Godfrey grew up in Fleming Island, Florida, the daughter of Tim and Stefannie Godfrey, and has a twin brother and older sister. Her father ran track at South Florida. She is of Italian descent on her mother's side.[2][3] Godfrey joined Clay County Soccer Club at age five, and her club coach tabbed her as "the next Morgan Brian" at an early age.[4] She played DA club soccer for Clay County (which later became United Soccer Alliance) and ECNL soccer for Jacksonville FC.[2] She was twice named United Soccer Coaches All-American, and TopDrawerSoccer ranked her as the tenth-best recruit of the 2020 class. She graduated from Fleming Island High School.[2]
Virginia Cavaliers
Godfrey started all but her first game with the Virginia Cavaliers as a freshman in 2020, a shortened season due to the COVID-19 pandemic. She scored 4 goals and led the Atlantic Coast Conference with 9 assists in 21 games, helping Virginia to the semifinals of both the ACC and NCAA tournaments. She was named the ACC Freshman of the Year, TopDrawerSoccer National Freshman of the Year, second-team All-ACC, second-team United Soccer Coaches All-American, and first-team TopDrawerSoccer Best XI.[2][5] In her sophomore season, scored 3 goals and added a team-high 12 assists, earning first-team All-ACC and second-team All-American honors. Virginia went undefeated in conference play to claim the ACC regular-season title, before losing to Florida State in the ACC tournament final and BYU in the third round of the NCAA tournament.[2][6]
Godfrey scored a career-high 8 goals with 5 assists in 23 games in her junior season, being named first-team All-ACC and first-team All-American. She scored a brace against Xavier in the NCAA tournament as Virginia made the quarterfinals.[2] She missed the entire 2023 season due to a knee injury in the spring.[3] She came back the following year, reentering the starting lineup by the sixth game of the 2024 season. She ended the year with 2 goals and 3 assists and helped Virginia return to the NCAA tournament, which they had missed the year prior.[2][7]