IOS app approvals

Submissions for mobile apps for iOS are subject to approval by Apple's App Review team, as outlined in the SDK agreement, for basic reliability testing and other analysis, before being published on the App Store. Applications may still be distributed ad hoc if they are rejected, by the author manually submitting a request to Apple to license the application to individual iPhones,^[1] although Apple may withdraw the ability for authors to do this at a later date.^[2]

Non-disclosure agreements have always forbidden developers from publishing the content of their rejection notices, but Apple has now started labeling their rejection letters with an explicit non-disclosure warning.^[3] Apple later changed the NDA^[how?] citing that "it has created too much of a burden on developers"^[4] but they did not reverse the decision to forbid publication of rejection notices.^[5] Some applications are not available outside region specific App Stores at the request of the developer.^[6]

In addition, Apple has removed software licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL) from the App Store after complaints from one of the program's developers (the VLC media player), claiming that the App Store's terms of service are inconsistent with the GPL.^[7]

Functional restrictions

Applicants have been denied apps for fundamentally duplicating Apple apps, for example by providing an email interface with no added functionality or use,^[8] or having the same elements as the built in SMS app.^[9] Applications have also been rejected for duplicating the functionality of iTunes.^[10] Applications may be rejected if they are of only "limited utility".^[11] Some reports indicate that toolbars must be placed at the bottom of the screen, and the vibration function should only be used for alerts.^[12]

Approval process

Launched in July 2008, the App Store averaged about $1 million in application sales a day in its first month of existence.^[13] To get applications into the App Store, developers were required to submit their app and wait for approval or rejection by Apple. Rejected apps were given feedback on the reason they were rejected so they could be modified and resubmitted.^[14]

The approval process for Apple App Store has changed over time in terms of its feedback to developers and the time delay for apps to be approved. In the year July 2009, the application could take weeks. Apple streamlined the process at the end of 2009, and some apps were processed in a few days.^[15] In addition, in December 2009, the App Store began providing detailed feedback to developers on the approval process rather than simply showing "Waiting for Approval" and "Approved" or "Rejected".

In 2010, the iPad app approval process could have been lengthy, similar to the weeks experienced previously for iPhone applications. In June 2010, Steve Jobs at WWDC 2010 said 95% of apps were processed within 7 business days.^[16] According to Apple's developer portal as of 3 July 2014, 98% of new and updated apps were processed within 5 business days.^[17]

As of 2024, the app review times have decreased significantly with an app being reviewed within less than 12 hours on average and 90% of apps being reviewed in under 24 hours.^[18]

Review guidelines

On September 9, 2010, Apple published official App Store Review Guidelines for developers.^[19] At this time several development restrictions were lifted and many developers of previously rejected applications were asked to resubmit their applications under the new guidelines. The App Review Guideline Document is a living document that Apple can change at any time. The guidelines cover a wide array of rules and are categorized into five sections:

1. Safety: Apps should not contain objectionable content, cause physical harm and must follow additional strict requirements if they are listed in the "Kids" category.
2. Performance: Apps should be ready for real-world usage and work as a user would expect them to, without causing technical problems.
3. Business: Apps must use in-app-purchases under certain circumstances and are prohibited from offering certain services.
4. Design: Apps should provide value to the App Store, which excludes clones of existing apps and apps with very limited functionality.
5. Legal: Apps must respect intellectual property and users' privacy and disclose how they use users' data.

Apple checks each app against these guidelines before approving it for sale and inclusion on the App Store.

Over time, requirements have evolved as trends have appeared in application development. For example, applications accessing the user's location for advertising were valid prior to the fall of 2009. After this point, apps were rejected that did not provide more robust user experience beyond simply using location data for advertising. Other requirements, such as using undocumented APIs, have always led to rejection.

