Harding Street raid

Harding Street Murders
Location	Pecan Park, Houston, Harris County, Texas, U.S.
Date	January 28, 2019 (2019-01-28)
Attack type	Mass shooting, shootout, police brutality
Deaths	2
Injured	5 (4 by gunfire)

On January 28, 2019, in the Pecan Park area in the East End district of Houston,^[1] Houston Police Department (HPD) officers initiated a no-knock raid on a house, killing the two homeowners, a husband and wife: Dennis Wayne Tuttle and Rhogena Ann Nicholas.^[2] They were aged 59 and 58, respectively.^[3] Five HPD officers sustained injuries.^[1]

St. John Barned-Smith and Keri Blakinger of the Houston Chronicle described the event as "one of the worst [scandals] to hit HPD in years".^[1]

Background

Dennis Wayne Tuttle (March 26, 1959 – January 28, 2019) was raised in the Denver Harbor neighborhood of Houston and had once served in the U.S. Navy. Tuttle's brother Cliff stated that Tuttle liked the water and chose the Navy for that reason.^[4] However, he sustained injuries from an accident during his service which caused him to develop seizures,^[5] and he was honorably discharged as a result.^[3] He fathered two children with his wife, and suffered from a car crash and additional accidents.^[4] He was not working at the time of his death due to his health issues.^[5] Tuttle's sister, Elizabeth, stated that the man "had debilitating injuries for many years and it's a sad situation."^[3] He married Nicholas circa 1999,^[3] after having a ceremony at a courthouse. The two had ended their previous relationships prior to becoming romantically involved.^[4] Tuttle owned the house on Harding Street.^[6]

Rhogena Ann Nicholas (March 1, 1960 – January 28, 2019) was born in Ackerman, Mississippi to a dentist and a housewife. She was of partial Lebanese descent through her father. From approximately 1962 onward, she grew up in Macon, Mississippi, attending Central Academy in Macon and Bauder College in Atlanta, before moving to her parents' new residence in Florida. She moved to Houston in the 1980s with her then-boyfriend. At the time of her death, she was taking care of Tuttle and also made some income helping care for her ex-partner who lived nearby.^[5] At the time, some members of her family also lived in the Houston area.^[3]

Gerald Goines, the officer responsible for writing the search warrant, began working for HPD circa 1985. He had worked in narcotics for many years and had been shot twice before. The first incident occurred in 1992 after a controlled drug buy. The second occurred on a freeway where Goines and another motorist allegedly were competing for space. The other driver reportedly drew a gun and shot Goines in the arm but was killed when Goines returned fire.^[7]

Incident

The raid was precipitated by calls from Patricia Ann Garcia, a next door neighbor of the couple who had had multiple bitter disagreements with them. She made a "swatting" call to police on January 8, 2019, reporting that her 25 year-old daughter was doing heroin at the couple's house. She also reported seeing that they had machine guns in the home. In reality, there were no machine guns or heroin found and Garcia did not even have a daughter.^[8]

Based on this false information, Goines, an officer with the Houston Police Department, obtained a no-knock search warrant for the residence. To bolster the case, he lied, saying a confidential informant had obtained black tar heroin in a hand-to-hand buy at their house. However, the named informant denied having made such a buy as did all other informants Goines had worked with.^[9][10][11]

Three weeks after Garcia's initial calls, police officers raided the Tuttle/Nicholas home on January 28, 2019.^[1] After the officers entered the home, they shot a dog owned by the couple. According to the HPD report, Tuttle was armed with a revolver and engaged the officers before being killed by return fire. Nicholas was unarmed but was shot by a backup officer when she allegedly reached for a wounded officer's shotgun.^[6] There is no video footage of the raid.^[12] Four of the police suffered gunshot wounds, though there was some doubt early on that they were all from Tuttle's alleged revolver.^[9]

Casualties

The autopsies of Tuttle and Nicholas were conducted by the Harris County Institute of Forensic Sciences in Houston on January 29 and 30.^[2]

