A son of immigrants, after high school he served in the navy before college (NYU, Brooklyn Law School). Prior to running for office he was a longshoreman.[1]
An example of Barbaro working as a legislator with others[6] involved reclaiming a Bensonhurst public school that was transferred to the Transit Authority in 1981 due to it being underutilized. By 1992, with population growth, it was needed, yet in 1998 it still had not been given back.[7]
In 1999, Barbaro presided over a bench trial for a murder case, finding the defendant guilty and sentencing him to 15 years to life in prison. The verdict was upheld in a 2004 appeal.[8] However, Barbaro later felt his judgment was in error. In 2013, he testified in favor of reversing his decision, but it was again upheld, with Justice ShawnDya L. Simpson concluding that, while she was also deeply troubled by the case, there were no legal grounds to overturn the ruling.[9]
Barbaro ("BAR-ba-roe"[10]) and his wife, the former Mary Borysewicz, had three daughters.[1]
In the 2000s, Barbaro moved from Brooklyn to Watervliet, New York.[1] He died from heart failure at his home on September 4, 2016, at the age of 88.[1]