This page details arguments that are commonly seen in deletion discussions that have been identified as generally unsound and unconvincing. These are arguments...

Bharatanatyam · C. Rajagopalachari · Coolie · Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam · Idli · Kaveri River · List of Chief Ministers of Tamil Nadu · M. G. Ramachandran ·...

b • bl; (16) to Idli (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: hebbarskitchen.com/idli-recipe-idly-with-idli-rava-recipe/ (R/Xmeta/L-...

b • bl; (16) to Idli (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: hebbarskitchen.com/idli-recipe-idly-with-idli-rava-recipe/ (R/Xmeta/L-...

b • bl; (5) to Idli podi (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: digiclown.com/perfect-recipe-to-make-idli-at-home/ (R/Xmeta/L-...

WP:COPIES from Idli. Srf123 (talk) 18:04, 12 March 2025 (UTC) Delete - This is a content fork that does not reflect updates made to Idli since 2014. Robert...

b • bl; (5) to Idli podi (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: digiclown.com/perfect-recipe-to-make-idli-at-home/ (R/Xmeta/L-...

bl; (4) to Idli (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: cookclickndevour.com/soft-idli-recipe-how-to-make-soft-idli-batter/ (R/Xmeta/L)...

The result was speedy keep. Procedural keep. Looks like a clear case of WP:IDLI and it's an ugly nomination. (non-admin closure) Masum Reza📞 21:49, 25 July...

Coffee Curd Milk Soft drink Beer Whisky --preparations Cottage cheese Paneer Idli Dosa Rasam Momo (dumpling) Biryani Paratha Puri (food) Khichdi Jalebi Laddu...

delete vote. Nateji77 19:51, 24 September 2005 (UTC) Keep. If Pizza and Idli can have articles, why not this ? Tintin 22:30, 25 September 2005 (UTC) The...

User 2409:4043:407:3FB6:0:0:1F54:A0AC t • c • dc • l • ef • b • bl; (5) to Idli (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: www.beatbeast...

should be made to this page. The result was This isn't a good nom as per WP:IDLI. Kindly, renominate this after it crossed the April 1st, at Delaware River...

English–Konkani Dictionary" "Sanna – idli fluffed with toddy or yeast" the en dash should be replaced with the unspaced em dash: "Sanna—idli fluffed with toddy or yeast"...

here - WP:Not notable is in WP:ATADD, and "poor in taste" is close to WP:IDLI. RebeccaGreen (talk) 18:40, 4 August 2019 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

long textdump nobody can read through, and there was no assertion of WP:IDLI at all. Who beyond the editors who care about SBSP gag characters are actually...

— Insertcleverphrasehere (or here) 22:42, 16 September 2018 (UTC) Keep IDLI argument; the concept forms a genre of reality television in and of itself...

there are better ways to deal with it than nuking them. This is a blatant WP:IDLI nomination. Ivanvector (Talk/Edits) 19:56, 31 January 2020 (UTC) The above...

paste made up of coconut, dal (lentils), green chilli and mint or coriander) Idli podi, a powder of chilli with spices and sometimes desiccated coconut, mixed...

think this can easily be WP:RESCUEd, and the nom rationale says to me WP:IDLI (everyone wants a Wikipedia page, who doesn't?). Nate • (chatter) 03:10,...

many haters of Modi so such people may not tolerate such article as per WP:IDLI but we need to be neutral while assessing the article. We don't have to act...

hypertension · Idiophone · The Idiot · Iditarod Trail Sled Dog Race · Eric Idle · Idli · Ido · Billy Idol · Idolatry · Muhammad al-Idrisi · Iðunn · IEEE 1394 interface ·...

fine for individual years. This isn't listcruft, which is functionally WP:IDLI. This isn't a database, either, and it is very discriminate - I'm tired of...

(talk) 12:09, 1 April 2013 (UTC) Idli orchid and me (edit, talk, history, links) — http://www.alotofpages.com/2011/08/idli-orchid-and-willpower.html. MadmanBot...

being low-sourced do you have a true reason for deletion beyond a rubbish WP:IDLI reason? We haven't deleted the cathode ray tube article because "nobody cares...

Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura · Idiophone · The Idiot (novel) · Eric Idle · Idli · Ido · Billy Idol · Idolatry Muhammad al-Idrisi · Morris Iemma · If and...

and guidelines. Your opinion that we don't need them is synonymous with WP:IDLI (3rd example).    — The Transhumanist   08:22, 1 March 2019 (UTC) (ec) These...

ef • b • bl; (6) to Idli (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) (diff  !top) - Link: www.wplinequotes.xyz/2020/03/world-idli...

are not models.  Unscintillating (talk) 13:53, 16 January 2017 (UTC) WP:IDLI states, "While some editors may dislike certain kinds of information, that...

8, 8, 1) 2009-10-16 00:07:18 (UTC): User Ividraj (talk - contribs; 8) to Idli (diff - undo) - Link: kidslunchbox.blogspot.com/2009/10/idly-sandwich-green-tur-beans-and...

2012 (UTC) Keep. Notability is apparent. Don't nominate just because WP:IDLI. 147.8.102.172 (talk) 07:28, 21 February 2012 (UTC)— 147.8.102.172 (talk)...

(UTC) Please don't attack the nominator or voters. I am seeing no sign of IDLI at all in the rationale or among other votes. I'd also advise using your...

sources along with Tataral's concerns make this deletion nomination a bit IDLI with the use of "article" in sarcasm quotes and 'nothing of value'. Nate...

Internet. WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 19:45, 28 January 2025 (UTC) Keep Textbook WP:IDLI, and we're not any kind of purity police; Wikipedia is WP:NOTCENSORED and...

Spirit of Eagle (talk) 05:17, 27 April 2021 (UTC) Comment Not meant to be IDLI at all. The statue simply doesn't have local history, or a connection to...

