As president, Fillmore has a poor or unremarkable reputation amongst the general American public,[2][3] primarily due to his stance on slavery.[1] Although personally opposed to the institution, as president he signed into law the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 as part of the larger Compromise of 1850, which mandated that escaped slaves in free states be returned to their owners in slave states.[1] However, in Buffalo, Fillmore enjoyed a large amount of public support due to his actions in the community,[2][3] as he was a founder of the University at Buffalo and was influential in establishing numerous public institutions in the city, such as several museums and libraries.[1]
Erection
A public statue honoring Fillmore was part of the original overall plans for the design of Buffalo City Hall.[4]Bryant Baker, a world-renowned sculptor based in New York City,[5] designed the statue,[2][3] as well as a nearby statue of Grover Cleveland, another president from Buffalo.[5][6] Both of these statues were crafted in 1930 and dedicated at the same time on July 1, 1932.[5][7] The Fillmore statue was paid for by a $25,000 (equivalent to $456,000 in 2023) appropriation from the New York State Legislature.[5]
In July 2020, The Spectrum, the student newspaper of the University at Buffalo, published an opinion piece from Professor Robert Silverman of the university's Department of Regional and Urban Planning advocating for the removal of the statue and other public honors to Fillmore.[8] The opinion piece was published following the Buffalo police shoving incident that occurred near the statue amidst the then-ongoing George Floyd protests and argued that Fillmore's legacy included supporting slave patrols and opposing civil rights for freedmen following the American Civil War.[8] This opinion piece followed a 2015 request from the local NAACP chapter in Buffalo asking the city to cease naming things in honor of Fillmore.[1] In response, in 2020, Buffalo MayorByron Brown requested the city government to review all of the city's public monuments.[1]
Design
The monument consists of a bronze statue of Fillmore atop a granitepedestal.[7] The statue is roughly 9 feet (2.7 m) tall and occupies a square base with side measurements of 3 ft (0.91 m), while the pedestal is 5 ft 6 in (1.68 m) and has length and width measurements of 5 ft (1.5 m) each.[7] Fillmore stands wearing a Prince Albert coat and a cloak.[7] The bottom front of the statue's bronze bears the sculptor's marks signature and year ("Bryant Baker 1932"), while the pedestal bears the following inscriptions:[7]
MILLARD FILLMORE / 1800-1874 / 13th PRESIDENT OF / THE U.S. / LAWYER / EDUCATOR / PHILANTHROPIST / STATESMAN
— Front
E. PLURIBUS UNUM
— Left
Erected by / the State of New York / to honor an illustrious / citizen of Buffalo
— Rear
Additionally, the right side of the pedestal bears the city's seal.[7]
The statue is situated in a triangular plot outside of the city hall,[6] at the southeast corner to the left of the front entrance.[2][3][7] The statue of Cleveland is situated in a triangular plot on the other side of the entrance.[6]