Dennis v. Sparks

Dennis v. Sparks
Argued October 8, 1980
Decided November 17, 1980
Full case nameDennis v. Sparks ET AL., DBA Sidney A. Sparks, Trustee
Citations449 U.S. 24 (more)
101 S. Ct. 183; 66 L. Ed. 2d 185; 1980 U.S. LEXIS 9
Case history
PriorSparks v. Duval County Ranch Co., 604 F.2d 976 (5th Cir. 1979); cert. granted, 445 U.S. 942 (1980).
Holding
The action against the private parties accused of conspiring with the judge is not subject to dismissal. Private persons, jointly engaged with state officials in a challenged action, are acting "under color" of law for purposes of 1983 actions. And the judge's immunity from damages liability for an official act that was allegedly the product of a corrupt conspiracy involving bribery of the judge does not change the character of his action or that of his co-conspirators. Historically at common law, judicial immunity does not insulate from damages liability those private persons who corruptly conspire with a judge. Nor has the doctrine of judicial immunity been considered historically as excusing a judge from responding as a witness when his co-conspirators are sued, even though a charge of conspiracy and judicial corruption will be aired and decided. Gravel v. United States[1] distinguished. The potential harm to the public from denying immunity to co-conspirators if the factfinder mistakenly upholds a charge of a corrupt conspiracy is outweighed by the benefits of providing a remedy [449 U.S. 24, 25] against those private persons who participate in subverting the judicial process and in so doing inflict injury on other persons. pp. 27–32.
Court membership
Chief Justice
Warren E. Burger
Associate Justices
William J. Brennan Jr. · Potter Stewart
Byron White · Thurgood Marshall
Harry Blackmun · Lewis F. Powell Jr.
William Rehnquist · John P. Stevens
Case opinion
MajorityWhite, joined by unanimous

Dennis v. Sparks, 449 U.S. 24 (1980), was a case in which the Supreme Court of the United States held that individuals who bribed a judge for an injunction were not protected by judicial immunity and therefore could be held liable for the damages resulting from the injunction.[2]

The case

In January 1973, a judge of the 229th District Court of Duval County, Tex., enjoined the production of minerals from certain oil leases owned by respondents. In June 1975, the injunction was dissolved by an appellate court as having been illegally issued. Respondents then filed a complaint in the United States District Court purporting to state a cause of action for damages under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.[3] Defendants were the Duval County Ranch Co., Inc., which had obtained the injunction, the sole owner of the corporation, the judge who entered the injunction, and the two individual sureties on the injunction bond, one of whom is now petitioner in this Court. Essentially, the claim was that the injunction had been corruptly issued as the result of a conspiracy between the judge and the other defendants, thus causing a deprivation of property, i.e., two years of oil production, without due process of law.

All defendants moved to dismiss, the judge asserting judicial immunity and the other defendants urging dismissal for failure to allege action "under color" of state law, a necessary component of a § 1983 cause of action. The District Court concluded that, because the injunction was a judicial act within the jurisdiction of the state court, the judge was immune from liability in a § 1983 suit, whether or not the injunction had issued as the result of a corrupt conspiracy. Relying on Haldane v. Chagnon,[4] the District Court also ruled that, with the dismissal of the judge, the remaining defendants could not be said to have conspired under color of state law within the meaning of § 1983. The action against them was accordingly dismissed "for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted."

In a per curiam opinion, a panel of the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed, agreeing that the judge was immune from suit and that, because "the remaining defendants, who are all private citizens, did not conspire with any person against whom a valid § 1983 suit can be stated,"[5] existing authorities in the Circuit required dismissal of the claims against these defendants as well. The case was reconsidered en banc, prior Circuit authority was overruled and the District Court judgment was reversed insofar as it had dismissed claims against the defendants other than the judge.[5] The court ruled that there was no good reason in law, logic, or policy for conferring immunity on private persons who persuaded the immune judge to exercise his jurisdiction corruptly. Because the judgment below was inconsistent with the rulings of other Courts of Appeals and involves an important issue, the Supreme Court granted the petition for certiorari.