2015 (UTC) Comment: Usually in such AfDs editors follow philosophy of WP:IDLI, "I Love Modi" Vs "I Hate Modi" battle. I think slogans have been integral...

19:49, 28 June 2018 (UTC) Keep 66 sources, done for every Cup since 1998. WP:IDLI doesn't apply to the layman (we've got plenty of articles here I could argue...

very reasonable. I will leave you to ponder the irony of your linking WP:IDLI in a comment which goes on to say WP:NCHESS is total crap. Usedtobecool TALK ✨...

History of the Republic of India · Hyderabad, India · Hyderabad State · Idli · Imphal · India national football team · Indian Armed Forces · Indian Institute...

History of the Republic of India · Hyderabad, India · Hyderabad State · Idli · Imphal · India national football team · Indian Armed Forces · Indian Institute...

cb (talk) 20:00, 25 March 2026 (UTC) Keep Per everyone else, with the WP:IDLI in the nomination statement being incredibly prejudicial, and the nominator...

1) 2008-07-07 23:39:27 (UTC): User 192.249.47.8 (talk - contribs; 32) to Idli (diff - undo) - Link: indian-recipe.net. * Links added in this diff: indian-recipe...

the nominator's motive here. The impetus for the nomination seems to be IDLI with NEO as a justification. The term is not that obscure (Google Books,...

13:53, 18 July 2016 (UTC) Hundreds of AfDs are just because of people's IDLI attitude. How many of those were started by you? And how many of those actually...

media, or academic books? Where you say he invented an extremely popular idli plate, is there some proof of that in news media? Note that blogs, forums...

articles about previously broadcasted sporting events at AfD using basically WP:IDLI arguments. Sometimes the AfDs are correct on sourcing grounds, sometimes...

reliable sources. - Aurorion (talk) 13:44, 1 December 2015 (UTC) Keep: Seems IDLI nomination. Article already has enough reliable sources and can be improved...

WP:NOTIMELIMIT, the creator abandoned it, and "does not add value" sounds like a WP:IDLI argument to me. As for the argument that it is too big, WP:SPINOUT is the...

the second spurious nomination of the week by LatinNerd with an awful WP:IDLI rationale and no further explanation. I suspect this will be kept just as...

explain why. Bookscale (talk) 11:49, 27 November 2019 (UTC) Comment Didn't say IDLI at all anywhere there; just said we already have a summary of it in the main...

There's no question that it is tendentious editing, including WP:IDHT and WP:IDLI but the result has a direct bearing on the public representation (or misrepresentation)...

17:50, 14 April 2025 (UTC) Keep Putting this much more simply, this is a WP:IDLI nom. Deletion is not happening here, and merging is a pie in the sky proposal...

was also nominated for deletion. Lootbox was nominated for deletion per WP:IDLI, claiming that "Government regulation won't be enough[;] we need to completely...

duing Synthesis of 4,4-Dimethyl-1,3-dioxane" by V. W. Zakoshanskii, G. S. Idlis, S. K. Ogorodnikov, O. E. Batalin, Yu. M. Blazhin I obviously agree with...

out your issues with MaranoFan however you need to, but don't drop a WP:IDLI nom because you don't agree with their ways (note this isn't agreeing with...

anyone, and is not 'reasonable'. JarrahTree 02:10, 30 December 2022 (UTC) WP:IDLI, WP:CITINGGREATERPROBLEMS. It's already been "standardised at the larger...

Lek (talk) 02:25, 19 August 2025 (UTC) Keep -- sounds somewhere between WP:IDLI and WP:WGW, but neither of which are policy based. Longhornsg makes some...

“WP:TRIGGERED” in the search bar while looking for a policy equivalent to WP:IDLI. More likely, this shortcut will be used in the context of talk page discussions...

Praxidicae (talk) 13:09, 18 October 2019 (UTC) Doncram has been making these IDLI arguments for a while or so .... ∯WBGconverse 13:20, 18 October 2019 (UTC)...

reason for deleting an article. --Orlady (talk) 02:28, 22 August 2012 (UTC) IDLI is not a valid reason, correct, but since that in no way was my argument...

idea what [lack of] policy Zxcvbnm is referring to but I'll suggest that WP:IDLI applies. Ivanvector's squirrel (trees/nuts) 13:10, 31 May 2021 (UTC) Keep...

the basis that the original AfD was simply a subjective 'I don't like it'. IDLI is not a policy or guideline for inclusion/deletion and therefore IMO such...

still currently unadressed, I do see evidence of WP:IDLI and the misunderstanding of Indian English. IDLI applies because India is part of the India-Pakistan...

September 2017 (UTC) No, their claim is that the nomination itself is WP:IDLI. TLDI would be "this is just a nomination from some console fan upset about...

13:21, 1 September 2019 (UTC) Keep per Andrew Davidson, Betty Logan and WP:IDLI. Miniapolis 13:58, 1 September 2019 (UTC) Keep People get coverage for this...

constitute a valid policy-based reason for deletion. They basically add up t0 WP:IDLI. Beyond My Ken (talk) 18:32, 14 June 2020 (UTC) Keep and add a redirect from...

warring game more than once, however, it's that coupled with a complete WP:IDLI/WP:WIN/WP:POINT attitude and behavior, name-calling/personal attacks, and...

India. {{subst:Idli|1=<!--Optional message goes here, DO NOT sign-->}} A plate of Idli for you Here is a plate of Idli for you. Idli is a south Indian...

using them as an excuse to nominate the entire page for deletion per WP:IDLI. Certes (talk) 12:20, 28 March 2019 (UTC) These portals are promoted as needing...

module and I probably lost my cool there (which I will admit crossed into WP:IDLI territory). I wanted to see what people wanted to say (and I probably shouldn’t...

