The X Factor: Battle of the Stars

The X Factor: Battle of the Stars
Hosted byKate Thornton
Judges
WinnerLucy Benjamin
Runner-upMatt Stevens
Release
Original networkITV
Original release29 May (2006-05-29) –
5 June 2006 (2006-06-05)

The X Factor: Battle of the Stars is a UK celebrity special edition of The X Factor, which screened on ITV, started on 29 May 2006 and lasting for eight consecutive nights. Pop Idol was meant to air in its place as Celebrity Pop Idol but was stopped shortly before transmission, when ITV picked The X Factor over it.

Nine celebrity acts participated, singing live in front of the nation and facing the judges of the previous The X Factor series, Simon Cowell, Sharon Osbourne and Louis Walsh. Voting revenues were donated to the celebrities' chosen charities.

Cowell originally axed the format after its first airing, describing as "pointless", however, a revamped variation of the format aired in 2019, titled The X Factor: Celebrity with Cowell and Walsh reprising their roles as judges and Nicole Scherzinger replacing Osbourne on the panel as well as Dermot O'Leary taking over from Kate Thornton as host.

Contestants

Key:

  – Winner
  – Runner-up
Act(s) Age(s) Category (mentor) Known For Result
Lucy Benjamin 35 Over 25s (Walsh) Former EastEnders actress Winner
Matt Stevens 23 16-24s (Osbourne) Rugby union player Runner-up
Chris Moyles 32 Over 25s (Walsh) Television & radio presenter 3rd place
The Chefs[a] 37–50 Groups (Cowell) Celebrity chefs 4th place
Nikki Sanderson 22 16-24s (Osbourne) Former Coronation Street actress 5th place
James & Rebecca[b] 48 & 28 Groups (Cowell) Former British Army cavalry officer (Hewitt)
Media personality & glamour model (Loos)
6th place
Michelle Marsh 23 16-24s (Osbourne) Page 3 girl & glamour model 7th place
Gillian McKeith 46 Over 25s (Walsh) Nutritionist, author & television presenter 8th place
Paul & Debbie 68 & 47 Groups (Cowell) Magician & television presenter (Daniels)
Magician's assistant (McGee)
9th place
  1. ^ The Chefs consists of Jean-Christophe Novelli, Aldo Zilli, Paul Rankin and Ross Burden.
  2. ^ Loos replaced Andrea Catherwood, who was originally scheduled to appear as James Hewitt's singing partner, but was not allowed to appear after ITV News bosses refused to give her permission.[1]

Live shows

Results summary

Colour key
  – Contestant was in the bottom two and had to sing again in the final showdown
  – Contestant received the fewest public votes and was immediately eliminated (no final showdown)
Act Show 1 Show 2 Show 3 Show 4 Show 5 Quarter-Final Semi-Final Final
Lucy Benjamin Safe Safe Bottom Two Safe Safe Safe Safe Winner
(day 8)
Matt Stevens Safe Safe Safe Safe Safe Safe Safe Runner-up
(day 8)
Chris Moyles Safe Safe Safe Safe Safe Safe 3rd Eliminated
(day 7)
The Chefs Safe Safe Safe Safe Bottom Two 4th Eliminated
(day 6)
Nikki Sanderson Safe Safe Safe Bottom Two Bottom Two Eliminated
(day 5)
James & Rebecca Safe Safe Safe Bottom Two Eliminated
(day 4)
Michelle Marsh Safe Bottom Two Bottom Two Eliminated
(day 3)
Gillian McKeith Bottom Two Bottom Two Eliminated
(day 2)
Paul & Debbie Bottom Two Eliminated
(day 1)
Final showdown McKeith,
Paul & Debbie
McKeith,
Marsh
Benjamin,
Marsh
James & Rebecca,
Sanderson
The Chefs,
Sanderson
No final showdown or judges' votes; results were based on public votes alone
Walsh's vote to eliminate (Over 25s) Paul & Debbie Marsh Marsh James & Rebecca Sanderson
Osbourne's vote to eliminate (16-24s) Paul & Debbie McKeith Benjamin James & Rebecca The Chefs
Cowell's vote to eliminate (Groups) McKeith McKeith Marsh Sanderson Sanderson
Eliminated Paul & Debbie
2 of 3 votes
Majority
Gillian McKeith
2 of 3 votes
Majority
Michelle Marsh
2 of 3 votes
Majority
James & Rebecca
2 of 3 votes
Majority
Nikki Sanderson
2 of 3 votes
Majority
The Chefs
Public vote
to save
Chris Moyles
Public vote
to save
Matt Stevens
Public vote
to win

