New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division

The four departments of the Appellate Division have a common seal design.^[1]

The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York is the intermediate appellate court in New York State.^[2] The state is geographically divided into four judicial departments of the Appellate Division.^[3] The full title of each is, using the "Fourth Department" as an example, the "Supreme Court of the State of New York, Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department".^[4]

Jurisdiction

The Appellate Division primarily hears appeals from the state's superior courts (Supreme Court, Surrogate's Court, Family Court, Court of Claims, the county courts) in civil cases, the Supreme Court in criminal cases, and, in the Third and Fourth Judicial Departments, from the county courts in felony criminal cases.^[5] In addition, in civil cases it may hear appeals from the appellate terms of the Supreme Court when these courts have heard appeals from one of the lower trial courts.

New York's rules of civil procedure allow for interlocutory appeals of right from nearly every order and decision of the trial court,^[6] meaning that most may be appealed to the appropriate appellate department while the case is still pending in the trial court.[[

Map of the four departments of the
New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division

First Department	Second Department
Third Department	Fourth Department

The Appellate Division may make decisions of law and fact with respect to its power to hear first appeals from state trial courts, including the Supreme Court and County Courts. These trial level courts exercise specific jurisdiction as conferred by law.^[7] In contrast, both the New York Court of Appeals and the Appellate Division, when it sits as a final appeals court with respect to appeals arising from decisions of the Appellate Terms in the First and Second Departments, generally may only decide questions of law.^{[citation needed]} The Appellate Division may adjudicate facts subject to specific constraints in the course of initial review of agency decisions under New York's CPLR Article 78, which provides for limited court review or agency and corporate decisions.

Decisions of the Appellate Division departments are binding on the lower courts in that department, and also on lower courts in other departments unless there is contrary authority from the Appellate Division of that department.^[8][9] If two different departments have made different rulings on the same issue, then the lower courts in each departmental area must follow the ruling made by their respective department. This can sometimes result in the same law being applied differently in different departments. When this occurs, the highest court in the state, the Court of Appeals, can remedy the situation by hearing the case and issuing a single ruling, which is then binding on every court in the state.^[10] Every opinion, memorandum, and motion of the Appellate Division sent to the New York State Reporter of the New York State Law Reporting Bureau is required to be published in the Appellate Division Reports.^[11][12][13] Opinions of the appellate terms are published selectively in the Miscellaneous Reports.^[12][14]

Organization

Appellate Division Courthouse of New York State in Manhattan, New York City, home of the First Department of the Appellate Division

The Monroe Place Courthouse in Brooklyn, New York City, home of the Second Department of the Appellate Division

Albany, Third Department

Rochester, Fourth Department

Departments

• The First Department, seated in Manhattan, covers both The Bronx (Bronx County) and Manhattan (New York County).^[4][15] Justice Dianne Renwick has been the department's Presiding Justice since June 21, 2023.^[16]
• The Second Department, seated in Brooklyn, covers Queens (Queens County), Brooklyn (Kings County), Staten Island (Richmond County), Long Island (Nassau and Suffolk counties) and Dutchess, Orange, Putnam, Rockland and Westchester counties.^[4][17] This department is the largest by population. Justice Hector LaSalle has been the Presiding Justice since May 25, 2021.^[18]
• The Third Department, seated in Albany, includes an area extending from the territory of the Second Department north to New York's borders with Vermont and Quebec, and includes the cities of Albany, Troy, Schenectady, Saratoga Springs, and Binghamton. This territory extends nearly as far west as Syracuse.^[4][19] Hon. Elizabeth A. Garry has been the Presiding Justice since January 1, 2018.^[20]
• The Fourth Department, seated in Rochester, covers the remainder of the state west of the Third Department's territory, and includes the cities of Buffalo, Rochester, and Syracuse.^[4][21] Hon. Gerald J. Whalen has been the Presiding Justice since January 7, 2016.^[22]

Programs and agencies

Attorneys and Counselors at Law

In addition to hearing appeals in matters of law and equity, the Appellate Division regulates the admission of lawyers to the Bar and their conduct and discipline.^[23]