Apps that get featured will get promoted by Apple within the App Store, typically within a specific app category. There are no specific guidelines for getting an app featured,^[20] but in some notable cases, app developers that gather feedback directly from Apple before releasing their app have indicated that this improves chances of getting featured.^[21]

Notable rejected apps

Newspaper and magazine content

In May 2009, Apple rejected the first version of 'Newspapers', an iPhone app that let users read content from 50+ newspapers around the world, including the New York Times, France's Le Monde, and the United Kingdom tabloid The Sun. The app was rejected because the topless "Page 3" girls daily features were described as "obscene". A second version of the application was submitted, removing access to The Sun, and adding a price tag of £0.59. The app was made available in the summer, after the release of the iPhone OS 3.0 software.^[22][23] Another application, of similar nature to 'Newspapers', called 'Eucalyptus' allowed users to download e-books to their iPhone, though was rejected by Apple because one of the e-books that could have been downloaded was the Kama Sutra. The ban has since been lifted.^[24]

We do believe we have a moral responsibility to keep porn off the iPhone ... Folks who want porn can buy an Android phone

— Steve Jobs^[25]

We can't adapt European magazines to the standards of Utah.

— Mathias Müller von Blumencron (editor of Der Spiegel, warning that the news magazine would not alter its content for the App Store)^[26]

The App Store has Playboy and Sports Illustrated adult-rated apps that have yet to be removed, while some apps by others were removed citing adult content which has resulted in accusations of hypocrisy. Despite this, adult sites continue to market for iPhone and iPad users.^[27][28][29] In November 2009, the application of Stern (a mainstream German weekly magazine with a print circulation of about 900,000) was deleted for several weeks without warning.^[26][30] In January 2010, Europe's largest newspaper, German tabloid Bild, removed content from the iPhone version of its print edition at the request of Apple, and later it had to modify one of its applications – like in the Stern case because of nudity.^[31] The Association of German Magazine Publishers (VDZ) warned that with such interventions Apple might be moving towards censorship.^[31]

The Guardian described rejection of explicit content by Apple as analogous to that of the distributor WHSmith, a main distributor which for many years imposed content restrictions on British publishers. Workers at the fashion magazine Dazed & Confused have nicknamed their iPad edition the "Iran edition".^[25]

Pulitzer Prize–winning cartoons

In December 2009, Apple banned a cartoon app called NewsToons by cartoonist Mark Fiore, on the grounds that it "ridiculed public figures."^[32][33] In April 2010, Fiore won the Pulitzer prize for his political satire cartoons, making history as the very first internet-only cartoonist to win the prestigious journalistic prize.^[32][33][34] Following public outcry after the story broke in the wake of the award, Apple asked Fiore to resubmit his app, and it was subsequently accepted. Fiore said, "Sure, mine might get approved, but what about someone who hasn’t won a Pulitzer and who is maybe making a better political app than mine? Do you need some media frenzy to get an app approved that has political material?"^[33]

Baby Shaker

In April 2009, a game called Baby Shaker was approved for the App Store then later removed due to complaints. The game allowed the user to shake their phone in order to quiet a crying cartoon baby onscreen.^[35] The app was criticized for making light of shaken baby syndrome, a condition where shaking a baby results in severe brain injury.^[36]

Nine Inch Nails

In May 2009, Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails announced, via his Twitter account, that Apple had rejected an update to the Nine Inch Nails application due to "objectionable content".^[37] The developer posted a message on the Nine Inch Nails discussion boards explaining the situation further:

v1.0 is live. v1.0.3 got rejected due to content yet the app has no content in it. This was mainly a stability release to fix the bug that crashes the app for international users. The bug was fixed 24 hours after 1.0 went live and we have been waiting for Apple to approve it ever since. Meanwhile the app continues to get a growing number of 1 star ratings from international users understandably frustrated by the bug, "but looks like our hands are tied".^[38]

Apple later permitted the update.^[39]

iPhone eBook

In December 2009, Ted Lando's eBook app "Take Control of iPhone OS 3" was rejected by Apple. The app was not permitted back into the App Store until all references to jailbreaking were removed.^[40]

Drone Strike Alert

In August 2012, Josh Begley created a drone strike iPhone app that sent out a push notification whenever a US military drone aircraft struck a target. The app was rejected, Apple finding the content "objectionable and crude".^[41]

HKmap.live

In September 2019, an anonymous developer submitted an app called HKmap.live to App Store, which is tracking police vehicles, armed officers and incidents in which people have been injured during 2019–20 Hong Kong protests. But Apple had rejected the app, and reversed its decision on October 4. People's Daily, the official media in China, has criticized Apple's action. On October 9, Apple announced that the app was removed.^[42][43]

