City Harvest Church criminal breach of trust case

City Harvest Church criminal breach of trust case

City Harvest Church, located in Jurong West
Date	31 May 2010, investigation commenced by the Commercial Affairs Department (CAD)[1]
Location	City Harvest Church, Jurong West, Singapore
Outcome	Serina Wee, Sharon Tan, Chew Eng Han, Tan Ye Peng, John Lam and Kong Hee were sentenced to imprisonment. Chew Eng Han later received a longer jail term for attempting to leave Singapore unlawfully.
Arrests	Serina Wee, Sharon Tan, Chew Eng Han, Tan Ye Peng, John Lam, Kong Hee
Convictions	Misuse of around S$50 million of City Harvest Church's funds

The City Harvest Church criminal breach of trust (CBT) case was one of the longest criminal trials in Singapore's history.^[2] Church founder Kong Hee and five other church leaders were found guilty by a District Court on 21 October 2015 of CBT by agent after misappropriating some S$50 million of church funds. Approximately S$24 million was invested in sham bonds to bankroll the pop-music career of his wife, Ho Yeow Sun, while a further S$26 million was used to later cover their tracks.^[3]

A subsequent appeal against conviction and sentence to a three-judge sitting of the High Court and by a 2-1 decision delivered on 7 April 2017, reduced their sentences by varying degrees due to a substitution of their initial charges of CBT by an agent (s409 of the Penal Code) with a less serious offence of simple CBT (s406 of the Penal Code).^[4]

The Public Prosecutor then applied for a criminal reference to the Court of Appeal to answer questions of law of public interest that arose from the appeal in the High Court and had an effect on the outcome. A unanimous five-judge decision was delivered on 1 February 2018 and resulted in no change to the reduced sentences.^[5]

Events

Church member blows the whistle

In January 2003, a businessman who had been attending the church for six years contacted and wrote in to the Straits Times, alleging that church members were being encouraged to buy Ho Yeow Sun's albums. He added that church funds were being used to promote her career.^[6]

As the incident blew up in the press, other church members alleged that the church was quickly becoming a personality cult and that it was using its platform to drum up votes for Ho at the MTV Asia Awards, where Ho was one of five nominees vying for the 'Favourite Music Artist from Singapore' award.

A tearful Ho told the press at the time, "I really don’t need this. At first, I was quite affected and wanted to give up everything and just go home. Then I thought, ‘Hey, my conscience is clear, and I’ve not done anything wrong.’ So, I’ll still come back to sing during the show."^[7]

Following pressure from the church, the whistleblower eventually issued five apologies in The Straits Times, Lianhe Zaobao, Lianhe Wanbao, Shin Min Daily News and The New Paper, retracting all his earlier statements in advertisements that cost him S$33,372.06 in total.^[8]

Investigation

On 31 May 2010, the Office of the Commissioner of Charities (COC) and the Commercial Affairs Department (CAD) of the Singapore Police Force announced in a joint press statement that 17 individuals linked to the City Harvest Church, including church founder Pastor Kong Hee and his deputy, Pastor Tan Ye Peng, were under investigation after complaints alleging the misuse of church funds.^[9][10][11] The police launched investigations into possible falsification of accounts and criminal breach of trust amounting to millions of dollars which dated back a number of years.^[12][13][14]

The investigation followed requests by church members for the COC to review the church's constitution, which denied ordinary members the chance to attend general meetings, or be privy to its annual reports and financial statements. Some members felt that the church board had utilized the church's building fund and committed it to "future liabilities" without consulting members at its latest AGM.^[15]

Trial

In June 2012, Kong Hee and four other members of the church were arrested by the Commercial Affairs Department of the Singapore Police Force.^[16] Charges were filed against the five individuals and who were released on $500,000 bail each.^[17] In July, charges were brought on one additional former finance director with the last of the pre-trial conferences set for 22 November.^[18][19][20] When the trial started on 15 May 2013, some Christians expressed concern that the slow pace of the trial may have a negative impact on public opinion.^[21][22]

