Sir Moses Haim Montefiore, 1st Baronet, FRS (24 October 1784 – 28 July 1885) was a British financier and banker, activist, philanthropist and Sheriff of London. Born to an Italian Sephardic Jewish family based in London, after he achieved success, he donated large sums of money to promote industry, business, economic development, education and health among the Jewish community in the Levant. He founded Mishkenot Sha'ananim in 1860, the first Jewish settlement outside the Old City of Jerusalem.
Moses Montefiore was born in Leghorn (Livorno in Italian), Tuscany, in 1784, to a Sephardic Jewish family based in Great Britain.[7] His grandfather, Moses Vital (Haim) Montefiore, had emigrated from Livorno to London in the 1740s, but retained close contact with the town. It was known for making straw bonnets. Montefiore was born while his parents, Joseph Elias Montefiore and his young wife Rachel, the daughter of Abraham Mocatta, a powerful bullion broker in London, were in the town on a business journey. Moses was close to his aunt, Selina Hannah Laurence (née Montefiore 1768–1838); a visit to her in 1829 prompted his recollection of the death of his beloved grandmother Esther Hannah Montefiore (1733 – c. 1812). Selina lived at Bury Court, St Mary Axe, London, and had anglicised the surname of her husband Zaccaria Levy (1751–1828) to Laurence following his death.[8][9][10][11][12]
The family returned to Kennington in London, where Montefiore attended school. His family's precarious financial situation prevented Montefiore from completing his schooling and he went out to work to help support the family.[13] After working for a wholesale tea merchant and grocer, he was hired by a counting house in the City of London.[14] In 1803 he entered the London Stock Exchange, but lost all of his clients' money in 1806 in a fraud perpetrated by Joseph Elkin Daniels.[15] As a result, he probably had to sell or give up his broker's licence.[16]
In 1812, Montefiore became a freemason, joining the Moira Lodge, No. 92 of the Premier Grand Lodge of England in London.[17] Between 1810 and 1814 Montefiore was part of the Surrey Militia.[16] In 1815, he again bought a broker's licence, and briefly operated a joint venture with his brother Abraham until 1816. He largely closed down his trading activities in 1820.[18]
Though somewhat lax in religious observance in his early life, after his visit to the Holy Land in 1827, Montefiore became a strictly observant Jew. He traveled with a personal shohet (ritual slaughterer), to ensure that he would have a ready supply of kosher meat.[21] Although Montefiore spent only a few days in Jerusalem, the 1827 visit changed his life.[22] He resolved to increase his religious observance and to attend synagogue on Shabbat, as well as Mondays and Thursdays when the Torah is read. The visit had been a "spiritual transforming event" for him.[22]
In 1831, Montefiore purchased a country estate with twenty-four acres on the East Cliff of the fashionable seaside town of Ramsgate. The property had previously been a country house of Queen Caroline, when she was still Princess of Wales. It was next owned by the Marquess Wellesley, a brother of the Duke of Wellington.[23] Soon afterward, Montefiore purchased the adjoining land and commissioned his cousin, architect David Mocatta, to design a private synagogue, known as the Montefiore Synagogue. It opened with a grand public ceremony in 1833.[23]
Montefiore is mentioned in Charles Dickens' diaries, in the personal papers of George Eliot, and in James Joyce’s novel Ulysses. It is known that he had contacts with Protestant non-conformists and social reformers in Victorian England. He was active in public initiatives aimed at alleviating the persecution of minorities in the Middle East and elsewhere, and he worked closely with organisations that campaigned for the abolition of slavery. A Government loan raised by the Rothschilds and Montefiore in 1835 enabled the British Government to compensate plantation owners under the Slavery Abolition Act 1833 and abolish slavery in the Empire.[24]
In 1836 Montefiore became a governor of Christ's Hospital, the Bluecoat school, after assisting in the case of a distressed man who had appealed to him to help his soon-to-be-widowed wife and son.[25] Montefiore was elected Sheriff of the City of London in 1837.[26] He was knighted in November 1837.[27]
From retirement until the day he died, Montefiore devoted himself to philanthropy, particularly alleviating the distress of Jews abroad. He went to the sultan of the Ottoman Empire in 1840 to liberate from prison ten Syrian Jews of Damascus arrested for blood libel in a case known as the Damascus affair; to Rome in 1858 to try to free Jewish youth Edgardo Mortara, who had been seized by the Catholic Church after allegedly being baptised by a Catholic servant; to Russia in 1846 (where he was received by the Tsar) and 1872; to Morocco in 1864, and to Romania in 1867. These missions made him a folk hero of near mythological proportions among the oppressed Jews of Eastern Europe, North Africa, and the Levant.[29]