I Am Rich

Main article: I Am Rich

I Am Rich was a 2008 iOS application developed by Armin Heinrich. When launched, the screen contained only a glowing red gem and an icon that, when pressed, displayed the following mantra in large text:

I am rich
I deserv [sic] it
I am good,
healthy & successful

The application is described as "a work of art with no hidden function at all", with its only purpose being to show other people that they were able to afford it; I Am Rich was sold on the App Store for US$999.99 (equivalent to $1,415 in 2023), €799.99 (equivalent to €934.74 in 2021), and £599.99 (equivalent to £1,011 in 2023), the highest price Apple allowed for App Store content for the time.

Then on August 6, 2008, exactly one day after it was launched, Apple removed the app from the App Store without explanation.

Emulators

In response to the United States v. Apple (2024) lawsuit (specifically about the section regarding "super-apps"), and growing European Union regulatory pressure, guideline 4.3, dictating mini-apps was edited allowing game emulators on to the store worldwide.^[44][45] Previously, video game emulators were not allowed even if they were officially licensed due to rules about downloading execuatable code,^[46] and emulators disguising themselves as file managers, baby name apps, and augmented reality mustache apps, getting removed quickly.^[47] After the rule changed, a clone of GBA4iOS named iGBA was allowed on the App Store, supporting import of Game Boy, Game Boy Color, and Game Boy Advance ROMs, but was taken down due to copying the GBA4iOS app under the Spam and Copyright guidelines.^[48][49] A Nintendo Entertainment System emulator named Bimmy was available for a few hours, but was taken down by the creator due to fears of legal action by Nintendo.^[50][51] A Commodore 64 emulator was also added to the app store.^[52] The official Delta emulator app (the official successor to GBA4iOS also supporting NES, SNES, Nintendo 64, and Nintendo DS as well as the GameBoy Series) supporting a variety of Nintendo systems was published shortly after the removal of Bimmy for free in the USA,^[53][54] but to install in EU you need to pay 1.50 euro a year subscription to AltStore PAL.^[55]

Security

All iOS App Store applications must support sandboxing and list all permissions required for the correct functionality.^[56] During the review process, each application is manually tested, and static analysis is run on its binary code.^[57][58]

In 2013, a test malware application, that was using dynamic code reassembly techniques and named "Jekyll" in reference to the Stevenson novella,^[59] was approved and released on the App Store. Apple claimed that unspecified changes were made to iOS in response to the attack.^[60][61]

In September 2015, infected programs were published for public download on the App Store. The malicious code had been embedded into Chinese legitimate software through a modified version of Xcode (see XcodeGhost).^[62][63] Some of the bigger applications that had the code were Angry Birds 2, CamCard, TinyDeal.com, among others.^[64][65] Apple confirmed the attack and stated to be working with the developers to make sure they were using the proper version of Xcode to rebuild the apps.^[66]

In October 2015, Apple also confirmed having removed applications from the App Store due to the privacy concerns. They commented that applications could be used to compromise SSL/TLS security solutions.^[67][68]