Hill Kafeel Ahmed Yakshagana Bellary Ron (city) H. Narasimhaiah HSR Layout Idli Indian Institute of Science Lucy d'Abreu National Law School of India University...

approached about their poor behavior and communication choices as well as WP:IDLI in regard to edits made by others at articles he "favors". I have attempted...

this is a simple case of one disgruntled user with a case of WP:IDHT and WP:IDLI. If Mhhossein reverts me with the reason that TP discussion is ongoing, however...

Muslim community in India just as vada pao is to the Marathi cuisine, or idli sambar to the Tamil community, or sarson da saag and makki di roti to the...

-- Millionsandbillions (talk) 18:40, 20 October 2016 (UTC) This is just IDLI trying to be justified with shortcuts. General notability has been established...

August 2015 (UTC) "/* pOLICE */ new section" Comments: Clear case of WP:IDLI, blanket revert of sourced content, not assuming good faith. You can read...

with, so "primary" has nothing to do with any of this, this is all just WP:IDLI. Sapedder (talk) 23:51, 22 August 2020 (UTC) Here you go so you are finally...

disrupt this article, articles like it and the project with their WP:IDHT, WP:IDLI and WP:BATTLE behaviour. As long as this report sits here unaddressed. -...

edit most of the time. AlbinoFerret 00:16, 26 August 2015 (UTC) Another IDLI When I first saw that there were no citations etc I thought that this was...

follow the discussion. He and User:Roman Spinner are engaged in a massive WP:IDLI campaign without actually initiating a WP:RFM, which they both know that...

the edit. Any comment I made was met with constant accusations of OWN and IDLI. For the admins looking in on this now, I suggest everyone involved, JDC808...

looking to make article talk pages into Q&A fora. "Poor taste" sounds like WP:IDLI. Since WP:BLP doesn't apply and WP:RD is open for all kinds of discussion...

reprints of a press release, which would make them not independent. Radio Idli has none of the characteristics of a reliable source. US India Monitor is...

seriously temped me to vote delete because wp:IDLI 10:30, 5 May 2018 (UTC) @Deliriousandlost: Voting WP:IDLI is a terrible reason to vote delete. It is along...

argument completely. He does feel the need to accuse me of WP:CENSORED, WP:IDLI, WP:COI and WP:CALMDOWN (not necessarily in that order). Just to mention...

September 2017 (UTC) No, their claim is that the nomination itself is WP:IDLI. TLDI would be "this is just a nomination from some console fan upset about...

glaringly incorrect). Pages to read further regarding that are at WP:IDHT and WP:IDLI. ——SerialNumber54129 21:04, 29 November 2018 (UTC) (Furthermore) this attempted...

conclude why. As far as the 3RR report he filed, his reverts were obviously WP:IDLI and out of anger. Rather than just reverting content the previous RfC was...

(UTC) Le defence Human has classic POV pushing, edit warring, TRUTH, STICK, IDLI issues. On top of that he has major competence issues and is a major timesink...

moribund, and, with respect, to the oppose comments, they mostly consist of IDLI arguments. Which, of course, are not supportive arguments.——SerialNumber54129...

LM2000 (talk · contribs), Jonotrain (talk · contribs) WP:GAMING, WP:TE, WP:IDLI, WP:IDHT I have to sleep after posting this, so won't be back until tomorrow...

"BLP" is not supposed to be a magic wand someone can wave because they WP:IDLI an edit. NE Ent 02:32, 6 February 2015 (UTC) New York Times.- MrX 02:34,...

one has cited any policy for moves to close. These are tantamount to WP:IDLI and WP:OTHERSTUFF. If you feel this should be closed, explain why Eric's...

68.198.160.243 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · filter log · WHOIS · RDNS · RBLs · http · block user · block log), (now blocked 3 months) added quite...

because there are newer references - that's against both WP:ITSOOLD and WP:IDLI. Also, the sources are reliable for what they are describing. Mathsci also...

In December, our article about Inez Jasper — a Canadian musician who clears WP:NMUSIC #8 as a two-time Juno Award nominee — was speedy deleted under criterion...

trash that needs to be disposed of. It gets me a bit irked to see these WP:IDLI comments, just because you may not like or use them doesn't mean you get...

real news source that meets WP:RS. A distaste for its political stances (WP:IDLI) is not grounds for disallowing it or comparing it to Infowars. Anyone who...

covers unnecessary portals, and there is no rationale presented other than WP:IDLI to delete a large proportion of all of them, which were all kept after a...

what is there to bring forward to ArbCom, aside from two schools of WP:IDLI? Anmccaff (talk) 04:29, 31 October 2017 (UTC) Support Closure and Oppose...

Softlavender (talk) 02:35, 17 September 2018 (UTC) The basis was not WP:IDLI, it was based on policy, specifically that the RfC question should be neutrally...

have kept the block going. Their noms at AfD for Digimon come down to WP:IDLI concerns and when I called them out for it, they made aspersions that I thought...

nomination). SpinningSpark 07:05, 16 May 2020 (UTC) Good close, weeding out the IDLI-ADTs is something too often overlooked. By the way, has anyone asked User:Momentum7...

The test for such a list is not what we editors think about it – see WP:IDLI. No, what matters is WP:LISTN – whether "it has been discussed as a group...

when you were unblocked. Rebbing 02:20, 17 December 2017 (UTC) It's not WP:IDLI because (1) it's actually disruptive, and (2) it's in violation of your unblock...

the discussion, as no reason has been articulated, other than perhaps WP:IDLI. I humbly suggest that if editors are disinterested in this discussion or...

ANI notice. For context to the edit summary, editor has a long-standing WP:IDLI issue with the outcome of this discussion. Hwy43 (talk) 03:41, 31 December...

inclusion is warranted (WP:NPOV)? This is a normal content dispute (WP:LIKE/WP:IDLI) which WP:BRD has failed to resolve, so a request for comment could be opened...

