The card included matches that resulted from scripted storylines, where wrestlers portrayed heroes, villains, or less distinguishable characters in scripted events that built tension and culminated in a wrestling match or series of matches. Results were predetermined by WWE's writers on the NXT brand,[3][4] while storylines were produced on WWE's weekly television program, NXT, and the supplementary online streaming show, Level Up.
On the May 30 episode of NXT, after Carmelo Hayes retained his NXT Championship, Baron Corbin, who became a free agent in the 2023 WWE Draft, made his return to NXT and attacked Hayes.[7] The following week, Ilja Dragunov interrupted Corbin's promo and challenged him to a match, which was made official for next week's episode.[5] During that week's episode, WWE executive Shawn Michaels announced on Twitter that the winner of this match would face Hayes for the NXT Championship on Week 2 of Gold Rush. The match was won by Corbin.[6]
On the June 6 episode of NXT, Dana Brooke and Cora Jade participated in the aforementioned battle royal, and they were the last two persons eliminated in the match.[5] The following week, Jade interrupted Brooke's interview and blamed her for costing her the battle royal. After Brooke answered that she should not blame her, Jade slapped Brooke across the face. That same episode, Brooke distracted Jade during her match, causing her to lose. A match between Brooke and Jade was scheduled for Week 1 of Gold Rush.[6]
On the June 13 episode of NXT, Malik Blade defeated his tag team partner Edris Enofé in which Hank Walker, Tank Ledger, Brooks Jensen, and Josh Briggs watched at ringside. After the match, Blade and Enofé hugged each other with accompaniment of this two teams. After that, NXT commentator Booker T announced that the three tag teams would face each other in a triple threat tag team match during Week 1 of Gold Rush, with the winners facing Gallus (Mark Coffey and Wolfgang) for the NXT Tag Team Championship during Week 2.[6]