Shortcuts {{oddTemplate:Odd}} {{dubTemplate:Dub}} {{debatableTemplate:Debatable}} Add {{Dubious}} after a specific statement or alleged fact...

11 December 2016 (UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that Debatable and Make Me an Egghead were both commissioned for 20 half-hour episodes...

class. {{infobox motion | name = | class = | inorder = | seconded = | debatable = | amendable = | voterequired = | reconsidered = }} Entering the characteristics...

Shortcuts {{oddTemplate:Odd}} {{dubTemplate:Dub}} {{debatableTemplate:Debatable}} Add {{Dubious}} after a specific statement or alleged fact that is sourced...

06:08, 7 December 2016 (UTC) ( Back to TM:TDYK Article history ) ... that Debatable and Make Me an Egghead were both commissioned for 20 half-hour episodes...

class. {{infobox motion | name = | class = | inorder = | seconded = | debatable = | amendable = | voterequired = | reconsidered = }} Entering the characteristics...

Shortcuts {{oddTemplate:Odd}} {{dubTemplate:Dub}} {{debatableTemplate:Debatable}} Add {{Dubious}} after a specific statement or alleged fact...

04:50, 3 September 2011 (UTC) Hook: Interesting enough, hook fact is debatable but cited, short enough. Article: Long enough, D9 on the date as this...

seems that determining what exactly constitutes a recording session is debatable. Whereas one session may end with the recordings being put onto record...

nominated at 00:56, 16 January 2015 (UTC). Most of the information here is debatable and it was removed from the original article. I believe my nomination...

sufficient and generally drawn from reliable published sources. (This one is debatable, but not overly so. Also, per MOS:ALLCAPS, the references which use all...

(UTC) Hi, I came by to promote this, but I wonder if the hook fact is debatable. This source names different record-holders, and there are others on a...

at 02:54, 19 October 2012 (UTC) The claim seems partially true, though debatable. It was likely the first feature film, so that would have to be qualified...

edit) Template:Disputed Point (redirect page) (links | edit) Template:Debatable (redirect page) (links | edit) Template:Disputable (redirect page) (links...

change in the hook, removing the word "unsuccessful" since the term is debatable (success means different things to different people) and the hook already...

expansion. Counting from 384 bytes on December 22nd it is long enough. (It is debatable whether this is the correct pre-expansion size but I am using my discretion...

centre specifically. Whether this needs to be made clear in the hook is debatable. When promoting, I would suggest tweaking the wording in both hooks as...

edit) Template:Disputed Point (redirect page) (links | edit) Template:Debatable (redirect page) (links | edit) Template:Disputable (redirect page) (links...

Cartwright in the development of the Knickerbocker rules." (p. 33) It's also debatable whether the 1845 Knickerbocker rules were "the first set of baseball rules...

Still, removed one hook from the queue, again.... Hook fact is at least debatable, and probably wrong; it wasn't supported by the body of the source used...

quote there needs a ref. Wiki-links the first time, - a second time is debatable, - yes when long ago, or when readers might read only a section where...

Reviewed: Fatimid desecration of Jerusalem Comment: It is admittedly debatable whether the first hook "involves the real world in some way" sufficient...

and so the extent to which such sources can be considered reliable is debatable. I'd prefer a MEDRS level of sourcing – reviews or other statements of...

shopfronts on Brunswick Street." Whether or not it "ended" is actually debatable, arguably it just paused, but the source is the source. ALT1: ... that...

"rest of the world" than that it was some sort of first. First are always debatable as they depend on the exact parameters chosen. There were two beneficiaries...

sourcing: Neutral: - debatable, see below Free of copyright violations, plagiarism, and close paraphrasing: Hook eligibility: Cited: - debatable Interesting:...

prom? The dystopia/prom contrast seems more "hooky" to me. But that's debatable, if you don't agree, then your proposed hook is fine as is. GRuban (talk)...

sources that are independent of the subject of the article". I think it's debatable, to be honest. He's famous for one thing. Secretlondon (talk) 18:08, 7...

Self-nominated at 20:57, 26 November 2015 (UTC). New enough (this is sort of debatable because while there's been continual development, no work was done between...

earlier types of tactical jet fighter in that service. If the issue seems debatable then we might quote the presidential commendation [1]: ALT1: * ... that...

States". Yoninah (talk) 23:06, 8 June 2016 (UTC) @Yoninah: No problem. It's debatable that the article had any close paraphrasing, because information can only...

like to include something other than "biggest/worst" (as that is always debatable) so I'm partial to something close to ALT0/ALT3, but I am generally terrible...

DYKcheck, well under the minimum required. The first (Idaho) review is more debatable, since DYKcheck gives 1581 characters, though I'm dubious about counting...

praised for making issues that are rarely dealt with in Ukraine in public debatable? ALT2:... that 2019 Ukrainian teen drama Early Swallows was responsible...

