that became global hits on multiple occasions. Shortcut WP:BADCHARTSWP:BADCHARTS Amazon: Charts pertaining to only one specific retailer should not be...

information, and especially not a WP:BADCHART archive. Stifle (talk) 16:38, 24 March 2011 (UTC) Delete, per WP:BADCHARTS and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United...

another article based on the United World Chart, a chart listed on WP:BADCHARTS. By the creator of Best selling albums in 2009, which is going down in...

(talk) 21:34, 31 May 2009 (UTC) Tagged as CSD G4 repost Obviously a WP:BADCHART with very little authority in Brazil. Nate • (chatter) 21:46, 31 May 2009...

cited to support them isn't actually Billboard -- it's an unreliable WP:BADCHART provider called Alphacharts, which is not accepted as a notability-conferring...

Wikipedia_talk:Record_charts, a consensus was reached that the chart is a WP:BADCHART due to a dubious chart methodology which does not pass both logic and validity...

until 1988), and has been specifically discouraged as a source per WP:BADCHART. No real sources or discussion of where the numbers came from at all. Nate...

whether it just uses its own random process to compile a self-created BADCHART -- and so there can be no automatic presumption of notability, just because...

(UTC) Delete per WP:BADCHARTS - RD (Talk) 17:53, 25 November 2008 (UTC) Strong delete Chile doesn't have an official chart. WP:BADCHARTS says it all. Ten...

notability claims here are charting #102 on Canada's campus radio charts (a WP:BADCHART that cannot establish musical notability, as it isn't IFPI-certified),...

review could carry GNG. But earshot has since been deprecated as a WP:BADCHART because it's not IFPI-certified, one album review in one publication isn't...

support it. The strongest notability claim here is charting on Spotify, a BADCHART that cannot count toward passing the charting criterion at all -- and apart...

press releases distributed by newswire service Relaxnews. Possible WP:BADCHART candidate. StarcheerspeaksnewslostwarsTalk to me 04:40, 27 May 2016 (UTC)...

tree. This is based on the United World Chart, which is listed at WP:BADCHARTS and was deleted per WP:Articles for deletion/United World Chart. An article...

tied to campus radio, meaning !earshot, meaning non-IFPI-certified WP:BADCHART — and nothing else here, neither in the substance nor in the sourcing,...

Wikipedia_talk:Record_charts, the Rolling Stone chart has been deemed a WP:BADCHART due to faulty methodology. Since that chart has been deemed unreliable...

topping a genre chart in !earshot, but earshot is a non-IFPI-certified WP:BADCHART that does not count toward NMUSIC's charting criterion. The only other...

musician is a song that charted on Beatport, but that's a single-vendor WP:BADCHART that does not pass NMUSIC #2 (which requires national charts on the order...

charting but checking what U.S. is linked to we can see it is reverbnation, a badchart. A bunch of links have been dumped into the page but none good, shops,...

JSTOR · TWL) Non-notable chart without any known methodology, fails WP:BADCHARTS. Should be deleted and pinging Kww who has a better knowledge. —Indian:BIO...

(note that Radio Disney is not a valid chart per WP:Record charts and WP:BADCHARTS). "Sources" are one PR interview on MTV, one passing mention in a tour...

appear on any major music charts". Charts shown are those listed on WP:BADCHARTS. --Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars (talk) 18:08, 1 May 2011 (UTC) That may...

charting claim doesn't pass NMUSIC #2, as it rests on an uncertified WP:BADCHART (Mediabase) rather than Canada's real notability-making pop charts (Billboard)...

notable on its own. JJL (talk) 00:42, 21 March 2009 (UTC) Delete The WP:BADCHARTS list shows that charts formed by viewer feedback via texts and phone calls...

chart included (which would be the saving grace) is disallowed per WP:BADCHARTS. — Lil_℧niquℇ №1 [talk] 14:58, 30 September 2012 (UTC) Delete fails WP:NMUSIC...

track listing or a reddit. fails WP:GNG. Beatport is considered as a WP:BADCHARTS and should not be used ofr notability purposes. Domdeparis (talk) 15:03...

only chart they are on is one that is listed on WP:BADCHARTS. I'm not certain that the WP:BADCHARTS listing is justifiable, but I do know that no one has...

sources rather than genuinely reliable ones. iTunes is a single-vendor WP:BADCHART, not a record chart that confers notability under NMUSIC #2, so topping...

non-primary, reliable or notable sources listed. Only notability is one non-WP:BADCHART. Potential WP:AUTO. Lazz_R 20:40, 12 July 2018 (UTC) Note: This discussion...

UK's Official Charts Company, and not on the basis of just any randoid WP:BADCHART you can find — which means nothing stated here passes WP:NMUSIC, and the...

could verify the chart placement, it's actually a non-IFPI-certified WP:BADCHART that doesn't count toward getting an album or an artist over NMUSIC's charting...

of the charts at the Russian Wikipedia satisfy chart requirements (WP:BADCHARTS discourages Apple Music and Spotify charts, because they are not record...

for deletion/MYX Hit Chart. The MYX chart has since been listed at WP:BADCHARTS, and it obviously violates WP:SINGLENETWORK. —Kww(talk) 22:36, 4 November...

discussions. North America1000 10:58, 2 February 2019 (UTC) Delete It's a WP:BADCHARTS and always will be. Nate • (chatter) 16:07, 2 February 2019 (UTC) Relisted...

charting on CBC Radio 3, but that's now much more clearly deprecated as a WP:BADCHART that cannot get a band over NMUSIC #2 by itself anymore, and they haven't...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:29, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

Comment - That might be true. But the chart that's used is listed on Wp:BADCHARTS, so is automatically discounted. DitzyNizzy (aka Jess)|(talk to me)|(What...

Cashbox or other RS charts, but in absence of a source that rules out WP:BADCHART, there's nothing that backs up the claim. Her own website states the song...

NMUSIC #8, and the chart success claims derive from an uncertified WP:BADCHART (Mediabase), not from the publication (Billboard) that actually qualifies...

March 2009 (UTC) Delete: unofficial non-notable chart, may qualify as WP:BADCHARTS. JamesBurns (talk) 01:06, 15 March 2009 (UTC) Delete as not notable --Boston...

The attempted notability claim here is that the song charted on a WP:BADCHART that does not pass NMUSIC's charting criterion (which is looking for IFPI-certified...

chart included (which would be the saving grace) is disallowed per WP:BADCHARTS. — Lil_℧niquℇ №1 [talk] 14:58, 30 September 2012 (UTC) Redirect to Nicole...

Wikipedia:NOT#NEWS Passportguy (talk) 15:19, 2 June 2009 (UTC) Delete and add to WP:BADCHARTS, the site from which this is sourced is a forum. Ten Pound Hammer, his...

mill song which only charted on the Billboard Twitter Real-Time (on WP:BADCHARTS) and made it to 90 on the TurnTable Top 100 for Nigeria (not on WP:GOODCHARTS)...

number-ones of a dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:08, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

number-ones of a dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:06, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

Some assertations of notability, but all the charts mentioned are on WP:BADCHARTS (Australian Country Tracks). The awards won do not seem to be notable...

charts such as Latvia and the Polish National Charts, both listed on WP:BADCHARTS, but, since neither chart is permitted, it doesn't count as a chart. References...

countries, the majority of which have been disallowed on Wikipedia per WP:BADCHARTS Paul75 (talk) 03:12, 9 February 2009 (UTC) Merge with the album Super...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Single network chart failing WP:BADCHARTS. —Indian:BIO [ ChitChat ] 08:30, 3 March 2015 (UTC) Note: This debate...

chart, which is considered a WP:SINGLENETWORK chart and listed at WP:BADCHARTS. StarcheerspeaksnewslostwarsTalk to me 21:08, 17 July 2015 (UTC) Note:...

