For the next two decades, the station was served by all Amtrak service on the line. The Pere Marquette began on August 5, 1984; the Cardinal was rerouted to the southwest on April 27, 1986.[1]: 53, 209 The Indiana Connection was discontinued on January 10, 1986, followed by the Calumet on May 6, 1991.[1]: 216–217 The Broadway Limited was replaced by the Three Rivers on September 10, 1995.[1]: 27 The Pennsylvanian was extended to Chicago with a stop at Hammond–Whiting on November 7, 1998.[1]: 76
Service reductions
The station was built cheaply, using a
standard Amtrak design.[4] The single side platform serves only one of the line's three tracks; this caused operational difficulties with routing numerous daily Amtrak trains onto that single track. Amtrak began reducing service to the station in the early 2000s because of low ridership and Norfolk Southern's requests due to the operational issues.[5][4] On October 29, 2000, the Wolverine stop at Hammond–Whiting was discontinued.[1]: 203 The Pere Marquette and International ceased stopping on April 29, 2001, followed by the Capitol Limited on July 9.[1]: 54, 210
The Pennsylvanian was cut back to Pittsburgh on February 10, 2003.[1]: 78 The Lake Shore Limited stop was discontinued on April 28, 2003, as the train averaged just five passengers per train at Hammond–Whiting, but the Capitol Limited stop was re-added.[5] The Three Rivers was cut on March 7, 2005.[1]: 33 The station lost its ticket agent on April 25, 2005, when the Capitol Limited again ceased to stop.[1]: 257 This left only two daily Wolverine round trips (the former Lake Cities and Twilight Limited, renamed on April 26, 2004) as the only service at Hammond–Whiting.[1]: 201, 257 In 2011, Amtrak considered stopping the Lake Shore Limited at the station; however, it was rejected due to operational difficulties and low projected ridership.[5]