"Last Forever" parts 1 and 2 are the 23rd and 24th and final episodes of the ninth season of the American sitcom television series How I Met Your Mother, and the series finale of the show as a whole. The episode, written by series creators Carter Bays and Craig Thomas and directed by Pamela Fryman. The episodes are the 207th and 208th overall. It originally aired in the United States on CBS on March 31, 2014, and was watched by 13.13 million viewers in the United States.
"Last Forever" received a negative response from television critics and fans of the show alike, primarily in regard to the final twist ending, the relationship between Ted Mosby (Josh Radnor) and Robin Scherbatsky (Cobie Smulders), and the fate of the series' titular mother. Many viewers expressed considerable disdain for the disregard for character development and said the episode rendered the whole season pointless, while some praised it for tying up loose ends; an alternate ending would later be included in the ninth season's home media release.
Plot
Part 1
In May 2013, at Barney and Robin’s wedding reception, Ted discusses his move to Chicago with Marshall and Lily. Barney recognizes the bass player as the woman who advised him to pursue Robin and tries to introduce her to Ted, but Ted declines. After saying goodbye, he heads to Farhampton train station. There, an elderly lady spots the Mother nearby, but Ted decides not to approach her since he's moving. The next night, Ted surprises Marshall and Lily at MacLaren's, revealing he met the bass player from the wedding and they hit it off.
In 2015, Ted, now engaged, discusses wedding plans with Robin and Barney at MacLaren's. Robin is busy with her career, causing tension in her marriage with Barney. The Mother arrives, revealing they need to postpone the wedding because she's pregnant.
By May 2016, Ted and the Mother host a get-together where Barney and Robin announce their divorce. The mood lifts when Marshall and Lily reveals they are expecting their third child. They all vow to stay friends.
In October 2016, Marshall and Lily throw a Halloween party before moving out. Robin, feeling outgrown and conflicted about her unresolved feelings for Ted, decides to leave, which upsets Lily.
Part 2
In 2018, Barney heads to MacLaren's meanwhile Marshall and Lily, now parents, plan an early night. Marshall announces he's replacing a retiring judge, sparking a celebration. Lily scolds Barney for reverting to his old self, but Barney insists he'll only ever work with Robin. Lily relents, letting Barney enjoy his night.
In 2020, Ted re-proposes to the Mother, setting their wedding for the next Thursday. At MacLaren's, Marshall announces he's running for New York Supreme Court. Robin shows up, having reconsidered after the Mother's encouragement. Lily toasts to Ted and the Mother's future.
In May 2013, Ted gathers the courage to introduce himself to the bass player under her yellow umbrella. She reveals her name is Tracy McConnell and remembers him from his first day as a professor. Ted recognizes her umbrella as the one he left at Cindy's. They realize how often they've narrowly missed each other as the train arrives.
In 2030, Luke and Penny, Ted's children, realize his story is more about his feelings for Aunt Robin than meeting their mother. They give their blessing for him to pursue Robin. Ted visits her with the blue French horn, and they share a meaningful smile.
DVD alternate ending
At Ted's and the Mother's wedding, Barney and Robin nod to each other as Future Ted's narration implies they later get back together. He then adds that he believes he is lucky to wake up next to the Mother every morning, and cannot help but be amazed at how "easy" it all really was, recalling his former relationships and expressing incredulity at how allowing Barney and Robin to fall in love led him to leave their wedding early and run into the Mother. After Ted meeting the Mother is shown, Future Ted narrates “See? Easy. And that, kids, is how I met your mother.”
Production
Writing
Before writing the episode, Carter Bays and Craig Thomas decided to watch the series finales of other sitcoms for inspiration. They said that they crafted the last ten minutes of the series right from the start. In February 2014, Bays tweeted that he found a rough draft of the series finale that he first wrote in 2006.[1] In an interview with CNN, Thomas revealed that there was worry among the cast that the series was doomed to fail. He added that he felt that they had written a successful ending for the series.[2]
Before the airing of the series finale, debates raged among fans concerning the fate of Ted and the Mother, fueled by scenes from various episodes through the ninth season which seemed to foreshadow a tragic ending.[3] Additionally the season 7 episode "Tailgate " featured a headstone reading "Mother". Which Screen Rant's Kara Hedash attributed to being for The Mother.
