Tammy Faye had its world premiere production at the Almeida Theatre in London, previewing from October 13, 2022 (with an official press night on October 26) running until December 2. The production was due to close on December 3, however due to illness in the cast the final performances were cancelled.[2] The production was directed by the Almeida's artistic director Rupert Goold with choreography by Lynne Page, design by Bunny Christie, costume design by Katrina Lindsay and lighting design by Neil Austin and produced by Joseph Smith
In November 2023, it was announced that the show would transfer to Broadway during the 2024–25 season.[4] On the red carpet at the 2024 Tony Awards, Andrew Rannells revealed that he would no longer be going to Broadway with the show, due to failed contract negotiations.[5] On June 26 , it was announced Christian Borle would be taking over the role of Jim Bakker.[6] One month later, Michael Cerveris joined the cast as Jerry Falwell.[7]
The show began previews on 19 October 2024, with an opening night on 14 November at the newly renovated Palace Theatre.[8]Katie Brayben reprised her role.[9] On November 19, it was announced that the show would close on December 8, after receiving negative reviews and poor ticket sales, losing $25 million throughout its run.[10][11] The show played 24 preview performances and 29 regular performances.[10][12]
In its review of the Broadway production, The New York Times called the show "disjointed, strangely bland."[19]Variety's Frank Rizzo said the Broadway production lacked "any sense of confidence, consistency or purpose. It’s as messy as Tammy’s mascara."[20]