As for the box, it was the choice of the editor who added it, and it's debatable (I can live with it as is.) Best, Andreas JN466 02:22, 20 September 2017...

books and even novels, including for the material cited in the hook. It's debatable whether this is really a noteworthy enough subject for an article at all...

looks good here, with some elements already covered at GAN. Slightly debatable where there's an inline citation for the hook fact right after it appears...

fictional character, what it means to "run for President" is inherently debatable, but hopefully that's clear enough. That campaign materials were produced...

delete "...and the foundation of General Practice in England." That is debatable and a bold statement like that should be expanded later in article (see...

approving ALT0 (the main one), however: the interestingness of ALT1 is debatable, as I don't find it quite suprising that one would threaten sue another...

have any copyright issues. However, the fact mentioned in the hook is debatable. The hook states that he knelt but did not bow before Elizabeth II. The...

architecture training platform. Basically the only source I'd consider even debatable for reliability is Hangzhou.com.cn, and that only because I don't know...

visiting the Shanghai's Tianfei Palace at the right time? Reviewed: Will do Debatable Comment: @Reviewers: Don't worry. You only need to review the cites for...

behind in Pinhal. Whether the Portuguese actually attacked Pinhal is debatable: Sousa Pinto says the Portuguese did not attack Pinhal since it would...

see, but suspect might be an entry of a large list; WP:RSNP calls it debatable), other database entries, and that's about it, really. I can barely see...

color". All of these claims are rather vague, and their independence is debatable. Is there no other coverage of the rally available? Edwardx (talk) 12:28...

"European" because Madaba was not European and the Crusader ones are debatable. ALT1... that almost all pre-modern historical maps of Jerusalem were...

really comfortable promoting a hook that is well-sourced but at least debatable. Fram (talk) 11:24, 14 October 2014 (UTC) Well, you're absolutely right...

Bengal. - According to whom? Based on the controversy section, this is debatable. Grammar is stilted Who is Mamata Banerjee Extensive controversy and criticism...

interesting. It might appeal to fans of The Voice, but it might be more debatable for non-fans. Narutolovehinata5 (talk · contributions) 00:39, 7 February...

(UTC). * This article is new enough and long enough. The original hook is debatable and ALT1 would have been more suitable if this was a joint nomination...

source, it was an award for 1983 that was published in a 1984 issue. It's debatable for the hook to say it was won in 1983, "for 1983" seems more accurate...

strong preference to the short main hook. ALT2 is from a newspaper and debatable, and alt1 is historical trivia about a single individual. --Piotr Konieczny...

kosher? Maury Markowitz (talk) 17:02, 27 September 2021 (UTC) That's ... debatable! I'd say a picture focusing on the controller would be kosher and on the...

problems: Overall: The only issue I can see is the hook's interesting-ness is debatable, and might not appeal to a wide audience. I found it pretty interesting...

current form of the name is already cited, admittedly common, and easily debatable as the common english form of the name. My opinion is that there is no...

Linking to Hooker (rugby union) would be the bare minimum to make this even debatable. Even then the ALT hook seems more informative. Huon (talk) 18:42, 22...

16 November 2022 (UTC). Policy compliance: Adequate sourcing: - highly debatable; the first three sources I looked at are close to unusable, and I would...

tag is a big deal, in multiple sources. "Not encyclopedic writing" is debatable; more important "brilliant prose" isn't a DYK criterion, this isn't a...

first suggestion does seem interesting to me. The second one, though, is debatable, as not all street signs within the city have English names (as some carry...

appears to have stuck. Whether the characters are gay or bisexual is also debatable. I think all the media sources refer to the movie as being India's first...

spoke to God) Ibrāhīm Khalīlullāh (Abraham Friend of God) Nūḥ (Noah) Debatable ones ʿUzayr (Ezra?) Dhū'l-Qarnayn Luqmān Maryam (Mary) Ṭālūt (Saul or...

and close paraphrasing: Hook eligibility: Cited: - The timing seems debatable as the pickelhaube article says that steel started to be used in 1915...

3% which is negligible. The extensive quotes and lengthy synopsis are debatable but I don't consider these to be show-stoppers and so we can move forward...

template is needed on the talk page. Hook eligibility: Cited: - The hook is debatable as other sources say that it's the Lunar Roving Vehicle (e.g. Lunar rover:...

cite it in the article, ideally in the #Career section. B) I know it's debatable but I don't really think the source supports the idea that he was/felt...

regarding the hook ALT5: what does "19th century" add? "Awakening" seems debatable. May we not mention Russia? Opression was severe enough to shoot the one...

species. "Or anything to do with Argentina's etymology" seems so OR-y and debatable; both of them come from the same Latin word. Neutral: Free of copyright...

North Mainland, South Mainland, West Mainland) Fetlar Unst Whalsay Yell North Isles Border areas Debatable Lands East March Middle March West March...

The press exerted a force of 50,000 tons and was 10 stories high. It is debatable if the ship is a single machine or the ship's engines, hoist etc. are...

still reckon we should nix this. The very definition of the topic seems debatable. Currently the article relies for this upon Hugh, Camille (June 30, 2013)...

the latter, and while Kirby's role in the creation of Iron Man may be debatable, this is not the case with several other, arguably more long-term notable...

