The Pluckemin Presbyterian Church complex is central to the district, rated pivotal. The church was built in 1851. It is located on the site of the former St. Paul's Lutheran Church built in 1757. British Captain William Leslie, who died during the Battle of Princeton on January 3, 1777, is buried in the graveyard of the former church.[3]
The Daughaday House, Strupp House, and McKiernan House are pivotal contributions to the district.[3]
The Center for Contemporary Art was once a former township building and school. The two-story four-room Pluckemin School House was built in 1912 and is rated a pivotal building in the district.[3][4]
The Pluckemin Inn, a restaurant and wine cellar - opened in 2005 and was built on the site of the revolutionary-war era tavern also called the Pluckemin Inn.[5] The tavern was a popular resting spot and refreshment choice for General Washington's continental army during the revolutionary war.[6] The building was built in 2005 and modeled after a revolutionary-war era farm house and is often quoted as the restaurant is situated within a "revolutionary war farm house." It is a contributing building due to the site it's on rather than the building iteself.[3]