Anthropology}}? That is what all the Support votes mention. It all sounds like WP:IDLI and/or an end-run attempt to chip away at the pterosaurs TF. See Wikipedia:Templates...

type "Template:R&B" into the search box, or to use "Preview" or "Undo" (WP:IDLI). --Jax 0677 (talk) 03:03, 14 April 2014 (UTC) Delete per BrownHairedGirl...

template redirects such as {{IPFW}}. I think that this is another case of WP:IDLI. --Jax 0677 (talk) 23:12, 27 May 2014 (UTC) But PM5K is also an abbreviation...

advanced as to why the existing name is bad. It seems like a case of WP:IDLI. Fourthly, that the new name is vastly more broad than the current name to...

you counter them, with a revolving repertoire of circular logic, IDHT & IDLI tautological arguments, off-topic rants, and demands for answers that have...

--- Coffeeandcrumbs 02:49, 15 July 2018 (UTC) Nope, not disruptive and nope, not a IDLI nom. If you want to work on the article in a collaborative manner, go for...

and other suggestions ('refs are a mess', for example) are pure WP:ATA. WP:IDLI presumably also applies :) Incidentally, regarding the question as to whether...

information about the feud. Redirects do not require notability. Sounds like WP:IDLI. The controversy did happen, information about it can be on Charles' article...

place" as it's used here. fuzzy510 (talk) 04:02, 26 January 2023 (UTC) WP:IDLI. Fortunately, you weren't participating when this decision was discussed...

Party «High» Semerah Sheila Majid Universiti Malaysia Pahang Bukit Beruang Idli Mustapha bin Harun Sultan Mahmud Airport Kuala Terengganu Mahathir bin Mohamad...

provide a deletion rationale and the subsequent delete arguments amount to WP:IDLI. Note that I declined a G4 speedy deletion request on this for the sole reason...

165.21 (talk) 00:10, 1 October 2016 (UTC)) Strong Keep classic case of WP:IDLI, WP:POVPUSH, WP:OWN and many other policies where the nom just wants anti-India...

from a neutral perspective), then I'd be fine with them working on it. WP:IDLI is not an issue there, because it's not the article subject in itself that...

nothing to do with "I don't like it" and your suggesting that I'm arguing IDLI by pointing out that people can change their minds borders on an accusation...

out your issues with MaranoFan however you need to, but don't drop a WP:IDLI nom because you don't agree with their ways (note this isn't agreeing with...

(UTC) It seems to me that the nominating statement is a combination of WP:IDLI and WP:VAGUEWAVE. Can you elaborate to explain how this article doesn't meet...

nothing to do with "I don't like it" and your suggesting that I'm arguing IDLI by pointing out that people can change their minds borders on an accusation...

the nominator's motive here. The impetus for the nomination seems to be IDLI with NEO as a justification. The term is not that obscure (Google Books,...

because I've shown them to be false. If there were legitimate (i.e. non-IDLI arguments) I would be willing to reconsider the nomination (as I did by striking...

that being used on articles is good enough. This seems like a case of WP:IDLI, and people can preview their work before they submit their changes. --Jax...

type "Template:R&B" into the search box, or to use "Preview" or "Undo" (WP:IDLI). Anyone who used {{r&b}} before I made it got a red link. --Jax 0677 (talk)...

— Insertcleverphrasehere (or here) 22:42, 16 September 2018 (UTC) Keep IDLI argument; the concept forms a genre of reality television in and of itself...

and other suggestions ('refs are a mess', for example) are pure WP:ATA. WP:IDLI presumably also applies :) Incidentally, regarding the question as to whether...

The result was Swag Like Ohio. Clippy was nominated for deletion per WP:IDLI (it's super annoying, thank goodness it was completely removed in 2007) The...

many haters of Modi so such people may not tolerate such article as per WP:IDLI but we need to be neutral while assessing the article. We don't have to act...

WP:FIXTHEPROBLEM, WP:NOTPAPER, and the "arguments to avoid in deletion discussions" WP:IDLI, WP:NOTCLEANUP, WP:EASYTARGET, WP:UNKNOWNHERE, WP:ADHOM. NeatGrey (talk)...

2015 (UTC) Comment While I can't support this by adding a "keep" vote, WP:IDLI isn't a reason to delete. the Wikipedia:User pages guideline says that users...

previously berated @Sulfurboy a few days ago. This AfD is entirely based on WP:IDLI and WP:SURMOUNTABLE issues, neither of which are grounds for deletion. AfD...

104 (talk) 11:27, 2 January 2019 (UTC) You should also have a read of WP:IDLI too. You are making a ridiculous set of wild and just plainly wrong accusations...

very reasonable. I will leave you to ponder the irony of your linking WP:IDLI in a comment which goes on to say WP:NCHESS is total crap. Usedtobecool TALK ✨...

explain why. Bookscale (talk) 11:49, 27 November 2019 (UTC) Comment Didn't say IDLI at all anywhere there; just said we already have a summary of it in the main...

constitute a valid policy-based reason for deletion. They basically add up t0 WP:IDLI. Beyond My Ken (talk) 18:32, 14 June 2020 (UTC) Keep and add a redirect from...

The test for such a list is not what we editors think about it – see WP:IDLI. No, what matters is WP:LISTN – whether "it has been discussed as a group...

context here, steam vessels are required for Idli making. From the article, so, how did south indians make Idli if they didnt have steaming vessels? please...

feel they are "imperfect." That is circumventing Wikipedia guidelines. WP:IDLI would apply here and should be avoided. --CNMall41 (talk) 20:46, 11 August...

Praxidicae (talk) 13:09, 18 October 2019 (UTC) Doncram has been making these IDLI arguments for a while or so .... ∯WBGconverse 13:20, 18 October 2019 (UTC)...

