Indonesia–Israel relations

Indonesian–Israeli relations

Indonesia	Israel

Israel and Indonesia have no formal diplomatic ties, although they maintain quiet trade, tourism and security contacts.^[1] In 2012, Indonesia spoke of upgrading relations with Israel and opening a consulate in Ramallah,^[2] but this agreement was never implemented.

Relations between the two countries have worsened since the 2023 Israel–Hamas war, especially when Israel attacked and occupied an Indonesian hospital in Gaza. It was reported that this increased Indonesia's support for Palestine.^[3]

As Indonesia is working towards accession to the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Israeli media reported that Indonesia has committed to establishing diplomatic ties with Israel for the first time.^[4] The OECD Secretary-General, Mathias Cormann, confirmed that Indonesia must establish diplomatic relations with all OECD member countries before any decision on its admission to the OECD is made.^[5] However, the Indonesian Government denied reports of any plan to develop diplomatic ties with Israel and confirmed its support for Palestine's independence.^[6]

History

Indonesia purchased over 30 Douglas A-4 Skyhawks from Israel in the early 1980s, despite no recognition or diplomatic relations.^[7]

While not openly opposed to Israel necessarily, Indonesia does not want to provoke the country's Islamist elements which held a staunch opposition against Israel.^[8]

Indonesia's first president, Sukarno, brushed aside Israeli overtures and eventually adopted a strong pro-Arab policy as part of his anti-colonialist worldview.^[9] A notable incident was the expulsion of Israel and the Republic of China (Taiwan) from the 1962 Asian Games held in Jakarta. Because of the pressure from Arab countries and the People's Republic of China, the Indonesian government refused to issue visas for the Israeli and Taiwanese delegations, thus refused the entry of delegations from Israel.^[10]

However, with the transition to the New Order and the installation of General Suharto as president, military and intelligence ties were opened through unofficial channels, especially Iran and Turkey, in 1968. In 1971, Indonesian and Israeli military officers are believed to have started negotiations on transfer of military hardware and sharing of intelligence on global Communist terrorist groups. In November the following year, some counter-battery radars for accurate artillery fire were bought by the Indonesian military from the Israel Military Industries. In March 1974, a team of 27 officers and 90 soldiers from the Indonesian Army were sent to study a 2-month course to Israel on artillery radar and land surveillance, as well as ELINT and SIGINT from the Israeli Defence Forces. In January 1975, the Indonesian Navy and Indonesian Air Force sent a 60-man team to Israel to learn special insertion and covert operations from Shayetet 13 and the Israeli Navy. The result was the establishment of a Special Forces Training School to train small units of the Kopassus in airborne and seaborne insertion, in November 1975. In August 1976, Indonesian and Israeli Chiefs of Air Staff met during a supposedly coincidental visit to Tehran to discuss the Indonesian procurement of 35 Douglas A-4 Skyhawk fighter aircraft from Israel, which were ultimately delivered in 1981–82 under Operation Alpha. Indonesia is also interested in Israeli-made drones, especially the IAI Searcher and IAI Heron drones. Four Searcher UAVs have been delivered through Philippines Kital Group, with Heron UAV still in consideration. Singaporean leased Searcher drones also assisted the Indonesian army in Operation Tinombala.^[11]

In 1993, Prime Minister of Israel Yitzhak Rabin met Indonesian president Suharto at his private residence in Jakarta. This, what press said was Rabin's unscheduled visit, happened during Suharto's chairmanship of the Non-Aligned Movement and shortly after the Oslo Accords.^[12] This was the first ever high-profile meeting between both leaders.

In 1999, after entering the Reformation era, Indonesian president Abdurrahman Wahid and Foreign Minister Alwi Shihab mentioned their wishes to open ties with Israel although only at the level of economic and trade links.^[13] Wahid believed that Indonesia has no reason to be against Israel. He pointed to the fact that Indonesia has "long-term relationships" with China and the Soviet Union, two countries he viewed as having atheism as part of their constitutions, and further explained that Israel "has a reputation as a nation with a high regard for God and religion."^[14] However, after Wahid's removal from office in 2001, no effort was maintained to improve the relations between Indonesia and Israel.^[9]

In 2005, Indonesia said that establishing full diplomatic ties with Israel will only be possible after peace has been reached between Israel and Palestine.^[15] Israeli Foreign Minister Silvan Shalom held a discreet first meeting with his Indonesian counterpart Hassan Wirajuda during a UN summit in New York City in September 2005.^[2] However, President of Indonesia Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono ruled out establishing formal diplomatic ties but said: "Any communication between Indonesian and Israeli officials will be oriented to the objective of assisting the Palestinian people in gaining their independence".^[16]

