Novellae Constitutiones

The Novellae Constitutiones ("new constitutions"; Ancient Greek: Νεαραὶ διατάξεις), or Justinian's Novels, are now considered one of the four major units of Roman law initiated by Roman emperor Justinian I in the course of his long reign (AD 527–565). The other three pieces are: the Codex Justinianus, the Digest, and the Institutes. Justinian's quaestor Tribonian was primarily responsible for compiling these last three. Together, the four parts are known as the Corpus Juris Civilis. Whereas the Code, Digest, and Institutes were designed by Justinian as coherent works, the Novels are diverse laws enacted after 534 (when he promulgated the second edition of the Code) that never were officially compiled during his reign.^[1]

History

Justinian’s first Code, issued in 529, compiled and harmonized the imperial enactments (constitutiones, or constitutions) of previous emperors.^[2] After the Code was promulgated, only it, and not the prior imperial legislation, could be cited as law. However, in 530 and 531, Justinian issued the quinquaginta decisiones (fifty decisions) that resolved differences among the writings of classical jurists, and he continued to issue other new laws as well.^[3] This meant the Code could no longer be the sole, unified source of imperial legislation. Hence, in 534 Justinian issued the Constitutio cordi nobis,^[4] creating a second edition of the Code (Codex repetitae praelectionis). This edition integrated his new legislation into the imperial enactments in the first edition and superseded it.

Justinian continued to legislate after he created the second edition of the Code. Thus, in his pragmatic sanction of 554 (Sanctio pragmatica pro petitione Vigilii),^[5] he foresaw that he would need to maintain a collection of these new constitutions modifying the Code (novellae constitutiones, quae post nostri codicis confectionem). This he did in the form of an archive called the Liber legum or Libri legum.^[6]

Timeline

While Justinian never made an official manuscript compilation of the new laws, private persons filled this void by making unofficial collections in several forms. The following timeline provides a succinct description of these collections and explains how they were transmitted through the centuries.^[7]

• 556 Julianus, a law professor in Constantinople, creates the Epitome Juliani, a summary of 124 novels (or 122, as two are duplicates) from 535-555, for his Latin-speaking-students.^[8] The E.J. is a partially annotated Latin summary of the novels, most of which were officially issued in Greek. Because it is in Latin, the Epitome Juliani is the preferred source of the Novels in the West in the early Middle Ages, until about 1100, when another version is discovered there.^[9]
• 556? A collection of 134 novels issued between 535-556 is compiled around this time. Mostly a word-for-word, full-text translation of Greek novels, it also includes those few novels originally in Latin and the Latin versions of a few originally done in both Latin and Greek. When it is discovered in Bologna around 1100, it comes to be known as the Authenticum, because Irnerius and other Glossators think it an official compilation made at Justinian's order.^[10] (It is also sometimes called the versio vulgata.)
• 575–580 A collection of 168 novels (or 166, as most are in Greek but two are repeated as Latin versions) is created during the reign of Tiberius II Constantine. Two manuscripts of this compilation discovered in the Middle Ages—the Venetian and the Florentine—form the basis of print editions during the Renaissance that are referred to as the Greek Collection of 168.^[11] (Two Greek epitomes of the Novels that did not prove influential for Roman law in the West also are compiled around this time. The "Epitome of Athanasius," composed around 572, contains summaries of 153 novels found in the Greek Collection of 168. Unlike those of other collections, these are arranged entirely by subject.^[12] "The Epitome of Theodore," using the same novels included in Greek Collection of 168, is compiled between 575-600.^[13])
• 600-800 Juliani Epitome manuscripts circulate in Europe. The E.J. is the main source of Roman law there until the Authenticum surfaces. Other parts of what come to be known as Corpus Jurus Civilis are little known in the West.
• 892 The Basilika is published during reign of Byzantine Emperor Leo VI the Wise. Based on the Greek Collection of 168 novels, it includes extracts of many novels, along with parts of the Digest, Code, & Institutes, supplemented by scholia (interpretive notes). The Basilika is used later to help reconstruct the Novels.^[14]
• 12th century The Authenticum appears in Bologna and largely replaces the Epitome Juliani. Justinian's Digest, Institutes, Code, and Novels begin to be called Corpus Juris Civilis (body of the civil law) to differentiate them from the Corpus Juris Canonici (body of the canon, or Church, law). The CJC at that time is organized differently than today. Its units were: each of the three volumes of the Digest; the first 9 books of the Code; and, together as a fifth volume, the Institutes, the last 3 volumes of the Code (Tres libri), and the Novels in the form of the Authenticum.^[15] The latter was called Volumen, or Volumen parvum (insignificant volume—as compared with the other volumes of the CJC).
• 13th century The Venetian manuscript (Codex Marcianus—so called because it was housed in the library of St. Mark's in Venice; an early 16th century copy of this manuscript in the Vatican is referred to as the Palatino-Vaticanus)^[16] of the 168 novel Greek Collection is created around this time. Its last 3 laws are decrees of the praetorian prefect, 4 are novels of Justin II, and 2 are given twice. Also included, as an appendix, are 13 edicta, or edicts, some of which repeat novels in the main collection.
• 14th century The Florentine manuscript (Codex Laurentianus—called the Laurentianus because it belongs to the Laurentian Library in Florence.)^[17] also based on the 168 novel Greek Collection, but of lesser quality, is drafted in the 14th century.
• 1476 The first print edition of Novels^[18] is published in Rome with the Tres Libri of the Code and the Institutes; the novels are based on the Authenticum.