CheckUser(log) · investigate · cuwiki · SI) Jeodin has been edit-warring WP:BADCHARTS into Lass uns laufen for some time. [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]. This finally...

parent album. The only chart I found it on was a depracated chart WP:BADCHARTS. The article is not likely to expand. Notability of the artist is also...

party notability or charting methodology and failing lists present at WP:BADCHARTS. —Indian:BIO [ ChitChat ] 08:28, 3 March 2015 (UTC) Note: This debate...

01:16, 7 August 2009 (UTC) Comment it could possibly be included on WP:BADCHARTS. It doesn't appear to be there already, unless I skipped over it somehow...

apply to Heart Surgery Isn't That Bad... since it was a charted song. WP:BADCHARTS suggests the chart is not reliable, but it still is a chart, it's something...

notability per WP:MUSIC. As an aside, the Aussie country singles charts are WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters want attention)...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Non notable musician. Claimed charting is BADCHARTS. Touring lacks coverage. Running three non notable businesses does not...

JSTOR · TWL) Dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:05, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

claim with an independent reliable source (It would qualify under WP:BADCHARTS anyway as it appears to be a sourced from a "single vendor"). Does not...

peaked at #16 on the Canadian iTunes R&B Charts but iTunes doesn't pass WP:BADCHARTS. CBS527Talk 17:57, 13 February 2017 (UTC) Delete - non-notable WP:MUSICBIO...

reached No. 1 in the iTunes chart, this is considered unreliable under WP:BADCHARTS. The cited sources are standard press releases, and I cannot find any...

Chart performance for Aleyce Simmonds version is chart that's on WP:BADCHARTS. Neither McCann's nor Herndon's version charted, nor did any version receive...

links | watch | logs | views) I would think that if the chart meets WP:BADCHARTS, then there's no reason to archive the #1 hits on it. Fails WP:RS. Ten...

him of manipulating iTunes sales to force a charting position, but WP:BADCHARTS discourages mention of iTunes and the sources didn't look 100% solid,...

WP:NMUSIC unremarkable band fails WP:GNG. Beatport is considered as a WP:BADCHARTS and should not be used for notability purposes.--MassiveYR ♠ 12:02, 16...

has charted only in the Bulgarian Top 40, a chart which is listed in WP:BADCHARTS. Since that chart is not valid, the song has effectively not charted at...

 — Berean Hunter (talk) 16:06, 10 February 2019 (UTC) Weak delete per WP:BADCHART. I wouldn't say Spotify has become to the professional music world what...

July 2018 (UTC) @Ultimograph5: iTunes chart is not a valid factor WP:BADCHARTS. Only official charts. Cornerstonepicker (talk) 04:36, 3 July 2018 (UTC)...

there's almost nothing else of substance stated here, and other than the WP:BADCHARTS the only other reference here is an unrecoverable dead link from a shortlived...

suitable source, but of the article's other sources: Top40-Charts.com is WP:BADCHARTS; MTV is self-published; DRT is not WP:GOODCHARTS; Record World is a reprint...

number-ones of a dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:09, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

published by Billboard Publications. top40-charts.com has been listed in WP:BADCHARTS and should not be used as a source. ARIA has end-of-year Australian charts...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:10, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

all non-WP:RS sources, WP:SINGLEVENDOR unsuitable charts and other WP:BADCHARTS and Youtube view counts. §§Dharmadhyaksha§§ {Talk / Edits} 04:10, 11 September...

grow beyond stub. Has only charted on Los 40 Principales, and, per WP:BADCHARTS, Los 40 Principales is not to be used. Previous efforts to redirect article...

Songwriter Chats" (the fact remains unreferenced) which is one of the WP:BADCHARTS. She has received scarce coverage and has not achieved anything notable...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Non notable promo single. Claimed charting is BADCHARTS. No significant sales, no national rotation. Lacks coverage in Independent...

September 2018 (UTC) Delete or redirect. The Spanish article cites WP:BADCHARTS sources for the presumed #1 spots. Reliable sources are required instead...

the Bon Jovi discography any other information in unsourced and from WP:BADCHARTS. This article should be deleted and any valuable sourced information be...

Singles Chart (2nd nomination). The Israeli Singles Chart has been on WP:BADCHARTS for a similar length of time. It's a single-network voting playlist: essentially...

A consensus of editors also found the MYX charts unreliable (see WP:BADCHARTS and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MYX Hit Chart). Magnolia677 (talk)...

beyond the purely local scene. Chart success is on a non-IFPI certified WP:BADCHART, not on one that can confer notability per NMUSIC #2; appearing on local...

number-ones of a dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:11, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

sales charts". It has ranked 59 on Sverigetopplistan, which is not a WP:BADCHART. बिनोद थारू (talk) 05:05, 26 November 2023 (UTC) Per WP:NSINGLE: Has been...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:12, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

chart for a national radio network it seems this completely avoids WP:BADCHARTS. Article has been improved and even if sourced by the network itself it's...

singles are on the Australian Country Tracks chart, which is listed at WP:BADCHARTS as an unreliable chart. There are claims of notability through awards...

either way. One one hand, platform-specific charts like iTunes fails WP:BADCHARTS, but that being said, usually something popular enough to top even a "bad...

not significant for inclusion, let alone establishing notability (WP:BADCHARTS). In any case, a stand-alone page is not justified because it can be covered...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:09, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

longer allow links to this site to be added, thanks to a listing on WP:BADCHARTS, XlinxBot's revert list, and some diligent follow-up by human editors...

notability in and of itself -- and the charting claims are tied to WP:BADCHARTS like CMJ and FMQB, where NMUSIC requires IFPI-certified charts on the...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:12, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

chart provider it's talking about. Since the world is filled with WP:BADCHARTS that aren't support for notability (iTunes, standalone radio stations...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:10, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

contribs) 01:12, 17 June 2017 (UTC) As I wrote on your talk page, WP:BADCHARTS states that the iTunes Store is not a chart. They do not meet any notability...

JSTOR · TWL) Fails WP:BAND, charted on Radio Disney which is listed on WP:BADCHARTS. No other claims to fame, no secondary sources save one listing in the...

notability. Even if it were, there's no mention of the Taiwan charts at WP:BADCHARTS or WP:GOODCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters...

User:Joesimnett —Preceding undated comment added 19:18, 4 December 2018 (UTC) WP:BADCHARTS The iTunes Store is not a chart. Walter Görlitz (talk) 19:22, 4 December...

charts are unreliable for purposes of establishing notability; see WP:BADCHARTS. Otherwise this artist is only present in the typical social media and...

and the Portugese and Bulgarian charts are listed as unreliable at WP:BADCHARTS, which only leaves the Hot Dance Club Play chart position. The article...

but the iTunes UK singles chart, a deprecated chart according to WP:BADCHARTS. Independent coverage seems to be limited to local press articles. Best...

almost entirely unverifiable. Regardless of outcome, should be added to WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer and his otters • (Broken clamshells • Otter chirps •...

me confirm it. I've found no evidence of this particular chart in our badcharts list. - Mgm|(talk) 09:13, 3 December 2009 (UTC) If for some reason, I...

put out by American Idol Alumni." Idolwaves obviously falls under WP:BADCHARTS. If he actually appeared on the show rather than the audition rounds,...

with the exception of this one userfied article: the UWC is listed on WP:BADCHARTS, and all references to it are removed on sight.—Kww(talk) 16:13, 2 May...

time on the project as single-source chart are not minor, they're WP:BADCHARTS. A minor chart is one that is not one of the main charts. Walter Görlitz...

