AllMusic wrote that "if Rizzo from Grease got cloned three times and they started their own band, it would definitely sound something like the Eyeliners."[3] The Chicago Tribune wrote that the band have "internalized [the Ramones'] way of pounding home massive garage-pop hooks with buzz-saw punk ferocity."[4]The Arizona Republic stated that the band "have a knack for taking classic rock and roll and reinventing it with sassy punk-rock attitude."[8]