On the same day as the initial arrests, the COC released a press statement detailing the results of its inquiry stating there were misconduct and mismanagement in the administration of the charity. There were irregularities of at least $23 million in the charity's funds, which were used to finance Sun Ho's secular music career. There was also a concerted effort to conceal this movement of funds from stakeholders. Eight members including the five arrested such as Chew Eng Han and Sharon Tan,^[23] Sun Ho and the two others were suspended from their duties with the charity while the COC considered further course of action under the Charities Act.^[24][25] $24 million was taken from church building funds and put into sham investment bonds in Ho's artist management firm Xtron Productions^[26] and glass maker Firna.^[27] After church auditors raised questions about the bond investments, an additional $26.6 million was moved around to "create the false appearance that the purported sham bond investments had been redeemed" in what the accounting industry calls "round-tripping".^[28][29] The church stood by the five accused, stated that money for the investment bonds were returned to the church in full, with interest, and it did not lose any funds in the transactions, indicating that the accused "always put God and CHC first."^[30]

Revelations were made about a multi-purpose account (MPA) involving Kong Hee and his wife Sun Ho set up in 2006 and closed in 2010, made up of "love gifts" worth $2,888,334 from church members as well as $359,530 from an Indonesian businessman Wahju Hanafi.^[31] The Commissioner of Charities warned the church and its employees against raising funds for legal expenses. The church was also warned against paying the legal fees of the 6 accused.^{[32][33][34][35]} The chief prosecution led by Mavis Chionh noted the absence of a crucial board meeting between August and September 2008 as being without any meeting minutes,^[36] and also charged that Wahju Hanafi was the other beneficiary of funds allegedly diverted from City Harvest Church to further Sun Ho's music career.^[37][38]

Conviction

On 21 October 2015, all six accused were found guilty of all criminal breach of trust charges pertaining to 409 read with section 109 of the Penal Code, Chapter 224. Falsification of Accounts under section 477A of the Penal Code, Chapter 224.^[39] The judge called the case "unique and without precedent" and agreed with the defence that there was "a lack of any personal wrongful gain, any motive of self-interest or enrichment, and the absence of an intent to cause permanent loss" to the church as the funds were ultimately returned. Nevertheless, the accused were still found guilty of serious offences.^[40]

Alongside the conviction, other pastors and Christians began speaking out regarding the trial^[41] which was the second longest in Singapore history with the trial stretching over 140 days.^[42]

List of accused and convicts

Name	Conviction
Serina Wee	Former finance manager of CHC, was found guilty of 6 counts of criminal breach of trust and 4 counts of falsifying the church's accounts. The prosecutor labelled her as the most inextricably involved in the conspiracy due to her role as administrator of the Crossover project.
Sharon Tan	Former finance manager of CHC, was found guilty of 3 counts of criminal breach of trust and 4 counts of falsifying the church's accounts. The prosecutor noted her defense was deeply cynical and self-serving, attempting to minimise her involvement in the offences.
Chew Eng Han	CHC board member, was found guilty of 6 counts of criminal breach of trust and 4 counts of falsifying church accounts. The prosecutor noted that his defense was incoherent while lacking credibility.
Tan Ye Peng	Founding member and Deputy Senior Pastor of CHC, was found guilty of 6 counts of criminal breach of trust and 4 counts of falsifying the church's accounts.
John Lam	Former secretary of the church's management board, was found guilty of 3 counts of criminal breach of trust. The prosecutor noted that he was the inside man in church governance and oversaw bodies that prevented the sham investment bonds from being discovered.
Kong Hee	Senior Pastor and founder of the church, was found guilty of 3 counts of criminal breach of trust. The prosecutor noted that he was had not maintained a consistent position on critical factual issues.[43]

The 6 accused, and the Prosecution, have all filed appeals on their conviction, with the prosecution calling the current sentences "manifestly inadequate". The appeals were heard over 5 days from 19 to 23 September 2016.^[44]

In July 2016, Chew filed a new police report against 8 members of the church, including Kong Hee and Sun Ho. Chew alleged that this was for "fraudulent misrepresentation of vital facts about the church which induced me and other members to give our donations, and also for use of funds for purposes other than what was represented to the members of the church."^[45]

In May 2017, the Commissioner of Charities permanently barred the six convicted from having overall administrative control of any charity. In addition, two other church employees, Kelvin Teo Meng How and Tan Su Pheng Jacqueline, who had been suspended from their respective positions since 2013, were issued warning letters.