References

1. Sande, Steven (2008-09-15). "Podcaster app distributed via Ad Hoc after Apple rejection". Tuaw.com. Archived from the original on 2009-02-10. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
2. Palmer, Robert (2008-09-23). "Podcaster dev can't provision any more licenses". Tuaw.com. Archived from the original on 2010-02-13. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
3. "Apple Extends Non-Disclosure to App Store Rejection Letters". Mac Rumors. 2008-09-23. Archived from the original on 16 January 2010. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
4. "Apple Drops iPhone Non Disclosure Agreement (NDA)". Mac Rumors. 2008-10-01. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
5. Hansell, Saul (2008-10-01). "A Slice of Glasnost at Apple - Bits Blog - NYTimes.com". Bits.blogs.nytimes.com. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
6. "Eye-Fi Forums • View topic - Outside US". Forums.eye.fi. Archived from the original on 2009-03-15. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
7. David Murphy (8 January 2011). "Apple Pulls VLC Player from App Store Due to GPL". PCMag.com. PC Magazine. Archived from the original on 11 January 2011. Retrieved 8 January 2011.
8. Palmer, Robert (2008-09-22). "Apple rejects another app for duplicating functionality". Tuaw.com. Archived from the original on 2010-04-13. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
9. "Syncode - Blog – iTweetReply 1.1 Rejected". Blog.syncode.com.au. Archived from the original on 25 October 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
10. "Almerica's Blog About Technology and Other Interesting Stuff: Podcaster rejeceted because it duplicates iTunes functionality". Almerica.blogspot.com. 2008-09-11. Archived from the original on 15 November 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
11. "MacRumors iPhone Blog: Apple Rejecting Apps Based on 'Limited Utility'". Macrumors.com. 2008-09-04. Archived from the original on 15 November 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
12. Sadun, Erica (2008-08-08). "Dear Auntie TUAW: AppStore Rejection". Tuaw.com. Archived from the original on 5 December 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
13. "AppStore".
14. "Thoughts on the iPhone App Review Process". Archived from the original on 2015-02-19. Retrieved 2011-01-28.
15. "Apple's New Years Resolution". Archived from the original on 2015-01-31. Retrieved 2011-01-28.
16. WWDC 2010 Steve Jobs on the App Store.
17. App Store Approval Process. Retrieved 17 July 2014.
18. "How Long it Takes to Publish an App - Insights From 238 Apps". webtoapp.design. Retrieved 2024-05-11.
19. "App Review Guidelines". Apple Developer. Retrieved 2024-05-11.
20. "How to Put an App on the App Store: A Step-By-Step Guide".
21. "Retail Ecommerce Research & News – Digital Commerce 360".
22. "The Sun's 'obscene' Page 3 girls get iPhone newspaper app banned by Apple". Guardian. London. 2009-05-06. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
23. Sherwood, James (2009-05-05). "Apple bans Page 3 from iPhone app". Reghardware.co.uk. Archived from the original on 2009-11-26. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
24. Logged in as click here to log out (2009-05-24). "Apple backtracks over ban on ebook application Eucalyptus | Technology | guardian.co.uk". Guardian. London. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
25. Jack Schofield (2010-05-10). "Wikipedia's porn purge, and cleaning up for the iPad". The Guardian.
26. Pfanner, Eric (2010-03-14). "Publishers Question Apple's Rejection of Nudity". NYTimes.com. Archived from the original on 30 March 2010. Retrieved 2010-04-15.
27. MG Siegler (Feb 23, 2010). "Apple, There's Pornography On My iPhone. The App Is Called Safari. You Made It". TechCrunch. Archived from the original on 27 May 2010. Retrieved 30 May 2010.
28. Kincaid, Jason (Feb 20, 2010). "The New App Store Rules: No Swimsuits, No Skin, And No Innuendo". TechCrunch. Archived from the original on 26 May 2010. Retrieved 30 May 2010.
29. Charles "Zan" Christensen (May 24, 2010). "iPad Publishing No Savior for Small Press, LGBT Comics Creators". Prism Comics. Archived from the original on 29 May 2010. Retrieved 30 May 2010.
30. Goebel, Markus (2010-03-29). "Europe's biggest publisher embraces the WePad". Techcrunch. Archived from the original on 14 April 2010. Retrieved 2010-04-15.
31. Mercedes Bunz: German publisher in row with Apple over pin-ups in iPhone app The Guardian, 9 March 2010
32. Paul, Ian (2010-04-16). "Apple Rejects Pulitzer Prize Winner's App". PC World. Archived from the original on 18 April 2010. Retrieved 2010-04-17.
