As described in a film magazine review,[5] patrolman Larry O'Day loses his job on the police force due to a misadventure in which jeweler Thomas Egan's daughter Nelly is concerned. International famous detective John Granger is aiding the police in pursuit of the notorious Brady gang. Larry takes a hand in the game, and after a fight he captures Granger and two confederates while they were looting the Egan store. It transpires that the real Granger is dead, and a crook has been impersonating him. Larry is reinstated with the police force, promoted, and then marries Nelly.
^Pardy, George T. (February 20, 1926), "Pre-Release Review of Features: The Handsome Brute", Motion Picture News, 33 (8), New York City, New York: Motion Picture News, Inc.: 910, retrieved March 20, 2023 This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.