JSTOR · TWL) Previously deleted twice. Band's chart entries are on WP:BADCHARTS; awards do not appear to be notable; sources smell of WP:REFBOMBing. Doesn't...

sources. Also, I removed a listing of iTunes Charts, which are on WP:BADCHARTS. 3a. No sections on critical reception of their works. Also, I know Dia...

really a single-vendor chart like Spotify or iTunes instead, those are WP:BADCHARTs that cannot confer notability. The only "source" present here at all for...

Tyler is not a credited writer of that song. Claim of iTunes charting (a badchart anyway) is not supported by a source. A search found nothing good. duffbeerforme...

strongest things here are charting on iTunes, which is deprecated by WP:BADCHARTS as not satisfying NMUSIC's "charting hit" criterion (the hit has to be...

charts is considered reliable, and the chart is not inclued on the WP:BADCHARTS. Greenock125 (talk) 20:13, 29 April 2012 (UTC) Keep Passes WP:NSONG with...

opinion piece in the Minnesota Daily. @LilliamPumpernickl134: See WP:BADCHARTS which says "Spotify: Charts pertaining to only one specific retailer should...

hits that did not really chart (or which charted only on a non-notable WP:BADCHART) or nominations for awards that are not prominent enough to pass criterion...

(UTC) WP:BADCHARTS. duffbeerforme (talk) 13:30, 19 April 2016 (UTC) @Duffbeerforme: To be fair, Upcoming100.com is not on the WP:BADCHARTS list. Perhaps...

vendor chart (Anghami) that his songs have appeared on is considered a WP:BADCHART. The Top Naija Music Awards is not a credible award in my opinion.  Versace1608 ...

singles, but according to discussion at Talk:2009 in country music and WP:BADCHARTS, the Aussie country charts don't count. The sources are either primary...

are not national. The charts for Rock 108 (which should not be used (WP:BADCHARTS)) suggest local rotation there but claim of 99x rotation is not verified...

information on obscure shopping malls that were demolished 20 years ago. WP:BADCHARTS exists specifically to thwart usage of charts whose positions cannot be...

Apart from top40-charts.com being listed as a website to avoid at WP:BADCHARTS, if you actually bothered looking at the source, you would see that it's...

Comment that billboard you refer to looks like something straight out of WP:BADCHARTS and hardly serves to demonstrate sufficient notability of this artist...

is not inherited. The iTune chart is specifically precluded under WP:BADCHARTS and I can't find anything else to demonstrate lasting notability. ~dom...

(UTC) Hi NMGS19, Unfortunately Beatport charts are considered to be WP:BADCHARTS Ceethekreator (talk) 16:27, 29 May 2019 (UTC) Hi Ceethekreator, thank...

delete. Listmeister (talk) 20:11, 12 April 2013 (UTC) Per Wikipedia:Badcharts#Deprecated_charts, a guideline, retailer-specific charts, including iTunes...

DrColePorter 03:42, 30 December 2010 (UTC) No it doesn't. iTunes is on WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters want attention)...

music for a podcast -- and the "charting" claims here are all tied to WP:BADCHARTS rather than notability-conferring charts: notability because charting...

redirect have been thwarted by an IP under the misapprehension that WP:BADCHARTS is an exhaustive list of every bad chart. Given that I pretty much compiled...

non-notable radio airplay charts (referenced to a website to avoid per WP:BADCHARTS), links to user-generated content from iMDb and the like to prove the...

criteria, there is no evidence per my WP:BEFORE that any are met. WP:BADCHARTS applies to the claim that the band has charted. —Alalch E. 06:11, 7 December...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Non notable musician. CMT are badcharts anf not sourced. She lacks coverage in independent reliable sources. A...

information; no reason to keep chart info related to a chart listed on WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters want attention)...

methodology or claim to significance, so would appear to be a candidate for WP:BADCHARTS. The sources are: a link to a podcast episode about the album; an interview...

published by Billboard Publications. top40-charts.com has been listed in WP:BADCHARTS and should not be used as a source. ARIA has end-of-year Australian charts...

WP:Record charts. The list of charts to specifically avoid is located at WP:BADCHARTS, while a list of reliable sources for chart positions and certifications...

@Sockie16: the iTunes chart is not considered an important chart per WP:BADCHARTS. Social media such as Twitter and YouTube are not generally considered...

(UTC) Delete Parody group. Also iTunes is not a reliable chart per WP:BADCHARTS. Rockysmile11(talk) 21:08, 26 March 2017 (UTC) Keep there are an impressive...

hits that did not really chart (or which charted only on a non-notable WP:BADCHART) or nominations for awards that are not prominent enough to pass criterion...

combination of radio play and listener requests, so it would certainly be WP:BADCHARTS. Article is pure WP:PROMO. Richard3120 (talk) 21:02, 10 November 2016...

October 2016 (UTC) A note to this effect should probably be added to WP:BADCHARTS - David Gerard (talk) 05:27, 11 October 2016 (UTC)...

Nominator covers the problems with the sources fairly well, as well as WP:BADCHARTS. Additional RS are only tangentially about the subject, or trivial namechecks...

December 2018 (UTC) Actually article is really poorly written. Per WP:BADCHARTS, I don't believe that charting on Highest Global Chart rank automatically...

any credibility at all, and, should we delete them and list them on WP:BADCHARTS, there will no charts for South America. An entire continent lost. Not...

if the chart is unverifiable and/or would otherwise be included on WP:BADCHARTS — there's some Mediabase chart AFD floating around right now with positions...

not confirm the statement, and even so, Beatport is unreliable per WP:BADCHARTS. Delete per WP:PROMOTION. ---DOOMSDAYER520 (Talk|Contribs) 20:18, 15 April...

used on quite a few song articles within wikipedia, and not listed as WP:BADCHARTS. Musicline is difficult to use for most editors as it's all in German...

territory. Album appearances, and soundtracks are unsourced. According to WP:BADCHARTS, Acharts should not be used if there is another available source for chartings...

For WP:MUSIC, Amazon and iTunes are not national music charts, see WP:BADCHARTS. I would think Side Effect is a non-notable film and nothing in the sources...

acharts.us was being used as a reference, a deprecated chart listed on WP:BADCHARTS Finally, I was trying to get in touch with the GA reviewer, but he or...

2409:4073:2105:B4E8:0:0:359:C8B1 (talk) 10:27, 21 May 2022 (UTC) IP, please see WP:BADCHARTS: "Charts pertaining to only one specific retailer should not be used."...

done back in 2016 to circumvent the fact that said charts were on WP:BADCHARTS due to their positions not being archived, which makes it a WP:NOTWEBHOST...

unfortunately, none of your changes meet the notability criteria. 1) Per WP:BADCHARTS, Beatport is not a recognised chart as it is a single vendor chart. 2)...

Archives of positions on the Canadian Country chart which is listed on WP:BADCHARTS. Editor has been absent since October, so there is no foreseeable use...

have charted, none of the charts are recognized by Wikipedia, per WP:BADCHARTS. Magnolia677 (talk) 11:36, 8 October 2016 (UTC) Note: This debate has...

World Albums Top 40/World Singles Top 40 For more information, see WP:BADCHARTS If you want to get involved in this project, please add your name with...

deleting the Cash Box positions from other articles and adding it to WP:BADCHARTS since the positions can't be verified. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and...

charts is considered reliable, and the chart is not inclued on the WP:BADCHARTS. Greenock125 (talk) 19:51, 29 April 2012 (UTC) Keep. Significant coverage...

charts mentioned in the article are from iTunes, which is listed at WP:BADCHARTS. The only coverage I could find that came close to being significant was...

stations which just air American artists and call it a day). It's not a WP:BADCHARTS...because it isn't even a chart. It's just a carousel article which exists...

us here to check the hits. I have and I only found one, that being a WP:BADCHART. Someone else managed to find one other ref to a better chart. That's it...