"Arbor feudorum" diagramming feudal rights, from a 1553 Lyon edition of Justinian's Novels

• 1531 Gregor Haloander compiles the first book consisting only of the Novels—as taken from the Bolognese copy of the Codex Laurentianus.^[19]
• 1558 Henry Scrimgeour creates an edition of the Novels based on the Palatino-Vaticanus copy of the Venetian manuscript.^[20]
• 1571 Antonius Contius constructs an influential edition of the Novels using both the Authenticum and 168 novel Greek Collection texts.^[21]
• 1834 A German translation of the Novels, by Freiesleben and Schneider, is published as part of Carl Eduard Otto, Bruno Schilling & Carl Friedrich Sintenis's edition of the Corpus Juris Civilis.^[22] It is based mainly on the Greek Collection but also uses the Authenticum, the Epitome Juliani, and the Basilica.
• 1840 Eduard Osenbrüggen's edition of the Novels, based on both the Venetian and Florentine manuscripts of the Greek Collection, is published in the Kriegel brothers' edition of the CJC.^[23]
• 1851 Gustav Ernst Heimbach publishes his critical edition of the Authenticum.^[24]
• 1873 A critical edition of the Epitome Juliani is issued by Gustav Hänel.^[25]
• 1881 Karl Eduard Zachariae von Lingenthal's critical edition of the Novels^[26] re-establishes many of their subscriptions.
• 1895 The Novels by Rudolf Schoell (completed by Wilhelm Kroll), based on Greek collection of 168, and supplemented by the other versions and critical studies, is issued as volume 3 of Theodor Mommsen, Paul Krüger, Schoell, & Kroll's classic 3 volume editio stereotypa of the CJC.^[27] It includes the 13 edicts and an appendix of 9 other laws of Justinian found in various ancient manuscripts.^[28]
• 1932 Samuel Parsons Scott's English translation of the CJC is published.^[29] Unfortunately, Scott uses the Kriegel brothers' edition of the CJC rather than that of Mommsen, Krüger, Schoell and Kroll, and his translation is severely criticized.^[30] Moreover, he fails to translate the 13 edicts, which were included by Ossenbruggen in the Kriegel edition, and ignores the additional laws presented in the appendix by Schoell and Kroll.
• 1943 Fred H. Blume sends his English translation of Justinian's Code and Novels to Clyde Pharr.^[31]
• 1964 The first English translation of the Thirteen Edicts made from the Greek is published by William Sims Thurman as his doctoral dissertation.^[32]
• 2008 Blume's Code and Novels are published on Annotated Justinian Code website.^[33]
• 2013 Selective English translation of Kroll's Preface to the Novels published by Miller and Kearley.^[34]
• 2018 An English translation of the Novels from the original Greek, by David J.D. Miller and Peter Sarris, is published by the Cambridge University Press.^[35]

See also

• Constitution (Roman law)
• International Roman Law Moot Court
• List of Roman laws
• Novel (Roman law)

