1916 United States presidential election in California
1916 United States presidential election in California Turnout 79.57% (of registered voters) 7.89 pp 57.91% (of eligible voters) 12.80 pp [ 1]
County Results
Wilson
40–50%
50–60%
60–70%
Hughes
40–50%
50–60%
70–80%
The 1916 United States presidential election in California took place on November 7 , 1916 as part of the 1916 United States presidential election . State voters chose 13 representatives, or electors, to the Electoral College , who voted for president and vice president .
California narrowly voted for the Democratic incumbent , Woodrow Wilson , over the Republican nominee, Associate Justice Charles Evans Hughes .
Although very close, this was not as close as the previous election or the critical 1892 election in California, and was only the third-closest state in a thrilling election behind New Hampshire and Minnesota . As of 2024, no subsequent presidential election in California has been decided by a smaller margin, although California was decided by less than one point in 1948 and 1960 . This was the closest result where California's electoral votes were not split.
Following on from breaking half-a-dozen county droughts in 1912 , Wilson became the first Democrat to carry Placer County , Plumas County , and Santa Barbara County , since Stephen A. Douglas in 1860 , and the first to carry the counties of Contra Costa and Santa Cruz since James Buchanan in 1856 .[ 2] If Hughes had won California, he would have won the Electoral College despite losing the national popular vote by three points. This is the last election in which a Republican candidate carried Los Angeles County but failed to carry the state of California. Until 2020 this had been the most recent election when California would decide the overall winner of a presidential election, despite routinely having among the highest, or highest number of electoral votes after the next reapportionment following the 1930 census . Had Hughes carried the state, he would have been elected with 267 electoral votes to Wilson's 264.
Results
General Election Results[ 3]
Party
Pledged to
Elector
Votes
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Francis J. Heney
466,289
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Edward L. Doheny
465,936
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Jo V. Snyder
465,092
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Irving C. Ackerman
464,926
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
L. F. Puter
464,824
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
John F. Barry
464,808
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Oscar Hocks
464,731
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
James F. Peck
464,680
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Lorin A. Handley
464,515
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
R. F. Del Valle
464,477
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Virginia M. Spinks
464,233
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Mary Marshall Wiley
464,206
Democratic Party
Woodrow Wilson
Carrie L. Tyler
463,709
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
J. F. Carlston
462,516
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
John A. Britton
462,004
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
T. S. Montgomery
461,828
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
Willis H. Booth
461,826
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
W. F. Chandler
461,610
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
Albert E. Boynton
461,588
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
J. C. Needham
461,505
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
Joseph Scott
461,354