Montefiore received a baronetcy in 1846 in recognition of his services to humanitarian causes on behalf of the Jewish people.[30]
Philanthropy in Ottoman Palestine
Montefiore on his 100th birthday
He and his wife travelled to Palestine after the region was wracked by an earthquake in 1836. The towns of Safed and Tiberias were particularly damaged, with the few survivors suffering disorder, terror and disease. Moses and Judith launched an ambitious programme of relief in 1837.[31]
In 1854 his American friend Judah Touro, also a Sephardic Jew, died after having bequeathed money to fund Jewish residential settlement in Palestine. Montefiore was appointed executor of his will, and used the funds for a variety of projects to encourage the Jews to engage in productive labor. In 1855, he purchased an orchard on the outskirts of Jaffa that offered agricultural training to the Jews.[32]
In 1860, he built the first Jewish residential settlement and almshouse outside the old walled city of Jerusalem, which today is known as Mishkenot Sha'ananim. This became the first precursor of the New Yishuv. Living outside the city walls was dangerous at the time, due to lawlessness and bandits. Montefiore offered financial inducement to encourage poor families to move there. Montefiore intended Mishkenot Sha’ananim to be a new type of self-sufficient, sanitary settlement where Sephardi and Ashkenazi Jews lived together.[33] Later on, Montefiore established adjacent neighborhoods south of Jaffa Road, the Ohel Moshe neighborhood for Sephardic Jews and the Mazkeret Moshe neighborhood for Ashkenazi Jews, who had distinctly different traditions and languages.[34]
Montefiore donated large sums of money to promote industry, education, and health amongst the Jewish community in Palestine. The project, bearing the hallmarks of nineteenth-century artisanal revival, aimed to promote productive enterprise in the Yishuv. The builders were brought over from England. These activities were part of a broader program to enable the Old Yishuv to become self-supporting in anticipation of the establishment of a Jewish homeland.[35]
Montefiore built the Montefiore Windmill in an area that later developed as the Yemin Moshe neighbourhood, to provide cheap flour to poor Jews. He also established a printing press and textile factory, and helped to finance several Bilu agricultural colonies. The Jews of Old Yishuv referred to their patron as "ha-Sar Montefiore" ('The Prince' or simply 'Prince' Montefiore), a title perpetuated in Hebrew literature and song.[36]
Montefiore commissioned several censuses of the Yishuv, or Jewish community in Palestine: these were conducted in 1839, 1849, 1855, 1866 and 1875, and provided much data about the people. The censuses attempted to list every Jew individually, together with some biographical and social information (such as their family structure, place of origin, and degree of poverty).[37]
Later life and death
Seal of the "Kerem Moshe Montefiore and Yehudit" Society in Jerusalem ("Vineyard of Moses and Judith Montefiore" Society in Jerusalem); inscribed in Hebrew and German
Montefiore played an important role in Ramsgate affairs, and one of the local ridings still bears his name. In 1845 he served as High Sheriff of Kent.[38] In 1873, the year of his 89th birthday, a local newspaper mistakenly ran his obituary. "Thank God to have been able to hear of the rumour", he wrote to the editor, "and to read an account of the same with my own eyes, without using spectacles."[39]
The town celebrated his 99th and his 100th birthdays in great style, and every local charity (and church) benefited from his philanthropy. At East Cliff Lodge, he established a Sephardicyeshiva (Judith Lady Montefiore College) after the death of his wife in 1862. In the grounds he built the elegant, Regency architectureMontefiore Synagogue and mausoleum modeled on Rachel's Tomb outside Bethlehem. (He also paid for the refurbishment and upkeep of this historic tomb.) Judith was laid to rest there in 1862.[40]
Montefiore died in 1885, at age 100 years and 9 months. He had no known children. His principal heir in name, arms and property was his nephew Sir Joseph Sebag-Montefiore (1822–1903, born Joseph Sebag), a British banker, stockbroker and politician.[41]
Sir Joseph's descendant, British historian Simon Sebag Montefiore (born 1965), revealed that his family believes Sir Moses to have fathered a child late in life with a 16-year-old domestic servant.[42] Philanthropist Leonard Montefiore was a great-nephew of Sir Moses Montefiore.[43] Sir Moses Montefiore was buried in the mausoleum which he had had built near the Montefiore Synagogue at Ramsgate.[44]
The estate was sold to the Borough of Ramsgate around 1952, and the Lodge was demolished in 1954. All that remains today is a new building housing a firm of architects. It incorporates parts of the original structure, called the Coach House. There are also some outbuildings that survive (including the Gate House). The Italianate Greenhouse has been restored to its former glory in the early 21st century. The Greenhouse and the rest of the estate are now protected as King George VI Memorial Park. A plaque on the Gate House honors Sir Moses.[45]