Tuttle sustained up to nine bullet wounds to his head and neck, chest, left shoulder, left forearm and hand, left thigh and buttock, and right wrist. Other injuries included "minor blunt force" trauma to his left ear, extremity wounds, bullet grazing on the right forearm, neck lacerations possibly caused by a necklace, and upper left-side abdomen abrasions. Possible gunpowder residue was noted next to his left index finger. Toxicology testing found THC in his system.^[2]

Nicholas sustained two bullet wounds, with other injuries tentatively attributed to bullet fragments. She had been hit in the thigh and chest, and fragments may have hit her right leg and thigh. Toxicology reports later found benzoylecgonine, a byproduct associated with metabolism of cocaine, but no traces of cocaine in her system.^[2][9]

The injured police officers were treated at Memorial Hermann–Texas Medical Center.^[6] Four of them had received gunshot injuries and another had a knee injury.^[13] One of the officers was permanently paralyzed as a result of his injuries.^[14] Goines, one of the officers shot, later stated through his lawyer that he was retiring.^[15]

Investigations

Police reportedly found 18g of marijuana and 1.5g of cocaine in the house, which were user amounts but not distributor levels; the small amount and type of drugs were consistent with the toxicology findings.^[16] KHOU-TV received the reports on May 2.^[2] On May 15, 2019, HPD chief Art Acevedo announced that the investigation had concluded, with the information given to prosecutors.^[17]

The Tuttle and Nicholas families hired a forensic team headed by Mick Maloney formerly of Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS). The team processed the crime scene on May 10, 2019, three months after the raid. They were surprised and troubled to find significant evidence left behind or uncollected by the earlier Houston Forensic Science Center police investigation. They mapped out the trajectories from the bullet holes in the walls with the goal to reconstruct the shooting by matching bloodstains and bullet trajectories in the house to the wounds of the victims. The team spent four days reviewing the evidence. Attorney Chuck Bourque told the Houston Chronicle they found no evidence anyone in the house fired toward the door nor that Tuttle's two rifles and two shotguns had even been fired. This did not account for the .357 revolver and shell casings reportedly collected by police, though, a revolver was not listed in the inventory of confiscated items after the raid.^[17][12] The team did find evidence that suggests police outside the house fired blindly through the walls.^[16] Evidence also suggested that some of the officers' injuries were from friendly fire.^[18]

Legal action

On July 24, 2019, the federal grand jury investigating the raid heard testimony from Houston police officers.^[19] On August 23, 2019, Harris County District Attorney Kim Ogg announced that officer Gerald Goines had been charged with two counts of felony murder. Officer Steven Bryant had also been charged with evidence tampering for "knowingly providing false information" in a police report.^[20] In November 2019, the FBI arrested Goines and others as part of the organization's investigation.^[21]

On November 20, 2019, a federal grand jury returned indictments on federal charges in the Pecan Park raid case. Goines was charged with making false statements and depriving the victims of their constitutional right to be secure against unreasonable searches. Steven M. Bryant, another ex-HPD officer, was charged with making false statements and obstructing an official proceeding with further false statements. Patricia Ann Garcia was charged with making several fake 911 calls including the false claims that her daughter was in the Tuttle residence doing drugs and that the Tuttles were drug addicts who possessed machine guns. Authorities took the three into custody.^[22] Goines was charged with seven counts total; he surrendered to the FBI at his residence.^[23]

In January 2020, a Harris County grand jury indicted Goines and Steven Bryant under Texas law, charging both with tampering with government documents and Goines with felony murder.^[24] Bryant later pled guilty to his charges.^[8]

The relatives of the deceased filed the first document in a lawsuit against the municipal government in July 2019.^[25]

In July 2020, an additional 17 criminal counts were filed against six of the officers.^[26] As of June 2021, a total of 11 current or former HPD officers had been indicted.^[8][14]