• Each department has a Character and Fitness Committee, whose members interview applicants in person for admission to the bar.^[24]
• Each department has Attorney Grievance Committees that investigates complaints of attorney misconduct and may issue reprimands or recommend censure, suspension, or disbarment to the Appellate Division.^[25]

Protection of minors and the incapacitated

At English common law, the Lord Chancellor, as the king's delegate to exercise the Crown's special jurisdiction, had responsibility for the custody and protection of infants and the mentally incapacitated. Revisions to the constitution in 1847 abolished the New York Court of Chancery and transferred this role to the New York Supreme Court.^[26]

• The Appellate Division regulates the panels of attorneys that represent children in family law proceedings in the appellate, Supreme, Family and Criminal Courts, and each department has an Office for Attorneys for Children (Originally named Law Guardian).^[27]
• Each department also has a Mental Hygiene Legal Service (MHLS) program.^[28][29][30] Since its creation by statute in 1964 as the Mental Health Information Service, the MHLS has served as the watchdog of the rights of the institutionalized mentally disabled in New York and has been recognized by the courts as essential to the state's statutory "protective shield of checks and balances" governing the admission, transfer and retention of psychiatric patients.^[31]
• Court Examiners are designated by each department to ascertain whether guardians appointed pursuant to the Mental Hygiene Law have complied with the order of appointment and have performed the duties specified.^[32]

Procedure

Each case is decided by a panel of five, or in some instances four, justices of the Court. There is no procedure for the Court to sit en banc.

Some basic rules governing appeals are found in Articles 55 and 57 of the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules, but they are not detailed enough to fully provide for a comprehensive system of appellate procedure. Prior to September 2018, and unlike other states that have statewide rules of appellate procedure, there was no set of appellate procedure rules shared by all four departments beyond the rudimentary set in the CPLR. Instead, each of the four departments filled in the CPLR's gaps by promulgating its own individual set of rules governing more specific details of practice before that court. The result was considerable diversity in appellate procedure between the four departments, which extended to matters as basic as the form and formatting of appellate briefs, the deadline to perfect an appeal after filing of the notice of appeal, appellate motions, and oral argument.^[33]

During the 2010s, this problem was studied at length by the New York State Bar Association, and the NYSBA's recommendations for reform came to the attention of Chief Judge Janet DiFiore.^[33] In June 2018, the Presiding Justices of the Appellate Division promulgated statewide Practice Rules of the Appellate Division, which became effective in September 2018 and are codified outside of the CPLR in 22 N.Y.C.R.R. Part 1250.^[34] The four departments retain the ability to supplement and even supersede the uniform rules by promulgating rules of their own.^[35]

Appeals from the Appellate Division

Decisions by the Appellate Division may be appealed to the state's highest court, the New York Court of Appeals. In some cases, an appeal lies of right, but in most cases, permission (or "leave") to appeal must be obtained, either from the Appellate Division itself or from the Court of Appeals. In civil cases, the Appellate Division panel or Court of Appeals votes on petitions for leave to appeal; in most criminal cases, however, the petition for leave to appeal is referred to a single Justice or Judge, whose decision whether to grant or deny leave is final.

Case management

To keep caseloads under control, most Appellate Division opinions are extremely concise. Often, an Appellate Division panel will dispose of an entire case in only two paragraphs, with the second paragraph stating: "We have considered plaintiff's (or defendant's) remaining contentions and find them unavailing." In contrast, courts in most other states traditionally devote a few more paragraphs to disposing of the other "remaining contentions."

Appointment of justices

Justices of the Appellate Division are chosen by the Governor from among those elected to the State Supreme Court. A justice does not have to have been elected from one of the judicial districts within a department to be appointed to the Appellate Division for that department, although the Presiding Justice and a majority of the total number of justices are to reside within the department. They serve at least five years, or until the completion of their 14-year elected terms, or reaching the constitutional age limit of 70, beyond which the governor may choose to reappoint them for up to three two-year terms.