33. Stelter, Brian (2010-04-16). "A Pulitzer Winner Gets Apple's Reconsideration". New York Times. Archived from the original on 17 April 2010. Retrieved 2010-04-17.
34. "Slashdot Apple Story | Apple Blocks Cartoonist From App Store". Slashdot. 15 April 2010. Retrieved 2010-04-15.
35. "Baby Shaker Game Causes Outrage | BBC". BBC News. 2009-04-24. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
36. Choney, Suzanne (22 April 2009). "'Baby Shaker' app pulled from iPhone store". NBC. Archived from the original on May 29, 2014. Retrieved 19 July 2015.
37. trent_reznor. "Trent Reznor (trent_reznor) on Twitter". Twitter.com. Retrieved December 2, 2009.
38. "NIN iPhone app rejection". Forum.nin.com. Archived from the original on May 7, 2009. Retrieved December 2, 2009.
39. IOS application development services
40. "Rejected By Apple". Mac Observer. Retrieved June 16, 2016.
41. "Apple bans 'drone strike' app". Infosecurity Magazine. 31 August 2012. Retrieved November 5, 2012.
42. "Apple under fire from China over HKmap.live app that tracks police activity amid Hong Kong protests". South China Morning Post. 9 October 2019. Retrieved 10 October 2019.
43. "Apple Removes App That Tracked Hong Kong Police". The New York Times. 9 October 2019. Retrieved 10 October 2019.
44. Nield, David (2024-04-07). "Retro game emulators are now allowed in the iOS App Store, but there are caveats". TechRadar. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
45. Mauran, Cecily (2024-04-14). "Gaming emulators are now on the App Store after Apple relaxed the rules". Mashable. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
46. "Full Commodore 64 Emulator Rejected from App Store – TouchArcade". 2009-06-20. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
47. Perez, Sarah (2014-12-23). "Floppy Cloud Sneaks An NES And SNES Emulator Into The iTunes App Store". TechCrunch. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
48. Bennett, Brad (2024-04-13). "The first real emulator arrives in iOS App Store [Update]". MobileSyrup. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
49. Davis, Wes (2024-04-14). "The first Apple-approved emulator for the iPhone has arrived... and been pulled". The Verge. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
50. https://9to5mac.com/2024/04/16/bimmy-nes-emulator-is-the-latest-game-emulation-app-for-iphone-ipad-and-mac/ ^{[bare URL]}
51. Davis, Wes (2024-04-16). "A new NES emulator was briefly available on the Apple App Store". The Verge. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
52. Martin, Alan (2024-04-14). "First iPhone console emulators arrive on App Store". Tom's Guide. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
53. Davis, Wes (2024-04-17). "The free Delta game emulator for iPhones is live on Apple's App Store". The Verge. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
54. "Nintendo emulator Delta hits the iOS App Store, no sideloading required". Engadget. 2024-04-17. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
55. Ricker, Thomas (2024-04-17). "Third-party iPhone app store AltStore PAL is now live in Europe". The Verge. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
56. Jannie Zaaiman, Louise Leenan Iccws 2015 - The Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Cyber Warfare and Security, Academic Conferences Limited, 2015, pp. 160
57. "How Apple is improving mobile app security".
58. "How does iOS Mobile Security work and why do I need it?". 4 August 2014.
59. ""Jekyll" test attack sneaks through Apple App Store, wreaks havoc on iOS - Network World". Archived from the original on 2014-01-02. Retrieved 2014-01-02.
60. "IOS malware can sneak through Apple's approval process, researchers show". TheGuardian.com. 19 August 2013.
61. "Remotely Assembled Malware Blows Past Apple's Screening Process | MIT Technology Review". Archived from the original on 2014-01-02. Retrieved 2014-01-02.
62. "Novel Malware XcodeGhost Modifies Xcode, Infects Apple iOS Apps and Hits App Store". 17 September 2015.
63. "Apple cleans up iOS App Store after first big malware attack". The Register.
64. Lovejoy, Ben (21 September 2015). "Security firm publishes list of some of the iOS apps infected by XcodeGhost – including Angry Birds 2". 9to5Mac. Retrieved 2015-09-21.
65. "85 legitimate iPhone apps that were infected with malware in the big App Store hack". www.yahoo.com. 21 September 2015. Retrieved 2015-09-21.
66. "UPDATE 3-Apple cleaning up iOS App Store after first major attack". Reuters. 21 September 2015. Archived from the original on 2023-05-22.
67. "How to delete an app that has a configuration profile on your iPhone, iPad or iPod touch". 15 February 2020.
68. "Apple borks Apple News ad-blocking app due to 'privacy concerns'". The Register.