Despite the existence of established major league representation in Philadelphia, the Phillies of the National League (NL) and the Athletics of the AA, the new PL franchise was able to sign veteran players, including Buffinton, Billy Shindle, George Wood, and Ben Sanders.[6][7] The Quakers finished the season with a 68–63 win–loss record, with one tie, placing them fifth among the eight PL teams.[6]
Following the 1890 season, many players returned to their previous teams; however, the Athletics were able to sign quality veteran players, including Gus Weyhing, Elton Chamberlain, and Pop Corkhill.[8] The team completed the season with a 73–66 win–loss record, with four ties, placing them fifth among nine teams.[9] Following the 1891 season, the AA could no longer operate because of great financial losses, and was forced to fold; four of its teams became part of the NL, and the others, including the Athletics, accepted buyouts.[10] George Wood led the franchise in many batting categories, including; batting average with .299, at bats with 1067, hits with 319, and runs scored with 220.[11]Jocko Milligan's 44 doubles and 14 home runs led the franchise, while Weyhing's 31 wins in 1891 is tops among the pitching leaders, as well as his 3.18 earned run average.[11]
In his final major league season, Bowman was signed on August 24, and finished with a 2–5 win–loss record in eight games pitched, while also playing six games in the outfield.
During his lone season with the franchise, Buffinton had a 19–15 win–loss record as a pitcher, and a 3.81 earned run average. He was the team's player-manager for 116 games, taking over for Jim Fogarty after 16 games, and the team finished the season with a 61–54 win–loss record, for a .530 winning percentage.
Signed as an amateur free agent, Clymer's major league career consisted of three appearances with the Athletics. In 11 at bats, he did not collect a hit.
Corcoran appeared in 133 games played for the Athletics, had a batting average of .254, scored 84 runs, and hit 15 triples in 511 at bats, while leading all shortstops with 300 putouts.
Cross spent most of his first season with the team as a catcher, while playing sparingly in right field. However, he split time between the two evenly the following season. In 1891, he had a batting average of .301 in 110 games.
In his last major league season, Fogarty played in 91 games, and was the team's initial manager. After 16 games, and a 7–9 win–loss record, he was replaced by Charlie Buffinton for the remainder of the season.
Friel appeared in two games for the Athletics, collecting two hits in eight at bats, for a .250 batting average. It was the last of his two major league seasons.
During his lone season with the Quakers, Griffin appeared in 115 games, collecting 140 hits, scored 127 runs, and had a .286 batting average in 489 at bats.
After appearing in 84 games for the 1890 team as a utility player, Hallman was the everyday second baseman for 1891 team, leading the league in games played.
McGeachey played with the Athletics in two different stints during the 1891 season; he began the season playing 46 games before moving onto the Boston Reds for 41 more. He later returned to play four games in Philadelphia to finish the season, his last in the major leagues.
In his second and final major league season, McKeough appeared in 15 games, 14 as a catcher, and collected 14 hits in 54 at bats for a .259 batting average.
McTamany was signed on July 24, after having previously played for the Columbus Solons during the 1891 season. Although he led the league's outfielders in games played, it was his final major league season.
After playing for the 1890 team, he returned to his previous team, the St. Louis Browns, but was purchased by Philadelphia in February. He led the AA with 35 doubles, but led the league with 40 passed balls as well.
Sanders pitched in both of the franchise's seasons, and had win–loss records of 19–18 and 11–5, with earned run averages of 3.79 and 3.76 respectively.
As the starting shortstop for his lone season with the franchise, Shindle had a batting average of .324, collected 21 doubles, 21 triples, 10 home runs, and 189 hits, and scored 127 runs.
Sullivan began the season with the Athletics, appearing in two games and had a 0–2 win–loss record before finishing the season with the New York Giants of the NL.
Wood was the franchise's starting left fielder for both seasons. He had batting averages of .289 and .309, and collected 109 runs batted in in 1890. In 1891, he became the team's manager, taking over for Bill Sharsig 27 games into the season.