The State Constitution provides that the First and Second Department are each to comprise seven justices, and the Third and Fourth departments five justices. In addition to these "constitutional" justices, the presiding justice of each department may ask the Governor to designate "additional justices" where needed based on the court's workload. At present, for example, the First Department comprises 20 justices in total when there are no vacancies. The qualifications for additional Justices are the same as for other justices.

Administration of the courts

Attorneys are admitted to the New York bar by one of the Appellate Division departments rather than by New York's highest court, the Court of Appeals, though once admitted to any of the Appellate Division departments, such attorney is admitted to practice and appear before all non-federal courts in the state, including the Court of Appeals. Applicants must be interviewed in person by a member of the court's "Character and Fitness Committee" after passing the New York State Bar Exam (since July 2016, the Uniform Bar Examination^[36]) and Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination administered by the New York State Board of Law Examiners.^[37] Applicants are admitted in the department in which they reside; applicants residing outside New York are admitted through the Third Department in Albany.

Judges are regulated by the Rules Governing Judicial Conduct promulgated by the Chief Administrator, the Code of Judicial Conduct adopted by the New York State Bar Association, and the relevant rules of the respective Appellate Division departments.^[38] Attorneys are regulated by various state laws, the Rules of Professional Conduct (based on the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct), and rules adopted by each department of the Appellate Division.^[39][40] Each department of the Appellate Division has a committee that investigates complaints of attorney misconduct and may issue reprimands or recommend censure, suspension, or disbarment to the Appellate Division.^[41]

History

The Appellate Division was created by the New York State Constitution of 1894 to succeed the General Term of the Supreme Court, effective January 1, 1896.^[42]

See also

• Judiciary of New York
• Judicial Conference of the State of New York
• Appellate Division Courthouse of New York State
• New York State Courts Electronic Filing System

