From 2008 to 2013, List had a recurring role as Jane Siegel in the AMC period drama Mad Men. In film, she has appeared in The Greatest Game Ever Played (2005), Shuttle (2009) and Meeting Evil (2012). List also starred in the short-lived science fiction dramas FlashForward (ABC, 2009–2010), and The Tomorrow People (The CW, 2013–2014). During the 2016–17 television season, she starred as the lead character in The CW drama series Frequency. In 2018, she had a recurring role in season 3 of the science fiction series Colony. She also starred on a recurring basis as Poison Ivy in the Fox crime drama series Gotham (2018–2019), and voiced the character in the 2019 animated film Batman: Hush.
At the age of nine, she began a career as a model.[1] Her first significant commercial appearance was with her sister as one of the "daughters next door" in Washington Square.
In 2006, List was a series regular on the NBC drama Windfall, as Tally Reida. The series was canceled after one season, and List had a recurring role on the short-lived ABC drama Day Break. During the 2007 pilot season, List was cast in another ABC series, Big Shots, in which she played the role of Cameron Collinsworth, daughter of Dylan McDermott's character. The series also was canceled after one season. List also guest-starred on several television shows, including Moonlight, Ghost Whisperer, CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, Monk, Hawaii Five-0, and House of Lies. From 2008 to 2013, List appeared in a recurring role on the AMC series Mad Men, playing Don Draper's fill-in secretary who later became Roger Sterling's second wife. From 2009 to 2010, List starred on another ABC series FlashForward, as Nicole Kirby.[2] In film, she appeared in The Greatest Game Ever Played (2005), Shuttle (2008), and Meeting Evil (2011).
In 2013, List was cast in the female lead role of Cara Coburn on The CW series The Tomorrow People.[4] The series was cancelled after a single season. The following year, she had recurring roles in the CW series The Flash and in ABC's short-lived prime time soap opera Blood & Oil. In 2016, she was cast as lead character in the CW science fiction police drama Frequency.[5][6]
List shares the same name with a fellow actress, Peyton List, born in 1998.[8][9] The younger List was interviewed by Access Hollywood, saying she uses Peyton R. List to avoid confusion.[8] Union SAG-AFTRA's policy prohibits actors with the same name; however, this instance of identical professional names went unnoticed.[8]
They appeared in the same scene—when the older List starred on As the World Turns as Lucy Montgomery.[8][10] Years later, the younger List cited confusion when they stayed at the same hotel—they received daily call sheets and voicemails for each other.[8]IndieWire noted the confusion appeared on the website Wikipedia, where both actresses's articles started out with exactly the same introduction text of: "Peyton List is an American actress and model."[9] Both actresses provided voice performances for Batman: Hush (2019).
^ abNguyen, Hanh (October 5, 2016). "Peyton List-icle: 6 Ways to Identify Which Peyton List Is Which". IndieWire. Retrieved November 29, 2016. 'Peyton List is an American actress and model.' This Wikipedia description is accurate and true. The problem? It's true about two different people. That's right. Two Peyton Lists are working actresses and models. Two Peyton Lists are, um, listed on IMDb. Two Peyton Lists are currently on our TVs. Two Peyton Lists are confusing our Google searches. Two Peyton Lists are messing with our minds.