WP:NOTIMELIMIT, the creator abandoned it, and "does not add value" sounds like a WP:IDLI argument to me. As for the argument that it is too big, WP:SPINOUT is the...

reliable sources. - Aurorion (talk) 13:44, 1 December 2015 (UTC) Keep: Seems IDLI nomination. Article already has enough reliable sources and can be improved...

(UTC) It seems to me that the nominating statement is a combination of WP:IDLI and WP:VAGUEWAVE. Can you elaborate to explain how this article doesn't meet...

19:49, 28 June 2018 (UTC) Keep 66 sources, done for every Cup since 1998. WP:IDLI doesn't apply to the layman (we've got plenty of articles here I could argue...

165.21 (talk) 00:10, 1 October 2016 (UTC)) Strong Keep classic case of WP:IDLI, WP:POVPUSH, WP:OWN and many other policies where the nom just wants anti-India...

the basis that the original AfD was simply a subjective 'I don't like it'. IDLI is not a policy or guideline for inclusion/deletion and therefore IMO such...

Spirit of Eagle (talk) 05:17, 27 April 2021 (UTC) Comment Not meant to be IDLI at all. The statue simply doesn't have local history, or a connection to...

are not models.  Unscintillating (talk) 13:53, 16 January 2017 (UTC) WP:IDLI states, "While some editors may dislike certain kinds of information, that...

here - WP:Not notable is in WP:ATADD, and "poor in taste" is close to WP:IDLI. RebeccaGreen (talk) 18:40, 4 August 2019 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

--- Coffeeandcrumbs 02:49, 15 July 2018 (UTC) Nope, not disruptive and nope, not a IDLI nom. If you want to work on the article in a collaborative manner, go for...

13:53, 18 July 2016 (UTC) Hundreds of AfDs are just because of people's IDLI attitude. How many of those were started by you? And how many of those actually...

2015 (UTC) Comment: Usually in such AfDs editors follow philosophy of WP:IDLI, "I Love Modi" Vs "I Hate Modi" battle. I think slogans have been integral...

-- Millionsandbillions (talk) 18:40, 20 October 2016 (UTC) This is just IDLI trying to be justified with shortcuts. General notability has been established...

2012 (UTC) Keep. Notability is apparent. Don't nominate just because WP:IDLI. 147.8.102.172 (talk) 07:28, 21 February 2012 (UTC)— 147.8.102.172 (talk)...

long textdump nobody can read through, and there was no assertion of WP:IDLI at all. Who beyond the editors who care about SBSP gag characters are actually...

duing Synthesis of 4,4-Dimethyl-1,3-dioxane" by V. W. Zakoshanskii, G. S. Idlis, S. K. Ogorodnikov, O. E. Batalin, Yu. M. Blazhin I obviously agree with...

The result was speedy keep. Procedural keep. Looks like a clear case of WP:IDLI and it's an ugly nomination. (non-admin closure) Masum Reza📞 21:49, 25 July...

13:21, 1 September 2019 (UTC) Keep per Andrew Davidson, Betty Logan and WP:IDLI. Miniapolis 13:58, 1 September 2019 (UTC) Keep People get coverage for this...

think this can easily be WP:RESCUEd, and the nom rationale says to me WP:IDLI (everyone wants a Wikipedia page, who doesn't?). Nate • (chatter) 03:10,...

104 (talk) 11:27, 2 January 2019 (UTC) You should also have a read of WP:IDLI too. You are making a ridiculous set of wild and just plainly wrong accusations...

with the source, but because they don't agree with the information, i.e. WP:IDLI -- and that simply is not a criteria by which we judge reliability. Certainly...

from a neutral perspective), then I'd be fine with them working on it. WP:IDLI is not an issue there, because it's not the article subject in itself that...

which we have on offer here at WP: WP:RECENT, WP:UNENCYC, WP:ILIKEIT or WP:IDLI = WP:Essays and WP:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions (needs acronym)...

reason for deleting an article. --Orlady (talk) 02:28, 22 August 2012 (UTC) IDLI is not a valid reason, correct, but since that in no way was my argument...

information about the feud. Redirects do not require notability. Sounds like WP:IDLI. The controversy did happen, information about it can be on Charles' article...

be symmetrically applied, meaning that it would likely become a mask for IDLI behavior. Hunan seems to think primary sources are the main problem in the...

evidence to support RS. If you wish to refute it, you need more than WP:IDLI. EvergreenFir (talk) Please {{re}} 23:36, 11 August 2014 (UTC) Where did...

lot of the delete views presented (particularly the WP:EASYTARGET and [{WP:IDLI]] !votes), though considering WP:EFFECT wears me down. I have proposed a...

do not provide any substantial rationale or evidence (these are mostly WP:IDLI non-arguments), so I am left with the argument that promoting conversion...

Lake Portal:India/SC Summary/SP IAF Mirage 2000 Portal:India/SC Summary/SP Idlis Portal:India/SC Summary/SP India roadway map Portal:India/SC Summary/SP...

WP:FIXTHEPROBLEM, WP:NOTPAPER, and the "arguments to avoid in deletion discussions" WP:IDLI, WP:NOTCLEANUP, WP:EASYTARGET, WP:UNKNOWNHERE, WP:ADHOM. NeatGrey (talk)...

removed. File:Breakfast french toast.jpg (talk) removed. File:Breakfast idli sambar.jpg (talk) removed. File:Breakfast in Bali.jpg (talk) removed. File:Breakfast...

film director Hungary Romania 1981-09-07 Cluj-Napoca Q12353768 4 Yuliya Idlis Russian poet Russia 1981-02-04 Kaliningrad Q15067375 2 Liu Chien-Kuo Taiwanese...