Filming
According to tweets from Alyson Hannigan, approximately 18 minutes of the original episode had to be cut to fit the broadcast time. One cut sequence features Marshall paying Lily regarding a bet on whether Ted and Robin end up together, first referenced in the episode "No Pressure" (2012).[4] Other cut scenes feature Robin, wearing her Robin Sparkles jeans jacket over her wedding dress, singing "Let's Go to the Mall" (2007) with the Mother's band at the wedding reception,[5] and a montage showing Tracy's funeral.[6]
The scene involving Ted's future children (Lyndsy Fonseca and David Henrie) was secretly shot in 2006 during the production of the second season.[7] This was primarily done so the teenage characters would not age, since Fonseca and Henrie were adults by the time the final episode aired.[8] The scene was filmed on a set closed to everyone except Bays, Thomas, executive producer/director Pamela Fryman, a camera operator, and Fonseca and Henrie, who signed non-disclosure agreements. Fonseca stated that she had forgotten the details of the scene in the years since its filming, while Henrie said, "I do remember. I think I remember. We’ll see."[9][10] Josh Radnor was also told some parts of the finale from the start,[11] but neither he nor the rest of the cast were informed how the series would end.[12]
An alternative cut of the ending appeared on the season nine DVD and the box set. It did not contain any new footage, but is edited in a way that changes the fates of Tracy, Robin and Barney. The voiceover is performed by Saget, rather than Radnor, and is completely different.[13][14]
Radnor, not Bob Saget, plays future Ted when he appears on camera. During a RedditAsk Me Anything whether he should have played the role, Saget said that Radnor doing so "felt appropriate to me. It's not The Matrix where Ted CGI's into a narrator of his voice that was done as a sweet way to tell his story from almost his conscience from the future of his own life".[17]
Music
Everything but the Girl's acoustic cover of the Tom Waits song "Downtown Train" was used in the scene where Ted and The Mother meet at the Farhampton train station. Music supervisor Andy Gowan says that Carter Bays "basically put it in the script, and wrote that script with that song in mind"; Gowan described the song as "heartbreakingly beautiful" and captured both the "sweet and romantic" and the "somber, dark part" of the scene.[18]
"Heaven" by The Walkmen features in the final scene of "Last Forever". Gowan said that "it seemed like it was written for our show". Gowan had suggested the song before, especially for use in the season 8premiere, and said that when he pitched it for use in the season 9 finale, "[the song] was just the one that resonated with all of us the most".[18]
Reception
Ratings
Both parts of "Last Forever" aired back-to-back on CBS on March 31, 2014.[19] The episodes were watched by 13.13 million viewers in the United States in its original American broadcast and received a 5.4 rating/16% share among adults between the ages of 18 and 49.[20] This marked a significant increase, of over four million viewers, in the ratings from the previous episode, "The End of the Aisle".[21] It also ranks as the most-watched episode of the season, as well as the most-watched episode for the series, beating the season 1 episode "The Pineapple Incident", which was watched by 12.27 million viewers and received a 4.4 rating among adults ages 18–49.[22][23] The episode also ranked first in its timeslot and second of the night as a whole.[20][23]
Critical response
"Last Forever" received an overwhelming negative
response from critics and fans of the show alike.[24] Many viewers expressed considerable dissatisfaction regarding the resolution of Ted's story, his relationship to Robin, and the fate of the titular mother.[25][26] Additionally, the season-long buildup for Barney and Robin's wedding and their divorce 10 minutes into the next episode was criticized.[27][28] Fans took to social media, such as Tumblr and Twitter, to express their disappointment. Some fans joked that the episode was an early April Fools' joke, because it aired on March 31.[29]
Donna Bowman of The A.V. Club graded the episode a B+, saying, "The hour finale was a strange ride, marvelous in some ways, confounding in others. Endings are difficult, and I don’t think any objective assessment would say they nailed this one."[30] Emily VanDerWerff of The A.V. Club was more blunt in saying that "Bays and Thomas simply looked like shitty long-term planners, unable to understand that getting the audience so invested in the Barney and Robin coupling or in Tracy as a character would make it all the harder when the series finale abruptly dissolved the former and treated the latter’s death as an aside in the narration. That the show never seemed to suggest Ted mourned her feels like a vital betrayal of his character."[31]