There's virtually nothing about his personal life, and it's at best debatable if the article "adequately" deals with the subject. I don't expect personal...

though you can argue your side and we can argue ours, the mere fact it's debatable means we shouldn't be picking a side to put on the MP. Because that would...

blatantly untrue. 17 million British people may have told the EU to fuck off (debatable), but the British did NOT tell the EU to fuck off 17 million times. For...

between a coach service and an express bus service. This seems quite debatable and so we can't promote this without better support from sources. This...

it now? Daniel Case (talk) 05:33, 27 October 2015 (UTC) ALT3 seems too debatable. The most famous street in Canada, by a long way, has to be Yonge Street...

content from 2022–2023 Blue Nile clashes wasn't added, although it is debatable if that article was used at all, as the content is rewritten entirely...

Peter III John VI Peter IV Maria II Miguel I Maria II with Ferdinand II Peter V Luís I Carlos I Manuel II Debatable or disputed rulers are in italics....

wasn't a murder under British law, whether it is one more informally is debatable but this was supposedly a fistfight that ended with a fatal fall, the...

dealing with here. So, ALT0 is not approved. ALT1 is fine and ALT2 is debatable. We can make progress with ALT1 and so that gets a . One other point is...

is assumed to be the source. Whether or not this should be the case is debatable, but that's how things stand ATM, so a nomination should not be rejected...

with "Expandable card game" as the article title. The WP:COMMONTERM is debatable, and since "Living card game" is a copyrighted term, we should not underestimate...

Zen Healing? The use of quotations, or rather the overuse of them, is debatable, I think, but I could go through and paraphrase them if you like. And...

suggested hooks are in Cronica Walliae. The stories themselves may be debatable by modern scholars, but that is a different issue. The stories themselves...

nominations. This may be too WP:SYNTH to use, though WP:CALC makes it a bit debatable; but just as an example of how much of the entry it seems to me we're...

the same author. Whether that is best labelled as a copyvio or not is debatable, but I believe that there is a serious problem in basing such a lengthy...

sensible to leave in order to seek to spawn new articles. The third is debatable. All references filled and consolidated using reFill. One had to be done...

taking on this monster. But whether 3A gives away too much is of course debatable -- personally I believe the reader will think, "Really? She showed that...

species is ancestral to any other, or anything about molecular clocks. It's debatable whether or not this is a DYK blocker, but I think it should be. The second...

they themselves contain, i.e., those opinions themselves. (It is also debatable that court opinions are primary sources, more like secondary sources,...

antisemitism at large. The antisemitic nature of this particular item are debatable - most owners in Poland see it as a harmless folk superstition.Icewhiz...

from a western province.") So his connection to Britain is, admittedly, debatable. Now I suspect your concern is over the portion that he was maybe the...

based on it not having done "enough" to rescue Jews -- which depends on debatable definitions of what is "enough" (it's not enough that they supplied Jewish...

but for feuding with a school and/or getting a Rhodes scholarship on debatable pretext. That's what our article should be about, and honestly, that wheat...

22 June 2024 (UTC). Policy compliance: Adequate sourcing: Neutral: - yDebatable. I don't see a single source that actually agrees that the rifle is actually...

concerns, copied from WT:DYK:) I find the term [Eternal life] itself debatable, also the (of course) simplifying hook, and at least one unexplained line...

your guidance. convinced - rephrased to make stronger - it's not really debatable that the ruling was a direct outcome of the case. That was the point of...

wp:rm and/or wp:rfc to pull in more voices though. 30-40% certainly is debatable (not entirely wrong like you seem to think I'm saying) but it does seem...

his own actions and their consequences, but "unduly" is definitely a debatable point. 24.151.116.25 (talk) 20:31, 15 March 2014 (UTC) It appears that...

saw-tooth banksia and red honeysuckle), including the last two in lead is debatable as they aren't used much anymore, if at all. Cas Liber (talk · contribs)...

contentious part. The list of subjects isn't referenced and, at least debatably, parts of history, linguistics, philosophy (cf mathematics), are scientific...

Whether or not she had an especial predilection for Italian opera is debatable. She herself seems to have been very fond of French opera, whose diminished...

approach appears to be unsourced. Further this claim appears to be a highly debatable assertion. The managerial school was known prior to the 1950s and 60s...

WP:CHICAGO / WP:WAWARD) 02:12, 28 August 2025 (UTC) It's per WP:DYKTRIM. It's debatable if mentioning the exact amount is necessary to the hook fact. I'm not...

don't think anyone should be nominating COI articles at DYK. It's very debatable if this article should even have been written by Tony in the first place...

of Thames Estuary — North Sea (the few settlements further along the debatable estuary to the two points mentioned in the routemap are on inlets or far...

to fix. Basically I just search for " and see if these are quotes of a debatable statement of opinion, and the attribution is not obvious from the sentence...

this happened. This piece was named oratorio 13 years later (and it's debatable if it even is one, - not much changed from the cantata is was in 1725...