Legal fiction

A legal fiction is a construct used in the law where a thing is taken to be true, which is not in fact true, in order to achieve an outcome. Legal fictions can be employed by the courts[1] or found in legislation.

Legal fictions are different from legal presumptions which assume a certain state of facts until the opposite is proved, such as the presumption of legitimacy.

The term legal fiction is sometimes used in a pejorative way. Jeremy Bentham was a famous historical critic of legal fictions.[2][3] Proponents of legal fictions, particularly of their use historically, identify legal fictions as "scaffolding around a building under construction".[4]

Common law examples

Adoption

Child adoption is a legal fiction in that the adoptive parents become the legal parents, notwithstanding the lack of a biological relationship.[5] Once an order or judgment of adoption is entered, the biological parents become legal strangers to the child, legally no longer related nor with any rights related to the child. Conversely, the adoptive parents are legally considered to be parents of the adopted child. A new birth certificate reflecting this is issued, which is a legal fiction.[citation needed]

Doctrine of survival

If two or more people die within a period of time or in a manner that renders it impossible to tell the order in which they died, the older of the two is considered to have died first.[6] This is in order to safeguard the operation of certain general legal rules, e.g. in inheritance law, where the younger person will inherit the older, hence being able to pass on. If a parent dies alongside a child, who has a child of his/her own, the rule of the elder predeceasing the child will allow the grandchild (typically) to inherit both, the parent directly and grandparent indirectly, with the parent instantaneously inheriting and then bequeathing.

The doctrine of survival, although still existing in England, has been abolished in many U.S. states by the Uniform Simultaneous Death Act.

Doe and Roe

The use of John Doe or Jane Roe to identify an undisclosed party in a lawsuit is a type of legal fiction.

The fiction of Doe and Roe being the guardians of undisclosed parties who wish to bring suit, or the names of parties unknown, remains in some jurisdictions although not in England.

The fiction about Doe being left homeless by Roe, used often in property law, however, has been abolished in every common law jurisdiction.[citation needed]

Ejectment

The common law had a procedure whereby title to land could be put in direct issue, called the "writ of right". The defendant could insist on trial by "wager of battle", that is trial by combat, a judicially sanctioned duel. To avoid the plaintiff staking life and limb, a tale was told in the pleadings about how one John Doe leased land from the plaintiff but was ousted by Richard Roe, who claimed a contrary lease from the defendant. Such events would lead to the "mixed action in ejectment", a procedure to determine title via trial by jury. This is the origin of the names John Doe and Richard Roe for anonymous parties. The fiction of Doe, Roe, and the leases was not challenged by the parties unless they wished to stake their life on a trial by combat. Wager of battle fell into disuse by the end of the thirteenth century though it was not abolished in England until 1819.

Reasonable man

In cases where the court must determine whether a standard has been reached, such as whether a defendant has been negligent, the court frequently uses the legal fiction of the "reasonable man".[note 1] This is known as the "objective test", and is far more common than the "subjective test" where the court seeks the viewpoint of the parties (or "subjects"). Sometimes, the court may apply a "mixed test", as in the House of Lords' decision in DPP v Camplin 1978.[7][note 2]

English examples

Jurisdiction of the Exchequer

In England, a legal fiction extended the jurisdiction of the Court of the Exchequer to all types of cases involving debt. The Exchequer had a much lighter caseload than the King's Bench and other courts in England. Litigants would commence an action in the Exchequer Court by pleading that they owed money to the King, which they could not pay because their debtor had in turn wrongfully withheld payment to them. The debt owed to the King became a legal fiction in that the original debtor was not entitled to controvert this allegation in order to oust the Exchequer from jurisdiction.

Jurisdiction of the Court of King's Bench

The Bill of Middlesex was a legal fiction used by the Court of King's Bench to gain jurisdiction over cases traditionally in the remit of the Court of Common Pleas. Hinging on the King's Bench's retaining criminal jurisdiction over the county of Middlesex, the Bill allowed it to take cases traditionally in the remit of other common law courts by claiming that the defendant had committed trespass in Middlesex. Once the defendant was in custody, the trespass complaint would be quietly dropped and other complaints (such as debt or detinue) would be substituted.