In March 2021, Patricia Ann Garcia pleaded guilty to making the false call leading to the raid and, in June, was sentenced by Judge George C. Hanks Jr. to 40 months of federal prison.^[27]

Goines was convicted of murder in September 2024.^[28] During his sentencing on October 3, 2024, he suffered a medical emergency and was removed from the courtroom.^[29] Goines later recovered and was sentenced to 60 years' imprisonment.^[30]

Reaction

Radley Balko of The Washington Post wrote a criticism of no-knock raids based on this incident.^[31] The Houston Chronicle editorial board criticized HPD, stating that it lost the trust of Houstonians.^[32]

In light of the shooting, Texas House of Representatives member Gene Wu and Texas Senate member Borris Miles proposed a bill that would make no-knock warrants unlawful in Texas.^[33]

The group "We the People Organize", organized after the incident, created a mural in honor of the victims, which was unveiled in 2022.^[34]

As a result of the raid, HPD began requiring approval from the department head or a designee of that head before any no-knock raid.^[35]

Families of Tuttle and Nicholas sue

The families of those killed in the Harding Street raid filed lawsuits against the city in January 2021. They allege that the officers involved had violated the civil rights of Tuttle and Nicholas. ^[36]

On January 16, 2024, while announcing his resignation from the Aurora Colorado police department, Art Acevedo said he'd recently been served with a subpoena to testify in a federal lawsuit the victims' families filed against the City of Houston.^[37]

A week later the Houston City Council approved $1.7 million to defend itself and former Police Chief Art Acevedo against the lawsuit. This was in addition to $1.25 million paid to law firm Beck Redden, to file a motion for summary judgment to dismiss the lawsuit.^[38]

Reexamination of Goines cases

Due to the false statements made by Goines and Bryant concerning the raid, Houston police began a systematic review of some combined 14,000 cases which had been handled by the officers in Goines' squad.^[39] By the end of 2021, more than 160 of those cases had been dismissed.

George Floyd, who grew up and spent most of his life in Houston, had been convicted of a drug charge in 2004 in a case Goines had participated and his case had been examined. Based on a parole board's findings, Floyd was one of two dozen people scheduled to be pardoned in December 2021 by Governor Greg Abbott before the parole board abruptly withdrew their recommendation due to "unexplained departures" in its process.^[40]

In July 2022, Houston resident Frederick Jeffery was released on bond after findings that Goines had falsified evidence and perjured himself.^[41] His conviction was overturned by the appeals court in November 2022.^[42]