Live show details

Show 1 (29 May 2006)

Contestants' performances on the first live show
Act Order Song Result
Paul & Debbie 1 "Let Me Entertain You" Eliminated
Nikki Sanderson 2 "I've Got the Music in Me" Safe
Gillian McKeith 3 "I Just Want to Make Love to You" Bottom two
The Chefs 4 "Uptown Girl" Safe
Matt Stevens 5 "Mack the Knife" Safe
Lucy Benjamin 6 "Put Your Records On" Safe
James & Rebecca 7 "Addicted to Love" Safe
Michelle Marsh 8 "River Deep – Mountain High" Safe
Chris Moyles 9 "Ain't That a Kick in the Head?" Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
  • Cowell: Gillian McKeith - backed his own act, Paul & Debbie.
  • Walsh: Paul & Debbie - backed his own act, Gillian McKeith.
  • Osbourne: Paul & Debbie - based on the final showdown performance.

Show 2 (30 May 2006)

Contestants' performances on the second live show
Act Order Song Result
Chris Moyles 1 "You Really Got Me" Safe
Michelle Marsh 2 "Eternal Flame" Bottom two
The Chefs 3 "Volare" Safe
Lucy Benjamin 4 "Walking on Sunshine" Safe
Gillian McKeith 5 "The Shoop Shoop Song (It's in His Kiss)" Eliminated
James & Rebecca 6 "Baby, It's Cold Outside" Safe
Nikki Sanderson 7 "Emotion" Safe
Matt Stevens 8 "Smooth" Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
  • Walsh: Michelle Marsh - backed his own act, Gillian McKeith.
  • Osbourne: Gillian McKeith - backed her own act, Michelle Marsh.
  • Cowell: Gillian McKeith - based on the final showdown performance.

Show 3 (31 May 2006)

Contestants' performances on the third live show
Act Order Song Result
Lucy Benjamin 1 "Get the Party Started" Bottom two
Nikki Sanderson 2 "The Voice Within" Safe
Chris Moyles 3 "What a Wonderful World" Safe
Michelle Marsh 4 "Ironic" Eliminated
The Chefs 5 "To All the Girls I've Loved Before" Safe
Matt Stevens 6 "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" Safe
James & Rebecca 7 "Rock DJ" Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
  • Osbourne: Lucy Benjamin - backed her own act, Michelle Marsh.
  • Walsh: Michelle Marsh - backed his own act, Lucy Benjamin.
  • Cowell: Michelle Marsh - based on the final showdown performance.

Show 4 (1 June 2006)

Contestants' performances on the fourth live show
Act Order Song Result
Nikki Sanderson 1 "I Love Rock 'n' Roll" Bottom two
Chris Moyles 2 "Beautiful Day" Safe
James & Rebecca 3 "The Way You Make Me Feel" Eliminated
Matt Stevens 4 "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay" Safe
Lucy Benjamin 5 "See the Day" (Girls Aloud) Safe
The Chefs 6 "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
  • Cowell: Nikki Sanderson - backed his own act, James & Rebecca.
  • Osbourne: James & Rebecca - backed her own act, Nikki Sanderson
  • Walsh: James & Rebecca - based on the final showdown performance.