A number of synagogues were named in honour of Montefiore, including the 1913 Montefiore Institute, now preserved as the Little Synagogue on the Prairie.[49]
The Montefiore Club was a private social and business association, catering to the Jewish community located in Montreal, Quebec, Canada.[50]
He was commemorated on two Israeli banknotes. These were the IL10, which was in circulation from 1970 to 1979,[52] and the IS 1, which was legal tender from 1980 to 1986.[53]
The Montefiore Family Papers were initially deposited in the Montefiore Museum in Judith Lady Montefiore College, Ramsgate, Kent.[55] In 1961 the Montefiore Endowment deposited the papers of Montefiore Family at the Mocatta Library of University College London.[55] The archive spans 24 volumes and 515 items.[55] The papers comprise correspondence, account books, and a private appointment diary.[55] Also included are many testimonials and centenary tributes to Montefiore thanking him for his generosity; these have been digitised.[56]
Anecdote
Montefiore was renowned for his quick and sharp wit. A popularly circulated anecdote, possibly apocryphal, relates that at a dinner party he was once seated next to a nobleman who was known to be an anti-Semite. The nobleman told Montefiore that he had just returned from a trip to Japan, where "they have neither pigs nor Jews." Montefiore is reported to have responded immediately, "in that case, you and I should go there, so it will have a sample of each" (a similar anecdote is told of Israel Zangwill).[57]
^Macleod, N. (1867). Good Words. Strahan & Co. London. p. 72. Retrieved 16 November 2022. No man living has done so much for his brethren in Palestine as Sir Moses Montefiore....
^Creation of Israel. "Israel and You" (C) 2013 All Rights Reserved. 2013. Retrieved 21 November 2022. The modern legal attempts to establish a national homeland for the Jewish people began in 1839 with a petition by Sir Moses Montefiore to the Khedive of Egypt, for a Jewish homeland in the region of Palestine.
^Wolf, L. (1884). The Life of Sir Moses Montefiore. Cambridge University Press. p. 276. ISBN978-1-108-03668-9. Retrieved 4 March 2024. When questioned on the subject some years ago, he answered,"...Palestine must belong to the Jews..."
^"LEVY AKA LAURENCE Selina Hannah aka Simha aka Esther Ann". Synagogue Scribes. Synagogue Scribes Jewish Genealogy. 2023. Retrieved 15 November 2023. Usually residing at Bath Somerset but now Bury Court St. Mary Axe London...Following the death of her husband all of their children were baptised and none remained in the Jewish custom. She was baptised Suffolk 12 March 1835. Her son Joseph was baptised 17 November 1814 St. Mary Woolworth London. When Joseph married Penelope Jackson her grandmother Penelope Laurence Jackson specified in her will 1824..."It is my earnest wish that they may change their names to my family name of Laurence and may use their best endeavours to obtain that change by authority of parliament". Joseph agreed and changed his name by Deed Poll on 26 December 1826 – all his brothers adopted Laurence as their last name as did their mother. The Joseph Levy aka Laurence line links to Tim Laurence who married the Princess Royal in 1992. In her will provision was made by Selina for her son Alexander. He appears to have suffered from mental issues during his life and was cared for privately but later admitted to Camberwell Lunatic Asylum in 1856 and died in the institute in 1858.The family lines are well documented and include relatives who settled in Australia.Her husband Zaccaria is buried in the Novo Cemetery and a plot was reserved for his wife. However, she is buried as Mrs Selina Hannah Laurence in Stoke Newington Churchyard.
^Moshe Samet, "Moses Montefiore – Reality and Myth", Carmel, 1989, 20–22 (in Hebrew).
^Green, A. (2010). "Brothers-in-law: the Rothschilds and the Montefiores"(PDF). Brasenose College Oxford University. Retrieved 28 February 2024. Montefiore was not just a businessman and Jewish activist, he was also Nathan Rothschild's brother-in-law.
^Kessler, Daniel (2016). "The Jewish community in nineteenth century Palestine: evidence from the Montefiore censuses". Middle Eastern Studies. 52 (6): 996–1010. doi:10.1080/00263206.2016.1198323. S2CID151473627.
^"Montefiore". London Times. 5 September 1885. p. 9f. The Queen has granted to Mr. Joseph Sebag, nephew and residuary legatee of the late Sir Moses Montefiore, and his successor in the East Cliff estate, Ramsgate, her Royal licence to use the surname of Montefiore after his own paternal name, and to bear Sir M. Montefiore's arms.
^Erwin R. Steinberg. "James Joyce and the Critics Notwithstanding, Leopold Bloom Is Not Jewish". Journal of Modern Literature, Vol. 9, No. 1 (1981–1982), pp. 27–49 JSTOR3831274
.png){kind=small}
