The congregation was formed on March 27, 1874, through the merger of Congregation Anshe Chesed with Temple Adath Jeshurun.[1]David Einhorn served as the congregation's first rabbi.[2]Kaufmann Kohler succeeded his father-in-law Einhorn as rabbi in 1879, serving there until he became president of Hebrew Union College in 1903.[3]Rudolph Grossman was associate rabbi of Temple Beth-El from 1889 to 1896.[4] Samuel Schulman was elected associate rabbi in 1901, and in 1903 he succeeded Kohler as rabbi.[5] He continued to serve as its rabbi until its merger in 1927.[6]
The Romanesque Revival building with Byzantine and Moorish influences, designed by Brunner & Tryon, was dedicated on September 18, 1891.[1][7] Completed with Indiana limestone, and interior fittings using Mexican onyx, gold, Numidian marble, and a copper-domed roof, the land and building costs amounted to $700,000 in 1891 ($23.7 million in 2023).[1] The large 51-foot (16 m) dome was reportedly modelled on the New Synagogue in Berlin.[8]
An organ by Odell Company was installed in the synagogue in 1890; and it was replaced by a new organ by M. P. Möller, installed in 1924 at the front of the synagogue above the
bimah, obscured from public view.[9]
In 1927 the Temple Beth-El congregation merged with Congregation Emanu-El.[10][11] The congregation had barely used the synagogue since Yom Kippur in 1929, and was subsequently demolished in 1947.[1]