Spamouflage

Spamouflage, Dragonbridge, Spamouflage Dragon, Storm 1376, or Taizi Flood is an online propaganda and disinformation operation that uses a network of social media accounts to make posts in favor of the Chinese government and harass dissidents and journalists overseas since 2017.^[1][2][3] Beginning in the early 2020s, Spamouflage accounts also began making posts about American and Taiwanese politics.^[4][5] It is widely believed that the Chinese government, particularly the Ministry of Public Security, is behind the network.^{[6][2][7][8][5]} Spamouflage has increasingly used generative artificial intelligence for influence operations.^[9] The campaign has largely failed to receive views from real users,^[4] although it has attracted some organic engagement using new tactics.^[8][10]: 2

History

In September 2019, research firm Graphika published a report identifying a network of spam accounts across different social media platforms making posts supporting the Chinese government and attacking its critics, naming the network "Spamouflage Dragon" due to its tactic of mixing in non-political spam content as camouflage.^[11]: 2 The network initially targeted exiled businessman Guo Wengui in 2018 and gradually also added criticisms of the 2019–2020 Hong Kong protests.^[11]: 22 The spam network's content did not receive much genuine engagement or views from real users, and the report concluded at the time that the low quality of the operation suggests that "it was not a state-backed operation".^[11]: 22

In early 2020, after becoming mostly dormant for a period of time following takedowns by social media platforms that occurred as a result of the 2019 Graphika report,^[12]: 5 the Spamouflage network reemerged with a focus on praising the Chinese government response to COVID-19 in addition to posting about its previous topics of interest.^[12]: 2

In February 2021, a Graphika report indicated that some accounts in the Spamouflage network had begun to see some success in receiving views from real users.^[10]: 3 Instead of solely using disposable spam accounts, Spamouflage began using accounts with a veneer of plausibility, developing fictional personas and co-opting the identities of stolen accounts.^[10]: 45 Spamouflage posts began to be amplified through retweets by Chinese government officials, including Zhao Lijian and then-ambassador to Venezuela Li Baorong.^{[10]: 13, 56} Its posts closely followed Chinese government messaging and had a new focus on aggressively criticizing the United States and both of its major political parties.^{[10]: 4–5}

In October 2022, Google's Mandiant reported that Spamouflage, which it calls Dragonbridge, was spreading propaganda and disinformation targeting the 2022 United States midterm elections. One video discouraged Americans from voting and cast doubt on the American political system.^[13]

In April 2023, the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) unsealed an indictment against 34 officers of China's Ministry of Public Security (MPS) accused of running a disinformation campaign targeting US-based Chinese dissidents. Meta Platforms and private researchers cited by CNN believe that they are linked to Spamouflage, although the DOJ did not explicitly refer to Spamouflage by name.^[2][7]

In August 2023, Meta announced a takedown of nearly 9000 accounts and pages associated with Spamouflage; their threat intelligence report also covered the propaganda campaign's activities on YouTube, TikTok, and other social media platforms. They also indicated that Spamouflage had created a fake research paper blaming the United States for COVID-19 and attempted to publicize it via various social media networks.^[14]

In April 2024, Institute for Strategic Dialogue researchers stated that some Spamouflage accounts had begun making posts about American politics under false American personas, a strategy that was previously used by Russian disinformation campaigns.^[8] Under this new strategy, Spamouflage accounts pretending to be supporters of Donald Trump received engagement from real users, with one post being retweeted by conspiracy theorist Alex Jones.^[8] The researchers indicated that they did not find Spamouflage accounts pretending to be Joe Biden supporters, although the existence of such accounts could not be ruled out.^[8] The same month, Spamouflage accounts used the 2024 pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses to stoke outrage, according to Microsoft.^[15][16] In May 2024, OpenAI removed accounts used by Spamouflage in influence operations.^[17] Spamouflage was identified as interfering with the 2024 United States presidential election through fake accounts posing as Americans posting divisive content. Several of the accounts were believed to be created using AI. US intelligence analysts described the efforts as not supporting any particular candidate, but focusing on issues important to Beijing such as Taiwan, and "undermining confidence in elections, voting, and the U.S. in general."^[18] In October 2024, Taiwan's Doublethink Labs and Voice of America found that Spamouflage has also amplified antisemitic tropes and conspiracy theories about the U.S. government.^[19]