"guideline"? The majority of my edits are music and I was thinking of:- WP:BADCHARTS - Deprecated Charts - "This is a list of charts which should not be included...

charing on Apple Music music chart. However, this chart is considered a WP:BADCHART. References 2, 4, and 10 are unreliable promotional references. References...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) WP:SINGLENETWORK chart failing WP:BADCHARTS which violate WP:NOT#PROMOTION Akhiljaxxn (talk) 06:29, 15 July 2018 (UTC)...

does not have a searchable database. Charts that are listed under WP:BADCHARTS should not be used. Argentina CAPIF (albums only): Official website Mirror...

Delete: not compelling argument for keep. Fails WP:MUSIC. Last fm is a BADCHART under WP:MUSIC. Googled the man and very little came up. How this article...

22:33, 30 December 2008 (UTC) Comment The iTunes charts are listed on WP:BADCHARTS, and should not be viewed as qualifying as "charts" in order to satisfy...

just noticed, several of the charts they were listed as topping were WP:BADCHARTS. Jackmcbarn (talk) 16:00, 26 April 2014 (UTC) I guess you are talking...

"GLBT Hall of Fame" doesn't assist notability, and non-IFPI certified WP:BADCHARTS that don't count as notability for the purposes of clearing WP:NMUSIC's...

the United World chart (a chart deleted from Wikipedia, listed at WP:BADCHARTS, listed in XlinkBot's revert list ... just the worst of the worst). He...

Colombian, and min-skirt. Done. Per WP:BADCHARTS, removed information about video countdowns. WP:BADCHARTS says nothing about video countdowns. I believe...

information, and especially not a WP:BADCHART archive. Stifle (talk) 16:38, 24 March 2011 (UTC) Delete, per WP:BADCHARTS and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United...

for edit warring and I have warned 89.155.180.224 about violating WP:BADCHARTS. He hasn't listened. I recommend 72 hours for 89 and a week for Connie...

tsort.info to list international chart positions?!!!! That violates WP:BADCHARTS! You seriously need to check harder if the aritcle entirely meets 1(c)...

several warnings of being told not to add charts that are listed under WP:BADCHARTS (charts that are prohibited in music articles), the user stopped editing...

block log) was blocked for constantly inserting the charts that fail WP:BADCHARTS into Celestial (RBD album) (edit | talk | history | protect | delete |...

consolidated list of charts to be avoided, which ultimately resulted in WP:BADCHARTS. I produced the bulk of WP:Record charts/sourcing guide, aka WP:GOODCHARTS...

WP:GOODCHARTS. Please help the ongoing addition of erroneous content and WP:BADCHARTS. --Legolas (talk2me) 05:10, 8 February 2010 (UTC) He is from Canada that...

have been inserting information that violates WP:Record charts and WP:BADCHARTS into articles related to the group 30 Seconds to Mars. Neon White and...

block log) has been blocked twice for adding Brazilian charts (which fail WP:BADCHARTS into articles related to RBD, as have his socks Blandinocm (talk · contribs ·...

Also re: bubbling under, see WP:BADCHARTS. Nikthestunned 16:44, 22 October 2016 (UTC) I'm very familiar with WP:BADCHARTS and nowhere on that page does...

content, additional of unreliable sources and repeated addition of WP:BADCHARTS requires some sort of administrator intervention. Lil-unique1 (talk) 16:14...

some of it is a bit convoluted at time (there's WP:GOODCHARTS and WP:BADCHARTS stuff to know, for example.) But the problem isn't just "not knowing"...

coverage. The long-deleted United World Chart and various other charts at WP:BADCHARTS went through the same thing: people were citing the positions here and...

Billboard glitches, those peaks will not show up on the site and from WP:BADCHARTS, acharts.us can be used as an alternate source. Since I don't know that...

I assume the myriad citations to chart positions don't contain any WP:BADCHARTS violations? Oppose until issues are cleaned up. I'll need to run through...

version of the article, AngusWOOF explained that you should look at WP:BADCHARTS. Cyphoidbomb (talk) 23:36, 13 February 2021 (UTC) Thank you for the help...

Charts in France and Aficia. I believe Zobble.de, as explained at WP:BADCHARTS, is licensed by the Official Charts Company-licensed Hit Music magazine...

has a few bad archives: Italian, Portugese and Worldwide Single (see WP:BADCHARTS). But the rest are fine.--12345abcxyz20082009 (talk) 11:17, 9 September...

(talk) 05:26, 24 June 2012 (UTC) Internet charts are not reliable per WP:BADCHARTS. If he were on the main Country Breakout chart from Music Row, then maybe...

when it comes to reliability. Why are they now reliable? aCharts: WP:BADCHARTS states that aCharts is not reliable only for some countries like Italy...

→ "in August 2014"  Done iTunes rankings shouldn't be included per WP:BADCHARTS  Done The "M" in AllMusic should be capitalized  Done Only "Billboard"...

reliable (see WP:CHARTS)  Done No sources in this article are listed in WP:BADCHARTS. EditorEat ma talk page up, scotty! 18:33, 16 July 2013 (UTC) British...

Charts in France and Aficia. I believe Zobble.de, as explained at WP:BADCHARTS, is licensed by the Official Charts Company-licensed Hit Music magazine...

consolidated list of charts to be avoided, which ultimately resulted in WP:BADCHARTS. I produced the bulk of WP:Record charts/sourcing guide, aka WP:GOODCHARTS...

has been deemed as a non-notable chart with dubious methodology (see WP:BADCHARTS). Out of all the songs in the category, only two come from a reliable...

chart" as including campus radio charts. List of record charts and WP:BADCHARTS might help with this discussion. Fences&Windows 22:11, 1 December 2009...

tied to campus radio, meaning !earshot, meaning non-IFPI-certified WP:BADCHART — and nothing else here, neither in the substance nor in the sourcing,...

makes the band notable under WP:BAND. R&R is not listed in either WP:BADCHARTS or WP:GOODCHARTS, so whether Windows meets criterion 2 is debatable. As...

WP:NSONGS, because none of the charts are notable charts (some on WP:BADCHARTS, others just plain unsourced or non-notable). Article has fake references...

Billboard glitches, those peaks will not show up on the site and from WP:BADCHARTS, acharts.us can be used as an alternate source. Since I don't know that...

(UTC) We have a list of charts that have been deemed unreliable in WP:BADCHARTS. Unfortunately, we are having to take care of enforcement manually, and...

cited to support them isn't actually Billboard -- it's an unreliable WP:BADCHART provider called Alphacharts, which is not accepted as a notability-conferring...

tree. This is based on the United World Chart, which is listed at WP:BADCHARTS and was deleted per WP:Articles for deletion/United World Chart. An article...

Wikipedia_talk:Record_charts, the Rolling Stone chart has been deemed a WP:BADCHART due to faulty methodology. Since that chart has been deemed unreliable...

time on the project as single-source chart are not minor, they're WP:BADCHARTS. A minor chart is one that is not one of the main charts. Walter Görlitz...

sources. Has not charted on a countries national chart, Beatport charts are BADCHARTS. duffbeerforme (talk) 02:19, 20 August 2014 (UTC) No pass on WP:MUSIC#5...

