet Goren arranged to meet Unal to discuss his and Tulay's future. Having lured him to the meeting, he attacked Unal with an axe.^[11] In the intervening period between Tulay's disappearance and the later murder trial, Mehmet Goren was convicted of grievous bodily harm for the axe attack on Unal and jailed for five years.^[1]

On 22 January 1999,^[18] Unal reported Tulay missing.^[19]

Investigation

After initially corroborating her husband's story and maintaining that Tulay had run away, Hanim Goren was arrested on suspicion of perverting the course of justice and murder.^[20] On 23 March 1999, during a police interview, she admitted that she'd lied and that, although she hadn't witnessed her daughter's death, she believed that Mehmet had killed her. She noted that two kitchen knives, bin bags, and a washing line went missing after Tulay disappeared, that their garden had been dug up, and that her husband had visible injuries to his hands.^[11]

Hanim was prepared to testify against her husband but, without a body and a case heavily reliant on hearsay evidence, the Crown Prosecution Service declined to proceed.^[11] The investigation was further impeded by the familial "honour code" and a lack of awareness around "honour" crimes among British authorities at that time.^[21]

In 2007, the case was reinvestigated, as in the intervening period successful prosecutions had been brought in the "honour" killings of Heshu Yones and Banaz Mahmod, there was now a better understanding of honour-based violence, and criminal evidence reforms had changed the admissibility of hearsay evidence. On 25 November 2008, Mehmet Goren and his two brothers Ali and Cuma were arrested on suspicion of murder and conspiracy to murder.^[21] They were charged two days later.^[22]

Legal proceedings

In October 2009, Mehmet Goren and his two brothers stood trial at The Old Bailey for the murder of Tulay and conspiracy to murder Halil Unal.^[23]

After initially insisting that Tulay had run away, Mehmet Goren changed his evidence^[1] and alleged that his elder brother Ali had ordered him to kill Tulay and Unal when their planned December marriage ceremony was unable to go ahead;^[24] he claimed that he'd refused and so Ali had taken Tulay away, suggesting Mehmet say that she'd been "handed over" to the PKK.^[25]

The prosecution case was that, as head of the family, Ali Goren would've been "key" in making the decision to kill Tulay and Unal.^[1] He denied any involvement, maintaining that he was "distant" from his brother and had been shunned when he tried to act as "peacemaker" between father and daughter.^[5]

Hanim Goren testified for the prosecution, relaying the events of 6 and 7 January 1999 and her suspicions after she returned home and Tulay was missing. She spoke of missing items, such as bin bags and knives, and stains on the clothing Mehmet had been wearing the day Tulay disappeared. She claimed that the garden had been dug up and some of Tulay's belongings had been destroyed, and said her husband stated "From now on she's gone. I disown her. She is not my child any more. From now on we do not have four children any more. We will only have three children."^[17][26]

Halil Unal gave evidence from behind a screen, testifying that Tulay had called him the day after she was forced to go home, warning him: "don't come over. They are trying to lure you into a trap.' He spoke of Mehmet attacking him with an axe after tricking him into attending a meeting at a pub some two weeks after Tulay was last seen.^[27]

Expert in "honour" crimes, Professor Yakin Ertürk, gave evidence in what was the first use of expert witnesses in a case of this kind in the United Kingdom.^[3]

Mehmet Goren was found guilty of murder on 17 December 2009 and sentenced to life imprisonment, with a minimum tariff of 22 years. He was acquitted of conspiring to murder Halil Unal. Ali and Cuma Goren were acquitted on both charges.^[28]

After the trial, Hanim Goren's bravery in testifying against her husband was praised by the police^[29] and her daughter Nuray, who stated: "No one should fail to realise what this means within our culture. These people do not forget". Following her testimony, the police installed extra security measures in Hanim's home.^[30][31]

Further reading

• Honour-based Violence (HBV) and Honour-based Killings in Iraqi Kurdistan and in the Kurdish Diaspora in the UK (Journal of Gender Studies)^[32]
• The crimewave that shames the world Robert Fisk 2010

See also

• List of solved missing person cases

Honour killings in the United Kingdom

• Shafilea Ahmed
• Rania Alayed
• Banaz Mahmod
• Samaira Nazir
• Murder of Heshu Yones
• Rukhsana Naz

Honour killings of people with Kurdish ethnic heritage:

• Pela Atroshi (Iraqi Kurdistan)
• Fadime Şahindal (Sweden)
• Hatun Sürücü (Germany)