Countries and people affected

Guo Wengui

Criticizing exiled businessman Guo Wengui, who has become a prominent critic of the Chinese government, was the initial focus of the Spamouflage network, and Guo has continued to be one of the targets of the network.^[20]: 15 The prolonged propaganda campaign featured numerous political cartoons attacking Guo and associates such as virologist Li-Meng Yan and Steve Bannon in multiple languages.^[21]: 1

Overseas journalists

A June 2022 report by the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) found that several journalists, mostly women of Chinese descent working for overseas media outlets, were subjected to a harassment campaign carried out using Spamouflage accounts in what the ASPI called an instance of "digital transnational repression".^[22]

Canada

Further information: Chinese government interference in Canada

In 2023, fabricated videos in which Chinese dissident Liu Xin is depicted via deepfake to be making baseless allegations of legal and ethical violations by Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and other Canadian politicians were posted by Spamouflage accounts. Global Affairs Canada and Liu both believe that the videos may have sought to discredit Liu and hurt Canadian politicians' perception of him.^[23]

United States

Further information: Chinese interference in the 2024 United States elections

Prior to the 2020 United States presidential election, Spamouflage accounts made posts criticizing Donald Trump in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic, actions he took against China, and the George Floyd protests. Although the network made a large volume of videos, they were of poor quality and received few authentic views. Many of the videos had broken English, and the intended audience of the videos was unclear.^[24]

In February 2021, a Graphika report noted that Spamouflage, which previously focused on criticizing Trump and then-Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, began criticizing Biden after the new president was inaugurated. The report concluded that the focus of the network was to spread the narrative of "China's rise and America's fall" rather than partisan election interference.^{[10]: 4–5}

According to Mandiant, in April 2021, Spamouflage accounts called for protests in New York City against virologist Li-Meng Yan, Guo Wengui and Steve Bannon for spreading "rumors" about COVID-19 and publicized an address purportedly belonging to Guo. Although Spamouflage accounts claimed, sometimes using manipulated images, that the protests were successful, there is no evidence that protesters were successfully mobilized.^[25]

A 2022 Mandiant report indicated that Spamouflage accounts had called for protests against proposed rare earth mines in the United States and Canada. The minerals are of strategic importance in electronics manufacturing, and the United States had started trying to increase domestic production to counter China's control over the field.^[26] Before the 2022 United States elections, the Spamouflage network made posts casting doubts on the American political system, pointing to examples of political division and violence as purported evidence of the United States' decline.^[27] Videos they posted portrayed American elections and the American government as being ineffective in improving Americans' lives.^[13]

Start in mid-2023 in the lead-up to the 2024 United States presidential election, Spamouflage accounts began making posts about divisive American political issues targeted to actual Americans.^[1] Accounts pretending to be American Donald Trump supporters spread false conspiracy theories about Joe Biden and amplified Russian disinformation about the Russian invasion of Ukraine. In contrast to previous Spamouflage campaigns, these accounts received engagement from real American users.^[8]

Spamouflage has made posts criticizing American foreign policy decisions relating to Taiwan, Ukraine, and trade restrictions on China targeting semiconductors.^[28] It has also capitalized on the Israel–Hamas war to portray the United States as a threat to world peace.^[29][16]

In September 2024, Graphika reported that Chinese Spamouflage operations have involved networks of fake social media users that mimic Americans on social media sites such as X and TikTok in an attempt to manipulate and sway public opinion.^[30] According to a September 2024 Graphika report, "In the run-up to the 2024 election, these accounts have seeded and amplified content denigrating Democratic and Republican candidates, sowing doubt in the legitimacy of the U.S. electoral process, and spreading divisive narratives about sensitive social issues including gun control, homelessness, drug abuse, racial inequality, and the Israel-Hamas conflict. This content, some of which was almost certainly AI-generated, has targeted President Joe Biden, former President Donald Trump, and, more recently, Vice President Kamala Harris."^[30]