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
Rudolph J. Taussig
461,301
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
Louise Harvey Clarke
460,941
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
Mary Roberts Coolidge
460,908
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
A. J. Wallace
460,826
Republican Party
Charles Evans Hughes
J. P. Baumgartner
460,821
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Scott Anderson
42,898
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Joseph Bredsteen
42,562
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
M. P. Christensen
42,412
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Mollie Bloom Flagg
42,394
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
W. Scott Lewis
42,354
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Ethel Lynn
42,330
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Arnold R. Holston
42,327
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
C. W. Kingsley
42,320
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Noble A. Richardson
42,312
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Harry M. McKee
42,273
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
Ben F. Wilson
42,263
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
George W. Woodbey
42,232
Socialist Party
Allan L. Benson
A. E. Briggs
42,178
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Annie E. K. Bidwell
27,713
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Horace A. Johnson
27,408
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Fred F. Wheeler
27,208
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Robert Rogers
27,156
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Elam Biggs
27,116
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Minnie Goldthwaite
27,082
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
C. C. Selecman
27,067
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Wiley J. Phillips
27,050
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
A. K. Nash
27,027
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Ada E. Ferris
27,017
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Walter O. Woolever
27,013
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
Thomas K. Beard
26,980
Prohibition Party
J. Franklin Hanly
C. S. Corkhill
26,894
Write-in
Scattering
187
Votes cast[ a]
999,603
Results by county
County
Woodrow Wilson Democratic
Charles Evans Hughes Republican
Allan L. Benson Socialist
J. Franklin Hanly Prohibition
Scattering Write-in
Margin
Total votes cast[ b]
#
%
#
%
#
%
#
%
#
%
#
%
Alameda
43,748
42.84%
51,417
50.34%
5,422
5.31%
1,544
1.51%
0
0.00%
-7,669
-7.51%
102,131
Alpine
23
27.71%
60
72.29%
0
0.00%
0
0.00%
0
0.00%
-37
-44.58%
83
Amador
1,766
56.28%
1,209
38.53%
125
3.98%
38
1.21%
0
0.00%
557
17.75%
3,138
Butte
4,888
50.55%
3,956
40.91%
436
4.51%
389
4.02%
0
0.00%
932
9.64%
9,669
Calaveras
1,524
53.06%
1,175
40.91%
135
4.70%
38
1.32%
0
0.00%
349
12.15%
2,872
Colusa
1,998
62.89%
1,011
31.82%
123
3.87%
45
1.42%
0
0.00%
987
31.07%
3,177
Contra Costa
6,092
46.82%
5,731
44.05%
886
6.81%
302
2.32%
0
0.00%
361
2.77%
13,011
Del Norte
471
41.35%
499
43.81%
144
12.64%
25
2.19%
0
0.00%
-28
-2.46%
1,139
El Dorado
1,755
57.67%
1,068
35.10%
187
6.15%
33
1.08%
0
0.00%
687
22.58%
3,043
Fresno
14,241
49.95%
11,707
41.07%
1,648
5.78%
912
3.20%
0
0.00%
2,534
8.89%
28,508
Glenn
1,797
53.87%
1,342
40.23%
101
3.03%
94
2.82%
2
0.06%
455
13.64%
3,336
Humboldt
4,103
36.27%
5,786
51.14%
1,063
9.40%
361
3.19%
0
0.00%
-1,683
14.88%
11,313
Imperial
3,273
49.15%
2,694
40.46%
363
5.45%
329
4.94%
0
0.00%
579
8.69%
6,659
Inyo
966
47.92%
846
41.96%
152
7.54%
52
2.58%
0
0.00%
120
5.95%
2,016
Kern
9,566
59.86%
5,611
35.11%
553
3.46%
251
1.57%
0
0.00%
3,955
24.75%
15,981
Kings
2,905