References

1. "Tulay Goren: Rebelling 'in a big way' made her victim of father's rage". the Guardian. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 28 July 2020. Retrieved 29 July 2020.
2. "Father jailed for life for "honour" murder". Reuters. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 11 March 2022. Retrieved 30 July 2020.
3. "Tulay's murder 'a wake-up call'". BBC. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 1 June 2022. Retrieved 1 August 2020.
4. "Profiles: Tulay Goren 'honour killing'". the Guardian. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 28 July 2020. Retrieved 28 July 2020.
5. "Murdered in the name of 'honour'". BBC. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 27 August 2017. Retrieved 28 July 2020.
6. "Father killed girl 'to restore so-called honour'". The Independent. 8 October 2009. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022.
7. "Father jailed for life for daughter's 'honour killing'". The Independent. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022.
8. "Honour killing guilty verdict: profile of father Mehmet Goren". Telegraph. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 22 November 2021. Retrieved 30 July 2020.
9. "'Feudal' killer tried to inject wife with rat poison". Evening Standard. 17 December 2009.
10. Bingham, John (18 December 2009). "Honour killing: how mother Hanim Goren shattered the 'code of honour'". Telegraph. Archived from the original on 23 November 2021. Retrieved 30 July 2020.
11. "How a mother's courage solved daughter's murder". The Independent. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022.
12. Dominelli, Lena (28 December 2010). Social work in a globalizing world. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press. p. 134. ISBN 9780745640884.
13. "Honour killing girl 'wanted love'". BBC. 12 October 2009. Archived from the original on 25 July 2015. Retrieved 1 August 2020.
14. Bingham, John (18 December 2009). "Honour killing: why did police send Tulay Goren home to die by her violent father?". Archived from the original on 11 February 2021. Retrieved 2 August 2020.
15. "Honour killing". Telegraph. 18 December 2009. Archived from the original on 9 November 2020. Retrieved 1 August 2020.
16. "Honour killing guilty verdict: profile of the victim's boyfriend Halil Unal". Telegraph. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 23 November 2021. Retrieved 1 August 2020.
17. "Father 'tied up' honour case girl". BBC. 20 October 2009.
18. "Family plea to 'honour' killer father - News". The Asian Today Online. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 2 December 2022. Retrieved 1 August 2020.
19. "Teenage girl 'murdered by father'". BBC. 8 October 2009. Archived from the original on 7 December 2021. Retrieved 1 August 2020.
20. "Honour case mother denies killing". BBC. 26 October 2009.
21. "Tulay Goren: Police hampered by honour code that silenced family". the Guardian. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 12 December 2020. Retrieved 2 August 2020.
22. "Murder charge over missing girl". BBC. 27 November 2008. Archived from the original on 4 December 2008. Retrieved 2 August 2020.
23. "'Honour killing' girl Tulay Goren 'ran off to join PKK guerrillas' claim". Telegraph. 11 November 2009. Archived from the original on 26 February 2021. Retrieved 2 August 2020.
24. "Father of Tulay Goren says he defied 'honour killing' order from brother". the Guardian. 17 November 2009. Archived from the original on 1 March 2021. Retrieved 2 August 2020.
25. "Brother blamed for 'honour death'". BBC. 18 November 2009.
26. "Honour case mother demands answer". BBC. 21 October 2009.
27. "'Honour' killing girl Tulay Goren warned lover of trap". the Guardian. 13 October 2009. Archived from the original on 5 September 2021. Retrieved 3 August 2020.
28. "Father jailed for 'honour' murder". BBC. 17 December 2009. Archived from the original on 6 September 2017. Retrieved 3 August 2020.
29. McVeigh, Karen (17 December 2009). "Father jailed for life for 'honour killing' of Tulay Goren". The Guardian.
30. McVeigh, Karen (17 December 2009). "Tulay Goren's father given life sentence for 'honour killing'". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 28 July 2020. Retrieved 3 August 2020.
31. "Fear after husband jailed for 'honour killing'". The Sydney Morning Herald. 18 December 2009.
32. Hague, Gill; Gill, Aisha K.; Begikhani, Nazand (December 2013). "'Honour'-based violence and Kurdish communities: Moving towards action and change in Iraqi Kurdistan and the UK". Journal of Gender Studies. 22 (4): 383–396. doi:10.1080/09589236.2012.708825. S2CID 143845062.