Tottle began his professional hockey career with the Dallas Texans, and the Fort Worth Rangers, in the United States Hockey League.[3] He signed with the Springfield Indians, and wore uniform #5 for ten seasons.[4][5] During the three seasons which the Indians played as the Syracuse Warriors, he led the team with 187 penalty minutes.[5] He was named a first-team all-star in the 1954–55 AHL season, scoring six goals, and 31 points, his highest totals in the American Hockey League (AHL).[4][6] After his ten seasons with the Indians/Warriors, he had played the eighth most games (433), in Springfield AHL history, and was inducted into Springfield Hockey Hall of Fame.[4]
Tottle was married to Ann, and had two daughters and a stepson. He was the owner and operator of Gordie's Amoco in Harrisburg, North Carolina. He was a member of the Oak Branch Masonic Lodge No. 261 in Innerkip, Ontario, a member of the Scottish Rite and the Carolina Consistory, and a member of the Commonwealth Baptist Church. He died from cancer on March 9, 1987, at his home in Harrisburg, and was interred in Sunset Memory Gardens.[1][2]