(UTC) Delete per WP:BADCHARTS - RD (Talk) 17:53, 25 November 2008 (UTC) Strong delete Chile doesn't have an official chart. WP:BADCHARTS says it all. Ten...

that a song did well on the iTunes charts, but that's a single-vendor WP:BADCHART that does not pass NMUSIC's charting criterion -- notability because charting...

and WP:MUSICBIO. No awards. Billboard charts are deprecated, per WP:BADCHARTS. Sources cited in article are primary sources (interviews) or trivial...

of the charts at the Russian Wikipedia satisfy chart requirements (WP:BADCHARTS discourages Apple Music and Spotify charts, because they are not record...

JSTOR · TWL) Fails WP:BAND, charted on Radio Disney which is listed on WP:BADCHARTS. No other claims to fame, no secondary sources save one listing in the...

notability claims here are charting #102 on Canada's campus radio charts (a WP:BADCHART that cannot establish musical notability, as it isn't IFPI-certified),...

put out by American Idol Alumni." Idolwaves obviously falls under WP:BADCHARTS. If he actually appeared on the show rather than the audition rounds,...

talk | history | links | watch | logs) Nominator's rationale: Per WP:BADCHARTS and this AFD, the Canadian country music charts published by R&R/Nielsen...

has a few bad archives: Italian, Portugese and Worldwide Single (see WP:BADCHARTS). But the rest are fine.--12345abcxyz20082009 (talk) 11:17, 9 September...

WP:NMUSIC unremarkable band fails WP:GNG. Beatport is considered as a WP:BADCHARTS and should not be used for notability purposes.--MassiveYR ♠ 12:02, 16...

May 2018 (UTC) RecoChoku is listed as one of deprecated charts in WP:BADCHARTS. You need to show that it has charted in one of the accepted Japanese...

candidates to be added to the WP:BADCHARTS list. For those that don't get involved in the song articles, being listed on WP:BADCHARTS makes all references to that...

JSTOR · TWL) Non-notable chart without any known methodology, fails WP:BADCHARTS. Should be deleted and pinging Kww who has a better knowledge. —Indian:BIO...

chart included (which would be the saving grace) is disallowed per WP:BADCHARTS. — Lil_℧niquℇ №1 [talk] 14:58, 30 September 2012 (UTC) Delete fails WP:NMUSIC...

Comment - That might be true. But the chart that's used is listed on Wp:BADCHARTS, so is automatically discounted. DitzyNizzy (aka Jess)|(talk to me)|(What...

22:33, 30 December 2008 (UTC) Comment The iTunes charts are listed on WP:BADCHARTS, and should not be viewed as qualifying as "charts" in order to satisfy...

notability in and of itself -- and the charting claims are tied to WP:BADCHARTS like CMJ and FMQB, where NMUSIC requires IFPI-certified charts on the...

Wikipedia:NOT#NEWS Passportguy (talk) 15:19, 2 June 2009 (UTC) Delete and add to WP:BADCHARTS, the site from which this is sourced is a forum. Ten Pound Hammer, his...

(UTC) WP:BADCHARTS. duffbeerforme (talk) 13:30, 19 April 2016 (UTC) @Duffbeerforme: To be fair, Upcoming100.com is not on the WP:BADCHARTS list. Perhaps...

another article based on the United World Chart, a chart listed on WP:BADCHARTS. By the creator of Best selling albums in 2009, which is going down in...

(UTC) — Preceding unsigned comment added by Casshums (talk • contribs) WP:BADCHARTS. Neither iTunes nor Amazon are charts. Walter Görlitz (talk) 15:47, 20...

(talk) 21:34, 31 May 2009 (UTC) Tagged as CSD G4 repost Obviously a WP:BADCHART with very little authority in Brazil. Nate • (chatter) 21:46, 31 May 2009...

Talk 04:37, 28 August 2021 (UTC) I kinda wonder if we'd consider it a WP:BADCHARTS nowadays - the Flavour of NZ source states Not sales based music charts;...

and the Portugese and Bulgarian charts are listed as unreliable at WP:BADCHARTS, which only leaves the Hot Dance Club Play chart position. The article...

is not inherited. The iTune chart is specifically precluded under WP:BADCHARTS and I can't find anything else to demonstrate lasting notability. ~dom...

notable on its own. JJL (talk) 00:42, 21 March 2009 (UTC) Delete The WP:BADCHARTS list shows that charts formed by viewer feedback via texts and phone calls...

(note that Radio Disney is not a valid chart per WP:Record charts and WP:BADCHARTS). "Sources" are one PR interview on MTV, one passing mention in a tour...

suitable source, but of the article's other sources: Top40-Charts.com is WP:BADCHARTS; MTV is self-published; DRT is not WP:GOODCHARTS; Record World is a reprint...

number-ones of a dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:11, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

apply to Heart Surgery Isn't That Bad... since it was a charted song. WP:BADCHARTS suggests the chart is not reliable, but it still is a chart, it's something...

support it. The strongest notability claim here is charting on Spotify, a BADCHART that cannot count toward passing the charting criterion at all -- and apart...

used on quite a few song articles within wikipedia, and not listed as WP:BADCHARTS. Musicline is difficult to use for most editors as it's all in German...

if the chart is unverifiable and/or would otherwise be included on WP:BADCHARTS — there's some Mediabase chart AFD floating around right now with positions...

there's almost nothing else of substance stated here, and other than the WP:BADCHARTS the only other reference here is an unrecoverable dead link from a shortlived...

singles, but according to discussion at Talk:2009 in country music and WP:BADCHARTS, the Aussie country charts don't count. The sources are either primary...

review could carry GNG. But earshot has since been deprecated as a WP:BADCHART because it's not IFPI-certified, one album review in one publication isn't...

Delete: not compelling argument for keep. Fails WP:MUSIC. Last fm is a BADCHART under WP:MUSIC. Googled the man and very little came up. How this article...

information; no reason to keep chart info related to a chart listed on WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters want attention)...

Apart from top40-charts.com being listed as a website to avoid at WP:BADCHARTS, if you actually bothered looking at the source, you would see that it's...

For WP:MUSIC, Amazon and iTunes are not national music charts, see WP:BADCHARTS. I would think Side Effect is a non-notable film and nothing in the sources...

topping a genre chart in !earshot, but earshot is a non-IFPI-certified WP:BADCHART that does not count toward NMUSIC's charting criterion. The only other...

chart for a national radio network it seems this completely avoids WP:BADCHARTS. Article has been improved and even if sourced by the network itself it's...

described in their website) is considered serious, others you will find in WP:BADCHARTS not. Second point, yes, the Romanian branch of MF (www.mediaforest.ro)...

consolidated list of charts to be avoided, which ultimately resulted in WP:BADCHARTS. I produced the bulk of WP:Record charts/sourcing guide, aka WP:GOODCHARTS...

has charted only in the Bulgarian Top 40, a chart which is listed in WP:BADCHARTS. Since that chart is not valid, the song has effectively not charted at...

sources rather than genuinely reliable ones. iTunes is a single-vendor WP:BADCHART, not a record chart that confers notability under NMUSIC #2, so topping...

almost entirely unverifiable. Regardless of outcome, should be added to WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer and his otters • (Broken clamshells • Otter chirps •...

the Bon Jovi discography any other information in unsourced and from WP:BADCHARTS. This article should be deleted and any valuable sourced information be...

whether it just uses its own random process to compile a self-created BADCHART -- and so there can be no automatic presumption of notability, just because...

September 2018 (UTC) Delete or redirect. The Spanish article cites WP:BADCHARTS sources for the presumed #1 spots. Reliable sources are required instead...

information on obscure shopping malls that were demolished 20 years ago. WP:BADCHARTS exists specifically to thwart usage of charts whose positions cannot be...

