The Renegade Twins debuted in All Elite Wrestling on the January 11, 2022, episode of AEW Dark where they faced TayJay (Anna Jay and Tay Conti) in a losing effort.[3] They appeared again on the March 28 episode of AEW Dark: Elevation where they faced the team of Anna Jay and Ruby Soho and also lost.[4] On the July 19 episode of AEW Dark, they had their first win in AEW when they defeated Avery Breaux and Valentina Rossi.[5]
On the December 24, 2022, episode of the NWA Christmas Special, the Renegade Twins made their NWA debut, losing to the NWA World Women's Tag Team ChampionsPretty Empowered (Ella Envy and Kenzie Paige).[6][7] On the February 7, 2023, episode of NWA Powerrr, they defeated Pretty Empowered, which earned the twins a title shot at Nuff Said.[8] On February 11, at Nuff Said, the Renegade Twins defeated Pretty Empowered to win the NWA World Women's Tag Team Championship,[9][10] but then lost the titles on the February 21 episode of NWA Powerrr to Pretty Empowered 2.0.[11][12]
The Renegade Twins made their Ring of Honor debut on the March 2, 2023, episode of Ring of Honor Wrestling, losing to Madison Rayne and Skye Blue.[13] They would have their first ROH win on the July 27 episode of Ring of Honor Wrestling, defeating JC and Tiara James.[14] On the August 10 episode of Ring of Honor Wrestling, Robyn lost to Billie Starkz, leading the Renegades to attack Starkz, which was stopped by Athena.[15]
On the February 10, 2024, taping of Ring of Honor Wrestling, Robyn Renegade once more had another match against Billie Starkz, but this time the match was a first round tournament match to determine the inaugural ROH Women's World Television Championship holder. Robyn was once more unsuccessful at defeating Billie Starkz, who advanced in the tournament.[16]
^Lopez, Joshua (February 21, 2023). "NWA Powerrr Results 2/21/23". Wrestling Headlines. Archived from the original on November 14, 2022. Retrieved March 19, 2023.