Trivia

Dennis v. Sparks was the first opinion of the Court since the early 19th century where members of the Court were not referred to as "Mr. Justice." In February 1979, Justice John Paul Stevens participated in a moot court at the University of Notre Dame. Joining him on the bench were two lower court judges, including Judge Cornelia G. Kennedy, then chief judge of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. As was custom, the arguing counsel addressed him as “Mr. Justice” Stevens. When participants addressed Judge Kennedy as “Madame Justice,” she replied, “Why do you address me as ‘Madame Justice?’ The word ‘Justice’ is not a sexist term.” Justice Stevens later discussed this with his all-male colleagues. Justice Potter Stewart observed that women would inevitably join them on the Court someday, and thus suggested that they drop “Mr.” from the title. On November 14, 1980, the Justices agreed by a vote of 8-1. The lone dissenter was Justice Harry A. Blackmun, who felt they should wait until a woman joined the Court so she could participate in the decision.[6] The following year, Sandra Day O'Connor became the first woman nominated and the first confirmed to the Court.

See also

References

  1. ^ Gravel v. United States, 408 U.S. 606 (1972).
  2. ^ Dennis v. Sparks, 449 U.S. 24 (1980). Public domain This article incorporates public domain material from this U.S government document.
  3. ^ 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
  4. ^ Haldane v. Chagnon, 345 F.2d 601 (9th Cir. 1965).
  5. ^ a b Sparks v. Duval County Ranch Co., 604 F.2d 976 (5th Cir. 1979).
  6. ^ "Home - Supreme Court of the United States". November 15, 2022. Archived from the original on November 15, 2022. Retrieved November 18, 2022.

Read other articles:

Inre LapptjärnenInsjöLand SverigeLänNorrbottens länKommunPiteå kommunLandskapNorrbottenSockenPiteå sockenKoordinater   WGS 8465°24′11″N 20°25′19″Ö / 65.40319°N 20.42189°Ö / 65.40319; 20.42189 (Inre Lapptjärnen)  SWEREF 99 TM7264224, 751572 Inre Lapptjärnen Topografiska kartan över Inre Lapptjärnen. FlödenHuvudavrinnings­områdeÅbyälvens huvudavrinningsområde (17000)ÖvrigtSjöID726352-1714...

 

Cet article concerne l'entité administrative. Pour la région historique et culturelle, voir Occitanie (région culturelle). Pour les autres significations, voir Occitanie. Pour les articles homonymes, voir LRMP. Occitanie Logo du conseil régional d'Occitanie Blason Administration Pays France Siège du conseil régional Toulouse (siège principal)Montpellier (siège des assemblées plénières) Préfecture Toulouse Départements et collectivités territoriales Ariège (09)Aude (11)Aveyr...

 

County in New York, United States Not to be confused with Ontario, New York. 42°51′N 77°17′W / 42.85°N 77.29°W / 42.85; -77.29 County in New YorkOntario CountyCountyOntario County Courthouse in Canandaigua, 2014 FlagSealLocation within the U.S. state of New YorkNew York's location within the U.S.Coordinates: 42°51′N 77°17′W / 42.85°N 77.29°W / 42.85; -77.29Country United StatesState New YorkFounded1789Named forLake Onta...

село Слобідка-Кульчієвецька Центр села Слобідка-КульчієвецькаЦентр села Слобідка-Кульчієвецька Країна  Україна Область Хмельницька область Район Кам'янець-Подільський район Громада Слобідсько-Кульчієвецька сільська громада Основні дані Засноване 1789[1] Населе...

 

Para otros usos de este término, véase San Pedro (desambiguación). San Pedro del Valle municipio de EspañaBanderaEscudo Panorámica del pueblo San Pedro del ValleUbicación de San Pedro del Valle en España. San Pedro del ValleUbicación de San Pedro del Valle en la provincia de Salamanca.País  España• Com. autónoma  Castilla y León• Provincia  Salamanca• Comarca Tierra de Ledesma• Partido judicial Salamanca•&#...