Resignation from Parliament

In 1623, a rule was declared that Members of Parliament were given a trust to represent their constituencies and, therefore, were not at liberty to resign. However, an MP who accepted an "office of profit" from the Crown (including appointment as a minister) was obliged to leave the House and seek re-election, because it was thought their independence might be compromised if they were in the monarch's pay.

The device was invented that the MP who wished to quit applied to the Crown for the post of "Steward of the Chiltern Hundreds" or "Steward of the Manor of Northstead" with no duties or income, but legally an office of profit in the monarch's gift. The first MP to avail themself of the Chiltern Hundreds to leave Parliament was John Pitt in 1751. The requirement for ministerial re-election has been abolished, but the "Chiltern Hundreds" mechanism remains to enable MPs to resign.

2019 prorogation controversy

The 2019 UK prorogation controversy was resolved through the use of legal fiction. Although the United Kingdom Supreme Court found that Prime Minister Boris Johnson's prorogation of parliament had been unlawful, it lacked the authority to order the recall of Parliament. Instead, the legal fiction was maintained that Parliament had never been prorogued; any references to prorogation were expunged from the record, and Parliament was instead recorded as being adjourned, enabling it to reassemble the next day.[8]

Australian examples

Mabo v Queensland

Some legal fictions have been invalidated due to increased historical knowledge and changes in social norms, as in the Mabo case, where the High Court of Australia rejected previous authorities that held that Indigenous Australians were too "low in the scale of social organization" at the time of British settlement to be capable of holding title to land.[9][10][11]

Philosophical arguments

William Blackstone defended legal fictions, observing that legislation is never free from the iron law of unintended consequences.[citation needed] Using the metaphor of an ancient castle, Blackstone opined:

We inherit an old Gothic castle, erected in the days of chivalry, but fitted up for a modern inhabitant. The moated ramparts, the embattled towers, and the trophied halls, are magnificent and venerable, but useless. The interior apartments, now converted into rooms of convenience, are cheerful and commodious, though their approaches are winding and difficult.

Henry Maine, on the other hand, argued that legal fictions seem an ornate outgrowth of the law that ought to be removed by legislation. Jeremy Bentham sharply criticised the notion of legal fictions, saying that "fictions are to law what fraud is to trade."[2][3]

Use in fiction

In the novel Joan and Peter (1918) by H. G. Wells, Peter's parents die in a sailing accident. As it is not known which parent dies first, a legal fiction is applied maintaining that the husband, being a man and therefore stronger, lived longer which results in the father's will determining Peter's legal guardian. Later in the novel a witness to the accident declares seeing the mother floundering some time after the father has disappeared, and so the legal fiction is overturned and the mother's will is followed, providing Peter with a new legal guardian. Wells was in error as to the English law, which actually presumes that the older person died first.[dubiousdiscuss]

In Act II, Scene 1 of Gilbert and Sullivan's The Gondoliers, Giuseppe Palmieri (who serves jointly with his brother Marco as King of Barataria) requests that he and his brother be recognized individually, that they might receive individual portions of food as they have two independent appetites. He is turned down because the joint rule "... is a legal fiction, and legal fictions are solemn things."[12]

In the novel Lud-in-the-Mist (1926) by Hope Mirrlees, the concept of the legal fiction as a secular substitute for spiritual mysteries and magical illusions is a central theme. Legal fictions in the novel include referring to fairy fruit, mention of which is taboo, as woven silk fabric in order to allow the law to regulate it; and declaring members of the country's Senate "dead in the eyes of the law" in order to remove them from office, since the senators serve for life.

Limitations on use

Legal fictions derive their legitimacy from tradition and precedent, rather than formal standing as a source of law. Historically, many legal fictions were created as ad hoc remedies forged to meet a harsh or an unforeseen situation. Conventions and practices over the centuries have imparted a degree of stability both to the institution of legal fictions and to specific legal fictions (such as adoptions and corporate personhood) that have been repeatedly invoked in judicial precedents. While judiciaries retain discretion in the use of legal fictions, some general propositions regarding the appropriateness of using legal fictions might be expressed as follows:

  • A legal fiction should not be employed to defeat law or result in illegality: it has been always stressed that a legal fiction should not be employed where it would result in the violation of any legal rule or moral injunction. In Sinclair v. Brougham 1914 AC 378 the House of Lords refused to extend the juridical basis of a quasi-contract to a case of an ultra vires borrowing by a limited company, since it would sanction the evasion of the rules of public policy forbidding an ultra vires borrowing by a company. In general, if it appears that a legal fiction is being used to circumvent an existing rule, the courts are entitled to disregard that fiction and look at the real facts. The doctrine of "piercing the corporate veil" is applied under those circumstances.
  • Legal fiction should operate for the purpose for which it was created and should not be extended beyond its legitimate field.