0 Elena Vlădăreanu Romanian poet Romania 1981-02-02 Q12727507 1 Yuliya Idlis autodesc unavailable Russia 1981-02-04 Kaliningrad Q15067375 2 Marie Ďulíková...

journalist and writer Romania 1981-05-20 Ștefănești Q12736994 2 Yuliya Idlis Russian poet Russia 1981-02-04 Kaliningrad Q15067375 2 Maria Ulfsak-Sheripova...

who into thinking what? When you click on them, it goes to the essay. WP:IDLI if I've ever seen it. From WP:SHORTCUT: "Shortcuts are created for the convenience...

CNN are considered RSs, then Fox News is as well. I'm seeing a lot of WP:IDLI and bias being used in place of rational, reasonable, critical thinking....

who argued in the sixth AfD. I certainly would never fall back on to an IDLI argument during an AfD but the leeway given by the closing admins in the...

thing is, my leaping reliable sources style wiki-fu beats their crouching WP:IDLI style. Osu! All the sources already found for Landrace clearly indicate the...

(UTC) @WilyD:: Please provide links (or at least quotes) to the supposed WP:IDLI arguments by the delete side, personal attacks that occurred by the delete...

As I told the nominator despite their insistence, I did not vote! on WP:IDLI concerns, only that there's few sources to individual years of this event...

(talk) 14:06, 16 May 2020 (UTC) Endorse, Good close, weeding out the WP:IDLI/WP:AADDs is something too often overlooked. By the way, has anyone asked...

on vote, not a review of sources, which goes against WP:MAJORITY and WP:IDLI, when the decision should be based on WP:GNG policy. I brought this up with...

Subsequently, any !vote which amounted to "because Neelix" is equivalent to WP:IDLI and must be discounted. That knocks the straw tally down to 4:3 favouring...

rant and Unclear Magazine are clearly SIGCOV, your nomination is clearly WP:IDLI. Govvy (talk) 20:49, 18 February 2025 (UTC) Interviews are not independent...

(lest we get started on the wrong foot, or if I have unknowingly given an IDLI argument or sth), or join in, if necessary, if you can. Again, many thanks...

sides--that I found little of use there. It seemed like a whole lot of WP:IDLI from one side, with a round of WP:IDHT from the other, so I thought that...

which we have on offer here at WP: WP:RECENT, WP:UNENCYC, WP:ILIKEIT or WP:IDLI = WP:Essays and WP:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions (needs acronym)...

who argued in the sixth AfD. I certainly would never fall back on to an IDLI argument during an AfD but the leeway given by the closing admins in the...

didn't actually !vote. They are within their right to state an opinion. WP:IDLI does not apply here. 11WB (talk) 15:48, 19 November 2025 (UTC) You may have...

f4Yl5E-Ldf5H4o55FxvyIBtu4vOD5Ty4xaK646z4kOjhkzV7vzomox1q7YQQzrpi-cLWIQpjiIdliDuvda7LvT1BwkKjqdHjTI_1P7m_1kN4tC_1PB1Hs2tMpDG3E3X9v2q7_1vGphXdF3rBfv4Qbm...

Peninsular Malaysia 8,549 284 Start High 214 Banteng 8,467 282 GA Low 215 Idli 8,365 278 B Mid 216 Arthur Percival 8,328 277 B Mid 217 Malaysia Airlines...

October 2025 (UTC) I agree that I do not like it, but not in the sense of WP:IDLI. Her bio IS truly "mind-numbingly mundane". The fact that she is the oldest...

(UTC) @WilyD:: Please provide links (or at least quotes) to the supposed WP:IDLI arguments by the delete side, personal attacks that occurred by the delete...

delete vote. Nateji77 19:51, 24 September 2005 (UTC) Keep. If Pizza and Idli can have articles, why not this ? Tintin 22:30, 25 September 2005 (UTC) The...

liking the EL is that it's objectifying and "fitness porn" (but I know WP:IDLI is not sufficient reason for excluding it). Regardless, there is clearly...

Kadhal Varum Paruvam - Idhu Malai Nerathu Mayakkam - Idikarai - Idiyappam - Idli - Ilaiyangudi - Ilaiyaraaja - Ilaiyavan - Ilamai Oonjal Aadukirathu - Ilamcetcenni...

if Xmas pudding is okay, there is also Xmas cake. Plus icebox cake. And idlis!!! Could you be more specific? Mothperson cocoon 15:24, 21 October 2006...

(talk) 17:56, 10 May 2017 (UTC) Support. ITN is becoming one of the worst WP:IDLI and WP:RIGHTGREATWRONGS venues on the encyclopedia these days. I hear the...

(talk) 14:06, 16 May 2020 (UTC) Endorse, Good close, weeding out the WP:IDLI/WP:AADDs is something too often overlooked. By the way, has anyone asked...

your request to post it there, and my notifications. Just so you know, wp:IDLI is not a valid defense.) Pinging @El C: just in case, as he is also active...

about whether editors personally like or dislike the article subject (WP:IDLI). Promising to make or withhold monetary donations to the Wikimedia foundation...

labeling of anti-feminist. S806 (talk) 20:41, 15 March 2018 (UTC) Seems to be a IDLI issue to me. EvergreenFir (talk) 20:47, 15 March 2018 (UTC) There has been...

by Pulitzer Prize recipients, etc. Your response has been WP:IDHT and WP:IDLI, and inventing rationales for dismissing sources that have no basis in policy...

As I told the nominator despite their insistence, I did not vote! on WP:IDLI concerns, only that there's few sources to individual years of this event...

subject is controversial and has a shaky public image. Hardly anywhere near WP:IDLI and just stating a known fact. Nate • (chatter) 23:16, 18 November 2024 (UTC)...

Jansons school of business Chittarkottai Congee Media in Chennai Mudhalvan Idli Loyola College, Chennai Peruvilai Tamil Nadu Mylapore Paruthiveeran Saindhavi...

still currently unadressed, I do see evidence of WP:IDLI and the misunderstanding of Indian English. IDLI applies because India is part of the India-Pakistan...