51.86%
2,221
39.65%
256
4.57%
220
3.93%
0
0.00%
684
12.21%
5,602
Lake
1,164
52.13%
791
35.42%
182
8.15%
96
4.30%
0
0.00%
373
16.70%
2,233
Lassen
1,323
55.75%
877
36.96%
143
6.03%
30
1.26%
0
0.00%
446
18.79%
2,373
Los Angeles
114,070
42.58%
135,554
50.59%
8,076
3.01%
10,061
3.76%
160
0.06%
-21,484
-8.02%
267,921
Madera
1,880
54.01%
1,323
38.01%
183
5.26%
86
2.56%
6
0.17%
557
16.00%
3,481
Marin
3,789
43.82%
4,328
50.05%
424
4.90%
106
1.23%
0
0.00%
-539
-6.23%
8,647
Mariposa
802
58.24%
451
32.75%
95
6.90%
29
2.11%
0
0.00%
351
25.49%
1,377
Mendocino
3,371
45.14%
3,494
46.79%
453
6.07%
150
2.01%
0
0.00%
-123
-1.65%
7,468
Merced
2,637
50.36%
2,132
40.72%
285
5.44%
182
3.48%
0
0.00%
505
9.64%
5,236
Modoc
1,222
58.25%
768
36.61%
79
3.77%
29
1.38%
0
0.00%
454
21.64%
2,098
Mono
158
48.47%
137
42.02%
26
7.98%
5
1.53%
0
0.00%
21
6.44%
326
Monterey
3,878
48.28%
3,599
44.81%
364
4.53%
191
2.38%
0
0.00%
279
3.47%
8,032
Napa
3,088
41.39%
3,914
52.46%
304
4.07%
155
2.08%
0
0.00%
-826
-11.07%
7,461
Nevada
2,548
56.58%
1,586
35.22%
279
6.20%
90
2.00%
0
0.00%
962
21.36%
4,503
Orange
6,474
34.54%
10,609
56.59%
643
3.43%
1,020
5.44%
0
0.00%
-4,135
-22.06%
18,746
Placer
3,375
58.28%
1,954
33.74%
314
5.42%
148
2.56%
0
0.00%
1,421
24.54%
5,791
Plumas
1,025
56.50%
663
36.55%
102
5.62%
24
1.32%
0
0.00%
362
19.96%
1,814
Riverside
4,561
33.44%
7,452
54.64%
790
5.79%
836
6.13%
0
0.00%
-2,891
-21.20%
13,639
Sacramento
14,538
54.63%
10,696
40.19%
833
3.13%
546
2.05%
0
0.00%
3,842
14.44%
26,613
San Benito
1,688
51.80%
1,440
44.19%
91
2.79%
40
1.23%
0
0.00%
248
7.61%
3,259
San Bernardino
9,398
39.92%
11,932
50.68%
805
3.42%
1,410
5.99%
0
0.00%
-2,534
-10.76%
23,545
San Diego
16,815
46.02%
16,978
46.47%
1,612
4.41%
1,132
3.10%
0
0.00%
-163
-0.45%
36,537
San Francisco
78,225
52.45%
63,093
42.30%
6,423
4.31%
1,404
0.94%
7
0.00%
15,132
10.15%
149,152
San Joaquin
11,454
55.44%
7,861
38.05%
789
3.82%
557
2.70%
0
0.00%
3,593
17.39%
20,661
San Luis Obispo
3,539
49.85%
2,854
40.20%
547
7.71%
159
2.24%
0
0.00%
685
9.65%
7,099
San Mateo
4,485
43.08%
5,207
50.01%
540
5.19%
179
1.72%
0
0.00%
-722
-6.93%
10,411
Santa Barbara
5,198
49.65%
4,453
42.54%
470
4.49%
347
3.31%
1
0.01%
745
7.12%
10,469
Santa Clara
14,185
43.40%
16,592
50.77%
1,006
3.08%
887
2.71%
11
0.03%
-2,407
-7.37%
32,681
Santa Cruz
4,511
47.76%
4,228
44.76%
383
4.05%
324
3.43%
0
0.00%
283
3.00%
9,446
Shasta
2,828
52.39%
2,008
37.20%
449
8.32%
113
2.09%
0
0.00%
820
15.19%
5,398
Sierra
594
58.35%
360
35.36%
55
5.40%
9
0.88%
0
0.00%
234
22.99%
1,018
Siskiyou
3,447
57.15%
2,059
34.13%
417
6.91%
109
1.81%
0
0.00%
1,388
23.01%
6,032
Solano
5,678
58.37%
3,536
36.35%
322
3.31%
192
1.97%
0
0.00%
2,142
22.02%
9,728
Sonoma
8,377
43.35%
9,733
50.37%
921
4.77%
293
1.52%
0
0.00%
-1,356
-7.02%
19,324
Stanislaus
5,490
46.98%
4,401
37.66%
729
6.24%
1,067
9.13%
0
0.00%
1,089
9.32%
11,687
Sutter
1,543
53.52%
1,211
42.00%
80
2.77%
49
1.70%
0
0.00%
332
11.52%
2,883
Tehama
2,534
52.92%
1,739
36.32%
334
6.98%
181
3.78%
0
0.00%
795
16.60%
4,788
Trinity
661
54.81%
424
35.16%
104
8.62%
17
1.41%
0
0.00%
237
19.65%
1,206
Tulare
7,299
46.87%
6,845
43.96%
895
5.75%
533
3.42%
0
0.00%
454
2.92%
15,572
Tuolumne
1,584
54.21%
1,057
36.17%
237
8.11%
44
1.51%
0
0.00%
527
18.04%
2,922
Ventura
2,835
39.30%
3,980
55.18%
260
3.60%
138
1.91%
0
0.00%
-1,145
-15.87%
7,213
Yolo
2,922
53.12%
2,334
42.43%
167
3.04%
78
1.42%
0
0.00%
588
10.69%
5,501
Yuba
1,980
54.49%
1,530
42.10%
93
2.56%
31
0.85%
0
0.00%
450
12.38%
3,634
Total
466,289
46.65%
462,516
46.27%
42,898
4.29%
27,713
2.77%
187
0.02%
3,773
0.38%
999,603
Counties that flipped from Republican to Democratic
Counties that flipped from Democratic to Republican
Notes
^ Based on totals for highest elector on each ticket
^ Based on the highest elector on each ticket
References