July 2018 (UTC) @Ultimograph5: iTunes chart is not a valid factor WP:BADCHARTS. Only official charts. Cornerstonepicker (talk) 04:36, 3 July 2018 (UTC)...

claim with an independent reliable source (It would qualify under WP:BADCHARTS anyway as it appears to be a sourced from a "single vendor"). Does not...

countries, the majority of which have been disallowed on Wikipedia per WP:BADCHARTS Paul75 (talk) 03:12, 9 February 2009 (UTC) Merge with the album Super...

him of manipulating iTunes sales to force a charting position, but WP:BADCHARTS discourages mention of iTunes and the sources didn't look 100% solid,...

any credibility at all, and, should we delete them and list them on WP:BADCHARTS, there will no charts for South America. An entire continent lost. Not...

track listing or a reddit. fails WP:GNG. Beatport is considered as a WP:BADCHARTS and should not be used ofr notability purposes. Domdeparis (talk) 15:03...

A consensus of editors also found the MYX charts unreliable (see WP:BADCHARTS and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MYX Hit Chart). Magnolia677 (talk)...

non-primary, reliable or notable sources listed. Only notability is one non-WP:BADCHART. Potential WP:AUTO. Lazz_R 20:40, 12 July 2018 (UTC) Note: This discussion...

"guideline"? The majority of my edits are music and I was thinking of:- WP:BADCHARTS - Deprecated Charts - "This is a list of charts which should not be included...

contribs) 01:12, 17 June 2017 (UTC) As I wrote on your talk page, WP:BADCHARTS states that the iTunes Store is not a chart. They do not meet any notability...

appear on any major music charts". Charts shown are those listed on WP:BADCHARTS. --Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars (talk) 18:08, 1 May 2011 (UTC) That may...

charts is considered reliable, and the chart is not inclued on the WP:BADCHARTS. Greenock125 (talk) 20:13, 29 April 2012 (UTC) Keep Passes WP:NSONG with...

music for a podcast -- and the "charting" claims here are all tied to WP:BADCHARTS rather than notability-conferring charts: notability because charting...

charting claim doesn't pass NMUSIC #2, as it rests on an uncertified WP:BADCHART (Mediabase) rather than Canada's real notability-making pop charts (Billboard)...

(UTC) Delete Parody group. Also iTunes is not a reliable chart per WP:BADCHARTS. Rockysmile11(talk) 21:08, 26 March 2017 (UTC) Keep there are an impressive...

Chart performance for Aleyce Simmonds version is chart that's on WP:BADCHARTS. Neither McCann's nor Herndon's version charted, nor did any version receive...

hits that did not really chart (or which charted only on a non-notable WP:BADCHART) or nominations for awards that are not prominent enough to pass criterion...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Non notable musician. CMT are badcharts anf not sourced. She lacks coverage in independent reliable sources. A...

 — Berean Hunter (talk) 16:06, 10 February 2019 (UTC) Weak delete per WP:BADCHART. I wouldn't say Spotify has become to the professional music world what...

number-ones of a dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:06, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

reached No. 1 in the iTunes chart, this is considered unreliable under WP:BADCHARTS. The cited sources are standard press releases, and I cannot find any...

for deletion/MYX Hit Chart. The MYX chart has since been listed at WP:BADCHARTS, and it obviously violates WP:SINGLENETWORK. —Kww(talk) 22:36, 4 November...

parent album. The only chart I found it on was a depracated chart WP:BADCHARTS. The article is not likely to expand. Notability of the artist is also...

Comment that billboard you refer to looks like something straight out of WP:BADCHARTS and hardly serves to demonstrate sufficient notability of this artist...

NMUSIC #8, and the chart success claims derive from an uncertified WP:BADCHART (Mediabase), not from the publication (Billboard) that actually qualifies...

chart, which is considered a WP:SINGLENETWORK chart and listed at WP:BADCHARTS. StarcheerspeaksnewslostwarsTalk to me 21:08, 17 July 2015 (UTC) Note:...

all non-WP:RS sources, WP:SINGLEVENDOR unsuitable charts and other WP:BADCHARTS and Youtube view counts. §§Dharmadhyaksha§§ {Talk / Edits} 04:10, 11 September...

Remove the Argentinian chart, since Los 40 Principales is part of WP:BADCHARTS In the Composition and reception section: "The saxophone sound from "Mr...

us here to check the hits. I have and I only found one, that being a WP:BADCHART. Someone else managed to find one other ref to a better chart. That's it...

peaked at #16 on the Canadian iTunes R&B Charts but iTunes doesn't pass WP:BADCHARTS. CBS527Talk 17:57, 13 February 2017 (UTC) Delete - non-notable WP:MUSICBIO...

charts such as Latvia and the Polish National Charts, both listed on WP:BADCHARTS, but, since neither chart is permitted, it doesn't count as a chart. References...

could verify the chart placement, it's actually a non-IFPI-certified WP:BADCHART that doesn't count toward getting an album or an artist over NMUSIC's charting...

grow beyond stub. Has only charted on Los 40 Principales, and, per WP:BADCHARTS, Los 40 Principales is not to be used. Previous efforts to redirect article...

me confirm it. I've found no evidence of this particular chart in our badcharts list. - Mgm|(talk) 09:13, 3 December 2009 (UTC) If for some reason, I...

"GLBT Hall of Fame" doesn't assist notability, and non-IFPI certified WP:BADCHARTS that don't count as notability for the purposes of clearing WP:NMUSIC's...

observations: the year-end charts published by UKChartsPlus are listed at WP:BADCHARTS, and the release history table needs !scope="row"| for consistency with...

Some assertations of notability, but all the charts mentioned are on WP:BADCHARTS (Australian Country Tracks). The awards won do not seem to be notable...

really a single-vendor chart like Spotify or iTunes instead, those are WP:BADCHARTs that cannot confer notability. The only "source" present here at all for...

October 2016 (UTC) A note to this effect should probably be added to WP:BADCHARTS - David Gerard (talk) 05:27, 11 October 2016 (UTC)...

01:16, 7 August 2009 (UTC) Comment it could possibly be included on WP:BADCHARTS. It doesn't appear to be there already, unless I skipped over it somehow...

discussions. North America1000 10:58, 2 February 2019 (UTC) Delete It's a WP:BADCHARTS and always will be. Nate • (chatter) 16:07, 2 February 2019 (UTC) Relisted...

Songwriter Chats" (the fact remains unreferenced) which is one of the WP:BADCHARTS. She has received scarce coverage and has not achieved anything notable...

singles are on the Australian Country Tracks chart, which is listed at WP:BADCHARTS as an unreliable chart. There are claims of notability through awards...

unfortunately, none of your changes meet the notability criteria. 1) Per WP:BADCHARTS, Beatport is not a recognised chart as it is a single vendor chart. 2)...

User:Joesimnett —Preceding undated comment added 19:18, 4 December 2018 (UTC) WP:BADCHARTS The iTunes Store is not a chart. Walter Görlitz (talk) 19:22, 4 December...

images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Single network chart failing WP:BADCHARTS. —Indian:BIO [ ChitChat ] 08:30, 3 March 2015 (UTC) Note: This debate...

charts mentioned in the article are from iTunes, which is listed at WP:BADCHARTS. The only coverage I could find that came close to being significant was...

not confirm the statement, and even so, Beatport is unreliable per WP:BADCHARTS. Delete per WP:PROMOTION. ---DOOMSDAYER520 (Talk|Contribs) 20:18, 15 April...

@Sockie16: the iTunes chart is not considered an important chart per WP:BADCHARTS. Social media such as Twitter and YouTube are not generally considered...