On 21 February 2018, Chew Eng Han attempted to flee Singapore illegally for Malaysia, absconding from Pulau Ubin by boat. Chew Eng Han and the boat driver, Tan Poh Teck, were arrested at sea on the same day.^[46] Chew was subsequently charged the next day with Tan charged with helping Chew to flee Singapore.^[47] On 12 December the same year, Chew was found guilty of trying to escape Singapore and defeat justice^[48] and hence sentenced to an additional 13 months jail on 29 January 2019.^[49] Several others were arrested and convicted for their roles in the attempted escape. Khoo Kea Leng, who was arrested on 26 February 2018^[50] and charged two days later,^[51] was sentenced to six months jail on 12 April the same year for helping Chew to escape.^[52] Tan Kim Ho, who was arrested on 15 April 2018^[53] and charged a day later,^[54] was sentenced on 13 July the same year to 6 months jail for arranging Chew's escape. On the same day, Tan Poh Teck was sentenced to 27 weeks jail for helping Chew escape.^[55]

Appeal

On 7 April 2017, the outcome of the appeal against the conviction and sentences of the six accused resulted in the length of their jail term approximately halved.^[56] On 1 February 2018, the prosecutors' appeal to reinstate the original jail terms was dismissed by the Court of Appeal as the High Court had set the jail terms based on wrong interpretation of the meaning of "agent" in section 409 of the Penal Code hence they were charged under the 'less serious' section 406 instead.^[57][58]

List of accused and sentence

Name	Original sentence	After appeal
Serina Wee	5 years	2 years and 6 months
Sharon Tan	21 months	7 months
Chew Eng Han	6 years	3 years and 4 months
Tan Ye Peng	5 years 6 months	3 years and 2 months
John Lam	3 years	1 year 6 months
Kong Hee	8 years	3 years and 6 months

With the exception of Chew, 5 of the group began their sentences on 21 April 2017. Chew, who had been on bail pending the appeal, was granted permission by the court to begin his sentence on 22 February 2018. On 21 February a day before Chew was due to start his sentence he was arrested for trying to flee Singapore unlawfully^[46] and was subsequently charged by the police.^[47] Meanwhile Sharon Tan completed her sentence and was released from jail.^[59] Chew started his jail term on 1 March 2018.^[60] The Malaysian boatman, Tan Poh Teck, charged with abetting his escape is slapped with a jail term of 6 months.^[61][62] His brother, Chew Eng Soon, was arrested for abetting Chew Eng Han in leaving Singapore unlawfully, he was later released on bail on 23 February 2018.^[62][63]

The S$50 million taken from the mega-church’s coffers is the largest amount of charity funds ever misappropriated in Singapore.

Comments by the Minister for Law

External videos
Law minister K Shanmugam setting out the government's position on the court's ruling, Gov.sg video

Expressing his disappointment by the Court of Appeal's decision to overrule a 1976 High Court decision, which had held that company directors could be convicted for criminal breach of trust under section 409 of the Penal Code, Minister for Law K Shanmugam said, “The government believes the sentences are too low. But the sentences reflect the law as it stands after the High Court’s decision last year confirmed by the Court of Appeal. The courts decide these matters. All of us have to respect the decision regardless of whether we agree or disagree with it.”

“It is now up to Parliament to amend the law, and that we should do soon. We will ensure that legislation provides for higher penalties for directors and other senior officers who commit criminal breach of trust,” he added.^[64]

See also

• Sun Ho
• Phil Pringle
• Jim Bakker
• City Harvest Church
• Corruption in Singapore