 

Bonifasius Belawan Geh, S.H.Bupati Mahakam Ulu ke-1PetahanaMulai menjabat 26 Februari 2021WakilDrs. Yohanes Avun, M.Si.PendahuluDr. Stephanus Madang, M.M.Masa jabatan17 Februari 2016 – 17 Februari 2021WakilDrs. Yohanes Juan JenauPendahuluIr. Frederick Bid, M.Si.PenggantiDr. Stephanus Madang, M.M. Informasi pribadiLahir17 September 1966 (umur 57)Mamahak Besar, Long Bagun, Mahakam ulu, Kalimantan TimurKebangsaanIndonesiaPartai politik  GerindraSuami/istriYovita...

O samba de gafieira é um estilo de dança de salão brasileira, derivado do maxixe dançado no início do século XX no contexto do Império do Brasil (1822–1889).[1] Dança Passos de Samba de Gafieira (masculino) Um dos principais aspectos observados no estilo samba de gafieira é a atitude do dançarino de frente a sua parceira: malandragem, proteção, exposição a situações surpresa, elegância e ritmo. Na hora da dança, o homem conduz a sua dama, e nunca o contrário. Diz-se que, ...

 

Pesta Olahraga Difabel Asia Tenggara 2011Tuan rumahSoloJumlah negara peserta11 Negara/Kontingen ASEANJumlah atlet2000Jumlah pertandingan420 dalam 11 Cabang OlahragaUpacara pembukaan15 Desember 2011Upacara penutupan20 Desember 2011Dibuka olehBoedionoWakil Presiden IndonesiaDitutup olehAgung LaksonoMenteri Koordinator Bidang Kesejahteraan Rakyat IndonesiaPembawa oborDaniel Carlos, Sabar Gorky, dan Memet LesmanaTempat upacaraStadion Manahan, Solo Pesta Olahraga Difabel Asia Tenggara 2011 (bahasa...

 

Italian association football club This article is about the men's football club from Milan, Italy. For the women's team, see AC Milan Women. For other sports teams called Milan, see Milan (disambiguation) § Sports. Football clubAC MilanFull nameAssociazione Calcio Milan S.p.A.[1]Nickname(s)I Rossoneri (The Red and Blacks)Il Diavolo (The Devil)Founded13 December 1899; 123 years ago (1899-12-13),[2] as Milan Foot-Ball and Cricket ClubGroundSan SiroCapacit...

Dockyard Museum at Nelson's Dockyard on Antigua island. The Dockyard Museum is a museum located at Nelson's Dockyard in English Harbour on Antigua island, in Antigua and Barbuda. It was established in 1855 at the colonial British shipyard.[1] See also Antigua island topics List of museums in Antigua and Barbuda References ^ The Dockyard Museum ( Archived 4 November 2011 at the Wayback Machine) 17°00′29″N 61°45′55″W / 17.007987°N 61.765290°W / 17.007...

 

Frankish aristocratic family that ruled from around the middle of the 5th century to 751 Merovingian redirects here. For other uses, see Merovingian (disambiguation). Merovingian Kingdomsc. 481–751576FIRST TURKIC KHAGANATESASANIANEMPIREALCHONSCHALU-KYASNORTH.ZHOUNORTH.QICHENBYZANTINEEMPIREAVAR KHAGANATEKhitansPaleo-SiberiansTungusGOGU-RYEOMERO-VINGIANSVISIGOTHSTARUMA ◇ ▷ The Merovingian kingdoms and main contemporary polities c. 576 History • Established c. 481• ...

 

2009 role-playing game 2009 video gameShin Megami Tensei: Strange JourneyNorth American Nintendo DS box artDeveloper(s)AtlusLancarsePublisher(s)JP: AtlusNA: Atlus USAEU: Deep Silver (Redux)Director(s)Eiji IshidaProducer(s)Kazuma KanekoYasuda Suda (Redux)Ichigo Yamada (Redux)Programmer(s)Atsushi MotouchiArtist(s)Kazuma KanekoAkira Odagaki (Redux)Masayuki Doi (Redux)Writer(s)Shogo IsogaiKazuyuki YamaiTatsuya WatanabeComposer(s)Shoji MeguroToshiki Konishi (Redux)SeriesMegami TenseiPlatform(s)Nin...