See also

• Lists of killings by law enforcement officers in the United States

References

1. Barned-Smith, St. John; Blakinger, Keri (March 4, 2019). "DA reviewing 800 cases of second officer involved in deadly Pecan Park drug raid". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on March 5, 2019. Retrieved March 16, 2019.
2. Kennedy, Megan; Diaz, Mario; Wische, Aaron; Beausoleil, Sophia (May 2, 2019). "Autopsy reports for victims in botched Harding Street raid revealed". KHOU-TV. Archived from the original on July 4, 2022. Retrieved May 4, 2019.
3. Carter, Marla (January 31, 2019). "What we know about husband and wife killed in Houston officer-involved shooting". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on January 30, 2019. Retrieved March 16, 2019.
4. Blakinger, Keri; Barned-Smith, St. John (April 16, 2019). "Grieving family members tour Pecan Park home as questions swirl about botched drug raid". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on July 4, 2022. Retrieved April 17, 2019.
5. Blakinger, Keri; Barned-Smith, St. John (March 21, 2019). "'I want them to clear her name': Mother of woman killed in botched Pecan Park drug raid speaks out". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on March 21, 2019. Retrieved March 22, 2019.
6. Letterer, Samantha (January 29, 2019). "HPD chief Acevedo IDs suspects, gives update on injured officers". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on January 29, 2019. Retrieved April 18, 2019.
7. Willey, Jessica (February 16, 2019). "HPD officer at center of controversial raid shot twice before". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on February 16, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
8. Langford, Cameron (June 8, 2021). "Texas Woman Sentenced for 'Swatting' Calls That Led to Deadly Police Raid". Courthouse News Service. Archived from the original on June 8, 2021.
9. Sullum, Jacob (May 6, 2019). "Houston Police Shot Man Killed in Fraudulent Drug Raid at Least Eight Times". Reason. Archived from the original on May 6, 2019. Retrieved July 30, 2019.
10. Hutchinson, Bill (February 17, 2019). "Houston police embroiled in scandal after 'lies' found in no-knock warrant that led to fatal raid on alleged drug house". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on February 17, 2019. Retrieved March 16, 2019.
11. Blakinger, Keri; Barned-Smith, St. John (February 15, 2019). "Houston police officer in drug raid had previous allegations against him". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on February 16, 2019. Retrieved March 16, 2019. The Chronicle typically does not publish the names of undercover officers, but Goines was publicly identified Friday after the release of recent court documents.
12. Weingarten, Dean (February 12, 2019). "No-Knock Houston Raid Inventory Raises Questions after 2 Killed, 4 Wounded". AmmoLand.com. Archived from the original on February 13, 2019. Retrieved July 2, 2019.
13. Barned-Smith, St. John; Hensley, Nicole (January 28, 2019). "4 HPD officers shot in southeast Houston narcotics operation, a fifth injured". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on January 29, 2019. Retrieved April 18, 2019.
14. Barker, Aaron (January 28, 2021). "These are the 12 officers charged in Harding Street investigation". KPRC-TV. Archived from the original on January 28, 2021. Retrieved July 31, 2022.
15. KTRK. "HPD narcotics raid officer retiring in midst of review". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on March 22, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
16. Blakinger, Keri; Barned-Smith, St. John (May 13, 2019). "Evidence left behind after botched Pecan Park drug raid raises new questions about shootings". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on May 14, 2019.
17. Blakinger, Keri; Barned-Smith, St. John (May 15, 2019). "Houston police investigation into botched drug raid completed, turned over to prosecutors". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on May 15, 2019. Retrieved May 16, 2019.
18. Abrahams, Tom (April 12, 2021). "FAMILY OF RHOGENA NICHOLAS ALLEGES HPD USING OVERTIME FRAUD ALLEGATIONS AS RAID COVER-UP". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on June 9, 2021.
19. Barned-Smith, St. John (July 24, 2019). "Federal grand jury hears testimony from Houston police officers about botched Pecan Park raid". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on July 25, 2019.
20. Sullum, Jacob (August 23, 2019). "Houston Narcotics Cop Who Instigated a Deadly Drug Raid Is Charged With Murder". Reason. Archived from the original on August 23, 2019.
21. Blakinger, Keri; Barned-Smith, St. John; Banks, Gabrielle (November 20, 2019). "FBI arrests 2 ex-cops, 911 caller in deadly HPD drug raid". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on November 20, 2019. Retrieved March 15, 2021.
22. Department of Justice Office of Public Affairs (November 20, 2019). "Two Former Houston Police Department Officers Indicted in Connection to Fatal Raid". US Department of Justice. Archived from the original on November 21, 2019.