Alan Sepinwall of HitFix cited three reasons why Bays and Thomas should not have stuck with the ending they had originally envisioned at the start: the show's lengthy run forced them to stretch out events like Barney's and Robin's wedding, which would have to be quickly undone in the finale; the chemistry between Cobie Smulders and Neil Patrick Harris caused many fans to become deeply invested in Robin and Barney's relationship more than Robin and Ted's; and the casting of Cristin Milioti as the Mother caused fans to become invested in that character as well.[32] Sepinwall stated that "so much of what was terrible here was terrible because Bays and Thomas had a very specific vision for the ending of their show and would not—or, perhaps, after they filmed the kids' reactions, could not—deviate from it. And based on the initial reaction I've seen to the episode, it's going to forever sour the opinion many fans of the show had for it."[32]
Joyce Eng of TV Guide said that she'd prefer Ted not to have ended up with Robin, but "as I consider the romantics that co-creators Carter Bays and Craig Thomas are, it's obvious they would bring this long, winding love story full circle back to the person Ted wanted to be with when we met him. And The Mother—excuse us, Tracy—is reunited with her first true love, Max, too." Though the Mother served as a "cheap plot device" to a degree, Eng said that "Ted's time with her also taught him nothing lasts forever, nothing's perfect. And he needs to move on with his life, but that doesn't make his relationship with The Mother any less important. I don't think the Ted of 2005 would've done the same."[33]
Saim Cheeda from Screen Rant was critical of the episode, citing the low points to be the reversal of character development, Robin and Barney's divorce, and the Mother's death. His assessment was that "Fans weren’t given any moment to grieve, which undermined the impact of her passing". Cheeda singled out Ted using the Mother's death as a framing device to be "lame", stating that viewers "being forced to believe that Ted would use his wife’s death to justify chasing after “Aunt” Robin" was the main reason why the finale was disappointing.[34]
Legacy
Some fans of the show called on CBS to commission the creators of the show via a Change.org petition to rewrite and reshoot the finale. As of April 2, 2014[update], the petition had received more than 5,000 signatures.[35] On April 5, 2014, Carter Bays announced on Twitter that an alternative ending, from the same filmed material, would be included on the season 9 DVD.[36]
In the years succeeding its airing, it continued to be singled out as one of television's worst series finales,[37][38] The episodes topped USA Today's 2018 list of "Worst Series Finales of All Time".[39] Writing for Business Insider, Carrie Wittmer placed the episodes 10th on her 2018 list of the worst series finales. Wittmer felt they were worse than finales of Gossip Girl (2007–2012), "New York, I Love You XOXO" (2012), and Roseanne (1988–1997), "Into That Good Night" (1997), but better than the Dexter (2006–2013) finale "Remember the Monsters?" (2013). She added that the conclusion was both predictable and harmed the rewatchability of the series as a whole.[40]
The cast had varying opinions of the finale, with Radnor and Hannigan criticizing it and Harris and Smolders praising it.[41] In a 2014, interview with David Letterman, Harris spoke about the ending:
Some people just hated it, and I think that that's a compliment to the show in a weird way because it means that they have grown up with these characters and feel like they wanted it to go a certain way, though I think it's great. But our show really did cross the line between funny funny and really serious, and that was kind of the balance that this show had. And as the show grew up, and as we grew up in the show, it ended in a more adult way and I think it was a nice, reflective, kind of sad, but happy ending to a long, long story.[42]
^"Barney writes a book, Barney + Robin, Ted + Stella and other 'How I Met Your Mother' news". Chicago Tribune. July 19, 2008. Archived from the original on July 23, 2008. Retrieved August 13, 2017. He did reveal that more than two years ago ... With only the two kids who play Ted's future children ... they shot a scene that directly relates to the identity of the mother. That scene will be included in the show's series finale"
.jpg)