In October 2024, The Washington Post reported that China was using Spamouflage to target Representative Barry Moore (R-AL) with denigrating language and antisemitic tropes. Moore has been critical of the Chinese Communist Party, and has directed support for Taiwanese independence. Moore is not Jewish.^[31] Spamouflage has also targeted Marco Rubio as well as the congressional races of Michael McCaul and Marsha Blackburn due to their outspoken criticism of the Chinese government and its policies. The campaign involved dozens of fake accounts. Their content failed to reach a high level of organic engagement and was often shared by other bots, trolls, and Internet researchers. The Chinese embassy called the reports "full of speculations".^[32][6]

Taiwan

Leading up to the 2024 Taiwanese presidential election, the Spamouflage campaign used generative artificial intelligence to create memes and videos featuring AI television anchors to attack pro-independence presidential candidate Lai Ching-te with fabricated corruption allegations.^[5][9] Spamouflage also created a fake audio clip of Terry Gou endorsing another candidate.^[5]

Effectiveness

Low quality and limited authentic engagement

The network has largely been ineffective at getting views and engagement from real users.^[4] One reason identified for the failure of the propaganda campaign, in contrast to more successful campaigns by Russia and other state actors, is its operators' lack of familiarity with the global information environment owing to the closed-off nature of the Chinese internet.^[4] While some new technical tools adopted by Spamouflage operators, such as generative artificial intelligence, may increase the operation's efficiency, they will not necessarily make the operation more effective.^[4]

An August 2020 Graphika report noted the poor quality of Spamouflage content. Videos that Graphika discovered contained "clumsy" text-to-speech voiceovers, grammatically incorrect English, and poorly-translated Chinese idiomatic expressions like "cast a chestnut in the fire will burn themselves with fire".^[33]: 19

Successes

Spamouflage has been able to disrupt discussions on controversial subjects by taking up space in search results with spam posts.^{[21]: 14–15} Additionally, new tactics attempted by the network, such as a small cluster of Twitter accounts discovered in 2024 that pretended to be American supporters of Donald Trump, which researchers named "MAGAflage", have allowed it to receive some real engagement.^[8] Researchers have expressed concerns that Spamouflage may start to gain more traction due to amplification by authentic accounts or a scaling up of the MAGAflage strategy.^[4]

Attribution

The network has been attributed to the Chinese government by Twitter and Meta.^[2][22] Global Affairs Canada has also linked the campaign to the Chinese government.^[34] Sources have linked Spamouflage to the Chinese Ministry of Public Security's "912 Special Project Working Group", which was the subject of a 2023 indictment by the American Department of Justice.^[4][35][6]

An August 2023 threat report released by Meta notes that the timing of the network's activities match up with office hours in China, and that the network displays coordinated activity across multiple platforms.^[2] Institute for Strategic Dialogue researcher Elise Thomas notes that the operation's lack of innovation despite prolonged ineffectiveness is characteristic of a government campaign.^[4] In August 2023, Jack Stubbs of Graphika indicated that the firm had seen open source evidence pointing to the involvement of the Chinese group indicted by the DOJ with limited confidence.^[36]

Initial reports of Spamouflage's activities did not always attribute the campaign to the Chinese government. Graphika researcher Ben Nimmo speculated in 2019 that amateurs or a private firm was behind the campaign.^[37] In 2020, Graphika stated that it was unable to determine the relationship between Spamouflage and the Chinese government.^[24]

In a response to CNN, Chinese government spokesperson Liu Pengyu denied China's involvement in Spamouflage.^[2]

See also

• Artificial intelligence and elections – Use and impact of AI on political elections
• Chinese government interference in Canada
• Chinese information operations and information warfare
• State-sponsored Internet propaganda
• 50 Cent Party