In 2006, Indonesia and several Islamic groups in the country condemned Israel's ongoing military operation in Gaza and demanded the release of arrested Palestinian officials,^[17] and also called on Israel to withdraw its forces from Lebanon during the 2006 Lebanon War. The Indonesian Foreign Ministry advised that the national tennis team was pulling out of its Fed Cup matches in Israel, saying "We are witnessing a military invasion by Israel and the arrest of scores of Palestinian officials...It is now impossible to play there".^[18]

In a visit to Singapore in 2006, the Israeli Arab diplomat Ali Yahya called for direct ties between Israel and Indonesia. In an interview with The Jakarta Post he said,

I misunderstand why the relationship between the majorities of Muslims in Asia is hostile to Israel. If it is because of Israel and Palestine, then (how can it be reconciled that) we have peace with Jordan, Egypt, Morocco, but not with eastern Asia?

We protect the holy places in Israel, respect the Arabic language, and bring imams and rabbis together to have discussions. I am posing a question if the Muslim countries in Asia can open the gate to their country for us, so that we can open up relations with them.

There are so many opportunities in Israel and by stressing the need for cooperation we would like to get these countries to also have a share of these opportunities. But to do that, we need to have the opportunity to talk directly to these countries, which I hope, will come up soon.^[19]

In 2008, the Jakarta Post printed a letter from Israeli Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Majalli Wahabi, urging Indonesia to take a role in advocating for peace in the Middle East. Analysts suggested that the printing of the letter might be a signal of a thaw between the two nations.^[20] However, the Gaza War that lasted from late 27 December 2008 to 18 January 2009 affected relations. Indonesia harshly condemned Israeli actions, labeling it as "aggression", and expressed its support of the Palestinians.

In March 2016, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called for normalization of ties with Indonesia, citing "many opportunities for bilateral cooperation" and adding that reasons preventing relationship between the two countries were no longer relevant.^[21] However, Indonesia refused, stating that it will only consider normalization if Palestinian independence is fulfilled.^[22]

In 2018, member of Presidential Advisory Council Yahya Cholil Staquf visited Israel to meet Benjamin Netanyahu and joined a Jewish Forum, which was responded negatively by the Indonesian public.^[23]

In 2023 Israeli Olympic shooter Sergy Rikhter withdrew from international competition in Jakarta after the International Shooting Sport Federation (ISSF) refused to allow him to compete with any symbols representing Rikhter's home country of Israel.^[24][25] In order to qualify for the 2024 Summer Olympics in Paris, athletes are required to have participated in at least two ISSF Championships during the Qualifying period, reach a Minimum Qualifying Score (MQS), and secure a place in one of five quotas within a series of four World Cup meets, of which Jakarta is the first in this cycle.^[26][27] Richter won gold for Shooting at the 2019 European Games in 10 metre air rifle and competed in Tokyo Shooting at the 2020 Summer Olympics – Men's 10 metre air rifle.^[24][25] Reportedly, World Cup organizers informed Richter and the Israeli federation they would only allow him to participate with his weapon if he competes with identification symbols of the ISSF or the flag of the International Olympic Committee. Richter rebuffed the ISSF and chose not to compete in the World Cup, in part stating,

I will never accept to participate in a competition without the [IOC Country Code] ISR on my competition suit, on my personal rifle and on the results screen…I start the most important year on the way to Paris, when my opponents take a professional advantage over me due to political problems. If the Olympic movement, which advocates the existence of sports without distinctions of nationality, religion, race and sex, does not support its ideology, then what is its value? I don't understand how the state is allowed to organize some sort of competition with a national identity restriction.^[25]

On 29 March 2023, FIFA announced that Indonesia would lose its right to host the 2023 FIFA U-20 World Cup and a new country be selected instead. This is because of controversy over Israel's participation in the competition in Indonesia, which does not officially recognize Israel as a sovereign state.^[28]

Following the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel, Indonesia condemned Israel's bombing campaign against the Gaza strip. Specifically, Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi issued the "harshest of condemnations" towards Israel's assault on the Indonesian Hospital in Gaza. As part of a delegation of OIC countries, agreed to during an emergency session of the Islamic Summit Conference, Marsudi visited China and Russia, both Permanent Members of the UNSC, in an effort to garner support for a ceasefire.^[29][30][31] In Moscow, Marsudi stated that Israel's claim of self-defensive action, through its combined air- and ground assault, is inexcusable; "Israel, a colonialist, cannot use such an excuse" [ sic ]. Marsudi iterates that, even if it were a valid excuse, self-defensive action is not "a licence to kill civilian"[sic]. She states that the intention of the OIC delegation is to formulate peace through the implementation of the two-state solution.^[32][33]