2409:4073:2105:B4E8:0:0:359:C8B1 (talk) 10:27, 21 May 2022 (UTC) IP, please see WP:BADCHARTS: "Charts pertaining to only one specific retailer should not be used."...

DrColePorter 03:42, 30 December 2010 (UTC) No it doesn't. iTunes is on WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters want attention)...

redirect have been thwarted by an IP under the misapprehension that WP:BADCHARTS is an exhaustive list of every bad chart. Given that I pretty much compiled...

May 2011 (UTC) iTunes charts are not to be mentioned in articles per WP:Badcharts.—Iknow23 (talk) 00:36, 12 May 2011 (UTC) Although this entry meets the...

beyond the purely local scene. Chart success is on a non-IFPI certified WP:BADCHART, not on one that can confer notability per NMUSIC #2; appearing on local...

charting on CBC Radio 3, but that's now much more clearly deprecated as a WP:BADCHART that cannot get a band over NMUSIC #2 by itself anymore, and they haven't...

only chart they are on is one that is listed on WP:BADCHARTS. I'm not certain that the WP:BADCHARTS listing is justifiable, but I do know that no one has...

charts are unreliable for purposes of establishing notability; see WP:BADCHARTS. Otherwise this artist is only present in the typical social media and...

Singles Chart (2nd nomination). The Israeli Singles Chart has been on WP:BADCHARTS for a similar length of time. It's a single-network voting playlist: essentially...

UK's Official Charts Company, and not on the basis of just any randoid WP:BADCHART you can find — which means nothing stated here passes WP:NMUSIC, and the...

press releases distributed by newswire service Relaxnews. Possible WP:BADCHART candidate. StarcheerspeaksnewslostwarsTalk to me 04:40, 27 May 2016 (UTC)...

Also, I believe the digital chart should be removed per WP:USCHART/WP:BADCHARTS. Lastly, for the chart section, chartings in different years should appear...

deleting the Cash Box positions from other articles and adding it to WP:BADCHARTS since the positions can't be verified. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and...

coverage. The long-deleted United World Chart and various other charts at WP:BADCHARTS went through the same thing: people were citing the positions here and...

not significant for inclusion, let alone establishing notability (WP:BADCHARTS). In any case, a stand-alone page is not justified because it can be covered...

delete. Listmeister (talk) 20:11, 12 April 2013 (UTC) Per Wikipedia:Badcharts#Deprecated_charts, a guideline, retailer-specific charts, including iTunes...

May 2011 (UTC) iTunes charts are not to be mentioned in articles per WP:Badcharts.—Iknow23 (talk) 00:36, 12 May 2011 (UTC) Although this entry meets the...

March 2009 (UTC) Delete: unofficial non-notable chart, may qualify as WP:BADCHARTS. JamesBurns (talk) 01:06, 15 March 2009 (UTC) Delete as not notable --Boston...

JSTOR · TWL) Previously deleted twice. Band's chart entries are on WP:BADCHARTS; awards do not appear to be notable; sources smell of WP:REFBOMBing. Doesn't...

and WP:MUSICBIO. No awards. Billboard charts are deprecated, per WP:BADCHARTS. Sources cited in article are primary sources (interviews) or trivial...

May 2018 (UTC) RecoChoku is listed as one of deprecated charts in WP:BADCHARTS. You need to show that it has charted in one of the accepted Japanese...

(talk) 05:26, 24 June 2012 (UTC) Internet charts are not reliable per WP:BADCHARTS. If he were on the main Country Breakout chart from Music Row, then maybe...

recently edited by Kww: Special:AbuseFilter/81 - 8,491 hits enforcing WP:BADCHARTS (edited but did not create) Special:AbuseFilter/517 - 0 hits, train station...

opinion piece in the Minnesota Daily. @LilliamPumpernickl134: See WP:BADCHARTS which says "Spotify: Charts pertaining to only one specific retailer should...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Non notable promo single. Claimed charting is BADCHARTS. No significant sales, no national rotation. Lacks coverage in Independent...

chart provider it's talking about. Since the world is filled with WP:BADCHARTS that aren't support for notability (iTunes, standalone radio stations...

but the iTunes UK singles chart, a deprecated chart according to WP:BADCHARTS. Independent coverage seems to be limited to local press articles. Best...

hits that did not really chart (or which charted only on a non-notable WP:BADCHART) or nominations for awards that are not prominent enough to pass criterion...

JSTOR · TWL) Dubious and unreliable Media Traffic chart, also listed at WP:BADCHARTS. Widr (talk) 13:05, 29 August 2014 (UTC) Note: This debate has been included...

either way. One one hand, platform-specific charts like iTunes fails WP:BADCHARTS, but that being said, usually something popular enough to top even a "bad...

have charted, none of the charts are recognized by Wikipedia, per WP:BADCHARTS. Magnolia677 (talk) 11:36, 8 October 2016 (UTC) Note: This debate has...

non-notable radio airplay charts (referenced to a website to avoid per WP:BADCHARTS), links to user-generated content from iMDb and the like to prove the...

stations which just air American artists and call it a day). It's not a WP:BADCHARTS...because it isn't even a chart. It's just a carousel article which exists...

strongest things here are charting on iTunes, which is deprecated by WP:BADCHARTS as not satisfying NMUSIC's "charting hit" criterion (the hit has to be...

notability. Even if it were, there's no mention of the Taiwan charts at WP:BADCHARTS or WP:GOODCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters...

(UTC) Hi NMGS19, Unfortunately Beatport charts are considered to be WP:BADCHARTS Ceethekreator (talk) 16:27, 29 May 2019 (UTC) Hi Ceethekreator, thank...

notability per WP:MUSIC. As an aside, the Aussie country singles charts are WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Otters want attention)...

Cashbox or other RS charts, but in absence of a source that rules out WP:BADCHART, there's nothing that backs up the claim. Her own website states the song...

Tyler is not a credited writer of that song. Claim of iTunes charting (a badchart anyway) is not supported by a source. A search found nothing good. duffbeerforme...

December 2018 (UTC) Actually article is really poorly written. Per WP:BADCHARTS, I don't believe that charting on Highest Global Chart rank automatically...

musician is a song that charted on Beatport, but that's a single-vendor WP:BADCHART that does not pass NMUSIC #2 (which requires national charts on the order...

combination of radio play and listener requests, so it would certainly be WP:BADCHARTS. Article is pure WP:PROMO. Richard3120 (talk) 21:02, 10 November 2016...

WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL) Non notable musician. Claimed charting is BADCHARTS. Touring lacks coverage. Running three non notable businesses does not...

just noticed, several of the charts they were listed as topping were WP:BADCHARTS. Jackmcbarn (talk) 16:00, 26 April 2014 (UTC) I guess you are talking...

are not national. The charts for Rock 108 (which should not be used (WP:BADCHARTS)) suggest local rotation there but claim of 99x rotation is not verified...

Nominator covers the problems with the sources fairly well, as well as WP:BADCHARTS. Additional RS are only tangentially about the subject, or trivial namechecks...

described in their website) is considered serious, others you will find in WP:BADCHARTS not. Second point, yes, the Romanian branch of MF (www.mediaforest.ro)...

needs to be different, however: it needs to look for violations of WP:BADCHARTS ... edits whose effect has been to insert a chart that has been determined...

party notability or charting methodology and failing lists present at WP:BADCHARTS. —Indian:BIO [ ChitChat ] 08:28, 3 March 2015 (UTC) Note: This debate...

reference. Crowley Broadcast Analysis isnt discussed at WP:GOODCHARTS or WP:BADCHARTS. (CK)Lakeshade✽talk2me 00:20, 1 July 2010 (UTC) These recent edits to...