Ketua Mahkamah Agung Republik IndonesiaLambangPetahanaMuhammad Syarifuddinsejak 30 April 2020GelarYang MuliaMasa jabatan5 tahunDibentuk19 Agustus 1945; 78 tahun lalu (1945-08-19)Pejabat pertamaKusumah Atmadja Ketua Mahkamah Agung Republik Indonesia adalah pejabat negara yang melaksanakan tugas Kekuasaan Kehakiman sebagai salah satu Pimpinan Mahkamah Agung.[1] Ketua Mahkamah Agung dipilih dari dan oleh hakim agung dan ditetapkan oleh Presiden.[2] Masa jabatan Ketua Ma...

 

DNA-databank voor strafzaken kan verwijzen naar: DNA-databank voor strafzaken (Nederland) National Criminal Investigation DNA Database - Australië National DNA Data Bank of Canada Israel Police DNA Index System FNAEG - Frankrijk Bekijk alle artikelen waarvan de titel begint met DNA-databank voor strafzaken of met DNA-databank voor strafzaken in de titel. Dit is een doorverwijspagina, bedoeld om de verschillen in betekenis of gebruik van DNA-databank voor strafzaken i...

 

Ballestrem family Coat of Arms Palace Ballestrem in Pławniowice The Ballestrem family is the name of an influential German noble family, originally from Piedmont, Italy. Members of the family held significant political positions within the German Empire. They are still extant, despite losing much of their land in 1945. History Originally named Ballestrero di Castellengo, they are first attested to as patrician merchants in the sixteenth century. At the end of the seventeenth century, Marco F...

Canadian actor and singer Walter HustonHuston in The Furies (1950)BornWalter Thomas Huston(1883-04-05)April 5, 1883Toronto, Ontario, CanadaDiedApril 7, 1950(1950-04-07) (aged 67)Beverly Hills, California, U.S.OccupationsActorsingerYears active1902–1950Spouses Rhea Gore ​ ​(m. 1904; div. 1912)​ Bayonne Whipple ​ ​(m. 1914; div. 1931)​ Ninetta (Nan) Sunderland ​ ​(m.&#...

 

1978 film by Édouard Molinaro La Cage aux FollesFrench theatrical release posterDirected byÉdouard MolinaroScreenplay by Marcello Danon Édouard Molinaro Jean Poiret Francis Veber Based onLa Cage aux Folles1973 playby Jean PoiretProduced byMarcello DanonStarring Ugo Tognazzi Michel Serrault Claire Maurier Rémi Laurent Carmen Scarpitta Michel Galabru CinematographyArmando NannuzziEdited by Monique Isnardon Robert Isnardon Music byEnnio Morricone[1]Productioncompanies Les Productions...

 

The 1070 Council of Winchester was a church council convened in April of that year by William the Conqueror and three papal legates: Ermenfrid, Bishop of Sion, Cardinal John Minutus, and Peter. It deposed Stigand, Archbishop of Canterbury, and several other native English bishops and abbots and left their offices free to be filled by William's largely Norman appointees, thereby transforming the highest levels of the English Church. It also promulgated a large number of measures relating to ec...

Japanese manga series by Akira Amano Ron Kamonohashi: Deranged DetectiveFirst tankōbon volume cover, featuring Ron Kamonohashi鴨乃橋ロンの禁断推理(Kamonohashi Ron no Kindan Suiri)GenreCrime[1]Mystery[2] MangaWritten byAkira AmanoPublished byShueishaImprintJump Comics+MagazineShōnen Jump+DemographicShōnenOriginal runOctober 11, 2020 – presentVolumes12 Anime television seriesRon Kamonohashi's Forbidden DeductionsDirected byShōta IhataWritten b...

 

República de Ezo蝦夷共和国Ezo Kyōwakoku Estado desaparecido 1868-1869BanderaEscudo Ubicación de República de EzoCoordenadas 41°47′49″N 140°45′25″E / 41.796944444444, 140.75694444444Capital HakodateEntidad Estado desaparecidoIdioma oficial Japonés y AinuSuperficie   • Total 83 456,38 km² Período histórico Restauración Meiji • 15 de diciembrede 1868 Independencia de Imperio del Japón • 17 de mayode 1869 Rendi...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!