References

1. Bing, Christopher; Paul, Katie; Bing, Christopher (2024-09-03). "US voters targeted by Chinese influence online, researchers say". Reuters. Retrieved 2024-09-06.
2. O'Sullivan, Donie; Devine, Curt; Gordon, Allison (13 November 2023). "China is using the world's largest known online disinformation operation to harass Americans, a CNN review finds". CNN. Archived from the original on 14 November 2023. Retrieved 6 May 2024.
3. "How Microsoft names threat actors". Microsoft Learn. 2024-10-17. Retrieved 2024-10-24.
4. Gilbert, David (April 29, 2024). "Why China Is So Bad at Disinformation". Wired. Archived from the original on 9 May 2024. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
5. Milmo, Dan (2024-04-05). "China will use AI to disrupt elections in the US, South Korea and India, Microsoft warns". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Archived from the original on 2024-05-25. Retrieved 2024-04-07.
6. "China-linked bots targeting Republicans including Marco Rubio in run-up to election, Microsoft says". The Guardian. Reuters. 2024-10-24. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2024-10-25. The group allegedly responsible is known as Taizi Flood, which has been previously associated with China's Ministry of Public Security, researchers say.
7. Hsu, Tiffany; Myers, Steven Lee (1 April 2024). "China's Advancing Efforts to Influence the U.S. Election Raise Alarms". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 3 April 2024. Retrieved 1 April 2024. The accounts sometimes amplified or repeated content from the Chinese influence campaign Spamouflage, which was first identified in 2019 and linked to an arm of the Ministry of Public Security.
8. Yang, Lin (8 April 2024). "Chinese nationalist trolls pretend to be Trump supporters ahead of US elections". Voice of America. Archived from the original on 9 May 2024. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
9. Milmo, Dan; Hawkins, Amy (2024-05-18). "How China is using AI news anchors to deliver its propaganda". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Archived from the original on 2024-05-25. Retrieved 2024-05-20.
10. Nimmo, Ben; Hubert, Ira; Yang, Cheng (February 2021). Spamouflage Breakout: Chinese Spam Network Finally Starts to Gain Some Traction (PDF) (Report). Graphika. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2021-03-05. Retrieved 2024-05-09.
11. Nimmo, Ben; Eib, C. Shawn; Tamora, L. (September 2019). Cross-Platform Spam Network Targeted Hong Kong Protests (PDF) (Report). Graphika. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2024-05-11. Retrieved 2024-05-06.
12. Nimmo, Ben; Eib, C. Shawn; Camille, François; Léa, Ronzaud (April 2020). Return of the (Spamouflage) Dragon: Pro-Chinese Spam Network Tries Again (PDF) (Report). Graphika. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2024-05-11. Retrieved 2024-05-09.
13. Mandiant Intelligence (26 October 2022). "Pro-PRC DRAGONBRIDGE Influence Campaign Leverages New TTPs to Aggressively Target U.S. Interests, Including Midterm Elections". Archived from the original on 9 May 2024. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
14. Taylor, Josh (29 August 2023). "Meta closes nearly 9,000 Facebook and Instagram accounts linked to Chinese 'Spamouflage' foreign influence campaign". The Guardian. Retrieved 12 May 2024.
15. Swenson, Ali (2024-08-09). "Iran is accelerating cyber activity that appears meant to influence the US election, Microsoft says". Associated Press. Retrieved 2024-08-10.
16. Watts, Clint (2024-08-09). "Iran Targeting 2024 US Election". Microsoft. Retrieved 2024-08-10.
17. Bond, Shannon (May 30, 2024). "In a first, OpenAI removes influence operations tied to Russia, China and Israel". NPR. Archived from the original on May 30, 2024. Retrieved May 30, 2024.
18. Klepper, David (September 3, 2024). "China-linked 'Spamouflage' network mimics Americans online to sway US political debate". The Associated Press. Archived from the original on September 4, 2024. Retrieved September 4, 2024.
19. Ma, Wenhao (2024-10-04). "China-connected spamouflage networks spread antisemitic disinformation". Voice of America. Archived from the original on 2024-10-05. Retrieved 2024-10-05.