References

1. "Appellate Division - Second Judicial Department". nycourts.gov. Retrieved 2023-09-02.
2. System, New York State Unified Court. "The Courts, General Info - N.Y. State Courts". www.nycourts.gov. Retrieved 9 April 2018.
3. New York State Const., Art. VI, § 4. https://www.dos.ny.gov/info/constitution.htm Archived 2016-02-07 at the Wayback Machine
4. NY Courts website Appellate Divisions page. Accessed June 24, 2009.
5. Practice of Law 2012, pp. 9–10.
6. See N.Y. CPLR 5701(a)(2).
7. "An Overview of the Appellate Division" on the New York State Courts website
8. Birnbaum, Edward L.; Belen, Ariel E.; Grasso, Carl T. (2012). New York Trial Notebook (6th ed.). James Publishing. pp. 1–23. ISBN 978-1-58012-104-0.
9. Duffy v. Horton Memorial Hospital, 66 N.Y.2d 473, 497 N.Y.S.2d 890 (1985); Mountain View Coach Lines v. Storms, 102 A.D.2d 663, 476 N.Y.S.2d 918 (2d Dept. 1984).
10. Mountain View Coach Lines v. Storms, 102 A.D.2d 663, 476 N.Y.S.2d 918 (2d Dept. 1984)
11. Gibson & Manz 2004, p. 149.
12. Gibson & Manz 2004, p. 153.
13. "About the Official Reports". New York State Law Reporting Bureau. Retrieved 20 August 2014.
14. Gibson & Manz 2004, p. 151.
15. NY Courts website 1st Department page. Accessed June 24, 2009.
16. "Appellate Division - First Judicial Department". www.courts.state.ny.us. Retrieved 2024-01-23.
17. NY Courts website 2d Department page. Accessed June 24, 2009.
18. "Appellate Division - Second Judicial Department". www.courts.state.ny.us. Retrieved 2021-06-21.
19. NY Courts website 3d Department page. Accessed June 24, 2009.
20. "Presiding Justice Elizabeth A. Garry". www.nycourts.gov.
21. NY Courts website 4th Department page. Accessed June 24, 2009.
22. "Appellate 4th". www.nycourts.gov. Retrieved 2021-06-21.
23. "Part 520 - Rules of the Court of Appeals for the Admission of Attorneys and Counselors at Law". Retrieved May 9, 2020.
24. NYSBA Committee on Legal Education and Admission to the Bar; NYSBA Membership Committee (September 2012). The Practice of Law in New York State: An Introduction For Newly-Admitted Attorneys (PDF). New York State Bar Association. pp. 18–19.
25. Gibson & Manz 2004, p. 138.
26. "Sporza v. German Savings Bank, 84 N.E. 406, 192 N.Y. 8". CourtListener.com. Retrieved May 10, 2020.
27. "Rules of the Appellate Division Fourth Department" (PDF). nycourts.gov. Retrieved May 10, 2020.
28. Mental Hygiene Law § 47.01
29. "An Act to amend the mental hygiene law…". Laws of the State of New York Passed at the Sessions of the Legislature. 208th sess.: III: 3110–3132. 1985. hdl:2027/nyp.33433107706321. ISSN 0892-287X. Chapter 789, enacted 1 August 1985, effective 1 April 1986.
30. New York State bill jackets - L-1985-CH-0789, New York State Library, 1 August 1985
31. "See, Fhagen v. Miller, 29 NY2d 348, 355 (1972". Leagle.com. Retrieved May 10, 2020.
32. "Guide To Becoming A Guardian Without A Lawyer" (PDF). CUNY.edu. Retrieved May 10, 2020.
33. Hartman, Denise (Winter 2019). "New Unified, But Not Uniform, Practice Rules of the Appellate Division" (PDF). Leaveworthy: The Newsletter of the NYSBA Committee on Courts of Appellate Jurisdiction. 8 (1): 1–3. Retrieved 5 January 2021.
34. Newman, Thomas R.; Ahmuty, Steven J. Jr. (6 November 2018). "New Practice Rules of the Appellate Division". New York Law Journal.
35. See, e.g., 22 N.Y.C.R.R. 670.1(a) (observing that the Second Department's rules "control[] when practicing within the Second Judicial Department")
36. Clifford, Stephanie; McKinley, James C. Jr. (May 5, 2015). "New York to Adopt a Uniform Bar Exam Used in 15 Other States". The New York Times. Retrieved November 6, 2017.
37. Practice of Law 2012, pp. 18–19.
38. Gibson & Manz 2004, p. 132.
39. Gibson & Manz 2004, pp. 136–138.
40. "New Attorney Rules of Professional Conduct Announced" (Press release). New York Office of Court Administration. 17 December 2008.
41. Gibson, Ellen M.; Manz, William H. (2004). Gibson's New York Legal Research Guide (PDF) (3rd ed.). Wm. S. Hein Publishing. p. 138. ISBN 1-57588-728-2. LCCN 2004042477. OCLC 54455036.
42. The new judicial system in NYT on January 2, 1896

Further reading

• Galie, Peter J.; Bopst, Christopher (2012). The New York State Constitution (2nd ed.). Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-986056-2. LCCN 2011051555.
• NYSBA Committee on Legal Education and Admission to the Bar; NYSBA Membership Committee (September 2012). The Practice of Law in New York State: An Introduction For Newly-Admitted Attorneys (PDF). New York State Bar Association.
• Lincoln, Charles Z. (1906). The Constitutional History of New York. Lawyers Co-operative Publishing. OCLC 1337955.
• "New York State Constitution". New York State Department of State. Archived from the original on 2021-04-23. Retrieved 2012-09-03.
• "The Historical Society of the Courts of the State of New York".

External links

• Appellate Division of the Supreme Court
  • First Judicial Department
  • Second Judicial Department
  • Third Judicial Department
  • Fourth Judicial Department
• Lower appellate courts
  • First Judicial Department Appellate Term
  • Second Judicial Department Appellate Term
• Supreme Court in the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations
• New York Slip Opinion Service from the New York State Law Reporting Bureau
• New York Official Reports Service from West