References

1. "City Harvest's Kong Hee and 4 others to be charged on Wednesday". The Straits Times. 26 June 2012. Retrieved 23 April 2024. Two years ago, on May 31 2010, the Commercial Affairs Department (CAD) started an investigation into certain financial transactions of CHC after receiving information of misuse of CHC funds.
2. "City Harvest case: Is this the end of the saga? Here's all you need to know". The Straits Times. 1 February 2018. Retrieved 23 April 2024. The trial stretched over 142 days, from its start in 2013 to sentencing in November 2015. It is one of the longest criminal cases in history, beaten only by a drug trafficking case in the 1990s that went on for 168 days.
3. "Kong Hee and City Harvest Church leaders found guilty: What next?". The Straits Times. 21 October 2015. Retrieved 23 April 2024. The court found the accused guilty of funnelling $24 million in church building funds into bogus bond investments to bankroll the music ambitions of Kong's wife, Ms Ho Yeow Sun. Later, they used a further $26 million to cover their tracks.
4. "City Harvest appeal verdict: Six church leaders get reduced jail terms, Kong Hee gets 3.5 years". The Straits Times. 7 April 2017. Retrieved 23 April 2024.
5. "City Harvest case: 5 highlights from the Court of Appeal's judgment". The Straits Times. 1 February 2018. Retrieved 23 April 2024.
6. "12 years ago, City Harvest Church threatened to sue whistleblower Roland Poon Swee Kay. They owe him an apology". mothership.sg. Retrieved 10 December 2020.
7. Truth, Nailed (2 October 2013). "The Dawning Truth: Valid Claims Made By Mr Roland Poon In Old Articles". C3 Church Watch. Retrieved 10 December 2020.
8. "Poon says sorry; pastor asks church to forgive". Religion News Blog. 29 January 2003. Retrieved 10 December 2020.
9. "City Harvest Church founder Kong Hee & 16 others under funds probe". Xin MSN News. 31 May 2010. Archived from the original on 23 August 2011. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
10. "City Harvest deputy also assisting in probe". Asia One. 7 June 2010. Archived from the original on 10 June 2010. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
11. "Over 18 people from City Harvest Church called up in probe so far". Channel NewsAsia. 16 June 2010. Archived from the original on 18 May 2011. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
12. "Individuals, firms linked to City Harvest Church under probe". Channel NewsAsia. 31 May 2010. Archived from the original on 15 November 2010. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
13. "Church members probed". Asia One. 31 May 2010. Archived from the original on 3 June 2010. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
14. "City Harvest Probe". Today. Singapore. Archived from the original on 24 November 2010. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
15. "Ordinary members have no right to attend general meetings". Singapore: TODAY. Archived from the original on 22 June 2011. Retrieved 21 February 2011.
16. "POLICE NEWS RELEASE" (PDF). The Straits Times. Archived (PDF) from the original on 24 September 2015. Retrieved 3 August 2015.
17. "City Harvest case: Allegedly total of $50m misused". The Straits Times. 28 June 2012. Archived from the original on 28 June 2012. Retrieved 28 June 2012.
18. Weber, Katherine (4 October 2012). "Singapore City Harvest Church Manager Accused in Fraud Case Allowed to Travel". The Christian Post. Archived from the original on 12 October 2012. Retrieved 11 October 2012.
19. "6th City Harvest member charged; cases adjourned for 5 weeks". Today. 25 July 2012. Archived from the original on 27 July 2012. Retrieved 25 July 2012.
20. "City Harvest Church case adjourned to Oct 4". The Straits Times. 22 August 2012. Archived from the original on 2 May 2013. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
21. "Singapore Christians want quick justice in City Harvest Church case". Bikya Masr. 5 October 2012. Archived from the original on 12 December 2012. Retrieved 11 October 2012.
22. "Trial involving City Harvest Church leaders to start on May 15". Today. Archived from the original on 9 March 2013. Retrieved 14 March 2013.
23. Lim, Joyce. "City Harvest trial: Accused weeps while quizzed by own lawyer". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 28 September 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
24. "Commissioner of Charities suspends 8 members of City Harvest board". Today. 26 June 2012. Archived from the original on 29 June 2012. Retrieved 28 June 2012.
25. "Inquiry found misconduct and mismanagement in the City Harvest Church". 26 June 2012. Archived from the original on 29 June 2012. Retrieved 28 June 2012.
26. Feng, Zengkun (1 September 2014). "CHC trial: Wee 'deceived brother about church business'". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 20 September 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
27. "What you need to know about the City Harvest trial". Straits Times. Archived from the original on 1 December 2015. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
28. Poh, Ian. "Finance manager 'part of plan to purge bonds'". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 2 October 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
29. "City Harvest case: Allegedly total of $50m misused". The Straits Times. 28 June 2012. Archived from the original on 28 June 2012. Retrieved 29 June 2012.
30. "City Harvest Church responds to allegations". The Straits Times. 29 June 2012. Archived from the original on 30 June 2012. Retrieved 29 June 2012.
31. "Money from 'love gifts' went into secret account". TNP. Archived from the original on 1 December 2015. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
32. "City Harvest warned over fund raising for six accused". The Straits Times. 22 August 2012. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