20. Warren, Patrick; Linvill, Darren; Fecher, Leland; Warren, Jayson; Sheffield, Steven (2023). The 5-year Spam: Tracking a Persistent Chinese Influence Operation (Report). Clemson University. Archived from the original on 2024-05-11. Retrieved 2024-05-09.
21. Fecher, Leland; Reich, Tyler; Taylor, Jack; Warren, Patrick (2022-01-01). Oh, the Places You'll Guo! The Tactics and Impact of a Chinese Multilingual Narrative Flooding Campaign through Political Cartoons (Report). Clemson University. Archived from the original on 2024-05-11. Retrieved 2024-05-09.
22. Allen-Ebrahimian, Bethany (3 June 2022). "China-linked Twitter harassment targets female Asian journalists outside China". Axios. Archived from the original on 21 November 2023. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
23. Shen, Nono (1 November 2023). "China critic says he's the target of deepfake 'spamouflage' attack by Beijing". CTV News. The Canadian Press. Archived from the original on 9 November 2023. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
24. Timberg, Craig; Harris, Shane (12 August 2020). "Chinese network of fake accounts targets Trump with English-language videos". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 8 November 2023. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
25. Serabian, Ryan; Foster, Lee (7 September 2021). "Pro-PRC Influence Campaign Expands to Dozens of Social Media Platforms, Websites, and Forums in at Least Seven Languages, Attempted to Physically Mobilize Protesters in the U.S." Mandiant. Archived from the original on 18 April 2024. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
26. Murphy, Margi (28 June 2022). "Pro-China Agents Posed as Activists to Protest US, Canada Mines". BNN Bloomberg. Bloomberg News. Archived from the original on 17 August 2022. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
27. Sganga, Nicole (26 October 2022). "China-linked influence campaign targeting U.S. midterms, security firm says". CBS News. Archived from the original on 7 November 2022. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
28. Pan, Che (2023-01-27). "Pro-China spammers flood YouTube with unpopular videos, Google says". South China Morning Post. Archived from the original on 2024-05-11. Retrieved 2024-05-12.
29. Michelle, Jamrisko; Saraiva, Augusta; Martin, Peter (2024-05-08). "Gaza Is China's New Wedge Issue to Split US From Global South – BNN Bloomberg". BNN Bloomberg. Bloomberg News. Archived from the original on 2024-05-12. Retrieved 2024-05-12.
30. "The #Americans - Chinese State-Linked Influence Operation Spamouflage Masquerades as U.S. Voters to Push Divisive Online Narratives Ahead of 2024 Election" (PDF). Graphika. September 2024. Retrieved October 19, 2024.
31. Merrill, Jeremy B; Schaffer, Aaron; Nix, Naomi (10 October 2024). "A firehose of antisemitic disinformation from China is pointing at two Republican legislators". The Washington Post. Retrieved 11 October 2024.
32. Myers, Steven Lee (October 23, 2024). "Bots Linked to China Target Republican House and Senate Candidates, Microsoft Says". The New York Times. Retrieved October 23, 2024.
33. Nimmo, Ben; François, Camille; Eib, C. Shawn; Ronzaud, Léa (12 August 2020). Spamouflage Goes to America (PDF) (Report). Graphika. Archived (PDF) from the original on 19 December 2021. Retrieved 11 May 2024.
34. Tunney, Catherine (23 October 2023). "China linked to propaganda campaign targeting Trudeau, Poilievre, says Global Affairs". CBC News. Archived from the original on 9 May 2024. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
35. Rawnsley, Adam (2023-08-29). "Chinese Intel Officers Interfered in U.S. Election". Rolling Stone. Retrieved 2024-05-31.
36. Martin, Alexander (29 August 2023). "Chinese law enforcement linked to largest covert influence operation ever discovered". The Record. Archived from the original on 12 May 2024. Retrieved 12 May 2024.
37. Uchill, Joe (25 September 2019). "Bumbling social media scheme hit Hong Kong protestors". Axios. Archived from the original on 5 December 2023. Retrieved 11 May 2024.