Show 5 (2 June 2006)

Contestants' performances on the fifth live show
Act Order First Song Order Second song Result
The Chefs 1 "Get Back" 6 "That's Amore" Bottom two
Nikki Sanderson 2 "Run to You" 7 "Shackles (Praise You)" Eliminated
Chris Moyles 3 "Achilles Heel" 8 "Avenues and Alleyways" Safe
Lucy Benjamin 4 "Call Me" 9 "Killing Me Softly with His Song" Safe
Matt Stevens 5 "Nobody Knows" 10 "Piano Man" Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
  • Osbourne: The Chefs - backed her own act, Nikki Sanderson.
  • Cowell: Nikki Sanderson - backed his own act, The Chefs.
  • Walsh: Nikki Sanderson - based on the final showdown performance.

Show 6: Quarter-final (3 June 2006)

Contestants' performances on the sixth live show
Act Order First Song Order Second song Result
Matt Stevens 1 "Moondance" 5 "Desperado" Safe
The Chefs 2 "Can't Take My Eyes Off You" 6 "Livin' la Vida Loca" Eliminated
Chris Moyles 3 "That's My Goal" 7 "Burning Love" Safe
Lucy Benjamin 4 "If I Ain't Got You" 8 "Maybe" Safe

For the first time in the series, there was no bottom two. The act with the fewest votes was eliminated.

Show 7: Semi-final (4 June 2006)

Contestants' performances on the seventh live show
Act Order First Song Order Second song Result
Chris Moyles 1 "Hard To Handle" 4 "Wonderwall" Eliminated
Lucy Benjamin 2 "That Ole Devil Called Love" 5 "Torn" Safe
Matt Stevens 3 "I Got A Woman" 6 "She's The One" Safe

For the second time in the series, there was no bottom two. The act with the fewest votes was eliminated.

Show 8: Final (5 June 2006)

All the contestants appeared to perform "I'd Like to Teach the World to Sing" and Shayne Ward performed "Stand by Me".

Act Order First song Order Second song Result
Matt Stevens 1 "Theme from New York, New York" 3 "Mack The Knife" Runner-Up
Lucy Benjamin 2 "Last Dance" 4 "See The Day" Winner

Reception

Ratings

All ratings are taken from the UK Programme Ratings website, BARB.[2]

Episode Air date Official rating
(millions)
Weekly rank for all UK TV channels
Live show 1 29 May 5.79 24
Live show 2 30 May 4.42 40
Live show 3 31 May 6.07 21
Live show 4 1 June 5.89 23
Live show 5 2 June 5.57 28
Live quarter-final 3 June 5.35 31
Live semi-final 4 June 6.31 19
Live final 5 June 6.62 14
Series average 2006 5.75

Axing and revival

It was reported on 26 August 2006 that Cowell had axed the show, describing it as "pointless" and adding "we are never going to do it again."[3] However, Cowell later stated in an interview with The Sun on 30 November 2018 that he would consider reviving the show for a second series as a charity special.[4]

The show's format was reported to return in 2019, along with a separate series for former contestants with a similar format, as the regular series is being put on hiatus due to declining ratings.[5][6] On 7 July 2019, Walsh spoke about the return of the series, stating, "I go to Los Angeles on Tuesday, I go to Simon's house in Malibu, it's me Simon and Nicole [Scherzinger] and we're doing the celebrity one."[7]

References

  1. ^ "X Factor 'ban' for reporter Andrea". The News Letter. 29 May 2006. Retrieved 23 November 2017.
  2. ^ BARB Official Site
  3. ^ "Simon Cowell confirms plans to launch TWO new versions of The X Factor in 2019". Radio Times. Retrieved 9 February 2021.
  4. ^ "Simon Cowell wants to revive Celebrity X Factor and mentor David Walliams". Metro. 1 December 2018. Retrieved 22 August 2019.
  5. ^ Harp, Justin (14 February 2019). "Simon Cowell's X Factor and BGT each getting TWO series in 2019". Digital Spy.
  6. ^ "Celebrity X Factor: Which Stars Are On The Line-Up And Who Are The Judges?". 16 July 2019.
  7. ^ Darvill, Josh (7 July 2019). "Louis Walsh and Nicole Scherzinger 'to return to The X Factor'". TellyMix.