The design was loosely based on that of Salisbury Cathedral.[2] It is Grade II* listed.[3] The first vicar was Thomas Jackson, who, as a young rector, was attracting congregations from all over London by his reputation as a preacher. The church's steeple, however, was not completed until 1890, by Scott's son John Oldrid Scott, which led to a humorous rhyme being composed:
"Stoke Newington's a funny place With lots of funny people; Thomas Jackson built a church But could not build a steeple."