33. Ng, Jun Sen (21 September 2014). "Finance manager was cross-examined by co-accused Chew". The New Paper. Archived from the original on 23 September 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
34. "CHC trial: New evidence of text conversation among accused". The Straits Times. 22 September 2014. Archived from the original on 25 September 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
35. Loh, Ronald (26 September 2014). "CHC trial: Chief Prosecutor says finance manager is being untruthful". The New Paper. Archived from the original on 28 September 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
36. Loh, Ronald (27 September 2014). "City Harvest trial: 'Incredible' there were no minutes". The New Paper. Archived from the original on 29 September 2014. Retrieved 28 September 2014.
37. Teh, Shi Ning. "Who is City Harvest's Wahju Hanafi?". The Business Times. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
38. Feng, Zengkun (22 May 2015). "City Harvest trial: Twists, turns and tears enough to fuel a Korean drama". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 14 July 2015. Retrieved 3 August 2015.
39. Cheong, Danson; Lee, Min Kok; Ng, Huiwen (21 October 2015). "City Harvest trial: All 6 accused, including founder Kong Hee, found guilty of all charges". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 21 October 2015. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
40. "City Harvest trial: Shocked faces after sentencing". The Straits Times. 21 November 2015. Retrieved 2 August 2020.
41. Cheong, Danson. "Controversy over City Harvest Church's 'prosperity gospel'". Archived from the original on 1 December 2015. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
42. "What you need to know about the City Harvest trial". The Straits Times. 20 November 2015. Archived from the original on 5 July 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
43. "Kong a 'well-practised liar': Prosecution". Archived from the original on 14 September 2016. Retrieved 15 May 2016.
44. "City Harvest Church appeal: Case to be heard in September". Archived from the original on 12 August 2016. Retrieved 4 August 2016.
45. "Ex-City Harvest Church leader Chew Eng Han files police report against 8 others". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 21 February 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
46. Mahmud, Aqil Haziq (21 February 2018). "Ex-City Harvest Church fund manager Chew Eng Han arrested for trying to flee Singapore by boat". Channel NewsAsia. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
47. "Former City Harvest Church leader Chew Eng Han charged with trying to flee the country". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 22 February 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
48. Lam, Lydia (12 December 2018). "Former City Harvest Church leader Chew Eng Han found guilty of trying to flee Singapore". Channel NewsAsia. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
49. Lam, Lydia; Abu Baker, Jalelah (12 December 2018). "Chew Eng Han slapped with additional jail term for trying to flee Singapore". Channel NewsAsia. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
50. "Malaysian man arrested in connection with Chew Eng Han's attempted escape from Singapore". Channel NewsAsia. 26 February 2018. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
51. Chelvan, Vanessa Paige (28 February 2018). "Malaysian charged with helping ex-City Harvest Church leader Chew Eng Han flee the country". Channel NewsAsia. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
52. Chelvan, Vanessa Paige; Chia, Lianne (12 April 2018). "Malaysian who helped Chew Eng Han flee Singapore jailed for 6 months". Channel NewsAsia. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
53. "Malaysian man arrested for role in Chew Eng Han's escape bid". Channel NewsAsia. 15 April 2018. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
54. Tang, Louisa (16 April 2018). "Third man charged with alleged role in Chew Eng Han's failed escape bid". Today. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
55. Lam, Lydia (13 July 2018). "2 men jailed for helping Chew Eng Han flee Singapore by boat". Channel NewsAsia. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
56. "City Harvest appeal: Kong Hee's sentence reduced to 3.5 years". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 5 July 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
57. "City Harvest Church: Jail terms maintained for Kong Hee and other ex-leaders". sg.news.yahoo.com. February 2018. Archived from the original on 14 June 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
58. "'Appropriate' revisions to Penal Code to be made following dismissal of appeal in City Harvest Church case". The Straits Times. 1 February 2018. Archived from the original on 7 July 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
59. "From legal battles to failed escape bid: The twists and turns of Chew Eng Han's City Harvest case". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 22 February 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
60. "Ex-City Harvest Church leader Chew Eng Han begins jail term; boatman remanded for further investigations". The Straits Times. 1 March 2018. Archived from the original on 12 March 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
61. "Malaysian who helped Chew Eng Han flee Singapore jailed for 6 months". Channel NewsAsia. Archived from the original on 16 June 2018. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
62. hermesauto (23 February 2018). "Brother of ex-City Harvest Church leader Chew Eng Han out on bail". The Straits Times. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
63. "Elder brother of Chew Eng Han released on police bail". TODAYonline. Retrieved 19 December 2018.
64. "Shanmugam on City Harvest case: Parliament to soon amend law on criminal breach of trust". sg.news.yahoo.com. 5 February 2018. Retrieved 10 December 2020.