Some legal fictions are codified in statutory or regulatory law. A person having ordinary skill in the art[13] is an example of such a legal fiction.

See also

Notes

  1. ^ The "reasonable man" is also known as the "objective bystander" or "the man on the Clapham omnibus".
  2. ^ In Camplin, in determining whether the defendant had been provoked to murder (an objective test), the jury should be allowed to consider the age of the defendant, who was 15 (a subjective test).

References

  1. ^ Black's Law Dictionary, 804 (5th ed. 1979)
  2. ^ a b Raymond Wacks (February 2, 2012). Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory. Oxford University Press. p. 202. ISBN 978-0-19-960826-3. Retrieved April 28, 2015.
  3. ^ a b Moglen, Eben (1998). "Legal Fictions and Common Law Legal Theory - Some Historical Reflections". Columbia University.
  4. ^ Fuller 1931, pp. 363, 513, 877.
  5. ^ Fuller, Lon L. (1931). "Legal Fictions". Illinois Law Review. XXV. CA, USA: Stanford University Press: 39. ISBN 9780804703284.
  6. ^ In England and Wales: Law of Property Act 1925, s. 184
  7. ^ DPP v Camplin [1978] AC 705 House of Lords
  8. ^ "R (on the application of Miller) (Appellant) v The Prime Minister (Respondent) Cherry and others (Respondents) v Advocate General for Scotland (Appellant) (Scotland)" (PDF). Supreme Court.
  9. ^ Mabo v Queensland (No 2) [1992] HCA 23 at paras. 39 to 42, (1992) 175 CLR 1
  10. ^ Hope, Deborah (25 February 2006). "'Minor role' for terra nullius". The Australian. News Corp Australia. ProQuest document ID: 356242488 – via ProQuest.
  11. ^ Brennan J (1995). "Aboriginal land claims, an Australian perspective". High Court of Australia. Retrieved 3 December 2022.
  12. ^ Gilbert, William S. The Savoy Operas. London: Macmillan, 1962. p.131
  13. ^ The Patent Act of 1952 - Legislative History - The Federico Commentary

Read other articles:

Parque Nacional do Superagui Nationalpark Atlantskog Land  Brasilien Delstat Paraná Höjdläge 10 m ö.h. Koordinater 25°25′10″S 48°13′09″V / 25.41957°S 48.21919°V / -25.41957; -48.21919 Tidszon BRT (UTC-3)  - sommartid BRST (UTC-2) Geonames 7622480 Parque Nacional do Superagui är en nationalpark i Brasilien.[1] Den ligger i delstaten Paraná, i den södra delen av landet, 1 100 km söder om huvudstaden Brasília. Par...

 

Cet article est une ébauche concernant une localité kosovare. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les recommandations des projets correspondants. Lipjan Lipljan Administration Pays Kosovo District Pristina (Kosovo )Kosovo (Kosovo) Province du Kosovo Lipjan Code postal 14 000 Démographie Population 6 870 hab. (2011) Géographie Coordonnées 42° 31′ 18″ nord, 21° 07′ 33″ est Altitude 563 ...

 

Die Kapelle im Jahre 1976 Die Kapelle im Jahre 2008 Die Dreifaltigkeitskapelle steht am Ortsrand von Jakobwüllesheim, einem Ortsteil der Gemeinde Vettweiß im Kreis Düren, Nordrhein-Westfalen. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Bauwerk 2 Ausstattung 3 Prozessionen 4 Weblinks Bauwerk Die Kapelle ist aus Ziegelsteinen gemauert. Das Dach ist mit Schiefer gedeckt. Das Bauwerk hat einen Durchmesser von sechs Metern. Es steht direkt am Ortseingang von Jakobwüllesheim an der Kreisstraße 33 von Vettweiß her k...

