Benz played college football at Northwestern, primarily as a running back, but also as a safety and occasionally as a quarterback.[3] As a junior in 1961, he threw two touchdown passes to lead the Wildcats to a 12–10 victory over Notre Dame.[3][4] Benz was an honorable mention all-Big Ten Conference selection as a senior.[2] He graduated with a degree in geography and history.[5]
Professional career
After going unselected in the 1963 NFL draft, Benz was signed by the Cleveland Browns as an undrafted free agent and became a regular member of their defensive unit as a safety after the accidental death of Don Fleming in the offseason.[1][6] As a rookie, Benz tied for the team lead for interceptions with seven.[6] In 1964, he recorded four interceptions and helped the Browns defeat the Baltimore Colts in the NFL Championship Game.[5][7] In his third season with the team, he led the team with five interceptions.[5]
In February 1966, Benz was one of three Browns players selected by the newly-created Atlanta Falcons in the 1966 NFL expansion draft.[8] However, he quit the team suddenly in July.[9]
Personal life
Benz is of German descent and has two older brothers named Tom and Dick.[10] He and his wife Dalia lived in Euclid, Ohio, during his time on the Browns.[2] After his playing career, Benz started his own construction business.[5]