The pews face one another rather than towards the altar.[4][7][6][3] The pulpit is triple-decked and is combined with the lectern and prayer desk to form an unusual structure at the western end.[4][6]
Over the altar is a c1600 Flemish painting which could be the work of the Otto van Veen school.[4][7] The ceiling of the church has the Sherard arms and the Sherard crest at either end.[6]
Richard Folville, a member of the Folville gang of robbers led by his older brother Eustace, was rector here from 1321. In 1340–1 he was besieged in the church and then summarily beheaded in his churchyard.
John Torkington was rector of Teigh (and vicar of Stapleford), 1787 – 1815.[8]