India. This variety of rice is popularly believed to result in soft idlis (idli is an edible common in South India). 2. Several poets and natable artists...

Subsequently, any !vote which amounted to "because Neelix" is equivalent to WP:IDLI and must be discounted. That knocks the straw tally down to 4:3 favouring...

Yes, in your mind, it certainly is going nowhere, but quit with your WP:IDLI attitude. Argue the merits of the idea instead of calling it a rubbish idea...

objections to posting this blurb simply boil down to "I don't like it," aka WP:IDLI. We are now one day away from this historic planetary conjunction. Is there...

It fits the criteria of being RS. Please point out where I am mistaken. IDLI is hardly a reason for pooh-pooh'ing it because it contains some gossip....

(their discussion consists not of policy-based rationale but WP:IDHT and WP:IDLI feelings. Here is a great place to resolve rather than attack (which ANI...

la vapeur (diff  !top) - Link: www.indianhealthyrecipes.com/soft-idli-recipe-using-idli-rava/ (R/Xmeta/L- still there) 2020-05-02 12:50:51 (UTC): w:kn:User:ಸಂಗೀತ...

Mavideol1 was declined by Dan arndt on 27 Apr 2023 28 Apr 2023 – Draft:THATTE IDLI submitted for AfC by Renu1990 was declined by DaxServer on 28 Apr 2023 20...

on vote, not a review of sources, which goes against WP:MAJORITY and WP:IDLI, when the decision should be based on WP:GNG policy. I brought this up with...

Idikarai - Idikatha Kaadu - Idiot (1992 film) - Idiot (film) - Idiyappam - Idli - Idris Hasan Latif - Idukki Dam - Idukki Township - Idukki district - Iduvoi...

Of course you don't like it, because it contradicts your beliefs, but WP:IDLI is not a reason to reject it. acupuncture is recommended by current guidelines...

rancheros 8,455 281 Start Unknown 79 Breakfast cereal 8,391 279 C Unknown 80 Idli 8,365 278 B Unknown 81 Johnnycake 8,267 275 C Unknown 82 Spanish omelette...

Muslim community in India just as vada pao is to the Marathi cuisine, or idli sambar to the Tamil community, or sarson da saag and makki di roti to the...

mean, or why you think that means it should be deleted? Keep in mind WP:IDLI. – Closed Limelike Curves (talk) 18:05, 5 November 2025 (UTC) My fault for...

result was there. Thick of It (KSI song) was nominated for deletion per WP:IDLI. The result was frozen. Timeline of the far future tried to predict the future...

(Armstrong Oscillator) 06:13, 11 Jul 2004 Vbganesh uploaded "Idli.JPG" (Picture of Idli, The copy right belongs to myself. Reproduction of this image...

- Raudat Tahera - Rauni (village) - Raurkela Industrial Township - Rava idli - Ravalnath - Ravanahatha - Ravanaprabhu - Ravanastron - Rave (magazine)...

encyclopedia." The other problem is WP:INDISCRIMINATE is often substituted for WP:IDLI - the sole problem here is that the information isn't properly contextualised...

Rajo Nizamani Raleigh Downtown Live Ralph Cindrich Sundar Raman Ramassery Idli Ramsay Sedation Scale Rancho Park Golf Course Random Laser Randy Boyd Thompson...

English–Konkani Dictionary" "Sanna – idli fluffed with toddy or yeast" the en dash should be replaced with the unspaced em dash: "Sanna—idli fluffed with toddy or yeast"...

Kazan Q4400390 2 Älbinä Äpsälämevä 1981-08-24 Kazan Q13203184 3 Yuliya Idlis Russian poet 1981-02-04 Kaliningrad Q15067375 2 Dina Gatina Russian poet...

as opposing the idea, although you didn't say why, sort of making it a WP:IDLI argument. ―Mandruss ☎ IMO. 20:57, 7 September 2025 (UTC) Edited after reply...

(talk) 12:09, 1 April 2013 (UTC) Idli orchid and me (edit, talk, history, links) — http://www.alotofpages.com/2011/08/idli-orchid-and-willpower.html. MadmanBot...

discussion 23 Oct 2025 – Idly Kadai move request to Idli Kadai by Kailash29792 was moved to Idli Kadai by Abhiimanyu7 on 30 Oct 2025; discussion 26 Sep...

Lake Portal:India/SC Summary/SP IAF Mirage 2000 Portal:India/SC Summary/SP Idlis Portal:India/SC Summary/SP India roadway map Portal:India/SC Summary/SP...

qcj+NJ2RLnIWi2nSwT6hos2/JNFgdh uXDUjVwdCI5mAKO7HTtCP/kVroaZ8TvN7vEt1DKIziIDLiAnbsbG444xjcv8 R8qh1/mSoyb4YKUyZTtxZbDaQSCpYcHT5n8qkGnLezbNAKhof7RRUvt1K4+0...

discussion 23 Oct 2025 – Idly Kadai move request to Idli Kadai by Kailash29792 was moved to Idli Kadai by Abhiimanyu7 on 30 Oct 2025; discussion 17 Oct...

(UTC) With all due respect, while the original complaint has elements of IDLI, I feel as if though the nominator has since raised genuine concerns of...

October 2025 (UTC) I agree that I do not like it, but not in the sense of WP:IDLI. Her bio IS truly "mind-numbingly mundane". The fact that she is the oldest...

Lake Portal:India/SC Summary/SP IAF Mirage 2000 Portal:India/SC Summary/SP Idlis Portal:India/SC Summary/SP India roadway map Portal:India/SC Summary/SP...

being low-sourced do you have a true reason for deletion beyond a rubbish WP:IDLI reason? We haven't deleted the cathode ray tube article because "nobody cares...

