Andy Schaeffer is a spoiled mama's boy who usually gets his way. He breezes through college, while girlfriend Susan Daniels works hard at a job to pay for her education. She isn't sure where their relationship is going. Andy's grades begin to worsen, and he's being drafted by the army. Andy reports for basic training at Fort Ord, making it clear to everybody there that he'd rather be anyplace else.
Hargrove agreed but wanted the story to be accurate, as he had left the army in 1945. He arranged through Warners to undertake enlistment and some basic training at Fort Ord. Hargrove told Warners he had enough material for the book. The studio paid him to write the novel and retained only the screen rights.[2]
The novel was published in 1956. Hargrove wanted to call it All Quiet in the Third Platoon, but Warners preferred The Girl He Left Behind.[3]
Tab Hunter and Natalie Wood had appeared in The Burning Hills together, and Warner Bros. was keen to build them into an on-screen team.[4]
Filming started May 1956.[5] Much of the film was shot at Fort Ord and used real soldiers.[2] "We had a very nice company and a very nice cast," said director David Butler, who claims he recommended James Garner play the lead, but had to accept Hunter.[6]
Tab Hunter recalled, "David Butler was more of a traffic cop than a director, keeping us on time, under budget, and thoroughly uninspired. The most memorable thing about the film was the supporting cast, brimming with more fresh talent: James Garner, David Janssen, Alan King, Henry Jones, and Murray Hamilton — all destined for long careers."[7]
Hunter said Natalie's Wood's "development" since The Burning Hills "was incredible. She became freer with herself in the way she used her face and body. She was maturing as a woman and an actress, and while her mother drilled her to never bite the hand that fed her... she privately groused about being stuck in such a tiny, lame role, unworthy of an Oscar nominee."[7]
James Garner had a small role. He later said the film "was awful and I was awful, but it was the best I could do at the time."[8]
Reception
Variety said "Film, with sometimes serious overtones, is mainly episodic and smacks of the service comedies turned out during World War II, but provides entertaining fare for the youthful and family trade."[9]
The film was the 72nd highest grossing film of 1957.[1]