Talk 04:37, 28 August 2021 (UTC) I kinda wonder if we'd consider it a WP:BADCHARTS nowadays - the Flavour of NZ source states Not sales based music charts;...

should be blocked, with a warning message that points the editor at WP:BADCHARTS. Reason:This would block addition of the most commonly added bogus charts...

sources (history)? I think it's a good practice. WP:GOODCHARTS and WP:BADCHARTS are the parallels in the music area, and I'm the primary author of them...

failed WP:BASIC, WP:ANYBIO, and WP:MUSICBIO because the chart failed WP:BADCHARTS (as argued by Magnolia677) and the article was promotional, had excessive...

insistence on adding charts that are either unsourced or are listed on WP:BADCHARTS. When I revert his edits, 83.109.100.230 comes to the rescue. Another...

sources (history)? I think it's a good practice. WP:GOODCHARTS and WP:BADCHARTS are the parallels in the music area, and I'm the primary author of them...

of adding unreliable sources, despite repeatedly being pointed to WP:BADCHARTS.[Talk:Cheap_Thrills_(song)#Colombia.5CCosta_Rica] (note: the IP is SalemHanna...

charts in articles (particularly song and album articles). Currently WP:BADCHARTS specifically disallows use of iTunes charts the discussion is on whether...

everyhit.com/ and the other three charts references. I don't much about WP:BADCHARTS or whatever. Are they all reliable sources for charting? Used in Californication...

(UTC) — Preceding unsigned comment added by Casshums (talk • contribs) WP:BADCHARTS. Neither iTunes nor Amazon are charts. Walter Görlitz (talk) 15:47, 20...

WP:MUSIC. John Nagle (talk) 22:13, 10 December 2016 (UTC) Nope, that's a WP:BADCHART. duffbeerforme (talk) 11:38, 14 December 2016 (UTC) United Family of Anomaly...

when it comes to reliability. Why are they now reliable? aCharts: WP:BADCHARTS states that aCharts is not reliable only for some countries like Italy...

with whose source I am deeply familiar with (especially as far as WP:BADCHARTS is concerned). What kind of source are "Columbia Records (2021). 30 (Media...

TheGreatestLuvofAll (talk) 14:46, 19 March 2024 (UTC) @TheGreatestLuvofAll: per WP:BADCHARTS, iTunes does not qualify, and in any case that source doesn't seem too...

discussions at WT:Record charts over the years, and it was listed on WP:BADCHARTS since the beginning) but I added the edit notice as just a portion of...

hits that did not really chart (or which charted only on a non-notable WP:BADCHART) or nominations for awards that are not prominent enough to pass criterion...

failed WP:BASIC, WP:ANYBIO, and WP:MUSICBIO because the chart failed WP:BADCHARTS (as argued by Magnolia677) and the article was promotional, had excessive...

on the article adding charts they have been told not to add before (WP:BADCHARTS). If the article is not protected, they will continue adding these charts...

Albums Chart. When i pointed out that the rules as WP:GOODCHARTS, WP:BADCHARTS and WP:record charts but the response from the user was "Im french, i...

observations: the year-end charts published by UKChartsPlus are listed at WP:BADCHARTS, and the release history table needs !scope="row"| for consistency with...

I assume the myriad citations to chart positions don't contain any WP:BADCHARTS violations? Oppose until issues are cleaned up. I'll need to run through...

acharts.us was being used as a reference, a deprecated chart listed on WP:BADCHARTS Finally, I was trying to get in touch with the GA reviewer, but he or...

reliable (see WP:CHARTS)  Done No sources in this article are listed in WP:BADCHARTS. EditorEat ma talk page up, scotty! 18:33, 16 July 2013 (UTC) British...

sources. Also, I removed a listing of iTunes Charts, which are on WP:BADCHARTS. 3a. No sections on critical reception of their works. Also, I know Dia...

September 2010 (UTC) Since TenPoundHammer also listed the chart on WP:BADCHARTS (see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Manual_of_St...

→ "in August 2014"  Done iTunes rankings shouldn't be included per WP:BADCHARTS  Done The "M" in AllMusic should be capitalized  Done Only "Billboard"...

81. Since it was released, the following charts have been added to WP:BADCHARTS: Australia Country Tracks Chile Singles Chart Chilean Singles Chart Columbia...

tsort.info to list international chart positions?!!!! That violates WP:BADCHARTS! You seriously need to check harder if the aritcle entirely meets 1(c)...

mill song which only charted on the Billboard Twitter Real-Time (on WP:BADCHARTS) and made it to 90 on the TurnTable Top 100 for Nigeria (not on WP:GOODCHARTS)...

everyhit.com/ and the other three charts references. I don't much about WP:BADCHARTS or whatever. Are they all reliable sources for charting? Used in Californication...

Colombian, and min-skirt. Done. Per WP:BADCHARTS, removed information about video countdowns. WP:BADCHARTS says nothing about video countdowns. I believe...

territory. Album appearances, and soundtracks are unsourced. According to WP:BADCHARTS, Acharts should not be used if there is another available source for chartings...

rationale: Per WP:OCAT this could be categorised as WP:TOPTEN, and also per WP:BADCHARTS, Spotify chart is NOT an official record chart in music-related articles...

Also, I believe the digital chart should be removed per WP:USCHART/WP:BADCHARTS. Lastly, for the chart section, chartings in different years should appear...

territory. Album appearances, and soundtracks are unsourced. According to WP:BADCHARTS, Acharts should not be used if there is another available source for chartings...

Remove the Argentinian chart, since Los 40 Principales is part of WP:BADCHARTS In the Composition and reception section: "The saxophone sound from "Mr...

be on WP:BADCHARTS due to a lack of an accessible archive, but the existence of worldradiohistory was enough to get them taken off WP:BADCHARTS. How else...

makes the band notable under WP:BAND. R&R is not listed in either WP:BADCHARTS or WP:GOODCHARTS, so whether Windows meets criterion 2 is debatable. As...

that a song did well on the iTunes charts, but that's a single-vendor WP:BADCHART that does not pass NMUSIC's charting criterion -- notability because charting...

hits that did not really chart (or which charted only on a non-notable WP:BADCHART) or nominations for awards that are not prominent enough to pass criterion...

vendor chart (Anghami) that his songs have appeared on is considered a WP:BADCHART. The Top Naija Music Awards is not a credible award in my opinion.  Versace1608 ...

sales charts". It has ranked 59 on Sverigetopplistan, which is not a WP:BADCHART. बिनोद थारू (talk) 05:05, 26 November 2023 (UTC) Per WP:NSINGLE: Has been...

The attempted notability claim here is that the song charted on a WP:BADCHART that does not pass NMUSIC's charting criterion (which is looking for IFPI-certified...

charing on Apple Music music chart. However, this chart is considered a WP:BADCHART. References 2, 4, and 10 are unreliable promotional references. References...

criteria, there is no evidence per my WP:BEFORE that any are met. WP:BADCHARTS applies to the claim that the band has charted. —Alalch E. 06:11, 7 December...

methodology or claim to significance, so would appear to be a candidate for WP:BADCHARTS. The sources are: a link to a podcast episode about the album; an interview...

Temporary semi-protection: Persistent vandalism – Edit warring over WP:BADCHARTS. Ten Pound Hammer • (What did I screw up now?) 20:11, 2 October 2025 (UTC)...

with whose source I am deeply familiar with (especially as far as WP:BADCHARTS is concerned). What kind of source are "Columbia Records (2021). 30 (Media...

to remove retailer-specific charts that are explicitly banned per WP:BADCHARTS - if you look through my editing history, music is a big interest of mine)...