23. Barned-Smith, St. John; Blakinger, Keri; Banks, Gabrielle (November 20, 2019). "FBI arrest 2 police officers, 911 caller linked to deadly Harding Street drug raid". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on November 20, 2019. Retrieved November 21, 2019.
24. KHOU staff (January 15, 2020). "Grand jury indicts former HPD officers for alleged involvement in Harding Street raid". KHOU. Archived from the original on January 16, 2020. Retrieved January 16, 2020.
25. Martin, Brittney; Rosenberg, Eli (July 26, 2019). "Two people were killed in a botched drug raid. Investigators say the official story was a lie". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on July 26, 2019. Retrieved July 29, 2019.
26. Fieldstadt, Elisha; Associated Press (July 31, 2020). "Six former Houston police officers indicted in botched drug raid that left two dead". NBC News. Archived from the original on July 31, 2020. Retrieved August 1, 2020.
27. Staff Writer (June 8, 2021). "Woman sentenced for making false 911 report that led to deadly HPD raid". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on June 8, 2021. Retrieved June 8, 2021.
28. "Former Houston officer found guilty of murder in deaths of couple during drug raid". NBC News. The Associated Press. September 25, 2024. Retrieved September 27, 2024.
29. "Ex-Houston officer rushed away in an ambulance during sentencing at double-murder trial". The Independent. October 3, 2024.
30. Lozano, Juan (October 9, 2024). "Retired Houston officer gets 60 years for deaths of couple during drug raid". The Independent.
31. Balko, Radley (February 11, 2019). "A fatal Houston drug raid is a familiar story of needless violence, death and destruction". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on September 16, 2020. Retrieved March 16, 2019.
32. "Cops lied, people died. Here's how HPD can restore Houston's trust [Editorial]". Houston Chronicle. February 16, 2019. Archived from the original on February 17, 2019. Retrieved March 16, 2019.
33. Schneider, Andrew (November 23, 2020). "Houston Lawmakers Propose Statewide Ban On No-Knock Warrants". Houston Public Media. Archived from the original on November 23, 2020. Retrieved November 23, 2020.
34. Vasquez, Lucio (January 28, 2022). "Harding Street mural unveiled as local advocates continue to push for answers". Houston Public Media. Archived from the original on January 28, 2022. Retrieved February 23, 2022.
35. Shay, Miya (February 20, 2019). "HPD announces new oversight and revisions after deadly raid". KTRK-TV. Archived from the original on February 21, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
36. Martin, Florian; Vasquez, Lucio (January 28, 2021). "Family Of Harding Street Raid Victims File Lawsuits Against The City". Retrieved January 31, 2021.
37. Zuvanich, Adam (January 17, 2024). "Ex-Houston police chief Art Acevedo leaving Colorado post, will testify in Harding Street raid lawsuit". Houston Public Media. Houston, Texas. Retrieved January 31, 2021.
38. Brown, Ashley. "Houston City Council approves $1.7 million to fight case in Harding Street drug raid lawsuit". Houston Public Media. Retrieved January 31, 2024.
39. Martin, Florian (May 13, 2021). "2 People Arrested By Former Houston Police Officer Gerald Goines Have Been Exonerated. Will There Be More?". Houston Public Media. Archived from the original on October 6, 2021.
40. Weber, Paul J. (December 23, 2021). "Texas board withdraws pardon recommendation for George Floyd". PBS. Associated Press. Archived from the original on December 23, 2021.
41. Lozano, Juan A (July 21, 2022). "Prosecutors seek 5th conviction tied to ex-cop be overturned". Associated Press. Archived from the original on September 21, 2022. Retrieved September 21, 2022.
42. "Judge embraces man who served 6 years for wrongful drug charge that was formally dismissed". ABC 13 News. November 18, 2022. Retrieved February 15, 2024.

Further reading

• Dennis Wayne Tuttle Autopsy Archived
• Rhogena Ann Nicholas Autopsy Archived
• John, Nicholas (June 3, 2020). "Opinion: What about Harding Street raid? Acevedo, Turner give soundbites on police brutality but stay silent about my sister's death". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on June 3, 2020.
• Scherer, Jasper (April 28, 2021). "Houston council OKs $1.25M contract with law firm to defend Harding Street raid lawsuit". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on April 28, 2021.

External links

• "Investigation into Shooting of Four Houston Police Officers at 7815 Harding Street". Houston Police Department. January 29, 2019. Archived from the original on February 17, 2019.
• Thread at Twitter by the official Houston Police Department account
• 4 Houston police officers shot while serving warrant Archived
• 4 HPD officers shot in southeast Houston narcotics operation, a fifth injured Archived
• 5 Houston Officers Hurt in Shootout at Suspected Drug House Archived
• Four Houston police officers shot while serving warrant Archived