Agreements

In 2008, Indonesia signed a medical cooperation agreement with Israel's national emergency medical service worth US$200,000.^[34]

According to the report from The Times of Israel in 2012, Indonesia agreed to informally upgrade its relations with Israel and to open a consulate in Ramallah, headed by a diplomat with the rank of ambassador, who also would have unofficially served as his country's ambassador for contacts with Israel. The move, which had been agreed upon after five years of sensitive deliberations, would have represented a de facto upgrading of relations between the two countries. Indonesia had formally presented the move to open a West Bank consulate as a demonstration of its support for Palestinian independence. In fact, while the ambassador-ranked diplomat was supposed to be accredited to the Palestinian Authority/PLO, a significant portion of his work would have been in dealings with Israel, and the office would have fulfilled substantial diplomatic duties as well as consular responsibilities.^[35] After Israel denied the Indonesian foreign minister entry to Ramallah in 2012, Indonesia backed out from the agreement and the consulate in Ramallah was not opened. Despite the absence of formal diplomatic relations, Israel and Indonesia quietly maintain trade, security and other relations which, however have been quietly deteriorating ever since the Middle East Peace Process has been stalled.^[36]

Indonesian exports to Israel was valued at $187 million as of 2022, with palm oil being highest valued product. Meanwhile, Israeli exports to Indonesia stood at $68.5 million as of 2022.^[37] The Economist reported that Indonesia purchased Israeli tech and weaponry, and before the Israel-Hamas war, carried out secret talks with Israel that would see trade offices established in both countries.^[38]

In May 2024, a joint investigation by Haaretz, Amnesty International, and Tempo, reported that Indonesia imported spying and surveillance technologies from Israel.^[39] Amnesty's reported that the technology is "highly invasive spyware tools are designed to be covert and to leave minimal traces...this built-in secrecy can make it exceedingly difficult to detect cases of unlawful misuse of these tools against civil society, and risks creating impunity-by-design for rights violations."^[40]

Tourism and travel

Israeli citizens are eligible for visas to Indonesia for single entry group tourist travel and single entry business travel. For Indonesians, tourist visas to Israel are only available for group travel through travel agencies.^[2] In May 2018, Indonesia barred Israeli passport holders from entering the country, which Israel reciprocated,^[41] although not for all types of visas.^[42] A month later, both countries reversed their tourism bans.^[43]

In 2018, 35.3 thousand Indonesian tourists visited Israel. A year later, there were 38.7 thousand Indonesians who visited Israel.^[44]

Condemning Israel

At a meeting at the UN Indonesian Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi left the room when Israel's Permanent Representative to the UN Gilad Erdan spoke to the organization's security agency.^[45]

The UN Security Council held an open debate on the Gaza war in New York on Tuesday local time. In Erdan's turn, Retno—along with other members of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OKI) -- decided to walk out.^[45]

"Minister Retno and the heads of delegations from other countries left the room when Israel's permanent representative gave his statement," said Foreign Ministry spokesman Muhammad Iqbal, Thursday.^[45]

However, Erdan was also not present when Indonesia and other OIC members delivered their statements, according to so.^[45]

In her speech, Retno criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's recent statement that he would not allow a Palestinian state to exist.^[45]

"Indonesia strongly rejects this statement," said Retno in the UNSC debate.^[45]

“This statement is unacceptable. This confirms Israel's ultimate goal of erasing Palestine from the world map. Will the council remain silent in the face of such intentions?” said Retno.^[45]

According to Retno, Israel must be held accountable for its atrocities in Gaza.^[45]

Prabowo's plan for Palestine

- The elected President of the Republic of Indonesia for the period 2024 - 2029 Prabowo Subianto said he was ready to send peacekeeping troops to the Gaza region, Palestine. Prabowo made this statement at the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) Shangri-La Dialogue 2024 forum, Singapore.^[46]

Responding to Prabowo's statement, the TNI stated that it was ready to implement it. Head of the TNI Information Center, Major General Nugraha Gumilar, ensured that TNI soldiers were ready to carry out peace operations under the United Nations (UN), wherever there was an order from the state.^[46]