To Fili Tis ZoisΤο Φιλί Της Ζωής Сингл Єлени Папарізу з альбому To Fili Tis Zois & Vrisko To Logo Na ZoВипущений 26 вересня 2007Формат завантаження через ІнтернетЗаписаний 2007Жанр поп-рокКомпозитор Янніс Доксас, Йоргос СабанісТривалість 3:36Лейбл Sony BMG Greece/RCAПродюсер Йоргос СабанісХронологія син...

 

Los cuatro santos de Denver, de izquierda a derecha: San Antonio abad, San Cristóbal, San Sebastián y Santo Tomás de Aquino. Detalle de los Santos Ansovino y Jerónimo. Detalle de la Madonna de la Candeletta. El Políptico del Duomo de Camerino es una gran pintura al temple y dorado sobre tabla (aproximadamente 340 x 442/474 cm) de Carlo Crivelli, datada hacia 1490 aproximadamente y posteriormente separada y los paneles trasladados a varios museos. El panel central, den...

 

The Pierces The Pierces Informação geral Origem Nova Iorque País  Estados Unidos Gênero(s) Folk rock, pop rock, country, rock alternativo Período em atividade 2000 – presente Gravadora(s) Sony Music Entertainment Universal Lizard King Polydor Integrantes Catherine Pierce Allison Pierce Página oficial http://www.thepiercesmusic.com/ The Pierces é uma banda americana de Nova Iorque banda que consiste nas irmãs Allison Pierce (nascido em 23 de julho de 1975) e Catherine Pierce (na...

Fubuki-class destroyer For other ships with the same name, see Japanese destroyer Shinonome. Shinonome in 1930. History Empire of Japan NameShinonome NamesakeDaybreak Ordered1923 Fiscal Year BuilderSasebo Naval Arsenal Yard numberDestroyer No.40 Laid down12 August 1926 Launched26 November 1927 Commissioned25 July 1928 Stricken15 January 1942 FateSunk on 17 December 1941, bombed by Dutch Aircraft General characteristics Class and typeFubuki-class destroyer Displacement 1,750 long tons (1,780&#...

 

Kota Padang PanjangKotaTranskripsi bahasa daerah • Jawi Minangڤادڠ ڤنجڠDari Atas, Kiri ke kanan: Museum Bustanil Arifin Pusat Dokumentasi dan Informasi Kebudayaan Minangkabau (PDIKM), Balai Kota Padang Panjang, Masjid Islamic Center Padang Panjang, Gerbang Perbatasan Padang Panjang - Tanah Datar, Kawasan Lembah Anai (jembatan kembar silaing), Pemandian Lubuk Mata Kucing, Mifan (Minang Fantasi) Waterpark LambangJulukan: Egypte van AndalasMotto: Kota Serambi M...

 

Japanese judoka and mixed martial arts fighter Hidehiko YoshidaHidehiko Yoshida in 2013.Born (1969-09-03) September 3, 1969 (age 54)Obu, Aichi, JapanOther namesKogane no Judo O (The Golden Judo King)NationalityJapaneseHeight5 ft 11 in (180 cm)Weight225 lb (102 kg; 16 st 1 lb)DivisionLight Heavyweight HeavyweightStyleMMAJudoTeamYoshida DojoRank     6th Dan black belt in JudoYears active2002–2010 (MMA)Mixed martial arts recordTotal18...

Gudrun Harrer (2021) Gudrun Harrer (* 24. Februar 1959 in Schwanenstadt, Oberösterreich)[1] ist eine österreichische Journalistin und Nahostexpertin. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Leben 2 Auszeichnungen 3 Publikationen 4 Weblinks 5 Einzelnachweise Leben Harrer studierte anfangs Musik in Detmold und Mailand, bevor sie von 1986 bis 1992 an der Universität Wien Arabistik und Islamwissenschaften studierte. 1993 trat sie als Außenpolitikredakteurin in die Tageszeitung Der Standard ein, 1998 wur...

 

Tsingtao Brewery Company LimitedPast packaging of Tsingtao Beer in a display at the Qingdao Beer Museum.Nama asli青岛啤酒股份公司JenisPublikKode emitenSSE: 600600Didirikan1903; 120 tahun lalu (1903)KantorpusatQingdao, Shandong, TiongkokTokohkunciChairman: Huang KexinPendapatan CN¥ 29.049 billion (2014)[1]Laba bersih CN¥ 1.990 billion (2014)[1]Situs webwww.tsingtaobeer.com Tsingtao Brewery Co. Ltd. (Hanzi sederhana: 青岛啤酒厂; Hanzi tradisiona...