17:50, 14 April 2025 (UTC) Keep Putting this much more simply, this is a WP:IDLI nom. Deletion is not happening here, and merging is a pie in the sky proposal...

submitted for AfC was declined by UtherSRG on 01 Oct 2024 19 Sep 2024 – Draft:Idli Kadai submitted for AfC by Qwerfjkl (bot) was declined by Robert McClenon...

subject is controversial and has a shaky public image. Hardly anywhere near WP:IDLI and just stating a known fact. Nate • (chatter) 23:16, 18 November 2024 (UTC)...

fine for individual years. This isn't listcruft, which is functionally WP:IDLI. This isn't a database, either, and it is very discriminate - I'm tired of...

Internet. WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 19:45, 28 January 2025 (UTC) Keep Textbook WP:IDLI, and we're not any kind of purity police; Wikipedia is WP:NOTCENSORED and...

provide a deletion rationale and the subsequent delete arguments amount to WP:IDLI. Note that I declined a G4 speedy deletion request on this for the sole reason...

Luluhumulunuku was declined by Thilsebatti on 01 Oct 2024 19 Sep 2024 – Draft:Idli Kadai submitted for AfC by Qwerfjkl (bot) was declined by Robert McClenon...

feel they are "imperfect." That is circumventing Wikipedia guidelines. WP:IDLI would apply here and should be avoided. --CNMall41 (talk) 20:46, 11 August...

(UTC) Please don't attack the nominator or voters. I am seeing no sign of IDLI at all in the rationale or among other votes. I'd also advise using your...

cb (talk) 20:00, 25 March 2026 (UTC) Keep Per everyone else, with the WP:IDLI in the nomination statement being incredibly prejudicial, and the nominator...

previously berated @Sulfurboy a few days ago. This AfD is entirely based on WP:IDLI and WP:SURMOUNTABLE issues, neither of which are grounds for deletion. AfD...

didn't actually !vote. They are within their right to state an opinion. WP:IDLI does not apply here. 11WB (talk) 15:48, 19 November 2025 (UTC) You may have...

Tahera Talk:Rauni (village) Talk:Raurkela Industrial Township Talk:Rava idli Talk:Ravalnath Talk:Ravanahatha Talk:Ravanaprabhu Talk:Ravanastron Talk:Rave...

rant and Unclear Magazine are clearly SIGCOV, your nomination is clearly WP:IDLI. Govvy (talk) 20:49, 18 February 2025 (UTC) Interviews are not independent...

Lek (talk) 02:25, 19 August 2025 (UTC) Keep -- sounds somewhere between WP:IDLI and WP:WGW, but neither of which are policy based. Longhornsg makes some...

articles about previously broadcasted sporting events at AfD using basically WP:IDLI arguments. Sometimes the AfDs are correct on sourcing grounds, sometimes...

sources along with Tataral's concerns make this deletion nomination a bit IDLI with the use of "article" in sarcasm quotes and 'nothing of value'. Nate...

the second spurious nomination of the week by LatinNerd with an awful WP:IDLI rationale and no further explanation. I suspect this will be kept just as...

encyclopedia." The other problem is WP:INDISCRIMINATE is often substituted for WP:IDLI - the sole problem here is that the information isn't properly contextualised...

clear but I have zero idea how that could possibly be enforced. If we get IDLI !votes in a bloody RfC, I don’t imagine that trend will stop in regular editing...

Poh Chuan Murphy Wiredu Murray Buttrose Murray Terrace Murtabak Murugan Idli Shop Musa Hassan Musang Berjanggut Musang King Musashi Okuyama Museum Planning...

issues. There are just so many excuses to cover up what is essentially WP:IDLI. OceanHok (talk) 15:41, 10 June 2025 (UTC) Support indef/site ban of BMWF...

managing not to criticize any of the delete comments that amounted to WP:IDLI. This was a WP:SUPERVOTE, plain and simple. I also advocate to restore the...

about whether editors personally like or dislike the article subject (WP:IDLI). Promising to make or withhold monetary donations to the Wikimedia foundation...

topics". WRT claims that those questioning it's reliability did so on WP:IDLI grounds - editors considered platforming anti-trans activists and talking...

weight" when it is relevant to the paragraph of text about it is just a IDLI arguement. 𐩣𐩫𐩧𐩨 Abo Yemen (𓃵) 17:52, 1 June 2025 (UTC) Heavy-handed...

(talk) 15:15, 31 August 2025 (UTC) Looks like a routine WP:IDLI / edit war between an IP and I'm not perfect. Very bizzare that they are...

Kowal2701 (talk) 21:10, 1 April 2025 (UTC) You mean me validly removing your WP:IDLI pov tags after all that you've done above? Sure 𐩣𐩫𐩧𐩨 Abo Yemen (𓃵) 21:11...

second week. Many of the RFD nominations I've seen have been akin to WP:IDLI arguments, and it's a bit soon to say there's a pattern but many of the nominated...

Your responses everywhere here are WP:IDHT. Your arguments at FAR are WP:IDLI. Your example of work at Braucherei is an illuminating one, I think, because...

issues. There are just so many excuses to cover up what is essentially WP:IDLI. OceanHok (talk) 15:41, 10 June 2025 (UTC) Support indef/site ban of BMWF...

Huguenin, G. (1937-2012) Hunten, Donald (1925-2010) Iannini, Gualberto (-2012) Idlis, Grigorij (1927-2010) Ilyasov, Yuri (1933-2010) Jorgensen, Henning (1939-2010)...

MOS:INFOBOXPURPOSE but reads it differently (diff). conduct – bludgeoning (diff) and WP:IDLI were raised at Talk (and also at the Teahouse @00:38, 15 Feb. (diff) by myself...

managing not to criticize any of the delete comments that amounted to WP:IDLI. This was a WP:SUPERVOTE, plain and simple. I also advocate to restore the...