"For Indonesia, the pursuit of peace, security, stability and prosperity is the main foundation of our international engagement. We believe that only through dialogue and cooperation can we achieve these goals," said Prabowo.^[46]

He considers collaboration to be the only way to create prosperity and harmony in the world. Therefore, he ensured that Indonesia was strongly committed to inviting various countries to collaborate and establish dialogue in achieving common interests.^[46]

Prabowo also ensured that the Indonesian government would also encourage the world to uphold international law, especially in the aspect of respecting each country's national sovereignty and territorial integrity as mandated by the UN Charter.^[46]

He also highlighted specifically the conflict in Gaza, Palestine. In particular, Israel's actions in attacking civilians who were taking refuge in Rafah. According to him, this action must be immediately investigated because it has victimized children, women and unarmed citizens.^[46]

"This heartbreaking incident encourages us to immediately call for a thorough investigation into this humanitarian disaster," stressed Prabowo.^[46]

"We believe that along with many other countries in the world today, the only real solution for lasting peace and security for Israel and Palestine is a two-state solution," he said.^[46]

See also

• Indonesia–Palestine relations
• History of the Jews in Indonesia
• Operation Alpha

References

1. Muhammad Zulfikar Rakhmat (11 March 2015). "The Quiet Growth in Indonesia-Israel Relations". The Diplomat. Archived from the original on 13 June 2018. Retrieved 8 September 2018.
2. Adams, Kayla J. (6 July 2012). "Indonesia to informally upgrade its relations with Israel via ambassador-ranked diplomat in Ramallah". The Times of Israel. Archived from the original on 25 November 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
3. "Indonesia outraged over Israeli assault on Indonesian hospital in Gaza". Le Monde.fr. 26 November 2023. Retrieved 1 April 2024.
4. "Indonesia Commits to Establishing Diplomatic Ties with Israel for First Time in History". Haaretz. 11 April 2024. Retrieved 11 April 2024.
5. "OECD Secretary-General Confirms Indonesia's Commitment to Diplomatic Ties with All Members". Haaretz. 11 April 2024. Retrieved 11 April 2024.
6. "Indonesia Denies Opening Ties with Israel for OECD Membership". Jakarta Globe. Retrieved 12 April 2024.
7. "Trainer Jets for Israel: From the Skyhawk, to the M-346 Lavi". Defense Industry Daily. 27 July 2016. Archived from the original on 29 June 2017. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
8. Barton, Greg; Rubenstein, Colin (2005). "Indonesia and Israel: A Relationship in Waiting". Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. 17 (1/2): 157–170. JSTOR 25834625.
9. Rubenstein, Colin (1 March 2005). "Indonesia And Israel: A Relationship In Waiting". Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. Archived from the original on 16 March 2012. Retrieved 12 November 2015.
10. Barker, Philip (19 August 2018). "Controversy ruled the last time Jakarta hosted the Asian Games in 1962". Inside the Games. Archived from the original on 19 December 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
11. "Aerostar TUAV: Drone Intai Andalan Skadron Udara 51 TNI AU". Indomiliter.com. 5 October 2015. Retrieved 16 February 2021.
12. "Rabin confers with Indonesian leader in surprise move". United Press International. 15 October 1993. Archived from the original on 19 December 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
13. "Controversy over Indonesia-Israel relations". The Jakarta Post. 20 November 1999. Archived from the original on 13 August 2009.
14. Odenheimer, Micha (7 July 2004). "A Friend of Israel in the Islamic World". Haaretz. Archived from the original on 6 December 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
15. "Indonesia-Israel ties said "possible"". The Jakarta Post. Jakarta. 20 September 2005.
16. "Indonesia rules out diplomatic ties with Israel, reaffirms pro-Palestine stand". Forbes.^{[dead link‍]}
17. "Indonesia condemns Israeli offensive". The Jakarta Post. 3 July 2006. Archived from the original on 21 February 2015.
18. "Indonesia pulls out of Fed Cup tennis in Israel to protest Gaza". USA Today. 4 July 2006. Archived from the original on 10 April 2017. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
19. Diplomat says Israel open to direct ties with Indonesia. BBC Monitoring International Reports| January 27, 2006, Source: The Jakarta Post, Jakarta, in English 26 Jan 2006 [1] Archived 22 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine
20. "Israeli-Indonesian Entree", Dateline World Jewry, World Jewish Congress, July/August 2008
21. Tamar Pileggi (28 March 2016). "Netanyahu calls for normalizing ties with Indonesia". The Times of Israel. Archived from the original on 25 December 2017. Retrieved 29 March 2016.
22. Desi Angriani (29 March 2016). "Indonesia Rejects Israel's Normalization Call". MetroTV News. Archived from the original on 3 May 2017. Retrieved 29 March 2016.
23. "Anggota Wantimpres Yahya Staquf Bicara di Forum Israel, Ini Respons Jokowi". kompas.com. 12 June 2018.
24. Ghermezian, Shiryn (1 February 2023). "Israeli Olympic Shooter Pulls Out of World Cup After Being Told He Cannot Compete With Israeli Symbols". algemeiner.com. Retrieved 1 February 2023.
25. Douillet, Claudine (1 February 2023). "Le tireur olympique israélien,Sergey Richter, se retire de la compétition de la Coupe du monde" [Israeli Olympic shooter Sergey Richter withdraws from World Cup competition]. alliancefr.com (in French). Retrieved 1 February 2023.
26. Lingcheng, Meng (27 July 2022). "How to qualify for shooting at Paris 2024. The Olympics qualification system explained". International Olympic Committee. Retrieved 4 February 2023.
27. "How Do You Qualify For Shooting In The Olympics?". Rookie Road. 13 August 2020. Retrieved 4 February 2023.
28. "Indonesia stripped of hosting Under-20 World Cup by FIFA". Associated Press News. 29 March 2023. Retrieved 29 March 2023.
29. Tanamal, Yvette. "Indonesia incensed by Israeli attack on Gaza hospital". thejakartapost.com. The Jakarta Post. Retrieved 21 November 2023.
30. Bimo, Edwin Shri. "Menlu Retno: Alasan Israel Membunuhi Warga Palestina untuk Membela Diri Sangat Tidak Bisa Diterima". kompas.tv. Kompas TV. Retrieved 25 November 2023.
31. "Ministers from Arab, Muslim Countries Arrive in Moscow to Discuss Israel's War on Gaza". palestinechronicle.com. The Palestine Chronicle. 21 November 2023. Retrieved 25 November 2023.
32. Difa, Yashinta; Nurfitra, Tegar (22 November 2023). "Israel's self-defense pretext is unacceptable: Minister Marsudi". antaranews.com. Antara News.
33. Andayani, Dwi. "Pertemuan OKI di Moskow, Menlu Retno Bahas Penyerangan RS Indonesia di Gaza Baca artikel detiknews, "Pertemuan OKI di Moskow, Menlu Retno Bahas Penyerangan RS Indonesia di Gaza". news.detik.com. detik news. Retrieved 25 November 2023.
34. Nafik, Muhammad (7 November 2008). "Representatives from Indonesia, Israel sign medical agreement". The Jakarta Post. Archived from the original on 7 June 2009. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
35. "Indonesia to informally upgrade its relations with Israel via ambassador-ranked diplomat in Ramallah". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 16 May 2024.
36. "Indonesia freezes plan to informally upgrade ties with Israel via envoy in Ramallah". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 16 May 2024.
37. "Indonesia (IDN) and Israel (ISR) Trade". The Observatory of Economic Complexity. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
38. "In South-East Asia, the war in Gaza is roiling emotions". The Economist. ISSN 0013-0613. Retrieved 12 May 2024.
39. Benjakob, Omer (2 May 2024). "Investigation: Israeli surveillance technology and spyware sold to Indonesia". Haaretz. Retrieved 12 May 2024.
40. "Israeli firms sold invasive surveillance tech to Indonesia: Report". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 12 May 2024.
41. Anya, Agnes (30 May 2018). "Israel bars Indonesian visitors in possible tit-for-tat". The Jakarta Post. Archived from the original on 12 June 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
42. Cashman, Greer Fay (10 June 2018). "Not All Indonesians Banned from Entering Israel". The Jerusalem Post. Archived from the original on 28 November 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
43. Bachner, Michael (27 June 2018). "Israel reverses ban on Indonesian tourists after officials protest". The Times of Israel. Archived from the original on 28 June 2018. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
44. "Israel: tourist arrivals from Indonesia". Statista. Retrieved 16 May 2024.
45. "Indonesia Walks Out During Israel's UN Security Council Speech". Jakarta Globe. Retrieved 1 April 2024.
46. Nugroho, M. Rosseno Aji. "Prabowo Bakal Kirim Pasukan ke Gaza, TNI Tegas Bilang Siap". CNBC Indonesia (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 June 2024.