 

1959 aviation accident 1959 Turkish Airlines Gatwick crashA Turkish Airlines Viscount 700 similar to the accident aircraftAccidentDate17 February 1959SummaryCFIT due to weather conditionsSiteJordan's Wood, Newdigate, Surrey, England 51°08′25″N 000°16′27″W / 51.14028°N 0.27417°W / 51.14028; -0.27417AircraftAircraft typeVickers Viscount 793OperatorTurkish AirlinesRegistrationTC-SEVFlight originEsenboğa International Airport Ankara, TurkeyStopoverAtatür...

This article deals with the system of transport in Bihar, both public and private. Jay Prakash Narayan Airport in Patna Road transport Bihar has national highways with total length of 5,358 km (3,329 mi)[1] and state highways with total length of 4,006 km (2,489 mi).[2] Also. Bihar has 921 km (572 mi) of proposed Expressways.[3] Expressways Main article: Expressways of India Listed horizontal (west to east) expressways first, followed by v...

 

For people surnamed Zhang, see Zhang Han (disambiguation). In this Chinese name, the family name is Han. This article does not cite any sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Han Zhang – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Fictional character Han Zhang (韓彰)Wuxia chara...

 

Naples played a prominent role in the rise of another industry of movement: the motion picture industry.— David Clarke[1]Sophia Loren, raised in Pozzuoli, is considered one of the most famous actresses in the history of cinema.Antonio de Curtis, alias Totò, the prince of laughter: Considered one of the greatest Neapolitan actor of all time.[2][3] The history of cinema in Naples begins at the end of the 19th century and over time it has recorded cinematographic...

Kürnberg Stadt Schopfheim Wappen von Kürnberg Koordinaten: 47° 40′ N, 7° 52′ O47.66493337.8700578507Koordinaten: 47° 39′ 54″ N, 7° 52′ 12″ O Höhe: 507 m ü. NN Fläche: 1,84 km² Eingemeindung: 1934 Postleitzahl: 79650 Vorwahl: 07622 Karte Lage von Kürnberg in der Stadt Schopfheim Kürnberg ist ein Ortsteil von Schopfheim im Südlichen Schwarzwald. Es befindet sich im Landkreis Lörrach im Dreiländereck...

 

Cosmic matter (remnant)GK Persei: Nova of 1901 – remnant A nova remnant is made up of the material either left behind by a sudden explosive fusion eruption by classical novae, or from multiple ejections by recurrent novae. Over their short lifetimes, nova shells show expansion velocities of around 1000 km/s,[1] whose faint nebulosities are usually illuminated by their progenitor stars via light echos as observed with the spherical shell[1] of Nova Persei 1901[2]...

 

Seigneurs du TempsDames du Temps Personnage de fiction apparaissant dansDoctor Who. Costume d'apparat du Seigneur Président Borusa dans l'épisode Arc of Infinity. Origine Gallifrey Activité Voyageurs temporels Séries Doctor Who Première apparition An Unearthly Child modifier  Les Seigneurs du Temps (Time Lords), au féminin Dames du Temps (Time Ladies), sont une espèce extraterrestre fictive de la série télévisée de science-fiction britannique Doctor Who, dont le personnage pri...

American computer scientist Richard Edwin StearnsRichard Stearns in 2009Born (1936-07-05) July 5, 1936 (age 87)Caldwell, New JerseyAlma materCarleton College (B.A.) Princeton University (Ph.D.)AwardsACM Turing Award (1993)Frederick W. Lanchester Prize (1995)Scientific careerInstitutionsUniversity at AlbanyDoctoral advisorHarold W. KuhnDoctoral studentsMadhav V. Marathe (joint with Professor Harry B. Hunt III), Tom O'Connell Richard Edwin Stearns (born July 5, 1936) is an American co...

 

Nationalist concept to unite traditionally Albanian territories Greater Albania is the proposal of 4 Albanian vilayets of the League of Prizren as agreed after the Albanian revolt of 1912 Greater Albania (Albanian: Shqipëria e Madhe) is an irredentist[1] and nationalist concept that seeks to unify the lands that many Albanians consider to form their national homeland.[2] It is based on claims on the present-day or historical presence of Albanian populations in those areas. In...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!