References

1. See generally, A. Arthur Schiller, Roman Law: Mechanisms of Development, §§ 12-16 at 29-40 (1978) and Tony Honoré, "Justinian's Codification" in The Oxford Classical Dictionary 803 (Simon Hornblower and Antony Spawforth eds. 3rd rev. ed 2003). For a detailed history of the Novels, see Timothy Kearley, "The Creation and Transmission of Justinian's Novels," available at [1].
2. See Constitutio haec quae necessario, or “Concerning the Establishment of a New Code” (Feb. 13, 528), translated by Justice Fred Blume in the “Annotated Justinian Code,” available at [2] and Constitutio summa rei publicae, or “Concerning the Confirmation of the Code of Justinian,” id. at page 2.
3. See Tony Honoré, Tribonian 124-222 (1978).
4. “Concerning the Correction of the Justinian Code, and the Second Edition Thereof” (November 16, 534), translated by Justice Fred Blume in the “Annotated Justinian Code,” [3] at page 4.
5. "That the Laws of the Emperor Shall be Extended into his Provinces” (August 13, 554), available at [4].
6. See Pierre Noailles, 1 Les Collections de Novelles de l’Empereur Justinian 31-58 (1912) available at [5].
7. For a more detailed examination of the Novels and their transmission, see Timothy Kearley, The Creation and Transmission of Justinian’s Novels (2010), supra note 1.
8. Detlef Liebs, Die Jurisprudenz im Spätantiken Italien 220-223, 264-265 (1987).
9. Charles M. Radding & Antonio Ciaralli, The Corpus Iuris Civilis in the Middle Ages: Manuscripts and Transmissions from the Sixth Century to the Juristic Revival 40 (2007).
10. Id. at 35-36 and Schiller, supra note 1, § 16 at 39.
11. See generally, Schiller, supra note 1 § 16 at 40, and Wolfgang Kunkel, An Introduction to Roman Legal and Constitutional History 176 (J.M. Kelly trans. 2nd ed. 1973).
12. See generally, Noailles, supra note 6 at 183-198.
13. Id. at 181-183.
14. On the Basilica, see Kunkel, supra note 11 at 179-181.
15. See Schiller, supra note 1, § 12 at 29-30.
16. On the Venetian manuscript, see generally, Noailles, supra note 6, vol. 2 at 5-45.
17. On the Florentine manuscript, see generally, Noailles, supra, note 6, vol. 2 at 107-116. Lodovicio Bolognini made copy of the Florentine manuscript in the early 16th century that is referred to as the Bolognese manuscript or Bononiensis,
18. Volumen Parvum.
19. Novellarum Constitutionum Dn. Justiniani Principis Quae Exstant, et ut Exstant, Volumen.
20. Impp. Iustiniani, Iustini, Leonis Novellae Constitutiones. Muirhead, Historical Introduction to the Private Law of Rome 410 (1899) dates it 1557, and Wenger, Die Quellen des Romischen Rechts 678 (1953) gives 1556, but WorldCat bibliographic records show only 1558.
21. Codicis D.N. Justiniani…
22. Das Corpus Juris Civilis (1831-39). Justice Fred Blume used this as an adjunct in his English translation of the Code and Novels.
23. Novellae et Reliquae, part of Kriegel et al., Corpus Juris Civiles (1840-43). Scott used a later edition of the Kriegel CJC (1872) for his translation in The Civil Law (1932, repr. 1973).
24. Authenticum Novellarum Constitutionum Iustiniani Versio Vulgata (1846-1851).
25. Iuliani Epitome Latina Novellarum Iustiniani.
26. Imperatoris Iustiniani Perpetui Augusti Novellae Quae Vocantur.
27. Corpus Iuris Civilis (1877-1895). For his English translation, Justice Blume employed Schoell and Kroll's Latin translation of the Novels, most of which were written originally in Greek. The Mommsen collection of the CJC has gone through several editions and reprintings, the most recent being 1993-2000. This version is accepted by scholars as the standard edition.
28. See Guilelmus [Wihelm] Kroll, "Praefatio," 3 Rudolf Schoell & Wilhelm Kroll, Corpus Iuris Civilis: Novellae iii, vii (1912).
29. Scott's translation The Civil Law is available at [6].
30. See Kearley, supra note 7 at 537-538.
31. For further discussion of the work of Scott, Blume, and Pharr on Roman law translation see Kearley, Timothy G., Roman Law, Classical Education, and Limits on Classical Participation in America into the Twentieth Century (2022). For his translation of the Novels, Blume used the Latin translation of Schoell and Kroll in the Mommsen CJC. See also, Timothy Kearley, "From Rome to the Restatement: S.P. Scott, Fred Blume, Clyde Pharr, and Roman Law in Early Twentieth Century America," available at Social Science Research Network, http://ssrn.com/abstract=2737986.
32. Thurman, W. S. The Thirteen Edicts of Justinian; Translated and Annotated by William Sims Thurman. [University of Texas PhD dissertation; ProQuest Dissertations & Theses](1964).
33. For Blume's translation of these works see the Annotated Justinian Code web site available at [7]. For the history of Blume's Annotated Justinian Code, see Timothy Kearley, "Justice Fred Blume and the Translation of Justinian's Code," available at [8].
34. David J.D. Miller & Timothy Kearley, "Wilhelm Kroll's Preface to Justinian's Novels: An English Translation," University of Wyoming, Annotated Justinian Code website
35. David J.D. Miller & Peter Sarris, The Novels of Justinian: A Complete Annotated English Translation (2 vols., 2018). Sarris's introduction includes a full description of the Novels and a brief survey of the translations. See Peter Sarris "Introduction: The Novels of the Emperor Justinian" in volume 1, pages 1-51.

External links

• Annotated Justinian Code By Fred H. Blume
• Justinian's Novels by Fred H. Blume
• Justinian's Novels, Corpus Iuris Civilis, III, Berlin (1954), Recognovit Rudolfus Schoell, Opus Schoellii morte interceptum absolvit Guilelmus Kroll