Puflett started his career with the Western Sydney Wanderers FC, playing for its Under-21 team, scoring 5 goals in 11 games over 2 years. He also won the Y-League title in the 2017–18 season with them.[1]
He then made his debut a day after his signing, scoring a goal with an exquisite lobbed finish on his professional debut in a Uniform Derby win against Warriors FC.[2]